[ENDGAME]:Redacted Case of Ed & Lorraine Warren

#81

thellama73 wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:
thellama73 wrote:Changing my vote for reasons which are my own.

Sorry, MR.
Why did you switch your vote then, care to share? Is it because you wanted someone lynched?
What part of "my reasons are my own" don't you understand?

I can elaborate a little. I was pretty sure that the lone baddie in a game like this wouldn't miss the first opportunity to lynch a civilian, so I wanted to protect you from being killed.

I get that thinking - and was coming back to change my vote before time ran out - but I have to ask, if you were trying to avoid Metalmarsh from being killed, why wouldn't you have switched your vote to me or AP - we were the ones that voted him after all...

#82

I'm not sure what to make of anything yet. All I know is that MR is definitely not bad.

#83

bea wrote: I get that thinking - and was coming back to change my vote before time ran out - but I have to ask, if you were trying to avoid Metalmarsh from being killed, why wouldn't you have switched your vote to me or AP - we were the ones that voted him after all...

I'm happy to talk at night. I had to make a quick decision once I decided to change my vote, and I felt like I was getting a bit of a bad "look how helpful I am" vibe from MR. I am pretty upset about how wrong I was though.

#84

thellama73 wrote:
bea wrote: I get that thinking - and was coming back to change my vote before time ran out - but I have to ask, if you were trying to avoid Metalmarsh from being killed, why wouldn't you have switched your vote to me or AP - we were the ones that voted him after all...
I'm happy to talk at night. I had to make a quick decision once I decided to change my vote, and I felt like I was getting a bit of a bad "look how helpful I am" vibe from MR. I am pretty upset about how wrong I was though.

That's fair enough - what do you think of my point about AP and his fairly lame reason for voting MetalMarsh? I know my random was lame but AP said he did it because MM was too quiet - and a look at page one says that he was anything but quiet.

#85

bea wrote: That's fair enough - what do you think of my point about AP and his fairly lame reason for voting MetalMarsh? I know my random was lame but AP said he did it because MM was too quiet - and a look at page one says that he was anything but quiet.

The trouble with AP is that he says things that make no logical sense ALL THE TIME. I think I have lynched him like three times for being illogical, and he always flips civ. That being said, I do think you make a good point and I am not feeling great about him right now.

#86

yea. IDK - cuz I know matty is always saying things that make no logical sense -

It's frustrating when he's civ and also useful when he's bad so I see why he still does it.

And for as much as his vote makes me all "wait? wot?" the defense of vompi makes me pause a bit. I know they always do, but that post read genuine to me - ya know?

And also - there is only one baddie. So it's not like there's teammate defending going on...

#87

bea wrote: And also - there is only one baddie. So it's not like there's teammate defending going on...

Ture. This is something I keep having to remind myself about. No looking for potential BTSC in this game.

#88

bea wrote:
thellama73 wrote:
bea wrote: I get that thinking - and was coming back to change my vote before time ran out - but I have to ask, if you were trying to avoid Metalmarsh from being killed, why wouldn't you have switched your vote to me or AP - we were the ones that voted him after all...
I'm happy to talk at night. I had to make a quick decision once I decided to change my vote, and I felt like I was getting a bit of a bad "look how helpful I am" vibe from MR. I am pretty upset about how wrong I was though.
That's fair enough - what do you think of my point about AP and his fairly lame reason for voting MetalMarsh? I know my random was lame but AP said he did it because MM was too quiet - and a look at page one says that he was anything but quiet.

He'd not checked in for the vote before I'd posted, and it was a fairly lame reason, but day 1 votes are always lame.

#89

A Person wrote:
bea wrote:
thellama73 wrote:
bea wrote: I get that thinking - and was coming back to change my vote before time ran out - but I have to ask, if you were trying to avoid Metalmarsh from being killed, why wouldn't you have switched your vote to me or AP - we were the ones that voted him after all...
I'm happy to talk at night. I had to make a quick decision once I decided to change my vote, and I felt like I was getting a bit of a bad "look how helpful I am" vibe from MR. I am pretty upset about how wrong I was though.
That's fair enough - what do you think of my point about AP and his fairly lame reason for voting MetalMarsh? I know my random was lame but AP said he did it because MM was too quiet - and a look at page one says that he was anything but quiet.
He'd not checked in for the vote before I'd posted, and it was a fairly lame reason, but day 1 votes are always lame.

Day 1 votes might be all we have to go off of, that, and maybe a particularly strong read or two.

#90

bea wrote:how do we feel about talking at night? In a game this small and this fast, I can't see any practical reason to avoid it outside of the last minute PM by our one baddie.

I do think though it might be a risk I'm willing to take. I can't see any way around talking at night and still making an informed decision.

thoughts? Anyone?

I think it's a necessity, then again, I'm not sure I see why we shouldn't talk at night.

Another facet of mafia I'm not used to. Where I've played, typically the thread is shut down at night from discussion.

#91

Remember to only trust your exorcisms to demonologists and other licensed, bonded and certified exorcists.

http://www.cnn.com/2014/01/19/justice/m ... ?hpt=hp_t2

Don't forget your PMs! You have plenty of time, but I'm still missing some.

#92

That... was an interesting story Mongoose.

#93

Metalmarsh89 wrote:That... was an interesting story Mongoose.

Yeah, wasn't that just awful? How scary for those poor kids.

#94

Still missing 1 PM, so don't forget.

I am off for a busy day of errands, including taking James to the vet and then getting my hair cut and re-colored for my interview with the Office of the AG on Weds (woot), but I will endeavor to get the night post done in close as proximity to the night poll's end as possible.

#95

Mongoose wrote:Remember to only trust your exorcisms to demonologists and other licensed, bonded and certified exorcists.

I don't need the government telling me which exorcists to hire. I can make that judgement for myself, thank you.

#96

Who certifies demonologists? The Demonology alliance?

#97

A tour of their Room of Curiosities:

Ed and Lorraine arrived at 3246 Pleasant Terrace. Over the week of telephone conversations with the Nykvists, activity had grossly escalated at the house. Keys went missing and were found in the butter drawer of the fridge. Shoes mysteriously appeared in the back of an unused cubby under the stairs. Most worrying though was how morose Aria had been in the last week. Barely eating and barely talking, she had grown increasingly withdrawn after the wallpaper incident.

Lars and Matteo greeted the Warrens at the door.

"My goodness, I can really feel a heavy presence in this house," Lorraine said.

Ed talked to the men while Lorraine wandered through the first floor. She shivered as she walked by the cubby under the stairs.

May I go to the upper floors?" she asked Matteo and Lars.

"Yes, of course, you have free run of the house," Lars said.

"Yeah, let us know if you need anything," Matteo added.

"And where is the child right now? Aria, where is she?" Ed asked.

"She's at a neighbor's house for the day. They have a little boy that's the same age as Aria. I think they are going to a park today," Matteo explained.

Lorraine headed up the stairs. She paused at Aria's room. She put her hand on the doorknob, but did not go inside. Instead, she went down the hall to the door that lead to the third floor. The stairs had a door at each end, which made the air in that stairwell quite heavy and stagnant.

"I'm going up to third floor," she said to the men below.

"Wait until we get up there!" Ed said from below.

As Ed, Matteo and Lars hustled up the stairs, Lorraine opened up the bottom door of the stairwell. Stepping gingerly, she was taken aback by the palpable level of dread she was feeling. The men had reached the second floor and Ed was standing at the bottom of the stairs, holding the door open.

"Should we follow her?" Matteo asked Ed.

"Not just yet," Ed replied. "I like to give her a little space to figure out who we have living here with you first."

Lorraine reached the top of the stairs and opened the door. As she tried to enter the darkened room, she was pushed down the stairs.

thellama73 has been killed by The Demon.

It is now Day 2. You have 24 hours to lynch someone.

#98

Which case file of the Warrens' do you find most interesting? (NPs & Deadies Can Vote)

The Lutz Family (Amityville Horror is based upon this)
1
S~V~S (6) 17%

The Smurl Family
1
bea (5) 17%

Annabelle (the haunted doll)
1
Mongoose (1) 17%

The Perron Family (The Conjuring is based upon this)
0
No votes

Arne Johnson (The Demon Murder Trial)
1
thellama73 (3) 17%

Demonic Werewolf
1
Vompatti (2) 17%

Snedecker Family (The Haunting in Connecticut is based upon this)
1
MovingPictures07 (4) 17%

Total votes : 6

#99

Aw man.

#100

Why am I not on the poll?

Let it be known that I have no idea whatsoever why I'm not on the poll.

#101

A LIKELY STORY

also MR must've been resurrected.

#102

Vompatti wrote:Why am I not on the poll?

Let it be known that I have no idea whatsoever why I'm not on the poll.

You are there, but as "Wombat"

#103

like a glove...

#104

Mongoose wrote:
Vompatti wrote:Why am I not on the poll?

Let it be known that I have no idea whatsoever why I'm not on the poll.
You are there, but as "Wombat"

ture

#105

RIP Llama - that sucks.

So.....who we looking at today? I've got nothing but my slight ping on matty. If I can't find anything else, it'll be where my vote ends up going...

#106

also - I have pretty much tonight and first thing tomorrow morning, I'll have to vote before work as the poll ends during my lunch rush. Fair warning has been given.

#107

thellama73 wrote:Aw man.

Sorry to see you go llama. I think I realized why you switched your vote in the end yesterday.

#108

bea wrote:also - I have pretty much tonight and first thing tomorrow morning, I'll have to vote before work as the poll ends during my lunch rush. Fair warning has been given.

I have a little bit of time this evening and in the morning as well.

#109

Guys, I've been asked to teach some Writin' tomorrow, so I am extending the Day period until 5pm EST.

Don't forget to vote. We're already halfway through!

#110

bea wrote:
A Person wrote:I vote metalmarsh because he's been suspcicious ly quiet

So - I reread the thread. (I know - it took foreeeeever. ) And in this kinda bothers me.

Metalmarsh was waaaay more vocal on the last page than I was. How is that suspiciously quiet?

I'd say you're both correct about Day 1. I was active, but I hadn't really offered anything productive.

#111

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
thellama73 wrote:Aw man.
Sorry to see you go llama. I think I realized why you switched your vote in the end yesterday.

since you have time - would you care to elaborate on his reasoning? Or is it still something that can't be talked about?

I have issues with the tie lynch and the fact that MR died anyway. I think I understand *why* MR died, I just need bit of help connecting the dots.

Also - what do you think of APerson? or Vompibat? Or Me?

awe - MM - that's what I'm calling you - is that ok? or do you have a preference for something else?

you re-read the REAAAAAAAAALLLLLY hard to re-read thread too.

YAY YOU!

#112

MM works, or Marsh, I'll notice those easiest

There's only one way MR could have died, and that's because of Lars Nykvist's role of getting the possibility of a double vote. So that means Wombat or llama had that role, and based on llama's statement about switching, I believe it was him. Yes Llama originally suggested a no lynch, but he also apologized to MR after he voted, possibly insinuating MR was going to die. Llama also clarified that a tie would result in a no lynch, so there's more info to back that theory up.

thellama73 wrote:Changing my vote for reasons which are my own.

Sorry, MR.

There's the other possibility that Wombat has the aforementioned role, but I don't believe that is the case based on the above information.

#113

bea wrote:you re-read the REAAAAAAAAALLLLLY hard to re-read thread too. YAY YOU!

Luckily, there wasn't that much to read.

#114

Metalmarsh89 wrote:MM works, or Marsh, I'll notice those easiest

There's only one way MR could have died, and that's because of Lars Nykvist's role of getting the possibility of a double vote. So that means Wombat or llama had that role, and based on llama's statement about switching, I believe it was him. Yes Llama originally suggested a no lynch, but he also apologized to MR after he voted, possibly insinuating MR was going to die. Llama also clarified that a tie would result in a no lynch, so there's more info to back that theory up.

thellama73 wrote:Changing my vote for reasons which are my own.

Sorry, MR.

There's the other possibility that Wombat has the aforementioned role, but I don't believe that is the case based on the above information.

Marsh it is! I'm going with the one you suggested. I was Beatrice828 on sites for like ever - it was always naturally shortened to bea. If somehow somewhere someone just decided they would refer to me as 828 - even though it's my birthday - I would still be - "just call me bea. I'll recognize that." - Sorta like A person and "matty" At some point, He'll just be Matty. See what PA's habit of using real names gets you Matty?

And - your thinking is exactly what my thinking was. Before the night - I was convinced that either Lama or Vompibat was Lars, just wasn't sure which one. After the NK - I think you are right as well.

So - who do you think? vomibat or A Matty?

I know I'm a civ - so I've obviously taken myself out of that equation.

I'd also like to hear from both of them before I vote, because - hellz bells Marsh - you could have killed llama. Don't think I'm not also thinking that as well.

#115

bea wrote:I'd also like to hear from both of them before I vote, because - hellz bells Marsh - you could have killed llama. Don't think I'm not also thinking that as well.

Likewise on the others. Naturally, we need everyone's input.

I'm still crunching possibilities in my head, which I'll probably end up sleeping on. I'm possibly thinking Wombat, but that's not a very strong FOS. I think it was more circumstantial than anything else that he had voted MR on that lynch. But Llama had voted him before he switched to MR for the lynch.

As for Matty, I don't get the whole thing about me being quiet, as if I was the only one. He hasn't said much yesterday or today for that matter. Quite the behavior for someone who's expecting more from me.

And of course I haven't ruled you out bea, but I'm getting the strongest town vibes from you. But that very well could just be your playing style. If you try a random vote again today, I'm voting you without question.

#116

nope - no random at all ever again. I just needed to get my feel for the micro aspect of the game. I used to be a pretty decent speed player - but I've not played *quick* games in AGES - so I kept thinking day 1 I had more time- and I really -when I re-read - and saw how vocal you were on d1 - made me be all "FUCK!!! FUCK!!! I FUCKED UP HERE!!" and while I was trying to show why I was changing my vote (re matty's weird reasoning - ) the fucking vote ended.

honestly - at this point - matty has to make a really great case as to why I SHOULDN'T vote him.

Because it's where my natural insticts are telling me.

#117

Gentle Reminder: You have until 5pm EST to cast (or change) your ballot.

As for A Person, I'm rather prone to calling him "Mattmatt"

#118

I voted for A Person because it was unexpected of me.

#119

going with A Person because it's the only ping I got.

#120

Lizzy wrote:

like a glove...

#121

MattMattMatty, anything to say? We need your voice here!

#122

I think Matt is dead.

#123

2.5 hours to vote or finalize your vote!

#124

Vompatti wrote:I think Matt is dead.

I think so. I voted him, but this may help us learn something depending on his role.

#125

Matteo, Lars, and Ed rushed to Lorraine's side. He and Matteo hauled her up and toted her into their bedroom, where she could rest. Matteo kneeled by her bedside while Lars rushed to make her some coffee. Ed sat next to her, fingering his rosary.

Suddenly, Aria ran into the room, hair askew, and her eyes solid white. She put her hands around Matteo neck and snapped it with a loud thwack.

A Person has been lynched.

He was Matteo Primero.

It is now Night 2. You have 24 hours to send in your night actions and vote in the optional night poll.

#126

Who sacrificed a rather hirsute llama to The Demon at Pleasant Terrace?

You may select 1 option

A Person
3
Vompatti (4), bea (5), Metalmarsh89 (7)
43%

Bea
0
No votes

MetalMarsh89
0
No votes

Wombat
0
No votes

The Harry Stephen Keeler Mafia (Host/Deadie/NPs)
4
Mongoose (1), MovingPictures07 (2), Lizzy (3), Mister Rearranger (6)
57%

#127

#128

As for the poll, apart from the TS members, I don't have any of the above.

#129

#130

damnit.

RIP Matty - I'm sorry.

Also - of the list, my cats are prolly the least possessed. They are the truely wise ones in this house tbh.

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

Did You Have Fun?