Battlestar Galactica Mafia - GAME OVER

#2601

Epignosis wrote:
JaggedJimmyJay wrote:
Epignosis wrote:I've made a deal with Long Con, and unless he accepts, my vote goes to him. I'm sorry.
Why do you think he's good?
He's being stubborn, not manipulative.

THIS. And if you take two seconds to think about why he'd say the things he has, it makes sense. Not saying that necessarily makes him good, but it does mean he has his reasons. Plus, as his lovely wife so graciously pointed out, he be cray cray.

Luff LC and BR <3 If he sets to something, he's going to give it his all even if it's not something he wants to do or fully agrees with. I think in this case he has his reasons to contradict himself. That reason in itself doesn't make him bad.

Glorfindel wrote:So Say We All!

S~V~S wrote:
Epignosis wrote:I've made a deal with Long Con, and unless he accepts, my vote goes to him. I'm sorry.
He's trying to get lynched. I think he is not gonna die. There could be civvie reasons for this,but if he were a civvie I doubt he would play them up. He is egging people on, he made a vote that could not save him when he had the most votes, or the second most votes.

He wants to be lynched.
I'll admit, this is what it looks like to me. Epi seems convinced of LC's innocence and while I respect that, the next worst thing to a Mafia member is (in my opinion) a reckless Townie. I think the sortie hijack and his stubborn insistence in not accepting what I think should by now be obvious to everyone suggests a lack of discipline that even if he isn't Mafia isn't going to help us in the long run. I still have time and I am open to being convinced otherwise...

It's not a lack of discipline. LC is one of the most stubborn people I've ever played with and had much mafia discipline. If anything, I think he's using careful discipline in deciding that all cylons must die, even though he believes Athena to be good.

Epignosis wrote:You should go stand in the corner of you Cylon ship and think about what you just said.

Literally LOL'd

SokothQultuq wrote:This is my first game, so I'm trying to get a feel for how its played and even after so many posts I still feel kind of lost. And not really sure how to contribute.

Welcome to playing mafia.

You're doing fine. Stick with your gut. Often times it'll be right. Other times, it'll get you killed, but at least you'll have a cool story to tell the next game.

Black Rock wrote:
S~V~S wrote:
Matt wrote:Epi and Black Rock, follow Marmot!
No,vote Nutella
Well for my LoRab suspicion to work it would mean Nutella was her partner in murdering.

I apologize if you already said why, but can you explain (or link me to it)?

Black Rock wrote:
Matt wrote:Well, two reasons...

1) He joke voted Epi on Day One and got us a Cylon. A good cylon, but still.

2) Curiously, he is listed as "Marmot" on the poll, and I know Golden already "explained" it, but I can't help feel that it makes Marmot special somehow.
Matt, you are a curious fellow.

Right?!? I don't think I've seen someone use so much non-gameplay in their suspish before. LOL.

LC - Just freaking say it! Even if you don't follow it.

FWIW - I'm almost positive that if there are good cylons (and I think there are), Epi is one of them.

LINKI lots of it to read after I post

#2602

Oh I thought you were saying it was to pro town.

#2603

Which didn't make much sense, but I figured I'd role with it. :P

**http://www.last.fm/user/nutella23** · #2604

sig, people familiar with the show have insisted that Athena is a good character, are you ignoring that info? like I get that maybe we shouldn't assume that it's reflected in the roles in this game, but it would make some sense. are you not willing to entertain that possibility?

lorab I am so jealous!!!!!

#2605

LoRab wrote:
Black Rock wrote:
LoRab wrote:LA's latest posts are not feeling so good to me. She is starting to feel cornered baddie.

Interesting LoRab. I see you jumped a vote on LC and have stuck around to throw out this opinion. Is this to cover your ass if LA flips something bad or murdering like? (I'm sorry, I'm not getting the whole concept yet)

Just something to watch. Just know I am.
I've been starting to doze off in front of the computer for an hour or so, and didn't want to miss the vote. I'm not confident in my vote, but I felt suspish enough to vote. And then continued to contribute when I didn't actually fall asleep.

Not sure why you find that nefarious. I'm not bad. I don't have BTSC with Nutella. I don't know what else to say, because nothing else has been mentioned about why I'm suspish.

Black Rock wrote:
S~V~S wrote:
Matt wrote:Epi and Black Rock, follow Marmot!
No,vote Nutella
Well for my LoRab suspicion to work it would mean Nutella was her partner in murdering.
I'm confused by this, because later you say that I'm more suspish than she is. I'm not connected to her. At this poing, I don't trust her and I find her more suspish than I did when I voted. I don't know what esle to say, because you haven't really said anything about me.

bea wrote:taking a leap of faith here.

lorab

If I'm wrong please tell me why.

You are totally wrong. And, unless I missed it, you haven't said why you voted for me. If you explain, then I can tell you why you're wrong.[/quote
no -you didn't miss it I didn't say - but BR put some supsih here that i agree with. So yea. Twirl if I'm wrong I will happily prove I'm wrong. But you do have to prove I'm wrong....

#2606

nutella wrote:sig, people familiar with the show have insisted that Athena is a good character, are you ignoring that info? like I get that maybe we shouldn't assume that it's reflected in the roles in this game, but it would make some sense. are you not willing to entertain that possibility?

lorab I am so jealous!!!!!

Ugh fine, obviously I'm the super minority here. I'll ISO Epi over the night phase and see what I think and I'll take into consideration what they've said. However, I still don't believe we should put to much weight in the show. Take the Final five for example whatever they are they've been randomized and aren't the same people as they were in the show. I think getting to deep into the shows lore isn't good, especially with some of the text in game. You'll be seen as a cylon sympathizer if you don't say this ect.

#2607

I effed those quots 16 ways from sunday.

#2608

So,Bea, you found Lorab MORE suspect than Nutella who had votes,and was suspect for similar reasons?

#2609

sig wrote:And we both voted together for an outed teammate hmmm maybe.

Are you that sure he's mafia?

sig wrote:Can you explain your vote?

Yes, I can. Vomps is capable of everything, and that includes revealing he's mafia under everyone's nose and get ignored

. I also don't want to fail to vote today because I have plenty of exams in the coming weeks and I may have to abstain from voting in the future.

#2610

LoRab wrote:In totally unrelated news, I just got Hamilton tickets for December. And you all should vote for and play Dom's and my Hamilton game when we post it and the next poll goes up. And, I'm more than excited to have gotten tickets. I felt a need to share.

Then I think a congratulations is in order.

In other news, I was looking back in my FB photos and came across pics from Frex Halloween Party. There was one with you, me, LC, Sawyer540, and DD. Good times, miss the old crew.

#2611

Catching up now, on page 60 so far. Currently leaning my vote on LC.

linki - I would also be down with a vote on Vompatti if we can build support for it.

#2612

Ok, I'm uncomfortable with all these candidates. Of all of them LC is the only one I had any slight suspicion of, but he wouldn't even have made my list. But I feel even less suspect of the other leading candidates. In particular Nutella, I'm not seeing baddie Nutella, though she could be fooling me I suppose. Anyway, I guess I'm voting LC.

Vote: Long Con

#2613

Spacedaisy wrote:Ok, I'm uncomfortable with all these candidates. Of all of them LC is the only one I had any slight suspicion of, but he wouldn't even have made my list. But I feel even less suspect of the other leading candidates. In particular Nutella, I'm not seeing baddie Nutella, though she could be fooling me I suppose. Anyway, I guess I'm voting LC.

Vote: Long Con

Who would have made your list?

#2614

LC you're so freaking stubborn.

#2615

Black Rock wrote:LC you're so freaking stubborn.

You poor, poor woman.

#2616

ObscureAllure wrote:
Black Rock wrote:LC you're so freaking stubborn.
You poor, poor woman.

That's just the half of it, I have two of his boys. I'm still looking for my DNA in them.

#2617

Daisy is bad

#2618

Silverwolf wrote:Daisy is bad

Eother that or phoning it in. I'm leaning bad though.

#2619

That nutella portion of your post was very fencey Daisy.

#2620

I think I trust the people on the nutella wagon more than the people on the Long Con wagon for the most part. The Zebra wagon isn't terribly inspiring but I probably trust that group more than the LC wagon too.

#2621

sig wrote:
nutella wrote:sig, people familiar with the show have insisted that Athena is a good character, are you ignoring that info? like I get that maybe we shouldn't assume that it's reflected in the roles in this game, but it would make some sense. are you not willing to entertain that possibility?

lorab I am so jealous!!!!!
Ugh fine, obviously I'm the super minority here. I'll ISO Epi over the night phase and see what I think and I'll take into consideration what they've said. However, I still don't believe we should put to much weight in the show. Take the Final five for example whatever they are they've been randomized and aren't the same people as they were in the show. I think getting to deep into the shows lore isn't good, especially with some of the text in game. You'll be seen as a cylon sympathizer if you don't say this ect.

I'm a cylon synthesizer. And if you lynch me right now, I'm a human. i don't see how this is bad.
As I've said since the beginning - I have a hard time seeing athena as anything but good because of her role in the lore. I COULD be wrong. I've also always said that - but I've been asking for the BOTD here because it feels against the nature of the show.

everyone - incuding indi - who pointed to jjj's post about absolutely trusting epi based on his role card flip missed that I was the FIRST person to say - if he does something suspish we should hold him accountable, till then I give him *and* Athena the BOTD.

#2622

sig wrote:That nutella portion of your post was very fencey Daisy.

Yeah, "I have no clue, but Nutella isn't bad".

Linki @ bea~ did you miss this?

S~V~S wrote:So,Bea, you found Lorab MORE suspect than Nutella who had votes,and was suspect for similar reasons?

#2623

Did Scotty post his vote?

#2624

I'd like to give nutella the botd for one more day but she ends up at the top of the list to get my vote today. I also considered LC (no longer considering), Marmot (decided his antics did not necessarily mean he was bad), DFaraday (decided to give him another day to join in) and sig (his latest posts convinced me not to vote him) but rejected them for different reasons.

Vote: nutella

#2625

juliets wrote:and sig (his latest posts convinced me not to vote him)

What did you like from sig's latest posts?

**http://www.last.fm/user/nutella23** · #2626

Alriiight, I hate to do this because I really think LC is good, but there's only 10 minutes and basically no hope left for me

vote: Long Con

#2627

bea wrote:
sig wrote:
nutella wrote:sig, people familiar with the show have insisted that Athena is a good character, are you ignoring that info? like I get that maybe we shouldn't assume that it's reflected in the roles in this game, but it would make some sense. are you not willing to entertain that possibility?

lorab I am so jealous!!!!!
Ugh fine, obviously I'm the super minority here. I'll ISO Epi over the night phase and see what I think and I'll take into consideration what they've said. However, I still don't believe we should put to much weight in the show. Take the Final five for example whatever they are they've been randomized and aren't the same people as they were in the show. I think getting to deep into the shows lore isn't good, especially with some of the text in game. You'll be seen as a cylon sympathizer if you don't say this ect.
I'm a cylon synthesizer. And if you lynch me right now, I'm a human. i don't see how this is bad.
As I've said since the beginning - I have a hard time seeing athena as anything but good because of her role in the lore. I COULD be wrong. I've also always said that - but I've been asking for the BOTD here because it feels against the nature of the show.

everyone - incuding indi - who pointed to jjj's post about absolutely trusting epi based on his role card flip missed that I was the FIRST person to say - if he does something suspish we should hold him accountable, till then I give him *and* Athena the BOTD.

That definitely sounds cool.

#2628

Remember, folks: votes only count if you post the name of the target in dead red!. I'm looking at you, DFaraday, and any others I may have missed.

#2629

VOTE - NUTELLA

#2630

So say we all?

LC isn't reading bad to me, but I'm not really seeing the case on Nutella either (I agree with her that she gets lynched based on tone too often). Zebra's Rico vote didn't sit right with me, so I will vote a2thezebra

Linki: I was writing my post, Polo.

#2631

So I voted for Nutella.

Vote: Nutella

Two reasons: I really think LC is on the good side. I would like to see more distance between votes for him and Nutella

Also, if Nutella flips some sort of baddie/Mafia/Bad Cylon/Murderer. I am so going after LoRab with all I got.

Linkitis:

LET ME POST GUYS!!!

#2632

Nutella

The more I read from LC and BR, I don't think LC is the way to go anymore.

#2633

Black Rock wrote:So I voted for Nutella.

Vote: Nutella

Two reasons: I really think LC is on the good side. I would like to see more distance between votes for him and Nutella

Also, if Nutella flips some sort of baddie/Mafia/Bad Cylon/Murderer. I am so going after LoRab with all I got.

Linkitis:

LET ME POST GUYS!!!

BR - did you see me ask before? What's the connection you see between them? (If you already said it, can you link me?)

#2634

So Say We All!

I'm voting Long Con I already explained why and I've seen nothing since to sway me to other candidates.

#2635

all these last minute votes on nutella are worrying to me.

Though I really dislike Glorfs vote for LC.

#2636

ObscureAllure wrote:
Black Rock wrote:So I voted for Nutella.

Vote: Nutella

Two reasons: I really think LC is on the good side. I would like to see more distance between votes for him and Nutella

Also, if Nutella flips some sort of baddie/Mafia/Bad Cylon/Murderer. I am so going after LoRab with all I got.

Linkitis:

LET ME POST GUYS!!!
BR - did you see me ask before? What's the connection you see between them? (If you already said it, can you link me?)

I'll find it. I hadn't seen your question.

#2637

sig wrote:all these last minute votes on nutella are worrying to me.

Though I really dislike Glorfs vote for LC.

#2638

S~V~S wrote:
sig wrote:That nutella portion of your post was very fencey Daisy.
Yeah, "I have no clue, but Nutella isn't bad".

Linki @ bea~ did you miss this?

S~V~S wrote:So,Bea, you found Lorab MORE suspect than Nutella who had votes,and was suspect for similar reasons?

yes -a) I totes missed it. I've been drinking and talking to two of my under age nephews.

I did the best I could at the time. As I said - BR's opinion shaped mine. i'm not saying she's to "blame" i own my vote. I agreed with what she said and voted accordingly then went back to trying to get my nephew to come home to me.

#2639

sig wrote:all these last minute votes on nutella are worrying to me.

Though I really dislike Glorfs vote for LC.

Well, let's see how it goes. If Nutella flips bad, I don't see how Daisy is civ. A few other votes would worry me too.

Long Con wrote:
sig wrote:all these last minute votes on nutella are worrying to me.

Though I really dislike Glorfs vote for LC.

What mad that more people aren't voting for you? :P

#2640

Long Con wrote:
sig wrote:all these last minute votes on nutella are worrying to me.

Though I really dislike Glorfs vote for LC.

#2641

S~V~S wrote:
sig wrote:all these last minute votes on nutella are worrying to me.

Though I really dislike Glorfs vote for LC.
Well, let's see how it goes. If Nutella flips bad, I don't see how Daisy is civ. A few other votes would worry me too.

Long Con wrote:
sig wrote:all these last minute votes on nutella are worrying to me.

Though I really dislike Glorfs vote for LC.

What mad that more people aren't voting for you? :P

Quiet, you.

sig wrote:
Long Con wrote:
sig wrote:all these last minute votes on nutella are worrying to me.

Though I really dislike Glorfs vote for LC.

I saw you there!

#2642

Son Say We All!

sig wrote:all these last minute votes on nutella are worrying to me.

Though I really dislike Glorfs vote for LC.

Do you now, Sig? Tell me, what's new?

**http://www.last.fm/user/nutella23** · #2643

Now that my vote is even more meaningless I feel worse about it

My symbolic vote would be on Zebra.

#2644

THINGS GET META

Starbuck was sitting in the pilots locker room when indiglo walked in.

“OMG” said indiglo “You’re starbuck”

“Yes” said Starbuck “What the frak do you want?”

“I mean, I’m just watching season four and, what’s up with you? I’m not sure what’s going on?”

“What do you mean, season four?” said Starbuck

“You know… season four… of… Battlestar Galactica?” said indiglo “that TV show you’re on?”

Starbuck looked at indiglo in disgust. Indiglo began to hyperventilate.

“I don’t know what the frak you are talking about, but the very survival of the human race is at stake here and all you can talk about is a TV show? Get out of here, or I’ll make sure you get on report.

“Yes, sir” said indiglo, and she left abruptly.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Meanwhile, Snarmot was talking to Long Con in the mess. They were distracted by the sound of S~V~S munching on tinfoil.

“Hey, marmy!” said Long Con “Have you…”

Black Rock walked in and interrupted. “LC. We have a diaper situation. Can you please go to the armory and find some diapers. Stat.” Long Con rushed off in compliance.

“Thank goodness” said Black Rock “That’s the only time I can get a word in around here. As for my word, well, today it’s pretty simple.” She drew her gun, and shot nutella in the head.

Everyone was stunned. But not as stunned as they were when they discovered who she was.

Nutella has been lynched. She was Simon O’Neill.
It is now night two. The Galactica has flown too close to a black hole. This means everything is moving at half speed. While one hour appears to pass to those of you in the fleet, two hours is passing in the outside world. Any mechanics which refer to or are based on being available at or after set hours are affected.

#2645

nutella wrote:Now that my vote is even more meaningless I feel worse about it My symbolic vote would be on Zebra.

why? If you are dead girl walking...lay it all out on the line...

#2646

Immediate notes: nutella was a cylon and she stayed dead. No further alignment indicated.

#2647

Nice.

#2648

Ok OA.

Black Rock wrote:
LoRab wrote:LA's latest posts are not feeling so good to me. She is starting to feel cornered baddie.

Interesting LoRab. I see you jumped a vote on LC and have stuck around to throw out this opinion. Is this to cover your ass if LA flips something bad or murdering like? (I'm sorry, I'm not getting the whole concept yet)

Just something to watch. Just know I am.

It's this post from LoRab that just seemed to convenient. After she just voted for LC. Hold on I'll get that post...

LoRab wrote:I went ahead and

voted Long Con

Sorry, dude, but your posts are just reading more bad to me than good. It's more gut than anything.

And I'm under the weather and really tired, and don't trust that I won't fall asleep at the computer, so wanted to vote now rather than forget or sleep through it.

I felt this vote post was weak. She states she might be falling asleep. Although she has made post three hours later. She also seemed to be ticket shopping. Baddie LoRab is known for such excuses.

But once again it's this post...

LoRab wrote:LA's latest posts are not feeling so good to me. She is starting to feel cornered baddie.

Like she was covering her ass, after she voted for LC and could not change it.

If she was covering her ass and bad it would mean they were teammates in the most murdering sense.

Linki: So say we all.

That is not a good Cylon.

#2649

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:Immediate notes: nutella was a cylon and she stayed dead. No further alignment indicated.

Yes since we blew up one of their ships.

I'm thinking Daisy is a good candidate tomorrow so is epi.

#2650

Holy SHit! Thats a cylon! I had to look at the roles, lol!!

Who be you lynching today?