Dethy Mafia [Game Over]

#81

So what's the plan for tonight fellas? Other than avoid gettin killed out there on the streets.

#82

Turnip Head wrote:So what's the plan for tonight fellas? Other than avoid gettin killed out there on the streets.

Started a couple of TV shows this weekend, The Sopranos and It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia. I'm already obsessed with both.

#83

I'm going to check dear old FZ.

#84

insertnamehere wrote:
Turnip Head wrote:So what's the plan for tonight fellas? Other than avoid gettin killed out there on the streets.
Started a couple of TV shows this weekend, The Sopranos and It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia. I'm already obsessed with both.

How have you survived this long without seeing either of these?

insertnamehere wrote:I'm going to check dear old FZ.

Me too.

I assume FZ and Llama will check each other. Or rather one of them will, and the other will lie about it.

#85

Gol blimey. I a really annoyed about this. I was sure Lizzy was the one. I am going to check FZ tonight.

#86

thellama73 wrote:Gol blimey. I a really annoyed about this. I was sure Lizzy was the one. I am going to check FZ tonight.

Please don't kill me, Constable llama sir.

#87

Turnip Head wrote:
thellama73 wrote:Gol blimey. I a really annoyed about this. I was sure Lizzy was the one. I am going to check FZ tonight.
Please don't kill me, Constable llama sir.

I do not have the power to do so.

#88

#89

^ ... well feck

#90

For real??? I was freaking sure she was the baddie.

The only way that could be was if she just lied about her night info. It's possible with how she talked about wanting the baddie to win, but seriously, WTF?

You can be sure llama is my next investigation. I have no problem with all of you investigating me. I think maybe one of us should investigate himself to get a definite answer on the nature of at least one cop. But if you feel looking at me will help more, go ahead

#91

You're not allowed to investigate yourself btw. I asked. :P

#92

Turnip Head wrote:You're not allowed to investigate yourself btw. I asked. :P

Bummer. I was quite pleased with myself for thinking about it

Okay then, I'm going to go with llama. You all do what you want to do.

#93

FZ. wrote:
Turnip Head wrote:You're not allowed to investigate yourself btw. I asked. :P
Bummer. I was quite pleased with myself for thinking about it Okay then, I'm going to go with llama. You all do what you want to do.

And I'm investigating you. You have to be the baddie, assuming Lizzy didn't just lie to screw over the civs, so tonight will tell me which cop I am.

#94

thellama73 wrote:
FZ. wrote:
Turnip Head wrote:You're not allowed to investigate yourself btw. I asked. :P
Bummer. I was quite pleased with myself for thinking about it Okay then, I'm going to go with llama. You all do what you want to do.
And I'm investigating you. You have to be the baddie, assuming Lizzy didn't just lie to screw over the civs, so tonight will tell me which cop I am.

Looks like you're preparing the lies already. I don't know what happened with Lizzy, but we somehow screwed up and she wasn't really helping us make a better decision. It's going to come down to your word against mine, unless again, I'm missing something. I have no idea what. Good luck, because obviously, the two of us will still be alive next day, lol

#95

FZ. wrote:
thellama73 wrote:
FZ. wrote:
Turnip Head wrote:You're not allowed to investigate yourself btw. I asked. :P
Bummer. I was quite pleased with myself for thinking about it Okay then, I'm going to go with llama. You all do what you want to do.
And I'm investigating you. You have to be the baddie, assuming Lizzy didn't just lie to screw over the civs, so tonight will tell me which cop I am.
Looks like you're preparing the lies already. I don't know what happened with Lizzy, but we somehow screwed up and she wasn't really helping us make a better decision. It's going to come down to your word against mine, unless again, I'm missing something. I have no idea what. Good luck, because obviously, the two of us will still be alive next day, lol

Either you are the baddie or Lizzy lied for no reason. I think the former is more likely. I realize others may conclude the same thing about me, but I hope other people's investigations will prove my innocence.

#96

FZ. wrote:
thellama73 wrote:
FZ. wrote:
Turnip Head wrote:You're not allowed to investigate yourself btw. I asked. :P
Bummer. I was quite pleased with myself for thinking about it Okay then, I'm going to go with llama. You all do what you want to do.
And I'm investigating you. You have to be the baddie, assuming Lizzy didn't just lie to screw over the civs, so tonight will tell me which cop I am.
Looks like you're preparing the lies already. I don't know what happened with Lizzy, but we somehow screwed up and she wasn't really helping us make a better decision. It's going to come down to your word against mine, unless again, I'm missing something. I have no idea what. Good luck, because obviously, the two of us will still be alive next day, lol

Night 0.

TH asks us all to check him, and report back the findings. He's going to check Llama.

Day 0.

You, Lizzy, and Llama all find TH innocent. I find him guilty. One of you was lying. It wasn't Lizzy, obviously. TH checked Llama Night 0, and found him guilty.

Those are the facts based on the thread. Based on this, the logical assumption is that you are bad. This is assuming everyone but the baddie was honest about their role check.

#97

A little over 2 hours until the deadline. Don't forget to PM me your night action!

#98

Hello?

#99

insertnamehere wrote:Hello?

Hi. How are you?

#100

thellama73 wrote:
insertnamehere wrote:Hello?
Hi. How are you?

Doing okay. Found this: http://www.enterthelodge.com/entryway/ Someone's using twitter as a storytelling format in order to tell the story of a prospective Twin Peaks season three. So, I'm going to be doing nothing but reading that for the next couple of weeks. You may not be seeing me much. This type of stuff is like masturbation for me.

#101

Do you think our host is gone forever? That would be sad, to be trapped for an eternity with an evil baddie on the loose.

#102

If you want, I can just host Twin Peaks Mafia again. Maybe with a Fire Walk With Me theme! C'mon guys, let's do that!

#103

I'm just sittin' here watching the wheels go 'round and 'round.

#104

Sign me up for your mafia-within-a-mafia, Eddie.

#105

Jokes on you, this was Mulholland Drive Mafia the whole time!

#106

What happened? It's not day yet?

And INH, I want to play in the MD game, so I can't help you host

#107

What if there was a mafia game where everyone thought they had roles, but really they didn't?

#108

FZ, the suspense might literally kill me: who did you NK?

#109

thellama73 wrote:Do you think our host is gone forever? That would be sad, to be trapped for an eternity with an evil baddie on the loose.

No, you just have an irresponsible host who's gotten a little Irish.

#110

It looks like Turnip Head did not make it through the night alive.

Turnip Head was killed by the baddie

Day 2 has now begun. You have 24 hours to lynch someone.

#111

Turnip Head wrote:What if there was a mafia game where everyone thought they had roles, but really they didn't?

Don't tempt me. This game isn't over yet.

#112

TH, come join me at the zombie bar!

What can I get you?

#113

I'm sorry, TH! I should have listened to you about FZ yesterday. Don't worry, though. You will be avenged.
I investigated FZ and got innocent, meaning I am the Naive Cop. Lizzy was the Sane Cop. INH is either paranoid or insane (no surprises there). And I'm voting for FZ.

#114

thellama73 wrote:I'm sorry, TH! I should have listened to you about FZ yesterday. Don't worry, though. You will be avenged.
I investigated FZ and got innocent, meaning I am the Naive Cop. Lizzy was the Sane Cop. INH is either paranoid or insane (no surprises there). And I'm voting for FZ.

On Night 0, I investigated TH, and I got a result of guilty. Obviously, that was incorrect. Last night, I investigated FZ, and got a result of innocent. I see no other solution other than I am the insane cop, and FZ is the baddie. Definitely voting her.

#115

I know this looks bad for me, but llama, you have to trust me on this. I said I was going to investigate you, but I investigate INH, because he was really quiet this game after last game. So I thought if Lizzie was really messing with us, and wanted the baddie to win, the only person she didn't say could be the baddie was INH. She started with voting you. Then said was a genius baddie, and then voted for me. I think she wanted to mess with us, and I don't know who she investigated the first night, but maybe she bluffed.

Anyway, I thought that if she did bluff, that would mean you and me could both be telling the truth about TH, and INH was lying. I thought I'd say I'm going to look into you so he won't be afraid to say what he "found". I really investigated him, and found out he's the baddie, so I think I'm actually the sane cop, and he's just the baddie. I guess Lizzie was a naive or paranoid cop, but we just didn't get anything from her.

I know you don't want to trust me, but I also think that INH killed TH to make me look really bad.
Listen to me. If you vote me, you're losing the game for us with your own two hands. I beg you to reconsider!!!

#116

Lizzy wrote:TH, come join me at the zombie bar! What can I get you?

I'll have one of everything.

#117

FZ. wrote:I know this looks bad for me, but llama, you have to trust me on this. I said I was going to investigate you, but I investigate INH, because he was really quiet this game after last game. So I thought if Lizzie was really messing with us, and wanted the baddie to win, the only person she didn't say could be the baddie was INH. She started with voting you. Then said was a genius baddie, and then voted for me. I think she wanted to mess with us, and I don't know who she investigated the first night, but maybe she bluffed.

Anyway, I thought that if she did bluff, that would mean you and me could both be telling the truth about TH, and INH was lying. I thought I'd say I'm going to look into you so he won't be afraid to say what he "found". I really investigated him, and found out he's the baddie, so I think I'm actually the sane cop, and he's just the baddie. I guess Lizzie was a naive or paranoid cop, but we just didn't get anything from her.

I know you don't want to trust me, but I also think that INH killed TH to make me look really bad.
Listen to me. If you vote me, you're losing the game for us with your own two hands. I beg you to reconsider!!!

Let's think about this. If I assume that you, I and TH all told the truth, then you have to be sane, I have to be naive, TH has to be paranoid or insane, leaving one paranoid or insane cop left and one baddie, split between LIzzy and INH. We know lizzy wasn't the baddie, so she would have been either paranoid or insane, and gotten a guilty result when investigating TH. You're alleging that she got a guilty result and reported innocent for no reason. This would also require INH to report a guilty result when he really had none. He then would have had to lie about getting an innocent result for you, pretending to be the insane cop, which would make sense if what you say is true.

I simply do not believe Lizzy would deliberately throw the game for the civs when she is a civ. She is crazy, but not that crazy.

#118

Your story would also require a level of lucid cunning from INH that doesn't fit in with what I know of him as a somewhat daring and unconventional player.

#119

thellama73 wrote:
FZ. wrote:I know this looks bad for me, but llama, you have to trust me on this. I said I was going to investigate you, but I investigate INH, because he was really quiet this game after last game. So I thought if Lizzie was really messing with us, and wanted the baddie to win, the only person she didn't say could be the baddie was INH. She started with voting you. Then said was a genius baddie, and then voted for me. I think she wanted to mess with us, and I don't know who she investigated the first night, but maybe she bluffed.

Anyway, I thought that if she did bluff, that would mean you and me could both be telling the truth about TH, and INH was lying. I thought I'd say I'm going to look into you so he won't be afraid to say what he "found". I really investigated him, and found out he's the baddie, so I think I'm actually the sane cop, and he's just the baddie. I guess Lizzie was a naive or paranoid cop, but we just didn't get anything from her.

I know you don't want to trust me, but I also think that INH killed TH to make me look really bad.
Listen to me. If you vote me, you're losing the game for us with your own two hands. I beg you to reconsider!!!
Let's think about this. If I assume that you, I and TH all told the truth, then you have to be sane, I have to be naive, TH has to be paranoid or insane, leaving one paranoid or insane cop left and one baddie, split between LIzzy and INH. We know lizzy wasn't the baddie, so she would have been either paranoid or insane, and gotten a guilty result when investigating TH. You're alleging that she got a guilty result and reported innocent for no reason. This would also require INH to report a guilty result when he really had none. He then would have had to lie about getting an innocent result for you, pretending to be the insane cop, which would make sense if what you say is true.

I simply do not believe Lizzy would deliberately throw the game for the civs when she is a civ. She is crazy, but not that crazy.

Sadly, I can't stay and discuss this, because I have deadline for a job I took, and I'm so behind on it, and it's someone's thesis, so I can't play with that. But I don't want us to lose so I'll say what I can. All my interpretations are ad-hock, because I'm basing it on what's happened. I don't know INH very well, so I have no idea how conniving he or can be, but if there was ever an opportunity to try that out, this is just the type of game to do it. Don't forget about his Malhulland Drive mafia idea. Seems kind of conniving to me. Last game he was very proactive. I don't see him doing that this game. He's reacting...and in this game, the baddies needs to be reacting, because he has to sit and wait.
I don't know if Lizzie is the kind of player to throw a game, but if she was bluffing, then she probably realized INH was lying, and maybe that's why he's the only one she didn't mention could be a baddie. At this point, she wanted the baddie to win. I have no idea why, but she said so. I think that since MM said that info dumping is encouraged and more so if it's lying, she went with it. With the little I got to know her, it wouldn't surprise me at all.

I've said all I can. If it doesn't convince you I can't do anything about it, but it's the truth. Do with that what you will.
I don't know if I'll be here until the day ends.
It's all up to you llama.

#120

I would be a fool to change my vote in the face of all evidence, just based on your word. But I have to give you credit, you make a very compelling and impassioned argument. Your Latin is wrong though, so if nothing lse, it's worth lynching you for that.

#121

If you end up being right, I will be very sorry, but I have to make the logical decision here.

#122

thellama73 wrote:I would be a fool to change my vote in the face of all evidence, just based on your word. But I have to give you credit, you make a very compelling and impassioned argument. Your Latin is wrong though, so if nothing lse, it's worth lynching you for that.

English is not my native language, so since I don't write Latin, that is a very poor excuse for lynching me, not to mention the fact that your spelling is wrong, and English is your mother tongue.

Joking aside, while I can see why you are seeing things this way, and I'm not sure I would listen to me either, it's the truth! And not only will you be lynching me, but you'll be getting yourself killed and losing us all the game. If you want to joke about that, go ahead.

#123

Mafia isn't always about logic, but I guess I can't fault you. It's really kind of sad, because we were 4 and he's just one, and TH's idea was great. I can't believe we blew it. Sucks.

Okay, I can't stay anymore.

#124

FZ. wrote:Mafia isn't always about logic, but I guess I can't fault you. It's really kind of sad, because we were 4 and he's just one, and TH's idea was great. I can't believe we blew it. Sucks.

Okay, I can't stay anymore.

Just think about how I would feel if I voted against all logic and ended up being wrong. I would never live it down.

#125

There's three problems with your theory FZ.

1: Why wouldn't Lizzy say "Hey, I checked INH and he was bad" when the game began? There was still a pretty decent amount of time and posts before she apparently gave up on the game, if she wanted to help the civvies, why not at least mention my name?

2: I think that Lizzy was joking when she said that she wanted the baddie to win. I've played with her before, and she has never struck me as the type to ruin a whole teams game just because she got lynched.

3: I wish I was that good at playing mafia to pull off a move like that. My "talents" trend more towards the hosting side of things, and when I do participate in some crazy fucking scheme or something, it's usually an off-the-cuff, "Hey, why not?" type play. For example, I pretended to have some magical program that looked at players posting history, ran it through an algorithm, and was able to tell whether or not a player was bad using statistics. I didn't know at the time that one of the other players made computer algorithms that used statistics for his job, and saw through my bullshit immediately. That's maybe the most thought-out game I've played so far.

#126

FZ. wrote:
thellama73 wrote:I would be a fool to change my vote in the face of all evidence, just based on your word. But I have to give you credit, you make a very compelling and impassioned argument. Your Latin is wrong though, so if nothing lse, it's worth lynching you for that.
English is not my native language, so since I don't write Latin, that is a very poor excuse for lynching me, not to mention the fact that your spelling is wrong, and English is your mother tongue.

And since we're being pedantic, my spelling isn't bad, my typing is. There exists a difference. Not having English as your first language gives you even less of an excuse to not know Latin and to misspell ad hoc.

#127

thellama73 wrote:
FZ. wrote:Mafia isn't always about logic, but I guess I can't fault you. It's really kind of sad, because we were 4 and he's just one, and TH's idea was great. I can't believe we blew it. Sucks.

Okay, I can't stay anymore.
Just think about how I would feel if I voted against all logic and ended up being wrong. I would never live it down.

I'm so going to pay for this. I don't like losing as a civvie, so if I end up getting lynched and won't finish my work, I'm never going to let you live this down. Just because TH said I was the baddie, doesn't make it more logical. Check my answer to INH for the rest of this logic explanation...

insertnamehere wrote:There's three problems with your theory FZ.

1: Why wouldn't Lizzy say "Hey, I checked INH and he was bad" when the game began? There was still a pretty decent amount of time and posts before she apparently gave up on the game, if she wanted to help the civvies, why not at least mention my name?

2: I think that Lizzy was joking when she said that she wanted the baddie to win. I've played with her before, and she has never struck me as the type to ruin a whole teams game just because she got lynched.

3: I wish I was that good at playing mafia to pull off a move like that. My "talents" trend more towards the hosting side of things, and when I do participate in some crazy fucking scheme or something, it's usually an off-the-cuff, "Hey, why not?" type play. For example, I pretended to have some magical program that looked at players posting history, ran it through an algorithm, and was able to tell whether or not a player was bad using statistics. I didn't know at the time that one of the other players made computer algorithms that used statistics for his job, and saw through my bullshit immediately. That's maybe the most thought-out game I've played so far.

I love how you're saying there are problems with my theory, yet you're not calling me a baddie. It's like you're afraid to push this too hard, or llama will think you're sweating.
1. I think Lizzie decided to make things interesting long before she was voted for. You can even see it in her attitude before she even got one vote. So she didn't say anything like you're suggesting. Plus, I have no idea if she investigated you or not. She could have investigated TH and just lied about the results to mix things up. When I said she might have known you were lying, I was assuming it was based on your "results"

2. I have no idea how she is, because I've barely played with her, but she seems like a funky person (I'm bad at English slang), who would do crazy things, especially in a small game where it's not that serious, and no harm will really be done.

3. When people say "I wish I were that good", it just makes me think they are, but I guess we'll just have to see.

thellama73 wrote:
FZ. wrote:
thellama73 wrote:I would be a fool to change my vote in the face of all evidence, just based on your word. But I have to give you credit, you make a very compelling and impassioned argument. Your Latin is wrong though, so if nothing lse, it's worth lynching you for that.
English is not my native language, so since I don't write Latin, that is a very poor excuse for lynching me, not to mention the fact that your spelling is wrong, and English is your mother tongue.
And since we're being pedantic, my spelling isn't bad, my typing is. There exists a difference. Not having English as your first language gives you even less of an excuse to not know Latin and to misspell ad hoc.

Since we're elaborating on this, I'll just have you know, that I actually wrote ad hoc, yet the stupid spell checker told me I was wrong, and it suggested the "ad hock", so I thought that's how it's written when "said" in English. So will you now change your vote?

#128

FZ. wrote:So will you now change your vote?

No. :P

Bottom line is, your theory requires more assumptions than mine. I don't see a reason to make those assumptions.

#129

Suit yourself

I did my best. Loss is on you, not me. I was the only one seeing the truth.

#130

One last try, and then I'm moving to the other game or going to sleep.

llama, are you sure there's nothing that can change your mind? I think INH has been playing an incredible game, and he knew who to kill as well. But you're making a terrible mistake and now would be a good time to wake up and smell the coffee

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

Who was it that killed poor Turnip Head?