Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12

#6921

Chris wrote:
Long Con wrote:
zeek wrote:We truly are fucked then, aren't we?
DFaraday, Hedgeowl, S~V~S, and Gotrees still haven't voted.

Also, a tied vote could reveal the Cyber Head, which would be cool. As long as Amy Pond stays out of it.

Right now, Dom is going to be lynched by 1 vote.

Interesting. And if DFaraday is lynched over Dom in a tie, then you would consider Snow Dog to be the Cyber Role Blocker?

#6922

Alright, I feel fairly sure that DF is not the master, so I will vote Dom seeing as he is still a question.

Votes Dom

Linki

#6923

Dom won't be lynched. Ten bucks.

#6924

zeek wrote:Okay, one last time.

I KNOW Dom is bad.

Do you, though? Do you know?

Chris · #6925

So to be clear Gotrees, you're voting Dom based on your gut that he's bad?

And fewer lives left to be lost? He never survived an NK...

I don't understand your vote to be honest...

LINKI @ LC: No, Snow Dog is The Cyber Head.

#6926

I leave for work and the vote is split between like 5 people. I have to work late and come home to find all those other suspects gone and me in the lead again?

Gotrees wrote:Okay, I'm a bit late to the party (sorry), but it looks like it's between Dom and DF right now. I don't want to waste my vote again, so I'm gonna vote Dom tonight.

Between the two, I just don't understand how it could be DF. As a quieter player, I sympathize with him, and he comes across as genuine to me. At the very beginning of the game, Dom was overly-anxious to vote for Made, and I think he got some slack for that because most people ended up agreeing with him, but lately he seems to be a lot less anxious to accuse people like that. Might it be because he has fewer lives left to lose?

With everyone else's theories thrown in as well, the arrows point more to Dom tonight, it seems to me.

Gotrees, you're my new favorite person.

Obviously *Votes Dom*

#6927

keys56000000000 wrote:
zeek wrote:Okay, one last time.

I KNOW Dom is bad.
Do you, though? Do you know?

Yes.

#6928

Epignosis wrote:Dom won't be lynched. Ten bucks.

If Dom is Strax, will you vote for yourself next lynch?

#6929

Long Con wrote:
Epignosis wrote:Dom won't be lynched. Ten bucks.
If Dom is Strax, will you vote for yourself next lynch?

If Dom ain't, will you vote for yourself?

#6930

Chris wrote:So to be clear Gotrees, you're voting Dom based on your gut that he's bad?

And fewer lives left to be lost? He never survived an NK...

I don't understand your vote to be honest...

LINKI @ LC: No, Snow Dog is The Cyber Head.

I voted Dom because he seems more bad than DF.

Chris · #6931

We need MP's vote to make it a real tie. (And a behind the scenes tie too!)

#6932

I voted DF to make it 7-6 with Dom going down. If Snow Dog is The Head then it's 8-6 Dom. If DF goes down, then we'll need to re-evaluate who Snow Dog is supposed to be, right?

Chris · #6933

zeek, I hope you're right.

#6934

Chris wrote:zeek, I hope you're right.

I am, listen to me next time.

Chris · #6935

LC, if the head is on DF's votes, it's only worth 2, so it'll be a tie.

#6936

Epignosis wrote:
Long Con wrote:
Epignosis wrote:Dom won't be lynched. Ten bucks.
If Dom is Strax, will you vote for yourself next lynch?
If Dom ain't, will you vote for yourself?

No, that makes no sense. I'm not making the case he's Strax or not Strax, it's not my name on the line here.

#6937

zeek wrote:
keys56000000000 wrote:
zeek wrote:Okay, one last time.

I KNOW Dom is bad.
Do you, though? Do you know?
Yes.

And you know what the word "know" means, right? You know what it is to know? I.e. you literally had confirmation that Dom is bad? Because I don't believe that's what you mean to tell us. You merely [ithink[/i] Dom's The Master, based on your observations, correct?

#6938

Chris wrote:LC, if the head is on DF's votes, it's only worth 2, so it'll be a tie.

Perfect. Well, 50% chance of perfect? I dunno, who knows what would happen in a real tie? Possible great information!

I think Dom will be the lynched though, we'll see if it pleases us.

#6939

keys56000000000 wrote:
zeek wrote:
keys56000000000 wrote:
zeek wrote:Okay, one last time.

I KNOW Dom is bad.
Do you, though? Do you know?
Yes.
And you know what the word "know" means, right? You know what it is to know? I.e. you literally had confirmation that Dom is bad? Because I don't believe that's what you mean to tell us. You merely [ithink[/i] Dom's The Master, based on your observations, correct?

Zeek the Lie Detector?

#6940

And now we have to endure Dom lying about ways he isn't the Master until he's lost is other protections.

linki - I know, keys. I know it.
linki 2 - no.

#6941

Welp, I'm gonna be honest with you all-- it's gonna look a lot like me being the Master-- and this is why I didn't want to be lynched.

But, alas, I am not.

#6942

Long Con wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
Long Con wrote:
Epignosis wrote:Dom won't be lynched. Ten bucks.
If Dom is Strax, will you vote for yourself next lynch?
If Dom ain't, will you vote for yourself?
No, that makes no sense. I'm not making the case he's Strax or not Strax, it's not my name on the line here.

If I'm right, will you vote how I want you to vote from here on out?

Of course not. So why ask what you asked?

#6943

Dom wrote:Welp, I'm gonna be honest with you all-- it's gonna look a lot like me being the Master-- and this is why I didn't want to be lynched.

But, alas, I am not.

Thanks for the warning, feb.

#6944

Dom wrote:Welp, I'm gonna be honest with you all-- it's gonna look a lot like me being the Master-- and this is why I didn't want to be lynched.

But, alas, I am not.

Nice. Good start. Be quiet though

#6945

Orly Dom?

Chris · #6946

Dom wrote:Welp, I'm gonna be honest with you all-- it's gonna look a lot like me being the Master-- and this is why I didn't want to be lynched.

But, alas, I am not.

There's nothing to suggest any civ can survive a lynch.

How are you going to explain surviving?

#6947

Battle of the Jacks is coming, Chris.

#6948

Chris wrote:
Dom wrote:Welp, I'm gonna be honest with you all-- it's gonna look a lot like me being the Master-- and this is why I didn't want to be lynched.

But, alas, I am not.
There's nothing to suggest any civ can survive a lynch.

How are you going to explain surviving?

^whs.

Did you get a prize?

Chris · #6949

zeek wrote:Battle of the Jacks is coming, Chris.

No, it's not.

#6950

Chris wrote:
Dom wrote:Welp, I'm gonna be honest with you all-- it's gonna look a lot like me being the Master-- and this is why I didn't want to be lynched.

But, alas, I am not.
There's nothing to suggest any civ can survive a lynch.

How are you going to explain surviving?

There are absolutely ways civs can survive a lynch.

But I'm not allowed to talk about why I will survive this lynch. There is more to this game than meets the eye.

#6951

zeek wrote:Battle of the Jacks is coming, Chris.

Fight! Fight! Fight!

#6952

Epignosis wrote:
Long Con wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
Long Con wrote:
Epignosis wrote:Dom won't be lynched. Ten bucks.
If Dom is Strax, will you vote for yourself next lynch?
If Dom ain't, will you vote for yourself?
No, that makes no sense. I'm not making the case he's Strax or not Strax, it's not my name on the line here.
If I'm right, will you vote how I want you to vote from here on out?

Of course not. So why ask what you asked?

Don't be so hasty, if he's The Master then I'll be a lot more likely to follow your vote and your logic. Part of my worry was that you were The Master, and if Dom is The Master... looks good for you!

#6953

Dom wrote:Welp, I'm gonna be honest with you all-- it's gonna look a lot like me being the Master-- and this is why I didn't want to be lynched.

But, alas, I am not.

So if I survive this lynch, everyone is going to think you're the Master. It'll pretty much be a done deal.

#6954

Dom wrote:But I'm not allowed to talk about why I will survive this lynch. There is more to this game than meets the eye.

Or you're the Master, because you're the Master. You're the Master, so you survive masterfully.

Chris · #6955

LC, I was wrong. If the head is in the DF voters, DF is dead, and the head is narrowed.

But it's Snow. Don't worry about that anymore my friend.

Chris · #6956

zeek wrote:
Dom wrote:But I'm not allowed to talk about why I will survive this lynch. There is more to this game than meets the eye.
Or you're the Master, because you're the Master. You're the Master, so you survive masterfully.

I gotta say, and it'll be a hard sell, but there is one secret role left that we know nothing about.

#6957

I am so saddened that THIS is how we play Mafia now.

People playing horribly is causing people to come to faulty conclusions. Love it.

#6958

Chris wrote:I gotta say, and it'll be a hard sell, but there is one secret role left that we know nothing about.

Are you joking?

#6959

Post a reply
First unread post • 6932 posts • Page 174 of 174 • 1 ... 170171172173174
Who Shall Quench Your Hosts' Thirst for Blood?

Poll ended at Tue Oct 28, 2014 7:29 pm

Chris
0
No votes

DFaraday
6
Dom (4), nijuukyugou (13), Chris (14), keys56000000000 (15), S~V~S (16), Long Con (20)
30%

Dom
7
Epignosis (7), zeek (9), Snow Dog (10), juliets (11), DFaraday (17), Gotrees (18), Hedgeowl (19)
35%

Epignosis 2.0
0
No votes

Gotrees
0
No votes

Hedgeowl
0
No votes

Juliets 2.0
0
No votes

Keys56000000000
0
No votes

Long Con 2.0
0
No votes

MovingPictures07
0
No votes

Ninjablooper
1
MovingPictures07 (6)
5%

Snow Dog 2.0
0
No votes

SVS
0
No votes

Zeek
0
No votes

The Site Owner! Although that would taste a bit wooly... (Host/Non/Dead)
6
birdwithteeth11 (1), Metalmarsh89 (2), Enrique (3), Roxy (5), bea (8), Bass_the_Clever (12)

Chris · #6960

There isn't a secret role we don't know anything about?

I did say it would be tough for Dom to sell. I'm not saying he's it... but that last secret role does exist.

#6961

On the contrary, Dom, I thought that this lynch in particular was an invigorating and interesting one, very much what I consider to be good Mafia. I wanted to congratulate everyone on keeping this game very interesting, even if Dom ends up being the White Jacob secret role and it's a big mistake.

One thing, though... Dom's lynch survival is suspicious because there's nothing in the (unclaimed) Civvie roles that explain it. There is also nothing I can see in the Civvie roles that would explain Zeek's 100% knowledge that Dom is The Master. So... that's sort of suspicious for the same reason?

#6962

Chris wrote:There isn't a secret role we don't know anything about?

I did say it would be tough for Dom to sell. I'm not saying he's it... but that last secret role does exist.

I thought two secret roles still exist. Oh, wait, The Recruiter is one. Right.

*posts anyway*

#6963

Chris wrote:There isn't a secret role we don't know anything about?

I did say it would be tough for Dom to sell. I'm not saying he's it... but that last secret role does exist.

I'm inclined to believe MP's thoughts from yesterday on that. Keys seems pretty upset fingersplints has been passed over on the replacement list. I bet she can't replace in because she was that secret role.

#6964

Dom wrote:I am so saddened that THIS is how we play Mafia now.

People playing horribly is causing people to come to faulty conclusions. Love it.

I do think this game really got out of hand in a few different ways, and I'm as much to blame as anyone. I'm actually going to feel kind of bad if it turns out you are the Master at this point because of the lack of deductive reasoning any of us (except Zeek) used to get there.

EBWOP: Wow, LC, you're saying pretty much the exact opposite of what I said.

Chris · #6965

LC, what if zeek knew who Dom was because he's "the recruiter"?

Also, LC, do you like the idea of the "Jacob" vs "MIB" theory with 2 of the secret roles?

#6966

DFaraday wrote:
Dom wrote:I am so saddened that THIS is how we play Mafia now.

People playing horribly is causing people to come to faulty conclusions. Love it.
I do think this game really got out of hand in a few different ways, and I'm as much to blame as anyone. I'm actually going to feel kind of bad if it turns out you are the Master at this point because of the lack of deductive reasoning any of us (except Zeek) used to get there.

EBWOP: Wow, LC, you're saying pretty much the exact opposite of what I said.

I think there's nothing wrong with a healthy amount of gut being involved in Mafia decisions. Reasoning is also important of course. You need both for Good Mafia. I really just said it was a good lynch because I found it really interesting, and my suspicions changed over the course of it based on what I read, and there were some funny jokes in there too... I had fun!

#6967

Chris wrote:LC, what if zeek knew who Dom was because he's "the recruiter"?

Except I've been dead half the game.

Chris · #6968

zeek wrote:
Chris wrote:LC, what if zeek knew who Dom was because he's "the recruiter"?
Except I've been dead half the game.

And?

#6969

Chris wrote:LC, what if zeek knew who Dom was because he's "the recruiter"?

He tried and failed to recruit Dom. I find that to be an idea worth thinking about.

Let me know if I'm mistaken, but did we clear Zeek of being a Dalek (all dead) or a Cyberman (they killed him)? So, The Recruiter would be a fine possibility for him. Can you imagine if we rezzed The Recruiter?! Wow. Who was responsible for that rez?

Also, LC, do you like the idea of the "Jacob" vs "MIB" theory with 2 of the secret roles?

Nope... I don't think that's how it is. I see it as The Recruiter and The Neutral LMS With Some Power We Don't Know. Or Evil instead of Neutral, but they ain't killing, so

.

#6970

A "dead half the game" recruiter who also failed on The Master would be... very nice for the Civvies.

24 Hour Days?