A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder - Day 8

[fingersplints]

Splints... do you think its Roxy that's bad? Or someone else?

Dom was the mafias night one target. In your opinion is that someone that Roxy would want out of the game early?

It's possible, but like I said

I still can't see this as being Roxy's baddie game tbh, maybe she is fooling me but I honestly don't see it. Wrong does not equal bad.

I cannot see Dom being Roxy's first choice of a N1 kill at all. If she is bad though, it is possible that she was overruled by the rest of the team. I know she is busy with TSM and other stuff, so if she is bad I doubt she would even be around the chat much to be part of the decision making process.

[Roxy]

I really do not know about splints. I feel good about her game but maybe I am wrong.

Yes I thought Golden was bad.

Dom could still be indy but idk he seems wholly uninvolved.

[Sorsha]

Well it seems like scotty, llama and I are all roxy/splints and can't make up our mind. Not sure where Dom stands.



If we are wrong I guess Chauncy can take out the other tonight. I think dom, llama and scotty are all civs.

[thellama73]

Who wants to vote first? Honestly, the last few posts have me feeling better about SPlints and worse about Roxy. I am starting to second guess myself and wonder if I am being rolled by Scotty.

[Marmot]

Who wants to vote first? Honestly, the last few posts have me feeling better about SPlints and worse about Roxy. I am starting to second guess myself and wonder if I am being rolled by Scotty.

I already voted.

[Sorsha]

Ok. I voted roxy.

[Scotty]

Ok. I voted roxy.

Sounds good. We gave people time to vote if forced, so I don't feel bad about this.

[Scotty]

Who wants to vote first? Honestly, the last few posts have me feeling better about SPlints and worse about Roxy. I am starting to second guess myself and wonder if I am being rolled by Scotty.

Even if I were futzing around, Chauncey could just kill me tonight, and lynch splints tomorrow.

Unless...I guess having the detective alive leaves it 1 v 1 v 1 tomorrow, which means civs lose, don't they?

[Scotty]

Literally all we need is 1 more vote for Roxy and we can seal it. Come on guys! I want to move that much closer to my first win on this site.

[Dom]

Here are a couple of posts from Fingersplints I think are worth noting:

Actually I don't want to miss another vote so I am going to vote Elo right now. I trust Roxy and I think she is right. It does seem like Elo has been being saved by llama. Iirc he is the one who first commented to me about greybonez and then when he was lynched he was like "you all should have listened to me about MM". seems sketchy

I asked for a summary and literally the only thing I got was about greybonez. I don't think it's fair to say it's jumping on bandwagon considering I just entered the game so how was I supposed to express suspicion before then? Also while greybonez ended up being civvie I really think defending himself some would have gone a long way.

I'm not sure how you know what's going on in my life to judge how much time I should have or have not had to catch up, but I'm pretty sure everyone here except you who is not playing (has played, or is cohosting with me) the game I am hosting, so does not know that some pretty bad shit happened there and I have been preoccupied with that. I'm keeping up with what is being said now, but I literally haven't had a chance to read prior. (Minus greybonez - who I did read all host posts before voting)

I'm going to try to reread Elo first when I get a chance. I'm pretty good at reading Roxy, and I feel from her posts that she is a civvie. She seems pretty insistent, so I wonder if there is something there.

Very unsubtle defending of Roxy, and notably the only time she mentioned MM.

Recall that Splints replaces Lipsticklacey, and then read this:

I want to vote llama for saying to lynch Lips.
And we all know how I feel about noobs amirite?

I think a Roxy/Splints team looks probable. I would probably be more comfortable with a SPlints lynch than Roxy though, since the Eloh NK could be a setup.

I don't get this.
You think splints is defending rox, so you're clearly of the opinion that rox is bad.... so... you're more comfortable with a splints lynch because????

I really do not know about splints. I feel good about her game but maybe I am wrong.

Yes I thought Golden was bad.

Dom could still be indy but idk he seems wholly uninvolved.

I'm busy. :/ :/

[Dom]

I'll vote Roxy. :/

[thellama73]

I'll vote Roxy. :/

Me too.

[fingersplints]

I'm voting Scotty. If the numbers are correct and it has to be one of us I still don't see it as rox's baddie game and I know I am a civvie. Looks like she will be lynched anyways, so I hope you guys are right

[Sorsha]

Where. Is. DF?

[DFaraday]

So sorry for the delay, no Internet. Post will be up in the morning.

[Roxy]

You. people are foolish

[Elohcin]

I'm being very impatient about this, DF! :P

[DFaraday]

Day 7 - The Seventh Day

"I propose a game of billiards to solve this enigma," suggested Llama. After everything that's happened, billiards sounded wonderfully soothing. The crowd gathered and began a tournament, with the winner getting to use the ceremonial armour in the hall for defense against Sibella.

"So...one of us in this room is the killer..." said Scotty casually.

"I think it was Roxy!" exclaimed Sorsha.

"Yes, Roxy! Roxy, yeah! Roxy, indubitably!" agreed the crowd.

"You're making a terrible mistake," Roxy said. "It's not me, and you won't stand a chance without me!"

"Tell it to the judge," Llama said. The crowd grabbed a pool cue and charged Roxy, impaling her on it.

"Hey, she looks kind of familiar, huh?" said Dom.

"She's the D'Ysquith we abandoned years ago!" declared Splints.

"Oh well," said Sorsha sadly.

Roxy has been lynched. She was Chauncey D'Ysquith. It is now Night 7. You have 36 hours to send in your PMs.

[Scotty]

Day 7 - The Seventh Day

"I propose a game of billiards to solve this enigma," suggested Llama. After everything that's happened, billiards sounded wonderfully soothing. The crowd gathered and began a tournament, with the winner getting to use the ceremonial armour in the hall for defense against Sibella.

"So...one of us in this room is the killer..." said Scotty casually.

"I think it was Roxy!" exclaimed Sorsha.

"Yes, Roxy! Roxy, yeah! Roxy, indubitably!" agreed the crowd.

"You're making a terrible mistake," Roxy said. "It's not me, and you won't stand a chance without me!"

"Tell it to the judge," Llama said. The crowd grabbed a pool cue and charged Roxy, impaling her on it.

"Hey, she looks kind of familiar, huh?" said Dom.

"She's the D'Ysquith we abandoned years ago!" declared Splints.

"Oh well," said Sorsha sadly.

Roxy has been lynched. She was Chauncey D'Ysquith. It is now Night 7. You have 36 hours to send in your PMs.

I'm sorry Roxy.

I think I was right about golden and there is only 1 mafia member left. And her name is fingersplints.

We're not dead yet, boys. I could be bamboozling you, but take solace in the fact that, if my logic is correct, only me and splints can be bad.

[thellama73]

Day 7 - The Seventh Day

"I propose a game of billiards to solve this enigma," suggested Llama. After everything that's happened, billiards sounded wonderfully soothing. The crowd gathered and began a tournament, with the winner getting to use the ceremonial armour in the hall for defense against Sibella.

"So...one of us in this room is the killer..." said Scotty casually.

"I think it was Roxy!" exclaimed Sorsha.

"Yes, Roxy! Roxy, yeah! Roxy, indubitably!" agreed the crowd.

"You're making a terrible mistake," Roxy said. "It's not me, and you won't stand a chance without me!"

"Tell it to the judge," Llama said. The crowd grabbed a pool cue and charged Roxy, impaling her on it.

"Hey, she looks kind of familiar, huh?" said Dom.

"She's the D'Ysquith we abandoned years ago!" declared Splints.

"Oh well," said Sorsha sadly.

Roxy has been lynched. She was Chauncey D'Ysquith. It is now Night 7. You have 36 hours to send in your PMs.

I'm sorry Roxy.

I think I was right about golden and there is only 1 mafia member left. And her name is fingersplints.

We're not dead yet, boys. I could be bamboozling you, but take solace in the fact that, if my logic is correct, only me and splints can be bad.

I think it might be you.

[Marmot]

You. people are foolish

No, I'm just dead.

[Scotty]

Day 7 - The Seventh Day

"I propose a game of billiards to solve this enigma," suggested Llama. After everything that's happened, billiards sounded wonderfully soothing. The crowd gathered and began a tournament, with the winner getting to use the ceremonial armour in the hall for defense against Sibella.

"So...one of us in this room is the killer..." said Scotty casually.

"I think it was Roxy!" exclaimed Sorsha.

"Yes, Roxy! Roxy, yeah! Roxy, indubitably!" agreed the crowd.

"You're making a terrible mistake," Roxy said. "It's not me, and you won't stand a chance without me!"

"Tell it to the judge," Llama said. The crowd grabbed a pool cue and charged Roxy, impaling her on it.

"Hey, she looks kind of familiar, huh?" said Dom.

"She's the D'Ysquith we abandoned years ago!" declared Splints.

"Oh well," said Sorsha sadly.

Roxy has been lynched. She was Chauncey D'Ysquith. It is now Night 7. You have 36 hours to send in your PMs.

I'm sorry Roxy.

I think I was right about golden and there is only 1 mafia member left. And her name is fingersplints.

We're not dead yet, boys. I could be bamboozling you, but take solace in the fact that, if my logic is correct, only me and splints can be bad.

I think it might be you.

Could be.

But know that if you are wrong and I get mislynched tomorrow, civs have a chance of losing in lylo.

Honestly my logic hasn't been tested yet. No one has come back to me since yesterday with opposite logic. Am I wrong? Let me know.

[thellama73]

That's true about anyone though, Scotty. Not just you.

[thellama73]

Honestly Scotty, the extent to which you've stepped into a leadership role at the endgame has me worried. You seem excited. You have the air of someone about to pull off a desperate victory, and that makes me not trust you. I owe both you and Splints a reread today.

[Scotty]

Honestly Scotty, the extent to which you've stepped into a leadership role at the endgame has me worried. You seem excited. You have the air of someone about to pull off a desperate victory, and that makes me not trust you. I owe both you and Splints a reread today.

That's fair. Not disputing how excited I am, because I am sure we are close to winning.

Do you agree that the only possibilities of mafia at this point are me and splints? That's been my whole point.

[thellama73]

Honestly Scotty, the extent to which you've stepped into a leadership role at the endgame has me worried. You seem excited. You have the air of someone about to pull off a desperate victory, and that makes me not trust you. I owe both you and Splints a reread today.

That's fair. Not disputing how excited I am, because I am sure we are close to winning.

Do you agree that the only possibilities of mafia at this point are me and splints? That's been my whole point.

Yeah, I do agree with that, and I am agonizing over which one of you to choose. Why isn't Splints defending herself like you are? Is she a lone baddie who has given up, or is she a bored civ who was never really that engaged?

[Dom]

llama, i'm on your page. :/

[thellama73]

What does Sorsha think, I wonder?

[fingersplints]

Honestly Scotty, the extent to which you've stepped into a leadership role at the endgame has me worried. You seem excited. You have the air of someone about to pull off a desperate victory, and that makes me not trust you. I owe both you and Splints a reread today.

That's fair. Not disputing how excited I am, because I am sure we are close to winning.

Do you agree that the only possibilities of mafia at this point are me and splints? That's been my whole point.

Yeah, I do agree with that, and I am agonizing over which one of you to choose. Why isn't Splints defending herself like you are? Is she a lone baddie who has given up, or is she a bored civ who was never really that engaged?

I'm not bored, but yes I am less engaged being a civvie who replaced in. I don't think I have ever been very secretive that I prefer to be bad and am more engaged and interested when I have btsc. I'm not making any excuses, I'm just saying.

Scotty is defending himself, but he is also acting sketchy as all hell. Take yesterday for example. The way he tried to rush everyone into voting for Roxy.

Literally all we need is 1 more vote for Roxy and we can seal it. Come on guys! I want to move that much closer to my first win on this site.

A baddie would want to speed this along this close to the end and not have everyone fully think through their votes. I'm also not liking how sure he is that we only have one baddie left.

[Scotty]

Honestly Scotty, the extent to which you've stepped into a leadership role at the endgame has me worried. You seem excited. You have the air of someone about to pull off a desperate victory, and that makes me not trust you. I owe both you and Splints a reread today.

That's fair. Not disputing how excited I am, because I am sure we are close to winning.

Do you agree that the only possibilities of mafia at this point are me and splints? That's been my whole point.

Yeah, I do agree with that, and I am agonizing over which one of you to choose. Why isn't Splints defending herself like you are? Is she a lone baddie who has given up, or is she a bored civ who was never really that engaged?

I'm not bored, but yes I am less engaged being a civvie who replaced in. I don't think I have ever been very secretive that I prefer to be bad and am more engaged and interested when I have btsc. I'm not making any excuses, I'm just saying.

Scotty is defending himself, but he is also acting sketchy as all hell. Take yesterday for example. The way he tried to rush everyone into voting for Roxy.

Literally all we need is 1 more vote for Roxy and we can seal it. Come on guys! I want to move that much closer to my first win on this site.

A baddie would want to speed this along this close to the end and not have everyone fully think through their votes. I'm also not liking how sure he is that we only have one baddie left.

Of course I'm defending myself. And unlike other people, at least I'm attempting to pose solutions instead of just saying "I think he looks sketchy".

And I wasn't attempting to speed along the vote. We had literally all day to think about who to vote. Sorsha was leaning Roxy. Llama was leaning Roxy. If it had come up that I was the most suspicious at that point, then I would have gone with it.

You're not liking how I think there is only one baddie left?

Huh.

That's weird. If there were 2, are you saying you are the only one? Or are you still thinking one of the other 3 alive have a possibility of being bad?

[Scotty]

EBWOP: you are the only one = you are the other* one.

[fingersplints]

Umm, I am posing a solution too? I think we should lynch you next. Is "I think he looks sketchy" really all I said, because you are defending against the other things I said. Don't make it out like there aren't points and my suspicion of you is just vibes when it isn't.

Are you really trying to say you saying "Come on guys!" when people were taking there time deciding where to vote ISN'T speeding it along, because it really reads to me like that.

What exactly is weird about it? What I think is weird is how you seem to know there is only one baddie left. As far as I can see only one has been lynched, and the rest is just speculation. Only a baddie would know how many are left.
I'm not the one trying to say there is only one left. I think it's possible Golden could have been bad, but I'd rather lynch you and then see from there. I am not the one trying to rush votes to seal the lynch and end the game.

[Scotty]

Umm, I am posing a solution too? I think we should lynch you next. Is "I think he looks sketchy" really all I said, because you are defending against the other things I said. Don't make it out like there aren't points and my suspicion of you is just vibes when it isn't.

Are you really trying to say you saying "Come on guys!" when people were taking there time deciding where to vote ISN'T speeding it along, because it really reads to me like that.

What exactly is weird about it? What I think is weird is how you seem to know there is only one baddie left. As far as I can see only one has been lynched, and the rest is just speculation. Only a baddie would know how many are left.
I'm not the one trying to say there is only one left. I think it's possible Golden could have been bad, but I'd rather lynch you and then see from there. I am not the one trying to rush votes to seal the lynch and end the game.

Lets compartmentalize this then, splints.

If there were still 2 baddies left, and you are not one of them as I assume you aren't readily admitting, which of Dom, Sorsha, and llama is the other baddie?

[Sorsha]

You have got to be kidding me. Sorry Roxy

The only reason I began trusting Scotty yesterday was his survival the night before. The night post had the two of us together and Chauncy ending up targeting Scotty then also me. It looked to me like a lovers-type role which led me to believe that's what Scotty was. The only option I saw for that was in phoebe's secret role.

It has to be splints or Scotty then.

[Sorsha]

There was some scotty/golden back and forth. Scotty had expressed suspicion of both golden and mm. I just looked through his post history in this thread.. I haven't gone back to look at it in context though.

[thellama73]

All right, I've decided to vote for Scotty. Reading back on his posts, he always lists MM as a suspect, but always behind several other people. It's the classic baddie move to lightly attack a teammate without ever really putting them in jeopardy. As long as I or Greybonez or Elo was alive, he always had an excuse not to vote for MM.

If I had to pick the 3rd teammate of llama and greybonez, I'd probably pick MM. Just on a hunch.

But I see that you have agreed with my choices of GreyboneZ/Elo and possibly MM. So apparently we're on the same page there.

Also if I could place another vote it would have been for MM.

[DFaraday]

All of the PMs are in so I'll end the night early.

[thellama73]

All of the PMs are in so I'll end the night early.

Should I vote for Scotty, DH? I want your opinion.

[DFaraday]

All of the PMs are in so I'll end the night early.

Should I vote for Scotty, DH? I want your opinion.

DH isn't here, and I can't speak for him. :P

[thellama73]

All of the PMs are in so I'll end the night early.

Should I vote for Scotty, DH? I want your opinion.

DH isn't here, and I can't speak for him. :P

You know I meant DF. :P Come on, be honest. Is Scotty bad?

[thellama73]

If you don't want to post it in the thread, you can just PM it to me.

[DFaraday]

Night 7 - Alpaca Your Bags (That was a horrible pun)



"Scandal! Fire! Murder! Liar!" exclaimed the portraits on the wall, alarmed at all the mayhem of recent weeks. "Evil! Malice! Horrid! Callous!"

"Oh, do shut up for once," said Llama wearily, walking the hall in the dead of night. "I've much on my mind if we're to find this killer in the morning. How did the death of Monty Navarro not stem this accursed tide of villainy?"

"My dear Llama, what you didn't count on was the touch...of a woman," Sibella's voice came from around the corner.

"Eh? Who's there?" said Llama, moving closer for some reason.

"A nightmare in pink," she said menacingly (or as menacingly as she could pull off). With that, Sibella pushed the suit of armor which nobody had yet claimed forward, and it crashed down around Llama. When he stood up, his head was trapped inside the helmet, which was stuck backwards on his head.

"I can't see!" he declared. Llama stumbled forward blindly, but Sibella grabbed him and waltzed her way over to a nearby furnace, which was mostly there so I could fit in a Sweeney Todd reference as she threw Llama into the furnace and sealed him in. She danced gracefully away as Llama's helmet became red hot, his mustache burning up with every second.

Llama has been killed. It is now Day 8. You have 24 hours to lynch someone.

[Scotty]

Grr. That makes me madder than I can share.

Voting splints.

If we don't do this and all vote splints, it's game over in lylo.

splints will vote me, and Sorsha and Dom have some thinking to do.

I want you both to really analyze the thread, because it's important you both make the right decision today.

[DFaraday]

I have no idea what lylo means and it's come up like 50 times this game.

[Scotty]

Also, notice how splints mysteriously disappeared when I called her out on her critiquing of my assumption of there being 1 mafia member left.

Obviously this means Golden was bad since we haven't lost.

Now tell me that all this adds up to me being bad.

I have no idea what lylo means and it's come up like 50 times this game.

lylo = lynch or lose. If we mislynch today, we lose.

[Dom]

Question: Why would splints kill Llama?

[thellama73]

Oh phooey

[Sorsha]

Question: Why would splints kill Llama?

She wouldn't. Llama was pretty obviously suspicious of Scotty.

I'm thinking of voting Scotty myself.

[Sorsha]

Also RIP llama

[Scotty]

Question: Why would splints kill Llama?

She wouldn't. Llama was pretty obviously suspicious of Scotty.

I'm thinking of voting Scotty myself.

Which is exactly why she killed him.

Why on EARTH would I kill llama, especially after his comment directly before he got killed?