Arkham Mafia [ENDGAME]

#5502

MP when someone does not shut up no matter what I say to them, I don't want to talk anymore. Take that as you may. If all kinds of people see bread crumbs, the last thing that is fun for me is arguing with someone loves nothing more than talking about themself. I just give up.

#5503

MP I know you're straight up lying if you say the Typh as the Penguin theory "makes sense," unless you're not giving it any thought at all. Reassess, and if you're still alive, tell me what you think.

#5504

I think MP is invested in this game.

#5505

@Enrique: I'll confess that I had you pegged as high likelihood of Town after your Day 2 performance. MP accuses you of being opportunistic and you voted for me this phase without any justification that I can see when MP (a player you have suspected on many occasions throughout this game is a highly eligible candidate). Before I reassess my opinion of you, could you please explain on what grounds you considered me a better lynch choice than MP?

#5506

Who murdered sig?

Poll ended at Sat Feb 27, 2016 8:45 pm

Bass_the_Clever
0
No votes

bea
0
No votes

Bubbles
0
No votes

Bullzeye
0
No votes

DharmaHelper
0
No votes

DFaraday
0
No votes

Dom
0
No votes

ekeknat
1
Glorfindel (26)
4%

Enrique
0
No votes

Equivocate
0
No votes

Golden
0
No votes

Glorfindel
5
Turnip Head (6), Scotty (9), Metalmarsh89 (13), Enrique (14), Typhoony (16)
19%

juliets
0
No votes

Lorab
0
No votes

MacDougall
0
No votes

Matt
0
No votes

MetalMarsh89
0
No votes

MovingPictures07
16
MovingPictures07 (3), DharmaHelper (7), Matt (8), juliets (10), Golden (11), MacDougall (12), LoRab (17), S~V~S (18), Bullzeye (19), Dom (20), ekeknat (21), DFaraday (22), sabie12 (23), Sorsha (24), bea (25), sprityo (27)
59%

sabie12
0
No votes

Scotty
0
No votes

Sorsha
0
No votes

sprityo
0
No votes

S~V~S
0
No votes

TheFloyd73
0
No votes

Turnip Head
0
No votes

Typhoony
0
No votes

The Batcave (The Hosts, the Non, the Dead)
5
Epignosis (1), sig (2), Quin (4), Long Con (5), a2thezebra (15)
19%

Total votes : 27

#5507

Glorfindel wrote:@Enrique: I'll confess that I had you pegged as high likelihood of Town after your Day 2 performance. MP accuses you of being opportunistic and you voted for me this phase without any justification that I can see when MP (a player you have suspected on many occasions throughout this game is a highly eligible candidate). Before I reassess my opinion of you, could you please explain on what grounds you considered me a better lynch choice than MP?

I didn't.

#5508

Enrique wrote:
Glorfindel wrote:@Enrique: I'll confess that I had you pegged as high likelihood of Town after your Day 2 performance. MP accuses you of being opportunistic and you voted for me this phase without any justification that I can see when MP (a player you have suspected on many occasions throughout this game is a highly eligible candidate). Before I reassess my opinion of you, could you please explain on what grounds you considered me a better lynch choice than MP?
I didn't.

You're saying that you had no grounds upon which you based your decision to lynch me?

#5509

I'm saying there was no "decision to lynch you" lol.

#5510

Enrique wrote:I'm saying there was no "decision to lynch you" lol.

Thank you, Enrique.

#5511

Something's happening right now, and I get the feeling it's not MP being lynched.

#5512

It's habbening.

#5513

Bad Weather

Gotham City may be troubled by crime, but weather takes its toll as well.

A man wakes up in the middle of a storm and turned on his battery-powered radio. It comes on. He positions the channel to hear the local station clearly.

"...wasn't successful...crowds dispersed after..."

No one has been lynched. It is now Night 5. You have 24 hours to submit your PMs.

#5514

Fucking kidding me lol

#5515

Yeah, not really surprised. MP has some explaining to do about why that would be in our interests.

#5516

Well now that we got that over with...

#5517

S~V~S wrote:MP when someone does not shut up no matter what I say to them, I don't want to talk anymore. Take that as you may. If all kinds of people see bread crumbs, the last thing that is fun for me is arguing with someone loves nothing more than talking about themself. I just give up.

Duly noted, thanks for the explanation.

#5518

Enrique wrote:MP I know you're straight up lying if you say the Typh as the Penguin theory "makes sense," unless you're not giving it any thought at all. Reassess, and if you're still alive, tell me what you think.

Sure, I'll take a detailed look. Do you have any posts that you or others made that you particularly want me to consider?

#5519

MP, I feel as though you have pro-town motivations for this whole lynch thing, but I still want to hear more from you, within the bounds of what can be said.

Stuff like, well... this

... makes me paranoid.

#5520

Golden wrote:Yeah, not really surprised. MP has some explaining to do about why that would be in our interests.

I do? What were you expecting exactly?

Have I not said that you all would be wasting your time?

#5521

MovingPictures07 wrote:
Golden wrote:Yeah, not really surprised. MP has some explaining to do about why that would be in our interests.
I do? What were you expecting exactly?

Have I not said that you all would be wasting your time?

Yes... but you also equally encouraged the lynch and voted for yourself, so...

is there a reason for you encouraging us to 'waste our time'?

#5522

Golden wrote:MP, I feel as though you have pro-town motivations for this whole lynch thing, but I still want to hear more from you, within the bounds of what can be said.

Stuff like, well... this ... makes me paranoid.

You mean my usage of that emoticon? Lol, I was just playing. Or do you mean something else?

What questions do you have for me specifically?

I'm in intermission at a play with my wife at the moment, and I'm not sure what the evening will bring thereafter, and I've got a full phd schedule tomorrow, so just a heads up. I'll contribute as much as I can when I can though. On that note, if anyone has any questions on my rainbow list or wants to engage me in conversation about any player that'd be great. Just let me know.

BBL

Linki let me address this more later, but if you want an indirect answer I would suggest skimming my ISO, since I think my thought process is there to a degree.

#5523

It's impossible to be sure what was genuine thought process and what was obfuscation before the lynch. Better that you give a recap of which aspects of your behaviour were more pertinent / straightforward, when you have time.

#5524

Hey, Mac, your prisoner idea?

I just realised what the sockpuppets are currently called...

#5525

Golden wrote:Hey, Mac, your prisoner idea?

I just realised what the sockpuppets are currently called...

What do you think this means?

#5526

MacDougall wrote:
Golden wrote:Hey, Mac, your prisoner idea?

I just realised what the sockpuppets are currently called...
What do you think this means?

No idea, it could even be related to Turf Wars not this one. Just thought it is worth pointing out.

#5527

Golden wrote:
MacDougall wrote:
Golden wrote:Hey, Mac, your prisoner idea?

I just realised what the sockpuppets are currently called...
What do you think this means?
No idea, it could even be related to Turf Wars not this one. Just thought it is worth pointing out.

Let me rephrase... what could it possibly mean?

#5528

MacDougall wrote:
Golden wrote:
MacDougall wrote:
Golden wrote:Hey, Mac, your prisoner idea?

I just realised what the sockpuppets are currently called...
What do you think this means?
No idea, it could even be related to Turf Wars not this one. Just thought it is worth pointing out.
Let me rephrase... what could it possibly mean?

Threads that are only visible when you are logged into your sock.

#5529

A shadow game being played by people who are vanishing from the thread...

But I don't think it is worth speculating too far, because MP can surely confirm if they are for Turf Wars when he gets back, and if thats what they are then we don't need to speculate further.

#5530

MovingPictures07 wrote:
Enrique wrote:MP I know you're straight up lying if you say the Typh as the Penguin theory "makes sense," unless you're not giving it any thought at all. Reassess, and if you're still alive, tell me what you think.
Sure, I'll take a detailed look. Do you have any posts that you or others made that you particularly want me to consider?

I want you to think about where this comes from, Typhoony voting for you and your subsequent number one suspect "curse." Now, I can relate to what was happening to you, and I know it had nothing to do with the Penguin. I'm not allowed to say more, but you should know what I'm talking about.

And that's all there is on Typh, really. Nobody he voted for has been blackmailed as far as we know, so why do we think he's the Penguin again? Where's that good case with all the evidence people keep talking about?

#5531

Whatever just happened in that lynch, I think it really benefited the civilian cause.

#5532

Golden wrote:A shadow game being played by people who are vanishing from the thread...

But I don't think it is worth speculating too far, because MP can surely confirm if they are for Turf Wars when he gets back, and if thats what they are then we don't need to speculate further.

If MP knows what the socks are and they are part of this game, that wouldn't really be fair would it?

#5533

MacDougall wrote:
Golden wrote:A shadow game being played by people who are vanishing from the thread...

But I don't think it is worth speculating too far, because MP can surely confirm if they are for Turf Wars when he gets back, and if thats what they are then we don't need to speculate further.
If MP knows what the socks are and they are part of this game, that wouldn't really be fair would it?

He should know if they are part of HIS game. That's a different thing entirely.

#5534

Golden wrote:
MacDougall wrote:
Golden wrote:A shadow game being played by people who are vanishing from the thread...

But I don't think it is worth speculating too far, because MP can surely confirm if they are for Turf Wars when he gets back, and if thats what they are then we don't need to speculate further.
If MP knows what the socks are and they are part of this game, that wouldn't really be fair would it?
He should know if they are part of HIS game. That's a different thing entirely.

Sorry I thought the inference is that because he is El Presidente he is privy to such matters regardless... my bad.

#5535

Sorsha wrote:
LoRab wrote:MP's posts are reading, to me, like someone who wants to be lynched--not in a done with this game sort of way, but in a role needing to be lynched kind of way. Voting that way before I fall asleep on the keyboard.
Weren't you against this kind of thing when Mac was doing it in World Reborn?

I thought Mac was evil in world reborn. I'm not getting an evil vibe from mp. So that's a difference.

DFaraday wrote:
Sorsha wrote:
DFaraday wrote:
Sorsha wrote:
DFaraday wrote:
Sorsha wrote: What vote of mine was shifty?

Sorsha wrote:Isn't it a Syndicate Mafia tradition to lynch the new player first? Maybe that's why there was a no lynch yesterday

I had been thinking of giving Matt the botd in his lynch Nero/Enrique crusade anyway (and I don't think Matt is bad, I think he's Indy based on a couple of posts he's made today) so I'll be voting for Nero today's since he's come up with both Matt and Enrique.

I hope you guys are right!
You'd hardly discussed the case before coming in and voting, gave little reason for your vote, and tried to absolve yourself of responsibility by saying "I hope you guys are right!"
i explained this already
You did? I'm looking over your posts and not really finding an explanation. Except for where you say you'll take responsibility for your vote, but then close by saying it's pretty much all Matt and Enrique.
This post:
Sorsha wrote:Yes, them being right about Nero. I will take responsibility for my vote if it turns out to be bad but really.... Most of these votes are coming in because of Enrique and Matt.
I never really understood what was so wrong with this post of mine anyway. Quite a few players were just tossing on to Nero, trusting that Matt and Enrique were right. I happened to add the "hope you guys are right" and I'm the one who gets shit over it.... I don't understand.
Not the only one. I have also called out LoRab for her bandwagony vote as well. Bubbles is similar, but she always acts that way.

i voted for a player that was mafia and others had voted for them, as well. Not sure that constitutes a bandwagon, but semantics.

#5536

Only popping in for a minute, but I can confirm that those sockpuppets are not of relevance to this game.

#5537

Metalmarsh89 wrote:Whatever just happened in that lynch, I think it really benefited the civilian cause.

Where did I say this would really benefit the civilian cause? Link please.

#5538

Enrique, let me mull on that.

BBL all.

#5539

Metalmarsh89 wrote:I think MP is invested in this game.

no shit.
this is why i am so so so supsicious of him. he keeps saying he isn't invested but so clearly is.

#5540

Well shit now that MP has shed his skin I guess I should look into other suspects huh?

#5541

All in all a good result - we go into Night 4 not having lost a Townie - if nothing else, it's bought us some valuable time.

#5542

OK, that surprised me. I expected something unusual, but not that.

Golden wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:
Golden wrote:Yeah, not really surprised. MP has some explaining to do about why that would be in our interests.
I do? What were you expecting exactly?

Have I not said that you all would be wasting your time?
Yes... but you also equally encouraged the lynch and voted for yourself, so... is there a reason for you encouraging us to 'waste our time'?

This ^^

I really did feel he was encouraging us to lynch him, like there was a point to it. And Glorfindel, we did not lose any civs, true, but we did not learn anything either.

Early in the game I found Glorfindel to be somewhat suspicious, but then I did some reading of the roles, and rereading a few people, and backed off of that becasue I saw at least one civ possibility for his behavior. Now it looks like he is gathering suspicion again. So I plan to reread him, and the new suspicions of him.

One quick question, can anyone explain to me why they are so sure that Zebra was bad? Other than by who killed her? Becasue my thoughts on Glorfindel are wrapped up inmy thoughts on Zebra.

#5543

S~V~S wrote:OK, that surprised me. I expected something unusual, but not that.

Golden wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:
Golden wrote:Yeah, not really surprised. MP has some explaining to do about why that would be in our interests.
I do? What were you expecting exactly?

Have I not said that you all would be wasting your time?
Yes... but you also equally encouraged the lynch and voted for yourself, so... is there a reason for you encouraging us to 'waste our time'?
This ^^

I really did feel he was encouraging us to lynch him, like there was a point to it. And Glorfindel, we did not lose any civs, true, but we did not learn anything either.

Early in the game I found Glorfindel to be somewhat suspicious, but then I did some reading of the roles, and rereading a few people, and backed off of that becasue I saw at least one civ possibility for his behavior. Now it looks like he is gathering suspicion again. So I plan to reread him, and the new suspicions of him.

One quick question, can anyone explain to me why they are so sure that Zebra was bad? Other than by who killed her? Becasue my thoughts on Glorfindel are wrapped up inmy thoughts on Zebra.

Nobody except me is sure she was bad. Most think she was an inmate.

I think we learned one thing, and that's MP isn't Mafia. There is no Mafia role that can stop lynches.

#5544

Oh,I thought other people had said that as well.

#5545

S~V~S wrote:Oh,I thought other people had said that as well.

I think my case on her was water tight and she was pretty much a lock to be lynched imo. Then she died and the prevailing theory became that because she haphazardly indie claimed she must be one.

What's your theory?

#5546

MovingPictures07 wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:Whatever just happened in that lynch, I think it really benefited the civilian cause.
Where did I say this would really benefit the civilian cause? Link please.

MovingPictures07 wrote: For the record, just so you all know, I don't need to be lynched. It's a pros/cons thing, but I think there is benefit to it at this stage.

MovingPictures07 wrote: You're definitely one to talk, since you're likely anti-town. I'm not.

So you say you're not anti-town, but there is benefit to your lynch. The obvious implication behind your recent posts is a benefit to the civvie cause. But since we learned nothing from that lynch, I have a hard time taking anything you say at face value.

#5547

I don't trust MP. I tink it's become obvious he isn't bad, but I do not trust him.

#5548

well I got a little bug and was throwing up every hour on the hour last night and am traveling all day today. I will not be on at all and still feel like shit. I'm trying my best not to have the guy next to me get nervous and get me thrown of lf the plane because of Ebola or some shit.

Dom wrote:I don't trust MP. I tink it's become obvious he isn't bad, but I do not trust him.

Who is he then, Dom? Because I thematically see two possibilities, and one of those possibilities I've already expressed interest in before day 4 started. I think MP is nothing but good for town.

#5549

Make that 3 roles, but I'm relatively sure I know which of them it is.
Also a very good chance that the Penguin now knows MP's role.
I actually agree with most of MP's list.
Can we lynch Glorf tomorrow? Please?

Scotty out.

#5550

Scotty wrote:well I got a little bug and was throwing up every hour on the hour last night and am traveling all day today. I will not be on at all and still feel like shit. I'm trying my best not to have the guy next to me get nervous and get me thrown of lf the plane because of Ebola or some shit.

Dom wrote:I don't trust MP. I tink it's become obvious he isn't bad, but I do not trust him.
Who is he then, Dom? Because I thematically see two possibilities, and one of those possibilities I've already expressed interest in before day 4 started. I think MP is nothing but good for town.

Nothing but good?
Then why do what we did today?

I don't think he's Mafia, but I'm hesitant to trust him.

Scotty wrote:Make that 3 roles, but I'm relatively sure I know which of them it is.
Also a very good chance that the Penguin now knows MP's role.
I actually agree with most of MP's list.
Can we lynch Glorf tomorrow? Please?

Scotty out.

I'm down for a Glorf lynch.

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

Who killed no one?