STAR WARS Mafia [ENDGAME]

#2401

Well right now you suck at it, Golden.

#2402

BECAUSE GLORFINDEL SHALL DIE

#2403

I honestly think, if anyone does not believe Mac is bad, they should lynch me instead.

#2404

Fine, as usual my cases are either crap or scum driven. Next time I'm civ I will just act like a dick to people, wait until other cases are made and argue with them or just bandwagon them and generally just make obvious calls on things. I am so sick of trying. Anyone would think I'm never right the way people treat almost every case I make...

#2405

Golden wrote:I honestly think, if anyone does not believe Mac is bad, they should lynch me instead.

That is just whack yo.

linki - That is just whack yo.

#2406

I've said this before I believe this is mac/Golden thing is Civ on civ. However, I don't like Golden saying his statements are lie detectable first off we don't even know if that is a role, second off the only thing we know about a lie detecting item is that the Jawa sold one. this could've easily been bought by one of the scum teams and this is in fact what first pinged me about Sorsha.

linki: Why are we betting me? :P

#2407

It isn't whack.

If it was whack, I wouldn't suggest it.

I bet ONE sig.

#2408

MacDougall wrote:Fine, as usual my cases are either crap or scum driven. Next time I'm civ I will just act like a dick to people, wait until other cases are made and argue with them or just bandwagon them and generally just make obvious calls on things. I am so sick of trying. Anyone would think I'm never right the way people treat almost every case I make...

I mean this is pretty much what I do and I have to say I love it. That is when people aren't taking what I say too seriously, of course.

#2409

sig wrote:I've said this before I believe this is mac/Golden thing is Civ on civ. However, I don't like Golden saying his statements are lie detectable first off we don't even know if that is a role, second off the only thing we know about a lie detecting item is that the Jawa sold one. this could've easily been bought by one of the scum teams and this is in fact what first pinged me about Sorsha.

linki: Why are we betting me? :P

I like this post except the linki part because I wanted to make that joke first.

#2410

a2thezebra wrote:
Golden wrote:I honestly think, if anyone does not believe Mac is bad, they should lynch me instead.
That is just whack yo.

linki - That is just whack yo.

But it's true. Trust me. I am the person who it happens to.

Time and time again I get gut reads that turn out to be right but nobody ever actually acts on them. In fact in this very game I had a gut read that nobody acted on until days later and then Golden called my initial case bullshit and is taking the fucking credit for it. It sucks balls. It always happens. People just don't get the way I find scum and think I'm stupid or something.

#2411

I concur with Golden, if you think I am civ, and I assume that everybody does because I am civ and not everyone can be as wrong as he, you should vote for Golden. I have no idea how he arrived at that conclusion as a sound one. But I agree with it.

#2412

Interesting thing about Simon he was R2-D2

BTSC with C-3PO. R2D2 receives a transmission from another group’s BTSC.

I will ISO Simon with this in mind, he could've very well been dropping hints about what he heard in BTSC.

Everyone thoughts on Sorsha?

#2413

I'm wrong all the time. Doesn't stop me!

@Mac - you got full credit for it in Dune, after the game. If you are not on a team with Enrique, I'll give you full credit for that too. I've only played with you when you're a civvie once (that is so far known - world reborn and this game tbd) and I already have a great deal of respect for your civilian game.

It's part of the reason I don't feel like this is it.

However - I try not to let my own opinions on people within a game be influenced by emotive statements.

#2414

Jiminy Christmas Mac I don't think you are stupid just because I disagree with your gut reads and cases from time to time, which is way less often than you think. And I don't think others think you are stupid, either. I often feel that people think I'm stupid here too but that's their problem, not mine anyway. If you're right you're right and if you're wrong you're wrong, it ain't a big deal until someone makes it a big deal. I try not to ever be that someone and I think you'll have more fun here (and feel less anxious against players that are aggressive like me...and Golden...and yourself) if you do the same.

linki - I have no idea about Sorsha. I got nothing.

#2415

Whatever, it is what it is, I'm focusing elsewhere for the rest of the game.

Sorsha is a pretty good read for me. I have Canuck and sig are my strongest civ reads so I'd really like to see some good action from both of them today.

#2416

Oh hi Glorfindel, care to explain that MacDougall vote?

#2417

Pah! Glorfindel voted for me. I am confirmed town now.

#2418

MacDougall wrote:Pah! Glorfindel voted for me. I am confirmed town now.

Lol

Well, to be fair, I'd think Glorfindel is team Empire if bad.

#2419

So read over Simon, day 1 he mentions Roxy.

Simon wrote:I don't have a reason for chosing to ask Russ first about Boba Fett. I believe Russ when he answered me.

I think Roxy might be bad and I'll vote to lynch her. She isn't talking much and might be trying to hide about being a baddie.

Then again on Day 4

Simon wrote: I think Roxy might be bad.

Day 5 vote

Simon wrote:I'm voting Canucklehead. I think Canucklehead might be bad.

So he is suspicious of Roxy starting Day 1 and doesn't mention her again until Day 4, his day 5 vote goes to Canucklehead.

What does everyone think of this?

#2420

I don't know what to make of it. Any of it.

#2421

Just saw Glorfindel's vote, I have zebra in null slight civ read right know, golden and Mac are also civ reads to me so I won't be voting for either. I will most likely be placing my vote to save Mac/Golden without getting the other one lynched. As off right know I'd most likely lynch Glorfindel. I've had some really negative ping based around his posts, and I don't like the Mac lynch or the Golden lynch. I think they both riled the other up and are know seeing each other as scum, this is going to be awaste of a day phase if either are lynched, and if we only focus on them.

#2422

Glorfindel disappeared.

#2423

I will say that the BTSC Simon got a glimpse of was more likely to be the Empire than the Hutts.

#2424

Golden wrote:I honestly think, if anyone does not believe Mac is bad, they should lynch me instead.

I'm not 100% sold. Summary pls?

#2425

Dom wrote:
Golden wrote:I honestly think, if anyone does not believe Mac is bad, they should lynch me instead.
I'm not 100% sold. Summary pls?

On which half - lynching Mac, or lynching me?

#2426

Golden wrote:
Dom wrote:
Golden wrote:I honestly think, if anyone does not believe Mac is bad, they should lynch me instead.
I'm not 100% sold. Summary pls?
On which half - lynching Mac, or lynching me?

-_-

#2427

Lol - really though Dom, serious question.

#2428

Golden wrote:Lol - really though Dom, serious question.

Why do you think Mac is that bad?

#2429

Dom wrote:
Golden wrote:Lol - really though Dom, serious question.
Why do you think Mac is that bad?

Summary

I think there are links to him being Team Hutt
I think his case on me is insincere

The longer version has to wait for another day, when I have more time.

#2430

spacedaisy is replacing Glordindel

#2431

Dammit, I can't possibly vote for daisy, she's inside my clique.

#2432

Welcome spacedaisy don't think we've played together before so looking forward to it.

Are we able to lynch players who replace into the thread the first day they replace in?

#2433

I don't afford protections on people just because they replace in. That disrupts the game and effectively adds "powers" that didn't exist before. You want to lynch spacedaisy? Go for it. Votes for Glorfindel will go to spacedaisy.

#2434

Golden wrote:Dammit, I can't possibly vote for daisy, she's inside my clique.

Awwwe!!!

sig wrote:Welcome spacedaisy don't think we've played together before so looking forward to it.

Are we able to lynch players who replace into the thread the first day they replace in?

Yay! I love playing with new people! New to me anyway.

So I just got home a little while ago and I still haven't done dinner yet. I'll try to get myself situated game we've once I get done with that.

#2435

It's not often that Spacedaisy and MovingPictures are playing a game together.

And I have to go and be dead when it happens.

#2436

Okay thanks Epi, just making sure.

Space looking forward to some of your reads if you could specifically give me your thoughts on
Sorsha
Roxy
MP
Bass 2.0
Zebra

Know I was planning to vote for Glorfindel soon, however with Space replacing him I will hold my vote for the time, as of right know I'm still likely to place my vote on Glor/Space but won't be voting until closer to the deadline.

#2437

Spacedaisy hi.

Can u plz tell us if u r bad. Save time.

#2438

Epignosis wrote:spacedaisy is replacing Glordindel

Spacedaisy!!!

Anyway, no more waiting. Going to read the entire thread from Night 1 onward, tonight. Yay!

Can I still "PULL" ?

If so, PULL

#2439

What does PULL mean?

Also sig, my first read from your list was Sorsha. I'm not going to quote posts, I'm just going to give my impression and also note things that jumped out at me.

First impression, she isn't contributing all that much. Second impression, omg she is in three games at once it seems, judging by her user post page so I guess it is not surprising she is not contributing much. "She crazy"

Now the only thing of note from my read of her posts is the fact she clearly believed Matt had info on the Death Star option on some poll or other but once she learned it was a civ option she still found him pong worthy enough to vote for him. That seems odd.

Oh wait, there was one more thing. She seemed to soft defend Enrique, but then voted him. It seems she was the second to last vote on him, he was already dead so that is not an altogether convincing vote.

Judging just by those two things, I can see why she is on your list of people you want opinions about.

Ok. First ISO down. Now I want some sleep and I am not feeling extremely well. So apologies for not doing more, I intended to do a few tonight, but that's not going to happen.

Btw two things, first thanks sig for giving me a focus coming into the game. It's always hard to replace in when a bunch of crap has already happened so it's hard to find your footing, that helped give me a jumping off place coming into it.

Secondly, I use a crappy iPad to play, and for some reasons, big photos just run off the side of the page for me. What this means for this game is I can't view the polls DH posts in screen cap form. Luckily it seems the Enrigue vote was posted by Epi, so that was good. I may need some help when it comes to evaluating voting records.

Ok, sleep now.

#2440

Matt wrote:
Epignosis wrote:spacedaisy is replacing Glordindel
Spacedaisy!!!

Anyway, no more waiting. Going to read the entire thread from Night 1 onward, tonight. Yay!

Can I still "PULL" ?

If so, PULL

Matt!!!

P.S. you will always be Mr F to me. And yes I do hear it Arrested Development style in my head... "For British Eyes Only"

#2441

sig wrote:Interesting thing about Simon he was R2-D2

BTSC with C-3PO. R2D2 receives a transmission from another group’s BTSC.

I will ISO Simon with this in mind, he could've very well been dropping hints about what he heard in BTSC.

Everyone thoughts on Sorsha?

Sorsha has really no idea wtf is going on this game and is stupid for signing up for three games. Luckily she was killed off in one of them so she should have a little bit more time to spend on this one. I'm sure she is civ though since I've seen her role card. Anyway, hopefully she'll get some reading in this morning before she falls asleep, she works third shift so that sucks for her too.

#2442

Golden vs Mac, kiwi vs Aussie, east coast vs west coast, bloods vs crips, etc etc

I think Macs theory is fine, I checked the last couple of games Golden has played (recruitment and world reborn) and Golden Didnt make any memes in those. Mac might be bad too but I like the meme observation he found for golden.

#2443

Epignosis wrote:spacedaisy is replacing Glordindel

Well this day just got more interesting. Welcome daisy, sorry I've already voted for you before giving you a chance but the previous inhabitant of your role was pretty damning, I hope you agree, at least to an extent. If it helps I like your content a lot so far.

Metalmarsh89 wrote:It's not often that Spacedaisy and MovingPictures are playing a game together.

And I have to go and be dead when it happens.

I want you back too, you should ask DH or Epi to replace one of the lower posters! Bubbles perhaps?

Sorsha wrote:Golden vs Mac, kiwi vs Aussie, east coast vs west coast, bloods vs crips, etc etc

I think Macs theory is fine, I checked the last couple of games Golden has played (recruitment and world reborn) and Golden Didnt make any memes in those. Mac might be bad too but I like the meme observation he found for golden.

It was originally Matt's observation tho, at least the part about Salacious amusing Jabba.

#2444

What does it matter whose theory it was?

#2445

Sorsha wrote:What does it matter whose theory it was?

It matters because the one who initially found the connection wasn't anywhere near as sold on it being a confirmation as MacDougall is. Also, giving credit where credit's due eh

#2446

Welome to the game dance partner! Shall we take another twirl?

So... Sober state... Watching the progression of Golden vs Mac is rather sad, as amused Drunk Wilgy was by it...

I'm going to look through Canuck, for why do the good astromech droids die young?

#2447

a2thezebra wrote:
Sorsha wrote:What does it matter whose theory it was?
It matters because the one who initially found the connection wasn't anywhere near as sold on it being a confirmation as MacDougall is. Also, giving credit where credit's due eh

I don't think Matt saw that there was a second instance of Golden amusing Jabba. He only saw the one that could have been Black Rock amusing him too.

#2448

MacDougall wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:
Sorsha wrote:What does it matter whose theory it was?
It matters because the one who initially found the connection wasn't anywhere near as sold on it being a confirmation as MacDougall is. Also, giving credit where credit's due eh
I don't think Matt saw that there was a second instance of Golden amusing Jabba. He only saw the one that could have been Black Rock amusing him too.

Good point. I would love to hear from him about this when he returns.

#2449

Whoa. Lots and lots to sort out. Apologies if these forthcoming thoughts are scattered or useless...

#2450

Firstly, I don't understand why Golden thinks Matt's/Mac's theory is crazy, especially since he played Rober Rabbit where I invented a very similar gambit to catch ALLTHE BADDIES HAHAHAHAHHAHHAA, which Epi liked....unless, of course, Golden is bad. He's claiming he had a role similar to Crumb in that game, and I don't remember that....but maybe it was just because I was too wrapped up in CATCHING ALL THE BADDIES HAHAHHAHHAAHHAH.
Regardless, there is NO REASON that Golden should be pushing back so crazily against this idea of Mac's because, like, it has literally been done in an Epi game before. So Golden suggesting Mac is wrong is fine....but suggesting that the whole idea is preposterous is......preposterous.

And to be honest, I actually agree with Mac that the whole real-life-personal-ethics bets should be off the table. Dog bets, too, but I give less shits about those.

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

Who Dies Next?