[ENDGAME] ONE DIRECTION MICRO MAFIA

#81

SVS The point i am making is I DID NOT get a prize so the only way i can see Sabie and I survived was if we got something special unaware to us like - votes on that poll. I keep stressing i DONT know how i survived and am giving a solution i think makes sense. I dont think Sabie is bad, and i know i am not bad.

#82

Well, I guess we'll see. If i do die, I think it is probably not you that killed me, fwiw.

#83

why sabie AND you, Boogs? I'm not sure why you are assuming you both survived, even if it was a tie one of you would be lynched, not both. That is what doesn't make sense to me. Well I mean besides the host not telling you the result and keeping it secret and the fact that you are ignoring that their are baddie secrets

#84

Fingersplints i'm not ignoring secrets. I'm relying on the fact that I know my role and it doesn't include anything that would have saved me. I dont read Sabie as bad, so either I'm wrong and she is bad or something with the poll some how helped us. It's plain and simple. This kitty is not lying.

#85

So who do you read as bad?

#86

No tough reads yet SVS, but I don't know about Roxy or Fingersplints, also because the seemed to tag team quickly sabie was more innocent than me for some reason. The rest of us have been more talkative so I can't get as good vibes yet. Juliets and Kate also has been not as talkative. I mean if I had to vote right now, maybe Roxy just because she seemed to jump on me quickly. Idk. I don't want to No U Fingersplints but I just don't understand why she can't think I honestly don't know how I survived and throw out the option im bad. I doubt we (sabie and i) were both "secretly" able to not be lynched. That would be way too powerful for a team of 2 mafia to have. Also the fact that no other roles have anything the appears to have lynch saves or anything listed rules out we both were spared per role reasons. The only other option has to be that poll. I know I didn't get anything, but I wouldn't rule out maybe we got - votes and didn't die because of it some how.

#87

S the only person you have a strong opinion on is Sabie?

#88

S~V~S wrote:S the only person you have a strong opinion on is Sabie?

I do basEd on how we both survived with nothing to do with roles.

#89

How do you know her survival had nothing to do with her role?

I don;t mean to be pokey, but you did say this.

#90

How do you know it wasn't role related unless you know sabies role? the only roles with btsc are the baddies

linki great minds think alike

#91

S~V~S wrote:How do you know her survival had nothing to do with her role?

I don;t mean to be pokey, but you did say this.

SVs because I would have to also survive the same way and AGAIN the only two unknown roles are Baddies. That would make us both have to be bad and unlynchable which is very unlikely since baddies night kill.

#92

No.....only one of you got lynched, right?

#93

I can't believe you guys are doubting the poll as a possibility with all the games of mafia you have played and think we both would have to be bad and have the same power. Slim chances guys. I've never seen a game where the mafia can't be lynched for more than 1 role especially considering it was the same day. I know my role again, and it doesn't involve me surviving that poll.

Linki Yes but are you saying One of us is bad then when he randomized a tie? If that is a yes answer, then im wrong and it's Sabie that is bad.

#94

Dom wrote:
S~V~S wrote:Dom, do ties result in no death?
No. I randomize ties.

Dom has already clarified in the event of a tie he randomizes

#95

You keep sayong "both", but only one of you was lynched. Not both.

#96

And this is IF the lynch was tied.

Boogs has there never been a tie in a game you played before? I'm just getting really confused now as to why you'd even assume both of you were lynched where in this three page game Dom already clarified what happens in the event of a tie.

#97

S~V~S wrote:You keep sayong "both", but only one of you was lynched. Not both.

Wow I feel dumb. Okay I understand now. I was assuming both tied and I wasn't undrstanding you guys saying only one gets lynched. I Admit I am having a blonde moment. Then yes, SVS if option A) I was going to die my role again doesn't involve lynch saves so then B) Sabie was going to die and her role may involve a save. Then I must agree, one of us must be bad but I know my role so then Sabie could indeed be bad.

Fingersplints: Linki I know some games state a player decides ties so I was not reading and comprehending what you both were saying. I'm thinking Sabie was chosen and the role saved her.

#98

Yes boogs vote for me again for voting a pothead mixed with your reason that I pointed out you were being evasive after the lynch. Funny bc you were and still aare.

First you say it was not a poll prize. Then on to say its not role related openly speculating that on a team of 2 it would be too powerful, then you say it could be a secret vote thing from the day 0 poll.

How many more reasons do you have to share?

No way it would have been a secret poll prize as I was notified not of a prize for my poll vote for pothead but a punishment. So I have every reason to believe you would have been notified if your poll choice did or did not win and what the prize or consequence was.

Why do you want me dead so bad?

#99

Also why do youthink sabie was chosen for the lynch boogs?

#100

Roxy wrote:Also why do youthink sabie was chosen for the lynch boogs?

Because i have nothing that would save me from a lynch. That leaves her.

#101

And.....

#102

Night 1: Kate Had That One Thing

Kate rushed to her car in the parking garage. It was a long day at work, and she was more than eager to get home. After she got into the car, she noticed a sheet of paper on the back of her car. She got out to remove it, leaving the door open with the keys in the car. Justin Bieber rushed to her drivers seat, and threw the car in reverse, crushing her to death.

Kate has died.
It is now day 2.
You have 24 hours to lynch someone.

#103

I accidentally put the Host/Non option before Sabie. So, just don't vote the llama option

#104

Boogs wrote:
S~V~S wrote:You keep sayong "both", but only one of you was lynched. Not both.
Wow I feel dumb. Okay I understand now. I was assuming both tied and I wasn't undrstanding you guys saying only one gets lynched. I Admit I am having a blonde moment. Then yes, SVS if option A) I was going to die my role again doesn't involve lynch saves so then B) Sabie was going to die and her role may involve a save. Then I must agree, one of us must be bad but I know my role so then Sabie could indeed be bad.

Fingersplints: Linki I know some games state a player decides ties so I was not reading and comprehending what you both were saying. I'm thinking Sabie was chosen and the role saved her.

Please give an example of a game where the player decides in the event of a lynch tie.

#105

Actually, I have seen a few tie breaker roles. I think Epi had the first in MOTU. Perhaps you have not seen them Splints.

I think Kate was a very unusual choice for the NK. I don't see why a baddie Zayn voter would kill her, tbh. But I could be off, that is just my opinion.

#106

Rip Kate

Very odd.
Fingersplints in Epignosis X men game i played as well as my Pokemon game i hosted had a Civ character decide ties.

#107

I apologize to my host and my fellow players for not being here yesterday. I was here some of the time and had every intention of coming into the thread to add my two cents and vote in the night poll but I had an issue that drew me away and then I fell asleep! These 11:30 end times are going to kill me but thats ok. I won't miss voting again.

I'm having a hard time trying to decide what happened in the lynch. The thing that makes the most sense to me is someone had vote manips or there was a lynch stop. If one of sadie or boots were bad they or their team could have either (or both depending on what those secrets are in the baddie roles). I'm also trying to think through whether there is a way they could both be civ but so far I'm seeing only bad-civ or bad-bad. I'm going to have to re-read the thread this morning to re-visit the logic being used about the whole thing.

Also, I did not hear from Dom about a prize for my vote for Nialls (hope i spelled that right).

RIP Kate

. I don't understand that NK at all and she didn't say very much it didn't seem to me. Anyway Kate, please play another game soon!

#108

S~V~S wrote:Actually, I have seen a few tie breaker roles. I think Epi had the first in MOTU. Perhaps you have not seen them Splints.

I think Kate was a very unusual choice for the NK. I don't see why a baddie Zayn voter would kill her, tbh. But I could be off, that is just my opinion.

Ok this is why I asked him. But it doesn't seem to be the case in this game anyways since he thought they both were lynched so it's still just him throwing out another excuse.

#109

fingersplints wrote:
S~V~S wrote:Actually, I have seen a few tie breaker roles. I think Epi had the first in MOTU. Perhaps you have not seen them Splints.

I think Kate was a very unusual choice for the NK. I don't see why a baddie Zayn voter would kill her, tbh. But I could be off, that is just my opinion.
Ok this is why I asked him. But it doesn't seem to be the case in this game anyways since he thought they both were lynched so it's still just him throwing out another excuse.

and again that would be a baddie role since it's clearly not a civvie.

#110

Anyways, I'm voting Boogs. He has not provided me with a good civvie reason why he was saved from the lynch except a possible secret prize which I've already said seems unlikely.

#111

All this stuff happens when I'm not here. I'm not bad I don't know why either of us survived the lynch. Does surviving a lynch necessarily make someone bad? I don't know. It doesn't in my case but I can't speak for Boogs.

#112

I am voting boogs too prob but I am waiting to see if reponds to my other post from last night. he skipped over it and responded to another of my posts.

#113

Roxy i think sabie was because i know my role doesnt have lynch save abilities. However another thing that could have happened was a lynch stop or save used on whichever of us was going to die. For example, if the 1D Who has the extra vote in lynches voted us and it was unequal, someone couldhave assumed we wweren't bad and tried to save us which explains the "not a tie" as Dom stated because one of us had an extra vote.

#114

And sorry i drew a blank on tje name and I'm on my phone. Harry voted us.

#115

Roxy wrote:Yes boogs vote for me again for voting a pothead mixed with your reason that I pointed out you were being evasive after the lynch. Funny bc you were and still aare.

First you say it was not a poll prize. Then on to say its not role related openly speculating that on a team of 2 it would be too powerful, then you say it could be a secret vote thing from the day 0 poll.

How many more reasons do you have to share?

No way it would have been a secret poll prize as I was notified not of a prize for my poll vote for pothead but a punishment. So I have every reason to believe you would have been notified if your poll choice did or did not win and what the prize or consequence was.

Why do you want me dead so bad?

This was the post I wanted you to respond to. If you are still around. You already stated that about sabie once before.

#116

I am voting for Sabie; we keep griling Boogs, but she keeps saying the same thing over and over; whether or not she was asleep has no bearing, that is what teammates are for.

Boogs sounds pretty sincere to me, he usually gets a bit hissier when he is bad, IMO.

#117

I see Sabie voted for Boogs without posting.

#118

S~V~S you rang a bell for me - he does get hissy when he's bad and suspected. I had forgotten that hallmark of his playstyle. I don't know who I'm going to vote just yet - I want to re-read the little bit that has been said and sabies replies first.

#119

Boogs wrote:Roxy i think sabie was because i know my role doesnt have lynch save abilities. However another thing that could have happened was a lynch stop or save used on whichever of us was going to die. For example, if the 1D Who has the extra vote in lynches voted us and it was unequal, someone couldhave assumed we wweren't bad and tried to save us which explains the "not a tie" as Dom stated because one of us had an extra vote.

Dom said he wasn't going to tell us if it was a tie, not that it wasn't a tie. Unless I missed this.
How would someone who assumed you weren't bad have saved you?
Boogs I'm really trying to work with you but I just don't understand your explanations.

#120

What do you think of Sabies comments, Splints?

#121

They aren't sitting well with me either. Just because she isn't here when a couple posts happened (honestly it wasn't even that much, and I've been around most the day posting at all times) doesn't mean she can't contribute. So yea that seems a bit convenient to me.
I don't know what else to say to Boogs. His explanations have been a bit out there and improbable to me. I do not understand how he survived the lynch and I can't figure out a civvie explanation for it but for the life of me I don't understand why he wouldn't have just said "yea sabie" must be bad. Right? I mean, that's what I would have done if I was in his shoes. I just don't get it.

#122

If only one of them is bad, I am leaning more towards Sabie. I could be wrong.

#123

Wait, what's happening? Why Am I on the poll? And why do I have the most votes?

#124

Cause you're Supatown~

#125

S~V~S wrote:Cause you're Supatown~

Curse you, Dom, and your tricksy wiles!

#126

I am leery of voting for sabie without giving her the same chance to respond we gave boogs. If you were concerned about sabie SVS why didn't you bring her up sooner?

#127

I did, I brought up both of them. All she says is the same thing over and over.

Don't vote her, then. But i am expecting Boogs to come up civ if we lynch him, tbh. I wlll be surprised if it is otherwise.

#128

What do you see about Sabie that is defensible?

#129

Roxy i dont understand the question.
Voted Sabie to save myself.

#130

So Roxy, are you going to vote?

Who da bad