A Mafia of Unfortunate Events [END GAME]

#3251

sig wrote:Are you going to answer any of my questions or nah?

Why do I think Quin isn't scum? How could I possibly know Olaf doesn't have the bowl?

Those questions?

Gee, idk. Gut?

#3252

Jackofhearts2005 wrote:
sig wrote:Are you going to answer any of my questions or nah?
Why do I think Quin isn't scum? How could I possibly know Olaf doesn't have the bowl?

Those questions?

Gee, idk. Gut?

Gut? Seriously? That's why you think Quin isn't bad, but voted for him anyway, and believed his baseless declarations?

I apologize to all of you for getting upset, but this is just unacceptable for this late in the game regardless of how lucky town has been at Night.

#3253

MovingPictures07 wrote:
Jackofhearts2005 wrote:
sig wrote:Are you going to answer any of my questions or nah?
Why do I think Quin isn't scum? How could I possibly know Olaf doesn't have the bowl?

Those questions?

Gee, idk. Gut?
Gut? Seriously? That's why you think Quin isn't bad, but voted for him anyway, and believed his baseless declarations?

I apologize to all of you for getting upset, but this is just unacceptable for this late in the game regardless of how lucky town has been at Night.

#3254

Jackofhearts2005 wrote:
sig wrote:Are you going to answer any of my questions or nah?
Why do I think Quin isn't scum? How could I possibly know Olaf doesn't have the bowl?

Those questions?

Gee, idk. Gut?

Frankly I'll lay it all out, I can see one role you could be with any amount of info, you saying Quin isn't scum proves that role isn't yours. It also doesn't explain your and LC lockclearing junk. I'm tempted to vote for you or Lc since I'd bet one of you have the bowl. You'd have to bet at least say 5 or 6 votes so it would be quite easy to tie it.

Also Olaf not having the bowl has very little to do with anything, you voting for someone who you don't think is scum and pushing their wagon is an issue. If you thought MP was mafia why not vote for him?

If we assume Ishmael has BTSC (which we can't) then if we assume he recruited say Olivia Caliban, who is quin and got a check on MP, which turned up red, would be the only reason for this. Even then it is very an indirect and stupid way to do it. Not to mention it wouldn't find Olaf.

In theory Quin could be a converted Klaus, but the same logic applies why waste a phase lynching him, when you could have pursued and probably lynched MP?

There is no way in almost any world that LC and Jack are civs, they might not be mafia sure, but at this point non civs are just as dangerous espacilly if they're acting like this.

#3255

MovingPictures07 wrote:LOL sig, I didn't notice that obviously. I meant not bad.

Or did I...

#3256

sig wrote:
Jackofhearts2005 wrote:
sig wrote:Are you going to answer any of my questions or nah?
Why do I think Quin isn't scum? How could I possibly know Olaf doesn't have the bowl?

Those questions?

Gee, idk. Gut?
Frankly I'll lay it all out, I can see one role you could be with any amount of info, you saying Quin isn't scum proves that role isn't yours. It also doesn't explain your and LC lockclearing junk. I'm tempted to vote for you or Lc since I'd bet one of you have the bowl. You'd have to bet at least say 5 or 6 votes so it would be quite easy to tie it.

Also Olaf not having the bowl has very little to do with anything, you voting for someone who you don't think is scum and pushing their wagon is an issue. If you thought MP was mafia why not vote for him?

If we assume Ishmael has BTSC (which we can't) then if we assume he recruited say Olivia Caliban, who is quin and got a check on MP, which turned up red, would be the only reason for this. Even then it is very an indirect and stupid way to do it. Not to mention it wouldn't find Olaf.

In theory Quin could be a converted Klaus, but the same logic applies why waste a phase lynching him, when you could have pursued and probably lynched MP?

There is no way in almost any world that LC and Jack are civs, they might not be mafia sure, but at this point non civs are just as dangerous espacilly if they're acting like this.

You want to lynch specifically to get rid of the bowl? Red flag. Baddies want the bowl out of commission.

#3257

sig wrote:
Jackofhearts2005 wrote:
sig wrote:Are you going to answer any of my questions or nah?
Why do I think Quin isn't scum? How could I possibly know Olaf doesn't have the bowl?

Those questions?

Gee, idk. Gut?
Frankly I'll lay it all out, I can see one role you could be with any amount of info, you saying Quin isn't scum proves that role isn't yours. It also doesn't explain your and LC lockclearing junk. I'm tempted to vote for you or Lc since I'd bet one of you have the bowl. You'd have to bet at least say 5 or 6 votes so it would be quite easy to tie it.

Also Olaf not having the bowl has very little to do with anything, you voting for someone who you don't think is scum and pushing their wagon is an issue. If you thought MP was mafia why not vote for him?

If we assume Ishmael has BTSC (which we can't) then if we assume he recruited say Olivia Caliban, who is quin and got a check on MP, which turned up red, would be the only reason for this. Even then it is very an indirect and stupid way to do it. Not to mention it wouldn't find Olaf.

In theory Quin could be a converted Klaus, but the same logic applies why waste a phase lynching him, when you could have pursued and probably lynched MP?

There is no way in almost any world that LC and Jack are civs, they might not be mafia sure, but at this point non civs are just as dangerous espacilly if they're acting like this.

Please explain this.

I can think of like 5 reasons I could think Quin was good in spite of his posts. Maybe your role tells you one or two is invalid but if you can only think of 1 way I could think Quin is not scum, you aren't trying very hard.

That's what's especially frustrating. You're willing to tinfoil to extreme measures, coming up with made up powers for roles you aren't even sure are still in the game and vote for me just because you think I'm holding the bowl....but you aren't willing to read the role list.

#3258

Who says Jack has the bowl? Who says he is a civ with the bowl? Also I love the OMGUS even though it isn't directed at you.

Frankly I'll mess up this lynch which if my math is right I can on my own and just take control of the situation, unless people start answering my questions and stop being cryptic and annoying.

When your case for why quin isn't bad, but that we should vote for him anyway revolves around roles, that nobody but you knows are in play what else should I do or think? This entire post of yours is fundamentally hypocritical since you're doing what your accusing me of doing. Except I'm laying my thoughts out in thread

Any non town isn't on our side, they might rather have town win and right now the town is most likely looking good, so VFD, but Ishmael isn't since if town wins to soon then he can't win. If you and LC are VFD then you shouldn't have any knowledge of Quin's role and furthermore you have given us no reason for why we should lynch quin.

Also I'm not going to lynch you for having the bowl, I'm going to lynch you for being either a unhelpful indy or a mafia member. Since the way I see it you and Quin are already setting up lynches for tomorrow either mine or MP's. Something Quin has been low key doing all phase.

#3259

Also the fact Quin is here, but all he has done is accuse me of being bad, without doing anything else isn't helpful.

#3260

Supatownie is when you're a townie who flies straight forward and doesn't stop for nothing, just like Superman, right?

#3261

Literally there are rules against roleclaiming and infodumping.

I'm not sure what you want from me, Sig.

#3262

I'm not asking for a roleclaim/infodumping just some logic.

If you don't think Quin is mafia why are you voting for him?

If Quin isn't mafia who do you think is?

How will lynching Quin help reveal the mafia?

Since I literally see no reason to lynch Quin if you think he is a civ or not mafia. Unless you don't think he is a civ/Indy.

#3263

sig wrote:I'm not asking for a roleclaim/infodumping just some logic.

If you don't think Quin is mafia why are you voting for him?

If Quin isn't mafia who do you think is?

How will lynching Quin help reveal the mafia?

Since I literally see no reason to lynch Quin if you think he is a civ or not mafia. Unless you don't think he is a civ/Indy.

Cause the bowl will kill me instead if Quin doesn't get enough votes.

MP, Sorsha, Daisy and/or Dom2.

I won't. But it'll get you to stop giving me and LC such grief and get rid of the Troupe tonight/tomorrow. I would have rather lynched someone else but if it's Quin or me, I'll let it be Quin.

#3264

Pretty sure LC is the one with the bowl, not jack, sig. You could probably make the move with Dom if he were keen.

But I think the wise thing to do is to stick with Quin.

#3265

I could be wrong. Perhaps Jack thought that as a mechanically cleared person he would be safe to bid on it.

#3266

Why not then direct the lynch to another player to begin with instead of Quin? I'm sure it was possible instead of just jumping on board the wagon.

How will his lynch get me to stop giving you and LC grief do you think?

linki: Jack just made it seem like he had the bowl. And you're most likely right, but I dislike this whole situation.

linki 2: Could be.

#3267

Golden wrote:Pretty sure LC is the one with the bowl, not jack, sig. You could probably make the move with Dom if he were keen.

But I think the wise thing to do is to stick with Quin.

#3268

sig wrote:Why not then direct the lynch to another player to begin with instead of Quin? I'm sure it was possible instead of just jumping on board the wagon.

How will his lynch get me to stop giving you and LC grief do you think?

linki: Jack just made it seem like he had the bowl. And you're most likely right, but I dislike this whole situation.

linki 2: Could be.

Maybe go back and read what I said at the start of the phase. Maybe go see what LC said too.

Golden began with Quin cause Quin went ally Quinny. Then Daisy jumped on cause she either wanted an easy lynch or couldn't be bothered to some hunt cause real life. At that point, it was too late.

At this point, I'm kinda worried it won't. You're tunneling on a tinfoil and preemptively said you won't trust Quin's flip. But I guess we'll just have to wait and see.

#3269

Jackofhearts2005 wrote:
sig wrote:Why not then direct the lynch to another player to begin with instead of Quin? I'm sure it was possible instead of just jumping on board the wagon.

How will his lynch get me to stop giving you and LC grief do you think?

linki: Jack just made it seem like he had the bowl. And you're most likely right, but I dislike this whole situation.

linki 2: Could be.

Maybe go back and read what I said at the start of the phase. Maybe go see what LC said too.

Golden began with Quin cause Quin went all Quinny. Then Daisy jumped on cause she either wanted an easy lynch or couldn't be bothered to scum hunt cause real life. At that point, it was too late.

At this point, I'm kinda worried it won't. You're tunneling on a tinfoil and preemptively said you won't trust Quin's flip. But I guess we'll just have to wait and see.

Stupid phone. EBWOP.

#3270

sig wrote:Why not then direct the lynch to another player to begin with instead of Quin? I'm sure it was possible instead of just jumping on board the wagon.

It was possible. It was a massive overreaction. But I do kind of get it from their perspective.

#3271

Golden wrote:
sig wrote:Why not then direct the lynch to another player to begin with instead of Quin? I'm sure it was possible instead of just jumping on board the wagon.
It was possible. It was a massive overreaction. But I do kind of get it from their perspective.

You know how many votes I have already?

#3272

Well this day was no fun.

#3273

I would have like reasoned discussion.

Instead we got cryptic fearmongering.

We got people voting where they said we shouldn't.

We got (toilet) bowls.

And a big ass back and forth between Golden and Quin that was a waste of my time to read.

I'll probably vote out of the way just to be a dick.

#3274

Jackofhearts2005 wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:
Jackofhearts2005 wrote:
sig wrote:Are you going to answer any of my questions or nah?
Why do I think Quin isn't scum? How could I possibly know Olaf doesn't have the bowl?

Those questions?

Gee, idk. Gut?
Gut? Seriously? That's why you think Quin isn't bad, but voted for him anyway, and believed his baseless declarations?

I apologize to all of you for getting upset, but this is just unacceptable for this late in the game regardless of how lucky town has been at Night.

Fair enough.

#3275

Epignosis wrote:I would have like reasoned discussion.

Instead we got cryptic fearmongering.

We got people voting where they said we shouldn't.

We got (toilet) bowls.

And a big ass back and forth between Golden and Quin that was a waste of my time to read.

I'll probably vote out of the way just to be a dick.

Toilet bowls.

#3276

I voted Golden. I'm tired of him getting mad at somebody and then voting early before discussion has really had a chance to mean anything.

#3277

Epignosis wrote:I voted Golden. I'm tired of him getting mad at somebody and then voting early before discussion has really had a chance to mean anything.

Maybe we should have voted you.

#3278

MovingPictures07 wrote:
Epignosis wrote:I voted Golden. I'm tired of him getting mad at somebody and then voting early before discussion has really had a chance to mean anything.
Maybe we should have voted you.

Maybe. But you didn't.

#3279

Epignosis wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:
Epignosis wrote:I voted Golden. I'm tired of him getting mad at somebody and then voting early before discussion has really had a chance to mean anything.
Maybe we should have voted you.
Maybe. But you didn't.

I don't really think that, I was just messing.

#3280

MovingPictures07 wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:
Epignosis wrote:I voted Golden. I'm tired of him getting mad at somebody and then voting early before discussion has really had a chance to mean anything.
Maybe we should have voted you.
Maybe. But you didn't.
I don't really think that, I was just messing.

I know.

Boring Day though.

#3281

Useless day.

#3282

Jackofhearts2005 wrote:Literally there are rules against roleclaiming and infodumping.

I'm not sure what you want from me, Sig.

screaming you have info and then hiding behind this rule is the same thing as just telling us what is going on.

it's pretty sad tbh and makes me not veyr motivated to play

#3283

Dom wrote:
Jackofhearts2005 wrote:Literally there are rules against roleclaiming and infodumping.

I'm not sure what you want from me, Sig.
screaming you have info and then hiding behind this rule is the same thing as just telling us what is going on.

it's pretty sad tbh and makes me not veyr motivated to play

.....

He is basically saying he has info Quin isn't bad, also why do you believe his info? the amount of games I've faked having info is to many to count.

Also shush to bad, play. Tell me what you think of LC please? Tomorrow he might be a good lynch.

#3284

sig wrote:
Dom wrote:
Jackofhearts2005 wrote:Literally there are rules against roleclaiming and infodumping.

I'm not sure what you want from me, Sig.
screaming you have info and then hiding behind this rule is the same thing as just telling us what is going on.

it's pretty sad tbh and makes me not veyr motivated to play
.....

He is basically saying he has info Quin isn't bad, also why do you believe his info? the amount of games I've faked having info is to many to count.

Also shush to bad, play. Tell me what you think of LC please? Tomorrow he might be a good lynch.

1) i didn't say i believed it. i don't know what to believe. you're the one screaming quin can't be bad because of the votes
2) lc isn't civvie. that i think is true.

no clue where to vote.

#3285

Yeah, I really hope we can have constructive conversations going forward because this Day was not only incredibly frustrating to me but way too much lacking baddie hunting altogether.

#3286

When I left from work today, Quin had two votes. When I got home, showered, and ate, he had eight.

Not much I can say or do at that point.

#3287

Well, I did lots of baddie hunting. I put out a whole lot on LC, a whole lot on Quin.

Sig put in a good effort in looking in to Sorsha and Daisy.

It's just that it's been ignored by people saying 'you're wrong' and most recently epi calling it 'me getting mad' and a 'waste of time'.

But then, I've felt like this whole game is like that. I was saying the same thing after day one!

Calling it a useless day after not contributing to it being useful is on the nose.

#3288

Epignosis wrote:When I left from work today, Quin had two votes. When I got home, showered, and ate, he had eight.

Not much I can say or do at that point.

I agree.

Is it really my fault? Or is the fact that Jack bet so many votes that after only two on Quin, they had to panic bus someone they are claiming to be town and an ally?

#3289

I need someone to explain this bowl stuff to me like I have no idea what the hell it is. Because that's pretty much where I'm at.

#3290

MovingPictures07 wrote:I need someone to explain this bowl stuff to me like I have no idea what the hell it is. Because that's pretty much where I'm at.

Someone bet a lot of votes to protect themselves from nightkills for the next three nights. Either Jack or LC. Then they bussed quin to make sure they were alive to get the benefit.

I'm pretty sure that's not a baddie thing to do, because it shows they are scared about nightkills. On the other hand, they've basically put the target on the rest of us by making it clear they have it.

#3291

Golden wrote:Well, I did lots of baddie hunting. I put out a whole lot on LC, a whole lot on Quin.

Sig put in a good effort in looking in to Sorsha and Daisy.

It's just that it's been ignored by people saying 'you're wrong' and most recently epi calling it 'me getting mad' and a 'waste of time'.

But then, I've felt like this whole game is like that. I was saying the same thing after day one!

Calling it a useless day after not contributing to it being useful is on the nose.

You were wrong to suspect me and vote me early. Forgive me if I see the same thing going on here.

#3292

Golden wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:I need someone to explain this bowl stuff to me like I have no idea what the hell it is. Because that's pretty much where I'm at.
Someone bet a lot of votes to protect themselves from nightkills for the next three nights. Either Jack or LC. Then they bussed quin to make sure they were alive to get the benefit.

I'm pretty sure that's not a baddie thing to do, because it shows they are scared about nightkills. On the other hand, they've basically put the target on the rest of us by making it clear they have it.

Okay, I thought it was something like that but I wasn't sure of the full picture. Thanks.

#3293

Was I wrong, epi? Was I really?

I don't think I was. Even though I think you were civ. I think voting you helped lead to a good, informative day. I don't regret it.

#3294

Golden wrote:Was I wrong, epi? Was I really?

I don't think I was. Even though I think you were civ. I think voting you helped lead to a good, informative day. I don't regret it.

Is it, Marge? Is it?

Oh wait, it is.

#3295

Golden wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:I need someone to explain this bowl stuff to me like I have no idea what the hell it is. Because that's pretty much where I'm at.
Someone bet a lot of votes to protect themselves from nightkills for the next three nights. Either Jack or LC. Then they bussed quin to make sure they were alive to get the benefit.

I'm pretty sure that's not a baddie thing to do, because it shows they are scared about nightkills. On the other hand, they've basically put the target on the rest of us by making it clear they have it.

how do you know what the bowl does?

#3296

Dom wrote:
Golden wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:I need someone to explain this bowl stuff to me like I have no idea what the hell it is. Because that's pretty much where I'm at.
Someone bet a lot of votes to protect themselves from nightkills for the next three nights. Either Jack or LC. Then they bussed quin to make sure they were alive to get the benefit.

I'm pretty sure that's not a baddie thing to do, because it shows they are scared about nightkills. On the other hand, they've basically put the target on the rest of us by making it clear they have it.
how do you know what the bowl does?

It was stated by DF in the thread.

#3297

Golden wrote:Was I wrong, epi? Was I really?

I don't think I was. Even though I think you were civ. I think voting you helped lead to a good, informative day. I don't regret it.

No it didn't. Show me what your vote for me did to help inform everyone of anything.

I don't think you get the credit for that Day.

Your vote was shit and cast early because you were married to a theory.

#3298

Epignosis wrote:
Golden wrote:Was I wrong, epi? Was I really?

I don't think I was. Even though I think you were civ. I think voting you helped lead to a good, informative day. I don't regret it.
No it didn't. Show me what your vote for me did to help inform everyone of anything.

I don't think you get the credit for that Day.

Your vote was shit and cast early because you were married to a theory.

I can't have been that married to it, given I was advocating for people to vote Eloh.

#3299

Golden wrote:
Dom wrote:
Golden wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:I need someone to explain this bowl stuff to me like I have no idea what the hell it is. Because that's pretty much where I'm at.
Someone bet a lot of votes to protect themselves from nightkills for the next three nights. Either Jack or LC. Then they bussed quin to make sure they were alive to get the benefit.

I'm pretty sure that's not a baddie thing to do, because it shows they are scared about nightkills. On the other hand, they've basically put the target on the rest of us by making it clear they have it.
how do you know what the bowl does?
It was stated by DF in the thread.

#3300

Golden wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
Golden wrote:Was I wrong, epi? Was I really?

I don't think I was. Even though I think you were civ. I think voting you helped lead to a good, informative day. I don't regret it.
No it didn't. Show me what your vote for me did to help inform everyone of anything.

I don't think you get the credit for that Day.

Your vote was shit and cast early because you were married to a theory.
I can't have been that married to it, given I was advocating for people to vote Eloh.

You voted for me. Don't be a Jack(ass).

Who needs to practice their stabbing?