Seanzie wrote: ↑Thu Mar 16, 2023 12:34 am
I can easily reverse engineer many arguments about why it'd give information about your alignment.
nice
And you want me to believe you're on my side?
what
no i just can't think of any sensible arguments for why it's related to my alignment at all, any arguments like "outed wolf" "threadspewed town" or anything else are just immediately discounted as untrue because of logic
Scotty wrote: ↑Wed Mar 15, 2023 11:24 pm
All that said, I actually don’t get good vibes from SVS and think she is phoning it in today. She hasn’t voted yet and while that’s not AI, I haven’t got the impression she is making any waves nor do I know who she would vote for. She lightly defends sig, and puts a bit of suspicion on Doom, but isn’t going there?
I dunno. Nothing has thrilled me from her solving today. It’s like she doesn’t want to get her hands wet, if that makes any sense
is she normally someone who makes waves? my first impression as someone who was unfamiliar was that she seemed really towny
Seanzie wrote: ↑Thu Mar 16, 2023 12:34 am
I can easily reverse engineer many arguments about why it'd give information about your alignment.
nice
And you want me to believe you're on my side?
what
no i just can't think of any sensible arguments for why it's related to my alignment at all, any arguments like "outed wolf" "threadspewed town" or anything else are just immediately discounted as untrue because of logic
Scotty wrote: ↑Wed Mar 15, 2023 11:24 pm
All that said, I actually don’t get good vibes from SVS and think she is phoning it in today. She hasn’t voted yet and while that’s not AI, I haven’t got the impression she is making any waves nor do I know who she would vote for. She lightly defends sig, and puts a bit of suspicion on Doom, but isn’t going there?
I dunno. Nothing has thrilled me from her solving today. It’s like she doesn’t want to get her hands wet, if that makes any sense
is she normally someone who makes waves? my first impression as someone who was unfamiliar was that she seemed really towny
I’m not an expert on SVS, but I know she isn’t afraid to get down and dirty and make strong cases. Day 1 is gonna Day 1 and cases are flimsier than a paper plate covered in baked beans but I don’t get the impression she has worked to make any cases.
Seems hedgy
When I die, I want to go peacefully in my sleep like my grandfather;
not screaming like the people in his car
Seanzie wrote: ↑Thu Mar 16, 2023 12:34 am
I can easily reverse engineer many arguments about why it'd give information about your alignment.
nice
And you want me to believe you're on my side?
what
no i just can't think of any sensible arguments for why it's related to my alignment at all, any arguments like "outed wolf" "threadspewed town" or anything else are just immediately discounted as untrue because of logic
what do u have up your sleeve
If you cared, why did you wait to ask?
because i don't lmfao, i asked that question because i don't think have any sensible arguments and i was fishing for that. then i was gonna go back to your original question and realize that it's nai again
god it's too circular and i have a midterm tomorrow
Seanzie wrote: ↑Thu Mar 16, 2023 12:34 am
I can easily reverse engineer many arguments about why it'd give information about your alignment.
nice
And you want me to believe you're on my side?
what
no i just can't think of any sensible arguments for why it's related to my alignment at all, any arguments like "outed wolf" "threadspewed town" or anything else are just immediately discounted as untrue because of logic
what do u have up your sleeve
If you cared, why did you wait to ask?
because i don't lmfao, i asked that question because i don't think have any sensible arguments and i was fishing for that. then i was gonna go back to your original question and realize that it's nai again
god it's too circular and i have a midterm tomorrow
You didn't though. You didn't ask. Instead, you discredited Scotty, then when I said I could find an argument, you deflected. Only after I followed up did you try to find something to defend against.
Seanzie wrote: ↑Thu Mar 16, 2023 12:34 am
I can easily reverse engineer many arguments about why it'd give information about your alignment.
nice
And you want me to believe you're on my side?
what
no i just can't think of any sensible arguments for why it's related to my alignment at all, any arguments like "outed wolf" "threadspewed town" or anything else are just immediately discounted as untrue because of logic
what do u have up your sleeve
If you cared, why did you wait to ask?
because i don't lmfao, i asked that question because i don't think have any sensible arguments and i was fishing for that. then i was gonna go back to your original question and realize that it's nai again
god it's too circular and i have a midterm tomorrow
You didn't though. You didn't ask. Instead, you discredited Scotty, then when I said I could find an argument, you deflected. Only after I followed up did you try to find something to defend against.
DaughterOfOmega wrote: ↑Wed Mar 15, 2023 11:52 pm
I think calling a "wagon" static when its 16 hours from EOD in a 14 player game makes you look ridiculous. and possibly mafia
This. It's stupid to assume static wagon = wagon on town because I've seen static wagons on wolves quite often. Also I don't think 2-3 votes within 13 living votes should even be considered a wagon.
the thing about wagonomics reasoning is while i don't really subscribe to it i've seen townies use it all the time and i don't think it says anything about scotty's alignment
Scotty wrote: ↑Wed Mar 15, 2023 11:24 pm
All that said, I actually don’t get good vibes from SVS and think she is phoning it in today. She hasn’t voted yet and while that’s not AI, I haven’t got the impression she is making any waves nor do I know who she would vote for. She lightly defends sig, and puts a bit of suspicion on Doom, but isn’t going there?
I dunno. Nothing has thrilled me from her solving today. It’s like she doesn’t want to get her hands wet, if that makes any sense
is she normally someone who makes waves? my first impression as someone who was unfamiliar was that she seemed really towny
I’m not an expert on SVS, but I know she isn’t afraid to get down and dirty and make strong cases. Day 1 is gonna Day 1 and cases are flimsier than a paper plate covered in baked beans but I don’t get the impression she has worked to make any cases.
Seems hedgy
i might do some research if i have the time but i dunno if i will
i do get the sense i'm being overly generous to someone in my reading
maybe i'm giving to easy of a pass to falcon, but he just seemed like his classically overconfident town self on first impression. wouldn't vote him though because i think he's more readable with time
lucy wrote: ↑Thu Mar 16, 2023 12:58 am
@Gira is ur vote on sig self pres
naw i think he's scummy but haven't gotten around to explaining it, i basically read the game after remember it existed earlier today, then passed out in the afternoon and only came back now to there being a bunch of posts i had to catch up on.curious why you townread him, is there something beyond him pushing you?
sig is probably my only real scumread i feel sme level of confidence in? i thought doom's handling of the wagon on me was scummy in that she was hesitantly easing up to it and possibly looking for an excuse to vote me without looking like she was leading the charge, but otherwise she seems to be mostly off topic posting and not caring about the game which is =rand
it's one of those things where if you play enough with someone their rolecard flashes as green or red in your mind, however i also tend to tr those pushing me early game generally and me and he mightttt know that. i also don't know how accurate it is bc d1 but i'm gonna keep him as a tr right now and try to wagon outside of you two
DaughterOfOmega wrote: ↑Tue Mar 14, 2023 5:59 pm
First: The mechanics of this game seem weird to me.
Second: I said I would try this game, and I haven't seriously tried while town alignment in years.
Third: I have an exam two days after spring break ends, and last exam I did horrible. If I'm alive till endgame I will be studying for that pretty hard.
DaughterOfOmega wrote: ↑Tue Mar 14, 2023 5:59 pm
First: The mechanics of this game seem weird to me.
Second: I said I would try this game, and I haven't seriously tried while town alignment in years.
Third: I have an exam two days after spring break ends, and last exam I did horrible. If I'm alive till endgame I will be studying for that pretty hard.
Seanzie wrote: ↑Wed Mar 15, 2023 9:03 am
Okay, mech time. We should be able to gain a strong advantage if we do the following:
1. Choose 3 people, top 3 towns, need to so this soonish.
2. Sort the remaining 11 players into groups of 3,4,4 and assign each group to a top town.
3. funnel all breaths into those top town.
4. on subsequent days, townies who have breaths may choose to give them all to someone else without disclosing who (to make it harder for mafia)
This does a few things:
1. very likely that at least one town will get the 1st power. This will out people who did not do the thing. 3p did not do the thing, and if mafia choose not to, they'd also be outed.
2. This should maximize our ability to use doc shots.
3. sure, it could go to mafia, but if there are multiple janitors, that'd be kind of outing.
I think it’s a bit too early to hand out breaths just in case a mafia member is in the town core.
Scotty wrote: ↑Wed Mar 15, 2023 12:04 pm
3 people in a row town reading sig and it’s weirding me out
Why?
Because I don’t read sig as town so either I’m off or he’s done be foolin you
"he's done be foolin you" implies they are town(the 3)
In my experience over the years of playing with sig:
-if he appears invested and is generally town read,
He ain’t town
-if he looks scummy to the general public on D1 with a chop lining up with his name on a placard above the gallows,
He prolly town
I think you’re operating with some outdated meta generally in town read now in fact I usually make it to end game or very close to end game
sig wrote: ↑Wed Mar 15, 2023 4:39 pm
I’ve never seen lucy scum game but I’m assuming it’s the way she’s playing now so I’m happy with my vote staying there for now
these...just don't really look like the posts of someone who's looking for mafia at all. there's some posts that gesture at being "productive" some things where if you turn your head and squint your eyes, you could see it being a read, but i don't really get the sense sig believes the stuff he's saying, because there's no weight behind it. the best we get on the lucy read is "the way she's playing now", which is...disinterested, i guess? the thing being i think pushing someone for seeming disintested is a pretty basic mafia type of push. i also don't think the read on scotty writing a big mechanics post is a real read, more like an unserious thought that long post=town.
I also think posts like the "it's too early to hand out breaths in case a mafia member is in the town core" is the kind of post scum makes to feign productivity, it looks like it's saying something strategic but it's not actually anything useful, doesn't involve discussing any reads. filler, in other words.
DaughterOfOmega wrote: ↑Tue Mar 14, 2023 5:59 pm
First: The mechanics of this game seem weird to me.
Second: I said I would try this game, and I haven't seriously tried while town alignment in years.
Third: I have an exam two days after spring break ends, and last exam I did horrible. If I'm alive till endgame I will be studying for that pretty hard.
DaughterOfOmega wrote: ↑Tue Mar 14, 2023 5:59 pm
First: The mechanics of this game seem weird to me.
Second: I said I would try this game, and I haven't seriously tried while town alignment in years.
Third: I have an exam two days after spring break ends, and last exam I did horrible. If I'm alive till endgame I will be studying for that pretty hard.
Seanzie wrote: ↑Wed Mar 15, 2023 9:03 am
Okay, mech time. We should be able to gain a strong advantage if we do the following:
1. Choose 3 people, top 3 towns, need to so this soonish.
2. Sort the remaining 11 players into groups of 3,4,4 and assign each group to a top town.
3. funnel all breaths into those top town.
4. on subsequent days, townies who have breaths may choose to give them all to someone else without disclosing who (to make it harder for mafia)
This does a few things:
1. very likely that at least one town will get the 1st power. This will out people who did not do the thing. 3p did not do the thing, and if mafia choose not to, they'd also be outed.
2. This should maximize our ability to use doc shots.
3. sure, it could go to mafia, but if there are multiple janitors, that'd be kind of outing.
I think it’s a bit too early to hand out breaths just in case a mafia member is in the town core.
Scotty wrote: ↑Wed Mar 15, 2023 12:04 pm
3 people in a row town reading sig and it’s weirding me out
Why?
Because I don’t read sig as town so either I’m off or he’s done be foolin you
"he's done be foolin you" implies they are town(the 3)
In my experience over the years of playing with sig:
-if he appears invested and is generally town read,
He ain’t town
-if he looks scummy to the general public on D1 with a chop lining up with his name on a placard above the gallows,
He prolly town
I think you’re operating with some outdated meta generally in town read now in fact I usually make it to end game or very close to end game
sig wrote: ↑Wed Mar 15, 2023 4:39 pm
I’ve never seen lucy scum game but I’m assuming it’s the way she’s playing now so I’m happy with my vote staying there for now
these...just don't really look like the posts of someone who's looking for mafia at all. there's some posts that gesture at being "productive" some things where if you turn your head and squint your eyes, you could see it being a read, but i don't really get the sense sig believes the stuff he's saying, because there's no weight behind it. the best we get on the lucy read is "the way she's playing now", which is...disinterested, i guess? the thing being i think pushing someone for seeming disintested is a pretty basic mafia type of push. i also don't think the read on scotty writing a big mechanics post is a real read, more like an unserious thought that long post=town.
I also think posts like the "it's too early to hand out breaths in case a mafia member is in the town core" is the kind of post scum makes to feign productivity, it looks like it's saying something strategic but it's not actually anything useful, doesn't involve discussing any reads. filler, in other words.
Before I unspoilered I thought this post was talking about me
I just noticed my hair was in a ponytail all day. I don’t like doing it because I think it pulls hair out and I’m already going bald and getting depressed
i dunno, outside sig my only real suggestion would be shrugyeeting srceenplay for not having many posts and a suspicion of creature that seems kind of pants
beyond that not much sticking out to me, I think neon and pyxxy could both be low effort town so wouldn't really want to vote them. i'm reading a bit of svs in game of champions now and still think she's okay this game
well, anyway i wasn't trying to be rude, sorry. i just view being flippant different from someone who is making posts that look like they're trying to blend in but aren't actually doing a lot
sig wrote: ↑Wed Mar 15, 2023 4:39 pm
I’ve never seen lucy scum game but I’m assuming it’s the way she’s playing now so I’m happy with my vote staying there for now
nutella wrote: ↑Thu Mar 16, 2023 1:49 am
Eh you're slightly better now but middling yes
yes.. i also take kinda major issue with how creature has continually casually tossed gira's name around/tacking him on. like i went into sod thinking gira was main poe but he has been posting pretty well and i moved him up. creatye has just kinda maintained that he is basically on level with scotty and it feels wrong
