Rocky and Bullwinkle - The Legend of Frostbite Falls [Day 8]

#1251

DrWilgy wrote:
Long Con wrote:No, you are trying to change the story here. You claimed to be Natasha'd on the same night I did.
Show me

I looked... I think that maybe we had different definitions of the word "yesterday"? If you weren't claiming to be seduced for Day 3 (the vote I was Scrooched for) then... I was mistaken.

However, your claim that the Natasha PM contained no message of instruction from Natasha is still extremely suspicious, because it did for me.

#1252

Sloonei wrote:I also still don't think "one of LC or Wilgy is lying" has to be true. Right now I think they're both telling the truth, unless I'm misreadinng something.
LC claims to have been seduced and scrooched day 3, right? And Wilgy claims to have been seduced Day 4? Whatever potential differences exist in the alleged and off-limits Host PM do not strike me as necessarily contradictory. I am leaning town on both of them right now.

C'mon now LC, Sloon even pointed it out here.

If you misunderstood "yesterday" why did you post this?

Long Con wrote:
DrWilgy wrote:Yeah, yesterday and yesterday only.
You are not going to win this "who is lying?" debate, friend. Especially when someone comes forward and tells us that Natasha forced their vote in the last lynch.

It doesn't make sense for you to even suggest waiting for the counter claim, if you had thought I was strictly counter claiming you.

I also think you ignored a comment I made about you waiting for the counter claim. Had the story changed in your head by the time you read that?

#1253

Long Con wrote: However, your claim that the Natasha PM contained no message of instruction from Natasha is still extremely suspicious, because it did for me.

Please refrain from discussing the specific content of host PMs.

#1254

thellama73 wrote:
Long Con wrote: However, your claim that the Natasha PM contained no message of instruction from Natasha is still extremely suspicious, because it did for me.
Please refrain from discussing the specific content of host PMs.

I thought that was as unspecific as I could get, but no problemo.

Sloonei wrote:
DrWilgy wrote:
Sloonei wrote:Did I miss the reason why you are so confident Long Con is bad?
He lied about Natasha
how do you know? has natasha seduced you too?

DrWilgy wrote:Yeah, yesterday and yesterday only.

Wilgy, this is where it looks like you are claiming to be seduced by Natasha. You said I lied about Natasha, and then said you were seduced "yesterday". This was on Night 4. To me, saying you were seduced "today" means Day 4... when it is Night 4. And "yesterday" is referring to Day 3.

#1255

Long Con wrote:
thellama73 wrote:
Long Con wrote: However, your claim that the Natasha PM contained no message of instruction from Natasha is still extremely suspicious, because it did for me.
Please refrain from discussing the specific content of host PMs.
I thought that was as unspecific as I could get, but no problemo.

Sloonei wrote:
DrWilgy wrote:
Sloonei wrote:Did I miss the reason why you are so confident Long Con is bad?
He lied about Natasha
how do you know? has natasha seduced you too?

DrWilgy wrote:Yeah, yesterday and yesterday only.
Wilgy, this is where it looks like you are claiming to be seduced by Natasha. You said I lied about Natasha, and then said you were seduced "yesterday". This was on Night 4. To me, saying you were seduced "today" means Day 4... when it is Night 4. And "yesterday" is referring to Day 3.

Then why did you quote this with "
You are not going to win this "who is lying?" debate, friend. Especially when someone comes forward and tells us that Natasha forced their vote in the last lynch.

" Suggesting you were waiting for a counter claim?

#1256

DrWilgy wrote:
Long Con wrote:
thellama73 wrote:
Long Con wrote: However, your claim that the Natasha PM contained no message of instruction from Natasha is still extremely suspicious, because it did for me.
Please refrain from discussing the specific content of host PMs.
I thought that was as unspecific as I could get, but no problemo.

Sloonei wrote:
DrWilgy wrote:
Sloonei wrote:Did I miss the reason why you are so confident Long Con is bad?
He lied about Natasha
how do you know? has natasha seduced you too?

DrWilgy wrote:Yeah, yesterday and yesterday only.
Wilgy, this is where it looks like you are claiming to be seduced by Natasha. You said I lied about Natasha, and then said you were seduced "yesterday". This was on Night 4. To me, saying you were seduced "today" means Day 4... when it is Night 4. And "yesterday" is referring to Day 3.
Then why did you quote this with "
You are not going to win this "who is lying?" debate, friend. Especially when someone comes forward and tells us that Natasha forced their vote in the last lynch. " Suggesting you were waiting for a counter claim?

I was... but the whole genesis of that theory was based on you claiming to be Natasha'd the same night I was.

I'm sheepishly going to have to say that Wilgy is not currently a suspect of mine.

#1257

nijuukyugou wrote:
Sloonei wrote:Long Con's claim is thr first and only thing to give me pause so far on this Scotty wagon, but all the votes are locked into place anyway. Apparently the Battle of the Hosts has sucked me in completely and I don't know how to balance playing in two games at once as well. I promise to say more things later.
It gave me pause, too, but I'm wondering why he took so long (hehe) to reveal this information - why didn't he say it earlier yesterday when there were more people around (or would have eventually come to read it) to discuss it? He had posts earlier in the day, too. Strange timing.

I've caught up, and I'm voting Scotty, because it's the simplest route, logically - his survival most likely points to his being Nell or Fearless Leader, and it's a win-win voting again (except that it would "waste" a lynch if Nell, but not really waste since we'd get info, or it wouldn't win if Epi happened to be Dudley). Yes I know that's all been said, but that's the bane of my coming in so late in the Day when so much has been discussed.

Ninjablooper looks like she's very likely a Civ from this, so I wouldn't vote for her.

Long Con wrote:@bea: Yes, yesterday was the last lynch, and it is the one I'm talking about. The lynch that Wilgy and I are both claiming to have been seduced by Natasha is the lynch before that. I'm interested in finding out who was seduced into voting someone during the last lynch.

Just quoting this to show exactly where my mind was, and that I clearly thought you were claiming Day 3 seduction. Wilgy, why didn't you correct me immediately??

a2thezebra wrote:I'm not voting for DrWilgy or S~V~S today.

A baddie would know that both of these players are Civ. Zebra could be buddying here. Then she votes for Elohcin, who a (Civ) Epi was adamant was Civ.

Zebra, Sorsha, sprityo. Those are now my main suspicions.

#1258

I just voted for Sorsha.

#1259

Do we have a face palm smilie yet?

*previews*

Nope... We should get one of those.

I'm voting blooper.

#1260

geghghghghh i feel like i havent done anything

(and i havent)

i need some questions regarding a player thrown to me so i can contribute to the conversation

#1261

specifically, regards to blooper, sorsha, and zeebs

but i guess sorsha is about to be gone-zo?

#1262

just due to i dont see anything terribly wrong with sorsha (yet) im gonna vote blooper

more to come maybe later...ha

#1263

Scotty
7
Sloonei (5), S~V~S (6), a2thezebra (7), bea (8), Elohcin (9), Matt (12), nijuukyugou (14) 47%

Ok, my statement earlier about Ninjablooper was based on a mistake regarding her place in Scotty's (second) lynch. She got on the Scotty lynch train after he was already a goner.

I'm going with the Blooper vote for now instead of the Sorsha vote.

#1264

sprityo wrote:just due to i dont see anything terribly wrong with sorsha (yet) im gonna vote blooper

more to come maybe later...ha

I just voted Blooper... you have not yet.

#1265

a2thezebra wrote:
Elohcin wrote:Oh my goodness, finally I'm so glad we caught a baddie. I didn't think it would take this long. And Scotty...I was right about you. Haha, I guess I do know your baddie game after being bad with you. And you are now dead so you can't say a word about it :P.

honestly i agree with zebra from this, the entire post by elo irks me the wrong way. so i mean if you were to vote anyone it should be one of sorsha or eloh, in my opinion. Im not terribly concerned with the scotty/wilgy thing.

The only thing that really stands out among if i wanted to vote for either sorsha or eloh at this point is that eloh is voting for sorsha, and sorsha is in retaliation of blooper. who isnt wrong in their logic. so ill have to stick with sorsha :/

linki: i changed it after the fact

#1266

ill try my best to make something sufficient the next day, i promise

#1267

sprityo wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:
Elohcin wrote:Oh my goodness, finally I'm so glad we caught a baddie. I didn't think it would take this long. And Scotty...I was right about you. Haha, I guess I do know your baddie game after being bad with you. And you are now dead so you can't say a word about it :P.

honestly i agree with zebra from this, the entire post by elo irks me the wrong way. so i mean if you were to vote anyone it should be one of sorsha or eloh, in my opinion. Im not terribly concerned with the scotty/wilgy thing.

The only thing that really stands out among if i wanted to vote for either sorsha or eloh at this point is that eloh is voting for sorsha, and sorsha is in retaliation of blooper. who isnt wrong in their logic. so ill have to stick with sorsha :/

linki: i changed it after the fact

So, I vote Blooper, and now you don't want to.

#1268

Bea... Where are you?

Hmm... If Sprityo doesn't want to vote Bloopibops or Sorsha, perhaps he was today's Natasha target?

Meaning! We should lynch Eloh to pull Zebra back in the game.

#1269

I'm voting Sorsha rn

Also @LC, why exactly did you change your mind on Sorsha?

#1270

Yknow what, no. I don't particularly like blooper or Eloh as much as I like Sorsha, so I'll follow another trail

#1271

Also yes, bring back Zeebs

#1272

sprityo wrote:Also yes, bring back Zeebs

That was spooky sprityo. I disagree.

#1273

sprityo wrote:what did i miss? scotty is nell?

sprityo wrote:Oh, hur dur I can't read.

Okay, I can just believe people vote fornscotty just for being Scotty

It's comments like these and your non commitment towards anyone else that makes me not want to vote with you.

#1274

Wilgy, given the fact that I was reprimanded privately and what the host said publicly, forgive me for not talking more about my force vote. It's there if you go back and look.

I'm going to vote sorsha. I've had better I've read blooper as civ all game.

#1275

DrWilgy wrote:
sprityo wrote:what did i miss? scotty is nell?

sprityo wrote:Oh, hur dur I can't read.

Okay, I can just believe people vote fornscotty just for being Scotty
It's comments like these and your non commitment towards anyone else that makes me not want to vote with you.

And so what..... It makes him bad? Or you can't vote with him because you don't like how he's playing? Does him voting me and changing his mind and switching make you think that he and I are Mafia together? I'm not understanding how you're making your decisions here wilgy. There are only two Mafia in the game.

#1276

bea wrote:Wilgy, given the fact that I was reprimanded privately and what the host said publicly, forgive me for not talking more about my force vote. It's there if you go back and look.

I'm going to vote sorsha. I've had better I've read blooper as civ all game.

So you think I forced you to vote svs?

#1277

Sorsha wrote:
DrWilgy wrote:
sprityo wrote:what did i miss? scotty is nell?

sprityo wrote:Oh, hur dur I can't read.

Okay, I can just believe people vote fornscotty just for being Scotty
It's comments like these and your non commitment towards anyone else that makes me not want to vote with you.
And so what..... It makes him bad? Or you can't vote with him because you don't like how he's playing? Does him voting me and changing his mind and switching make you think that he and I are Mafia together? I'm not understanding how you're making your decisions here wilgy. There are only two Mafia in the game.

Yeah, and I spread out the votes to see if any mafia would try to do last min vote shenanigans. If you are bad, doing that may just have caught your teammate.

#1278

Genius plan wilgy!

#1279

Night 6

Meanwhile...

The long, lonely tracks stretched out in either direction as far as the eye could see. This was a desolate patch of land, with nothing to recommend it but solitude, which was the reason the sinister man with the handlebar moustache had chosen it. Far away, a train whistle could be heard.

"I'm sorry it had to come to this, my dear," sneered the man, as he flicked a bit of dust off his tall, stovepipe hat. "But since you continue to refuse my advances, you leave me no choice."

The red-haired ingenue stuck out her chin proudly, trying to ignore the discomfort of the ropes which bound her to the railroad tracks. When she spoke, it was in a high, clear voice rich with defiance.

"You'll never get away with this, Snidely Whiplash! My beloved Dudley Do-Right will save me."

The train whistle grew louder.

Snidely Whiplash could only laugh.

"Er, Dudley?" Nell, continued, her voice faltering just a little. "Any time now would be great. Dudley?"

Sorsha has been lynched. She was Nell.

Your beloved host has to travel for work starting this afternoon, and will be booked pretty solid until Sunday. It is very unlikely that the host posts will come at predictable times, and may be delayed considerably. Have a nice long, relaxing night to get me your PMs, and I will update when I can. Sorry for the inconvenience.

#1280

I think sprityo looks pretty bad in this lynch.

#1281

Crap. I'm sorry sorsha.

#1282

We have better drinks & snackzzz in dead land anyhow Sorsha

#1283

Long Con wrote:I think sprityo looks pretty bad in this lynch.

Why?

#1284

S~V~S wrote:

We have better drinks & snackzzz in dead land anyhow Sorsha

QFT

Sorry Sorsha.

#1285

So... Who was forced during the last day phase which?

#1286

man, she was Nell. I really thought this was going to be an easy game for the civs. Sorry Sorsha. I feel helpless.

#1287

RIP Sorsha

#1288

#1289

bwahahahaha

#1290

DrWilgy wrote:
Long Con wrote:I think sprityo looks pretty bad in this lynch.
Why?

The waffling on Ninjablooper or Sorsha, and then escaping to an Elohcin vote to let others lynch Sorsha.

#1291

Anyone get Natasha'd that time?

I'll be quite interested in your answer.

#1292

S~V~S wrote:

We have better drinks & snackzzz in dead land anyhow Sorsha

indiglo wrote:
S~V~S wrote:

We have better drinks & snackzzz in dead land anyhow Sorsha

QFT

Sorry Sorsha.

Golden wrote:RIP Sorsha

Scotty wrote:bwahahahaha

#1293

Anyone wanna baddie hunt?

#1294

Whatever keeps me alive, tbh.

#1295

to be fair LC, Eloh had an equal opportunity to be lynched.

so whatever floats your boat

#1296

sprityo wrote:to be fair LC, Eloh had an equal opportunity to be lynched.

so whatever floats your boat

Context?

#1297

at the time i voted for eloh (like 3 am or something) the votes were REALLY equal, like 2-2-4 (with sorsha being the 4)

i honestly didnt think sorsha was bad (and lo and behold) he wasnt.

Now, alternatively, we look at the people who did vote him, these are all people who've come under suspicion at least once, except maybe minus bea cause she's a.....busy bee.

but im willing to bet at least one of them isnt town aligned. I mean, what are the possibilities that Zebra and Longcon are both the mafia and the town all somehow managed to fudge this up?

#1298

basically what im getting at is what was up with hopping to sorsha last second?

so, @Wilgy and Bea.

LC didnt you have an argument that Wilgy faked being natasha'd?
if you could bring that back up they key points, i'd like to go over it.

But i mean my opinion doesnt REALLY matter right? im just the guy who we signed off as townish for getting scotty un-comfy and then i post a could of words at midnight every now and then

#1299

ebwop: couple* not could

#1300

as a final thing i guess, (if the whole arguement on who got Natasha'd is correct) then you could make the lynch between wilgy and LC tomorrow, but

Who's left?