Phenon Mafia: ENDGAME - Snuffed

Moderator: Community Team

How would you Rate this game?

1/5
1
7%
2/5
0
No votes
3/5
0
No votes
4/5
2
13%
5/5
2
13%
6/5
9
60%
MetalMarsh89 deserves an honorary win
1
7%
 
Total votes: 15
User avatar
Fredwood
Corrupt Union Official
Posts in topic: 213
Posts: 671
Joined: Mon Feb 06, 2017 5:14 am

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2351

Post by Fredwood »

Dyslexicon wrote:*Add me, not ass me. I don't think we're at that level of intimacy yet.
So you're saying there is a level of intimacy


Image

Don't know if that's the right Gif to convey...but it came up and amused me when I searched for Gifs from that show
Was I the same as when I got up this morning? I almost think I can remember feeling a little different. But if I am not the same, the next question is, Who in the world am I?
User avatar
Fredwood
Corrupt Union Official
Posts in topic: 213
Posts: 671
Joined: Mon Feb 06, 2017 5:14 am

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2352

Post by Fredwood »

Fudge
Was I the same as when I got up this morning? I almost think I can remember feeling a little different. But if I am not the same, the next question is, Who in the world am I?
User avatar
Golden
The Coward
Posts in topic: 344
Posts: 20125
Joined: Thu Feb 19, 2015 3:27 am
Location: Wellington, New Zealand

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2353

Post by Golden »

I'm trying to find the case on Jack.

I found a post from sloonei setting out marmot/jack interactions and saying he could see a jack vote. He referenced Jay's case on Jack. I can't find Jay's case, if it exists. I can find Jay talking about what he perceives to be unnatural progressions, and perhaps it has something to do with EoD 2.

Can anyone voting for Jack tell me, in their own words, why they think he is worth a vote?
Spoiler: show
ImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImage
ImageImageImageImageImageImage
ImageImageImageImageImageImage
Image
Canucklehead wrote:Civ Golden is a hurricane of self-assurance.
G-Man wrote: Coward
User avatar
Jackofhearts2005
something funny
Posts in topic: 270
Posts: 20512
Joined: Mon Nov 28, 2016 7:28 pm
Gender: Male
Preferred Pronouns: He/His/Him

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2354

Post by Jackofhearts2005 »

Quin wrote:
Jackofhearts2005 wrote:
Jackofhearts2005 wrote:
Quin wrote:
GTH reads after everything that's happened today, with a few exclusions.

Civ:
INH
Marmot
Long Con
Silver
Golden
speedchuck
Scotty

Bad:
3J
JOH
Sloonei
nutella
Dizzy
Fredwood
How much do you still agree with this rainbow, Quin?

Literally one of my supposed scumbuddies is undecided on me. The rest are saying I'm at the top of their scum list.

Who are my buddies? (Trick question. I don't have any. Answer anyway.)
Quin?
nutella, dizzy and Jay went up. Adding Eloh up as a civ. Scotty moved down. Removing Long Con entirely.
And my buddies? You're still voting for me aren't you?

Who are my teammates? Scotty, Sloonei and Fred?

Name one player you honestly think could be my scum teammate.
User avatar
Dyslexicon
<3
Posts in topic: 347
Posts: 12805
Joined: Wed Apr 13, 2016 2:12 am

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2355

Post by Dyslexicon »

Why on earth would anyone read Eloh as town?

Image
User avatar
speedchuck
Knight of No Renown
Posts in topic: 321
Posts: 10958
Joined: Wed Jan 25, 2017 11:43 am

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2356

Post by speedchuck »

Dyslexicon wrote:
speedchuck wrote:Vote insertnamehere

This is something I want to tussle about. Also, I'm back, baby. Done with my things for now, ready to vote all over the place.
I will be disappointed if you don't hammer scum in the last minute. And I will certainly scum read you for doing or not doing it.
Gotta admit, I love having you in this game, even if you constantly want to kill me.
SIGNATURE:
Spoiler: show
Speedchuck wins the "Jack Torrance Has Always Been The Caretaker" award.
ImageImageImageImage
ImageImageImageImage
ImageImage
User avatar
Dyslexicon
<3
Posts in topic: 347
Posts: 12805
Joined: Wed Apr 13, 2016 2:12 am

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2357

Post by Dyslexicon »

Fredwood wrote:
Dyslexicon wrote:*Add me, not ass me. I don't think we're at that level of intimacy yet.
So you're saying there is a level of intimacy


Image

Don't know if that's the right Gif to convey...but it came up and amused me when I searched for Gifs from that show
It's perfect, except it's not moving. :p
User avatar
nutella
Connoisseur of Spice
Posts in topic: 104
Posts: 24688
Joined: Wed Jun 12, 2013 6:23 pm
Location: Chicago
Gender: Female
Preferred Pronouns: she/her/hers
Contact:

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2358

Post by nutella »

Golden wrote:I'm trying to find the case on Jack.

I found a post from sloonei setting out marmot/jack interactions and saying he could see a jack vote. He referenced Jay's case on Jack. I can't find Jay's case, if it exists. I can find Jay talking about what he perceives to be unnatural progressions, and perhaps it has something to do with EoD 2.

Can anyone voting for Jack tell me, in their own words, why they think he is worth a vote?
Sorry, there was a post from JJJ that I thought was from Sloonei (the one about Jack easily going with popular opinions, which he's now responded to). But I think Sloonei's interaction review posts were also good.

The original case from JJJ is older, I believe it's actually back from early d2 (his analysis of the sig lynch + nacho kill). But that was weaker compared to the stuff from today.
to the spoiler go the victories:
Spoiler: show
Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image ImageImage Image Image Image
Image Image Image Image
Image Image Image Image Image
Image Image
User avatar
Fredwood
Corrupt Union Official
Posts in topic: 213
Posts: 671
Joined: Mon Feb 06, 2017 5:14 am

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2359

Post by Fredwood »

Dyslexicon wrote:Why on earth would anyone read Eloh as town?

Image
Because everyone is under the silly impression that Eloh is the town Busdrive, even though there is no evidentiary support for that assessment.
Was I the same as when I got up this morning? I almost think I can remember feeling a little different. But if I am not the same, the next question is, Who in the world am I?
User avatar
Quin
Indecent Bastard
Posts in topic: 555
Posts: 10900
Joined: Fri Feb 19, 2016 1:08 am
Location: The Future

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2360

Post by Quin »

Jackofhearts2005 wrote:
Quin wrote:
Jackofhearts2005 wrote:
Jackofhearts2005 wrote:
Quin wrote:
GTH reads after everything that's happened today, with a few exclusions.

Civ:
INH
Marmot
Long Con
Silver
Golden
speedchuck
Scotty

Bad:
3J
JOH
Sloonei
nutella
Dizzy
Fredwood
How much do you still agree with this rainbow, Quin?

Literally one of my supposed scumbuddies is undecided on me. The rest are saying I'm at the top of their scum list.

Who are my buddies? (Trick question. I don't have any. Answer anyway.)
Quin?
nutella, dizzy and Jay went up. Adding Eloh up as a civ. Scotty moved down. Removing Long Con entirely.
And my buddies? You're still voting for me aren't you?

Who are my teammates? Scotty, Sloonei and Fred?

Name one player you honestly think could be my scum teammate.
metalmarsh89
Lunalee wrote: Thu Nov 01, 2018 9:13 amQuin's ISO is full of posts that are actually trying to be helpful to the game. This doesn't look like town Quin.
ImageImageImageImage
User avatar
Jackofhearts2005
something funny
Posts in topic: 270
Posts: 20512
Joined: Mon Nov 28, 2016 7:28 pm
Gender: Male
Preferred Pronouns: He/His/Him

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2361

Post by Jackofhearts2005 »

unvote Scotty

Vote INH


His only defense (bonus: from other players) is WIFOM.

Yeah, maybe a bad townie but where is he now? Only scumhunted a player I'm convinced is town.

Most importantly, my role card doesn't say INH is town.
User avatar
speedchuck
Knight of No Renown
Posts in topic: 321
Posts: 10958
Joined: Wed Jan 25, 2017 11:43 am

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2362

Post by speedchuck »

Golden wrote:I'm trying to find the case on Jack.

I found a post from sloonei setting out marmot/jack interactions and saying he could see a jack vote. He referenced Jay's case on Jack. I can't find Jay's case, if it exists. I can find Jay talking about what he perceives to be unnatural progressions, and perhaps it has something to do with EoD 2.

Can anyone voting for Jack tell me, in their own words, why they think he is worth a vote?
It's an okay case.

Basically, more than once, Jack has had interesting and polarizing reads/theories/statements. Then he keeps gravitating toward the mass opinion, the safe opinion. (There are exceptions, and I think I'm one of them)

Here is my post where I voted Jack:
speedchuck wrote:
Scotty wrote: What do you think of jack?
Not great.
speedchuck wrote:
Jackofhearts2005 wrote: Note the extreme tone difference between my question and Quinn's accusation.

Also note that I have disagreed with the Dizzy lynch and put him as town. While Quin, INH and MM were after Dizzy, I was voting Scotty. Was gonna answer Quin's question towards me on Dizzy but figured I'd just clutter the thread with more linkis. Was sure she was town. Had already said so.

Can we be friends again?

Coming back with a full rainbow in a couple hours.
This post makes me feel happy/nervous.
Like, it's a reasonable come-around and I was hoping for it, but also feels suspiciously like backtracking in a slow way to avoid town wrath.
Sry Jack I am catching up and making notes about shifts like this and whatnot. Not necessarily wanting to murder your face yet.
But this post is important.
This, combined with my earlier saying that there is a scum in Golden/JJJ/Jack/Strawhenge (That was a gut feel.)
Good feelings about Golden right now.
Strawhenge is gone.
JJJ just got cleared.

Jack, today at least, seemed like he was going along with Quin (possibly misinformed towny, it's hard to read someone when you don't understand their thought process) without committing too hard, seeing if the lynch could be pushed toward Sloonei/other people that lynched mM.
Other days I've been iffy about him.
Strong anti-alignment with JJJ.
As Sloonei just pointed out, he's been iffy toward Marmot.
I could vote for Jack. What are the votals at?

Secondary suspicions that I want to iron out at the moment:
INH (I lumped him with mm yesterday, because they were buddying insanely. Could be scum taking town town with them, or... blatant buddying. Everything else was blatant at EOD.
Fredwood (Sorry, I've read you as town all game, but if Jack is bad, gotta reeval)
Soneji
Mayybe long con

Scotty isn't entirely in the clear, but I like his posts enough at the moment to not kick up a fuss over giving him time to use his role.
It's a lot of different small things.

But INH is a better vote, based on yesterday's actions and flip alone. People seem to be ignoring him, which is weird.
SIGNATURE:
Spoiler: show
Speedchuck wins the "Jack Torrance Has Always Been The Caretaker" award.
ImageImageImageImage
ImageImageImageImage
ImageImage
User avatar
Fredwood
Corrupt Union Official
Posts in topic: 213
Posts: 671
Joined: Mon Feb 06, 2017 5:14 am

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2363

Post by Fredwood »

Dyslexicon wrote:
Don't know if that's the right Gif to convey...but it came up and amused me when I searched for Gifs from that show
It's perfect, except it's not moving. :p[/quote]

Image


Yeah had to find a new link of it that old one fooled me.
Was I the same as when I got up this morning? I almost think I can remember feeling a little different. But if I am not the same, the next question is, Who in the world am I?
User avatar
Jackofhearts2005
something funny
Posts in topic: 270
Posts: 20512
Joined: Mon Nov 28, 2016 7:28 pm
Gender: Male
Preferred Pronouns: He/His/Him

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2364

Post by Jackofhearts2005 »

Quin wrote:
Jackofhearts2005 wrote:
Quin wrote:
Jackofhearts2005 wrote:
Jackofhearts2005 wrote:
Quin wrote:
GTH reads after everything that's happened today, with a few exclusions.

Civ:
INH
Marmot
Long Con
Silver
Golden
speedchuck
Scotty

Bad:
3J
JOH
Sloonei
nutella
Dizzy
Fredwood
How much do you still agree with this rainbow, Quin?

Literally one of my supposed scumbuddies is undecided on me. The rest are saying I'm at the top of their scum list.

Who are my buddies? (Trick question. I don't have any. Answer anyway.)
Quin?
nutella, dizzy and Jay went up. Adding Eloh up as a civ. Scotty moved down. Removing Long Con entirely.
And my buddies? You're still voting for me aren't you?

Who are my teammates? Scotty, Sloonei and Fred?

Name one player you honestly think could be my scum teammate.
metalmarsh89
For anyone keeping score at home, this is the point where Quin fell into the orange.

I remember tunneling town(ish) Quin. Not lazy town Quin.
User avatar
Dyslexicon
<3
Posts in topic: 347
Posts: 12805
Joined: Wed Apr 13, 2016 2:12 am

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2365

Post by Dyslexicon »

speedchuck wrote:
Dyslexicon wrote:
speedchuck wrote:Vote insertnamehere

This is something I want to tussle about. Also, I'm back, baby. Done with my things for now, ready to vote all over the place.
I will be disappointed if you don't hammer scum in the last minute. And I will certainly scum read you for doing or not doing it.
Gotta admit, I love having you in this game, even if you constantly want to kill me.
Aw. And same - and your likability adds to my suspicion tbh. :omg:

Read this if you're scum:
Spoiler: show
Image
Read this if you're town:
Spoiler: show
Image
User avatar
Fredwood
Corrupt Union Official
Posts in topic: 213
Posts: 671
Joined: Mon Feb 06, 2017 5:14 am

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2366

Post by Fredwood »

Lynch INH


I said I would lynch him so I guess I should, even if it looks like a superwagon at this point.

Also, Pink cus Fuck you that's why.
Was I the same as when I got up this morning? I almost think I can remember feeling a little different. But if I am not the same, the next question is, Who in the world am I?
User avatar
Quin
Indecent Bastard
Posts in topic: 555
Posts: 10900
Joined: Fri Feb 19, 2016 1:08 am
Location: The Future

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2367

Post by Quin »

Jackofhearts2005 wrote:
Quin wrote:
Jackofhearts2005 wrote:
Quin wrote:
Jackofhearts2005 wrote:
Jackofhearts2005 wrote:
Quin wrote:
GTH reads after everything that's happened today, with a few exclusions.

Civ:
INH
Marmot
Long Con
Silver
Golden
speedchuck
Scotty

Bad:
3J
JOH
Sloonei
nutella
Dizzy
Fredwood
How much do you still agree with this rainbow, Quin?

Literally one of my supposed scumbuddies is undecided on me. The rest are saying I'm at the top of their scum list.

Who are my buddies? (Trick question. I don't have any. Answer anyway.)
Quin?
nutella, dizzy and Jay went up. Adding Eloh up as a civ. Scotty moved down. Removing Long Con entirely.
And my buddies? You're still voting for me aren't you?

Who are my teammates? Scotty, Sloonei and Fred?

Name one player you honestly think could be my scum teammate.
metalmarsh89
For anyone keeping score at home, this is the point where Quin fell into the orange.

I remember tunneling town(ish) Quin. Not lazy town Quin.
I don't need to have an argument about who your teammates are to find you suspicious.
Lunalee wrote: Thu Nov 01, 2018 9:13 amQuin's ISO is full of posts that are actually trying to be helpful to the game. This doesn't look like town Quin.
ImageImageImageImage
User avatar
speedchuck
Knight of No Renown
Posts in topic: 321
Posts: 10958
Joined: Wed Jan 25, 2017 11:43 am

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2368

Post by speedchuck »

Fred, we had a claim of a redirected watcher night one. By definition, a redirecting role usually hits the roles it redirects to.
The watcher, after redirected, only saw Eloh. Thus, Eloh is probably redirector.

Granted, we may not trust the watcher (Golden), or clusterfuck rules might apply, but it's a pretty good bet that Eloh is redirector. Scum wouldn't have two of them, probably. Thus, Eloh is prob town.
SIGNATURE:
Spoiler: show
Speedchuck wins the "Jack Torrance Has Always Been The Caretaker" award.
ImageImageImageImage
ImageImageImageImage
ImageImage
User avatar
nutella
Connoisseur of Spice
Posts in topic: 104
Posts: 24688
Joined: Wed Jun 12, 2013 6:23 pm
Location: Chicago
Gender: Female
Preferred Pronouns: she/her/hers
Contact:

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2369

Post by nutella »

I'm pretty confused at the sudden influx of INH votes. I'm still pretty convinced that his behavior was not that of a marmot teammate. I could be wrong but I thought there was a pretty good reason we all backed off from him.
to the spoiler go the victories:
Spoiler: show
Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image ImageImage Image Image Image
Image Image Image Image
Image Image Image Image Image
Image Image
User avatar
Golden
The Coward
Posts in topic: 344
Posts: 20125
Joined: Thu Feb 19, 2015 3:27 am
Location: Wellington, New Zealand

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2370

Post by Golden »

speedchuck wrote:But INH is a better vote, based on yesterday's actions and flip alone. People seem to be ignoring him, which is weird.
Just from externally (as in, not there in the moment) inh comes out looking worst to me in the marmot vote.

Thanks nut and speed for giving me a little more context to the jack vote. It seems the primary beef against him is that he is blendy and that his opinions don't feel like they have held the weight of conviction behind them. Is that fair?
Spoiler: show
ImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImage
ImageImageImageImageImageImage
ImageImageImageImageImageImage
Image
Canucklehead wrote:Civ Golden is a hurricane of self-assurance.
G-Man wrote: Coward
User avatar
Golden
The Coward
Posts in topic: 344
Posts: 20125
Joined: Thu Feb 19, 2015 3:27 am
Location: Wellington, New Zealand

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2371

Post by Golden »

speedchuck wrote:Fred, we had a claim of a redirected watcher night one. By definition, a redirecting role usually hits the roles it redirects to.
The watcher, after redirected, only saw Eloh. Thus, Eloh is probably redirector.

Granted, we may not trust the watcher (Golden), or clusterfuck rules might apply, but it's a pretty good bet that Eloh is redirector. Scum wouldn't have two of them, probably. Thus, Eloh is prob town.
I'm not sure why eloh would be the redirector. Wouldn't she have targeted me? I still don't follow this.
Spoiler: show
ImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImage
ImageImageImageImageImageImage
ImageImageImageImageImageImage
Image
Canucklehead wrote:Civ Golden is a hurricane of self-assurance.
G-Man wrote: Coward
User avatar
Golden
The Coward
Posts in topic: 344
Posts: 20125
Joined: Thu Feb 19, 2015 3:27 am
Location: Wellington, New Zealand

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2372

Post by Golden »

nutella wrote:I'm pretty confused at the sudden influx of INH votes. I'm still pretty convinced that his behavior was not that of a marmot teammate. I could be wrong but I thought there was a pretty good reason we all backed off from him.
What's the good reason?
Spoiler: show
ImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImage
ImageImageImageImageImageImage
ImageImageImageImageImageImage
Image
Canucklehead wrote:Civ Golden is a hurricane of self-assurance.
G-Man wrote: Coward
User avatar
Dyslexicon
<3
Posts in topic: 347
Posts: 12805
Joined: Wed Apr 13, 2016 2:12 am

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2373

Post by Dyslexicon »

speedchuck wrote:Fred, we had a claim of a redirected watcher night one. By definition, a redirecting role usually hits the roles it redirects to.
The watcher, after redirected, only saw Eloh. Thus, Eloh is probably redirector.

Granted, we may not trust the watcher (Golden), or clusterfuck rules might apply, but it's a pretty good bet that Eloh is redirector. Scum wouldn't have two of them, probably. Thus, Eloh is prob town.
Redirector is usually anti-town role though? I won't clear Eloh based on these loose assumptions. The setup is ??? at this point. What reason would a town!Eloh not following the thread have to riderect Golden to Fred. That's just really random.
User avatar
nutella
Connoisseur of Spice
Posts in topic: 104
Posts: 24688
Joined: Wed Jun 12, 2013 6:23 pm
Location: Chicago
Gender: Female
Preferred Pronouns: she/her/hers
Contact:

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2374

Post by nutella »

Fredwood wrote:Lynch INH


I said I would lynch him so I guess I should, even if it looks like a superwagon at this point.

Also, Pink cus Fuck you that's why.
:suspish: :suspish: :suspish:

Y'know, I was gonna let you off the hook if you just didn't vote, because you defended your style of hesitance toward voting. But I found it pretty pingy when you kept saying you had been suspicious of Jack for a while and yet refrained from voting for him. Now you join the INH train. Any fool could see that if Jack's bad you're 100% his teammate.
to the spoiler go the victories:
Spoiler: show
Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image ImageImage Image Image Image
Image Image Image Image
Image Image Image Image Image
Image Image
User avatar
Jackofhearts2005
something funny
Posts in topic: 270
Posts: 20512
Joined: Mon Nov 28, 2016 7:28 pm
Gender: Male
Preferred Pronouns: He/His/Him

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2375

Post by Jackofhearts2005 »

@Golden and Speed

But both the "popular opinion" and "nobody but Jack would kill Nacho cause he's only played in one game" theories have been debunked. I had a clear and unique progression on Quin, Sloonei, Speed and JJJ. Dizzy and Silver, too, though nobody accused me of shifting on them. And of course, this is Macho's third game so that whole tinfoil is ridiculous.

Please correct me if I'm wrong but my only inconsistent and unexplained read to date has been on Scotty, who has hovered from the light green/yellow/orange area.
User avatar
Quin
Indecent Bastard
Posts in topic: 555
Posts: 10900
Joined: Fri Feb 19, 2016 1:08 am
Location: The Future

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2376

Post by Quin »

I don't suspect INH.

The voices in my head told me to say that.
Lunalee wrote: Thu Nov 01, 2018 9:13 amQuin's ISO is full of posts that are actually trying to be helpful to the game. This doesn't look like town Quin.
ImageImageImageImage
User avatar
Dyslexicon
<3
Posts in topic: 347
Posts: 12805
Joined: Wed Apr 13, 2016 2:12 am

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2377

Post by Dyslexicon »

Lynch Jack

Image
User avatar
Jackofhearts2005
something funny
Posts in topic: 270
Posts: 20512
Joined: Mon Nov 28, 2016 7:28 pm
Gender: Male
Preferred Pronouns: He/His/Him

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2378

Post by Jackofhearts2005 »

@Quin

But you need to think I have teammates if you think I'm mafia.

I don't think you think I have teammates. I don't think you think I'm mafia.
User avatar
Fredwood
Corrupt Union Official
Posts in topic: 213
Posts: 671
Joined: Mon Feb 06, 2017 5:14 am

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2379

Post by Fredwood »

speedchuck wrote:Fred, we had a claim of a redirected watcher night one. By definition, a redirecting role usually hits the roles it redirects to.
The watcher, after redirected, only saw Eloh. Thus, Eloh is probably redirector.

Granted, we may not trust the watcher (Golden), or clusterfuck rules might apply, but it's a pretty good bet that Eloh is redirector. Scum wouldn't have two of them, probably. Thus, Eloh is prob town.
If Golden was redirected, I wouldn't have been shown being targeted by Eloh. I've been over this with 3 different people, and have kind of given up on the discussion because it appears to be mechanical based culture shock. Twice it was mentioned that they view it as a town Busdrive to counter act mafia one.

I don't see that as a likely, because I doubt it would be a persistent Town Busdrive, and if it wasn't persistent I doubt it would have been wasted on me night one.

2. From my experience I'm not willing to make the Town BD logic leap.

3. It's really annoying because the only person (Eloh's) replacement, now has an easy out to account for the targeting, even though there is literally nothing to suggest what the targeting was, when the more than likely scenario was that Golden was just misdirected and that Eloh was targeting me independently of any Golden based shenanigans. I'm not saying Eloh had anything to answer for, or is likely scum because I was targeted, but we groupdecided without any input or clarifaction that the answer has to be X when Y is just as likely.
Was I the same as when I got up this morning? I almost think I can remember feeling a little different. But if I am not the same, the next question is, Who in the world am I?
User avatar
Quin
Indecent Bastard
Posts in topic: 555
Posts: 10900
Joined: Fri Feb 19, 2016 1:08 am
Location: The Future

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2380

Post by Quin »

Dyslexicon wrote:
speedchuck wrote:Fred, we had a claim of a redirected watcher night one. By definition, a redirecting role usually hits the roles it redirects to.
The watcher, after redirected, only saw Eloh. Thus, Eloh is probably redirector.

Granted, we may not trust the watcher (Golden), or clusterfuck rules might apply, but it's a pretty good bet that Eloh is redirector. Scum wouldn't have two of them, probably. Thus, Eloh is prob town.
Redirector is usually anti-town role though? I won't clear Eloh based on these loose assumptions. The setup is ??? at this point. What reason would a town!Eloh not following the thread have to riderect Golden to Fred. That's just really random.
I think there would be a big balancing issue if there were two roles capable of redirecting targets/roles in some way. If Eloh isn't town, she's either on a second mafia team or indy.

If we're assuming we've got her role pegged right, what's the issue in her picking Golden/Fred/3J if she's picking randomly?
Lunalee wrote: Thu Nov 01, 2018 9:13 amQuin's ISO is full of posts that are actually trying to be helpful to the game. This doesn't look like town Quin.
ImageImageImageImage
User avatar
nutella
Connoisseur of Spice
Posts in topic: 104
Posts: 24688
Joined: Wed Jun 12, 2013 6:23 pm
Location: Chicago
Gender: Female
Preferred Pronouns: she/her/hers
Contact:

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2381

Post by nutella »

Golden wrote:
speedchuck wrote:Fred, we had a claim of a redirected watcher night one. By definition, a redirecting role usually hits the roles it redirects to.
The watcher, after redirected, only saw Eloh. Thus, Eloh is probably redirector.

Granted, we may not trust the watcher (Golden), or clusterfuck rules might apply, but it's a pretty good bet that Eloh is redirector. Scum wouldn't have two of them, probably. Thus, Eloh is prob town.
I'm not sure why eloh would be the redirector. Wouldn't she have targeted me? I still don't follow this.
No, she would have targeted the two players who were switched as targets (JJJ and Fred). If her role works like Marmot's anyway.
Golden wrote:
nutella wrote:I'm pretty confused at the sudden influx of INH votes. I'm still pretty convinced that his behavior was not that of a marmot teammate. I could be wrong but I thought there was a pretty good reason we all backed off from him.
What's the good reason?
What I just said in the previous sentence. He had been defending/townreading Marmot for so strongly for the whole game that (especially combined with his strongly pushing the Dys case against marmot's lynch) would have been incredibly brazen of him to act that way as Marmot's teammate. I would be amazed if he was, but maybe he's the type to pull that. One point that others have brought up that may nudge me back toward thinking that is the fact that he's pretty much disappeared today with his tail tucked between his legs and has not made any effort to redeem himself.
to the spoiler go the victories:
Spoiler: show
Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image ImageImage Image Image Image
Image Image Image Image
Image Image Image Image Image
Image Image
User avatar
Jackofhearts2005
something funny
Posts in topic: 270
Posts: 20512
Joined: Mon Nov 28, 2016 7:28 pm
Gender: Male
Preferred Pronouns: He/His/Him

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2382

Post by Jackofhearts2005 »

speedchuck wrote:Fred, we had a claim of a redirected watcher night one. By definition, a redirecting role usually hits the roles it redirects to.
The watcher, after redirected, only saw Eloh. Thus, Eloh is probably redirector.

Granted, we may not trust the watcher (Golden), or clusterfuck rules might apply, but it's a pretty good bet that Eloh is redirector. Scum wouldn't have two of them, probably. Thus, Eloh is prob town.
Does not compute.

1) Lots of roles that could have messed with Golden could have done so by targeting Golden, not JJJ.

2) This is a CF game.
User avatar
Quin
Indecent Bastard
Posts in topic: 555
Posts: 10900
Joined: Fri Feb 19, 2016 1:08 am
Location: The Future

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2383

Post by Quin »

Jackofhearts2005 wrote:@Quin

But you need to think I have teammates if you think I'm mafia.

I don't think you think I have teammates. I don't think you think I'm mafia.
I don't have to justify an entire mafia team before getting any kind of result just so I can vote for you. I'm not that good at this game.

I think you're bad. That's good enough for me.
Lunalee wrote: Thu Nov 01, 2018 9:13 amQuin's ISO is full of posts that are actually trying to be helpful to the game. This doesn't look like town Quin.
ImageImageImageImage
User avatar
speedchuck
Knight of No Renown
Posts in topic: 321
Posts: 10958
Joined: Wed Jan 25, 2017 11:43 am

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2384

Post by speedchuck »

Dyslexicon wrote:
speedchuck wrote:Fred, we had a claim of a redirected watcher night one. By definition, a redirecting role usually hits the roles it redirects to.
The watcher, after redirected, only saw Eloh. Thus, Eloh is probably redirector.

Granted, we may not trust the watcher (Golden), or clusterfuck rules might apply, but it's a pretty good bet that Eloh is redirector. Scum wouldn't have two of them, probably. Thus, Eloh is prob town.
Redirector is usually anti-town role though? I won't clear Eloh based on these loose assumptions. The setup is ??? at this point. What reason would a town!Eloh not following the thread have to riderect Golden to Fred. That's just really random.
Answering your own question.

Also, I've played a town bus driver before. It can be a protective role.

Golden, busdrivers (for example) visit both target a and b. Then a watcher visiting target a would go to target b, then see the busdriver there.

Though, fair regarding the CF game. Could be something else entirely.
SIGNATURE:
Spoiler: show
Speedchuck wins the "Jack Torrance Has Always Been The Caretaker" award.
ImageImageImageImage
ImageImageImageImage
ImageImage
User avatar
juliets
Dancing Pancake
Posts in topic: 253
Posts: 16423
Joined: Mon Dec 24, 2012 3:16 pm
Location: Moobyworld
Gender: Female
Preferred Pronouns: she/her/hers
Aka: jules
Contact:

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2385

Post by juliets »

I haven't read INH. I know he built a case on Dyslexicon which I read and found to be lacking. Is the case abasing him that he argued a case that went against Marmot? Is there anything else to consider?

linki - nutella i see your point about him not showing up today

more linki
JaggedJimmyJay wrote: Sat Aug 21, 2021 3:24 pm Always good to remember that there is no such thing as a Mafia circumstance that is worth real human emotion. Sometimes it will naturally come out, but it can be contained if we just remember that this is a game on a message board forum that 99.99% of the population of the Earth has never heard of before. No matter how successful anyone is, it means just about nothing.

Spoiler: show
ImageImageImage
ImageImageImageImage
ImageImageImageImage
ImageImage
ImageImage
User avatar
juliets
Dancing Pancake
Posts in topic: 253
Posts: 16423
Joined: Mon Dec 24, 2012 3:16 pm
Location: Moobyworld
Gender: Female
Preferred Pronouns: she/her/hers
Aka: jules
Contact:

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2386

Post by juliets »

EBWOP: "case against him"
JaggedJimmyJay wrote: Sat Aug 21, 2021 3:24 pm Always good to remember that there is no such thing as a Mafia circumstance that is worth real human emotion. Sometimes it will naturally come out, but it can be contained if we just remember that this is a game on a message board forum that 99.99% of the population of the Earth has never heard of before. No matter how successful anyone is, it means just about nothing.

Spoiler: show
ImageImageImage
ImageImageImageImage
ImageImageImageImage
ImageImage
ImageImage
User avatar
Quin
Indecent Bastard
Posts in topic: 555
Posts: 10900
Joined: Fri Feb 19, 2016 1:08 am
Location: The Future

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2387

Post by Quin »

Quin wrote:
Dyslexicon wrote:
speedchuck wrote:Fred, we had a claim of a redirected watcher night one. By definition, a redirecting role usually hits the roles it redirects to.
The watcher, after redirected, only saw Eloh. Thus, Eloh is probably redirector.

Granted, we may not trust the watcher (Golden), or clusterfuck rules might apply, but it's a pretty good bet that Eloh is redirector. Scum wouldn't have two of them, probably. Thus, Eloh is prob town.
Redirector is usually anti-town role though? I won't clear Eloh based on these loose assumptions. The setup is ??? at this point. What reason would a town!Eloh not following the thread have to riderect Golden to Fred. That's just really random.
I think there would be a big balancing issue if there were two roles capable of redirecting targets/roles in some way on the same mafia team. If Eloh isn't town, she's either on a second mafia team or indy.

If we're assuming we've got her role pegged right, what's the issue in her picking Golden/Fred/3J if she's picking randomly?
ebwop
Lunalee wrote: Thu Nov 01, 2018 9:13 amQuin's ISO is full of posts that are actually trying to be helpful to the game. This doesn't look like town Quin.
ImageImageImageImage
User avatar
Quin
Indecent Bastard
Posts in topic: 555
Posts: 10900
Joined: Fri Feb 19, 2016 1:08 am
Location: The Future

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2388

Post by Quin »

juliets wrote:I haven't read INH. I know he built a case on Dyslexicon which I read and found to be lacking. Is the case abasing him that he argued a case that went against Marmot? Is there anything else to consider?

linki - nutella i see your point about him not showing up today

more linki
I didn't find his Dizzy case lacking at all. The only thing I wouldn't at least acknowledge is his argument that she was buddying Golden.
Lunalee wrote: Thu Nov 01, 2018 9:13 amQuin's ISO is full of posts that are actually trying to be helpful to the game. This doesn't look like town Quin.
ImageImageImageImage
User avatar
Dyslexicon
<3
Posts in topic: 347
Posts: 12805
Joined: Wed Apr 13, 2016 2:12 am

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2389

Post by Dyslexicon »

Quin wrote:
juliets wrote:I haven't read INH. I know he built a case on Dyslexicon which I read and found to be lacking. Is the case abasing him that he argued a case that went against Marmot? Is there anything else to consider?

linki - nutella i see your point about him not showing up today

more linki
I didn't find his Dizzy case lacking at all. The only thing I wouldn't at least acknowledge is his argument that she was buddying Golden.
*holds tongue*
*rolls eyes*
User avatar
Jackofhearts2005
something funny
Posts in topic: 270
Posts: 20512
Joined: Mon Nov 28, 2016 7:28 pm
Gender: Male
Preferred Pronouns: He/His/Him

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2390

Post by Jackofhearts2005 »

juliets wrote:I haven't read INH. I know he built a case on Dyslexicon which I read and found to be lacking. Is the case abasing him that he argued a case that went against Marmot? Is there anything else to consider?

linki - nutella i see your point about him not showing up today

more linki
There's nothing else INH has done but pursue Dizzy.

Even if he's wrong on Dizzy and Marmot, he's not playing like a townie.
User avatar
Golden
The Coward
Posts in topic: 344
Posts: 20125
Joined: Thu Feb 19, 2015 3:27 am
Location: Wellington, New Zealand

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2391

Post by Golden »

speedchuck wrote:
Dyslexicon wrote:
speedchuck wrote:Fred, we had a claim of a redirected watcher night one. By definition, a redirecting role usually hits the roles it redirects to.
The watcher, after redirected, only saw Eloh. Thus, Eloh is probably redirector.

Granted, we may not trust the watcher (Golden), or clusterfuck rules might apply, but it's a pretty good bet that Eloh is redirector. Scum wouldn't have two of them, probably. Thus, Eloh is prob town.
Redirector is usually anti-town role though? I won't clear Eloh based on these loose assumptions. The setup is ??? at this point. What reason would a town!Eloh not following the thread have to riderect Golden to Fred. That's just really random.
Answering your own question.

Also, I've played a town bus driver before. It can be a protective role.

Golden, busdrivers (for example) visit both target a and b. Then a watcher visiting target a would go to target b, then see the busdriver there.

Though, fair regarding the CF game. Could be something else entirely.
Yes, sorry. She could be a busdriver. I'm talking about if she was a straight misdirector. I think it's a big leap to make to presume Eloh is town and a busdriver simply because I saw her target fred.

I also think Eloh (knowing her) is unlikely to start by targeting people she doesn't know, so I'm wondering if she was also targeting Jay and misdirected to Fred.

Put it this way, I'm not giving eloh any kind of alignment read based on the fact I saw her target fred, and I think it would be awfully unwise to do it.
Spoiler: show
ImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImage
ImageImageImageImageImageImage
ImageImageImageImageImageImage
Image
Canucklehead wrote:Civ Golden is a hurricane of self-assurance.
G-Man wrote: Coward
User avatar
Quin
Indecent Bastard
Posts in topic: 555
Posts: 10900
Joined: Fri Feb 19, 2016 1:08 am
Location: The Future

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2392

Post by Quin »

Dyslexicon wrote:
Quin wrote:
juliets wrote:I haven't read INH. I know he built a case on Dyslexicon which I read and found to be lacking. Is the case abasing him that he argued a case that went against Marmot? Is there anything else to consider?

linki - nutella i see your point about him not showing up today

more linki
I didn't find his Dizzy case lacking at all. The only thing I wouldn't at least acknowledge is his argument that she was buddying Golden.
*holds tongue*
*rolls eyes*
:bighug:
Lunalee wrote: Thu Nov 01, 2018 9:13 amQuin's ISO is full of posts that are actually trying to be helpful to the game. This doesn't look like town Quin.
ImageImageImageImage
User avatar
Jackofhearts2005
something funny
Posts in topic: 270
Posts: 20512
Joined: Mon Nov 28, 2016 7:28 pm
Gender: Male
Preferred Pronouns: He/His/Him

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2393

Post by Jackofhearts2005 »

Quin wrote:
Jackofhearts2005 wrote:@Quin

But you need to think I have teammates if you think I'm mafia.

I don't think you think I have teammates. I don't think you think I'm mafia.
I don't have to justify an entire mafia team before getting any kind of result just so I can vote for you. I'm not that good at this game.

I think you're bad. That's good enough for me.
In fairness, you pursued DDL for most of Unfortunate Events without any buddy reads iirc.

I'll take that into consideration. Still holding you at Orange.
User avatar
Soneji
Corrupt Union Official
Posts in topic: 52
Posts: 572
Joined: Thu Apr 16, 2015 8:44 pm

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2394

Post by Soneji »

Dyslexicon wrote:
Soneji wrote:I saw Nutella cleared JJJ, though I'm not sure I exactly trust that. Nutella had been being buddy-buddy with JJJ early on and I don't care for JJJ's vote history.
Nutella's push was maybe the biggest reason the Marmot lynch gained traction, so what's not to trust about it?

If JJJ ever ends up scum, Soneji is scum buddies.
But lol. I'm done tinfoiling JJJ. He's sure town.
I haven't gotten to researching the MM lynch beyond seeing who all voted for him. If Nutella pushed on him that hard then I would be inclined to dismiss that suspicion.
Jackofhearts2005 wrote:@Quin

But you need to think I have teammates if you think I'm mafia.

I don't think you think I have teammates. I don't think you think I'm mafia.
That is some rather wack logic. It's like saying that if you don't know the entirety of how a puzzle will be completed, then you can't fit in a single piece of it.
Image

Image
User avatar
Jackofhearts2005
something funny
Posts in topic: 270
Posts: 20512
Joined: Mon Nov 28, 2016 7:28 pm
Gender: Male
Preferred Pronouns: He/His/Him

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2395

Post by Jackofhearts2005 »

Golden wrote:
speedchuck wrote:
Dyslexicon wrote:
speedchuck wrote:Fred, we had a claim of a redirected watcher night one. By definition, a redirecting role usually hits the roles it redirects to.
The watcher, after redirected, only saw Eloh. Thus, Eloh is probably redirector.

Granted, we may not trust the watcher (Golden), or clusterfuck rules might apply, but it's a pretty good bet that Eloh is redirector. Scum wouldn't have two of them, probably. Thus, Eloh is prob town.
Redirector is usually anti-town role though? I won't clear Eloh based on these loose assumptions. The setup is ??? at this point. What reason would a town!Eloh not following the thread have to riderect Golden to Fred. That's just really random.
Answering your own question.

Also, I've played a town bus driver before. It can be a protective role.

Golden, busdrivers (for example) visit both target a and b. Then a watcher visiting target a would go to target b, then see the busdriver there.

Though, fair regarding the CF game. Could be something else entirely.
Yes, sorry. She could be a busdriver. I'm talking about if she was a straight misdirector. I think it's a big leap to make to presume Eloh is town and a busdriver simply because I saw her target fred.

I also think Eloh (knowing her) is unlikely to start by targeting people she doesn't know, so I'm wondering if she was also targeting Jay and misdirected to Fred.

Put it this way, I'm not giving eloh any kind of alignment read based on the fact I saw her target fred, and I think it would be awfully unwise to do it.
Thank you.

The logical leaps from targeting Fred to busdriver to town busdriver are massive.
User avatar
JaggedJimmyJay
The Brassiere of The Syndicate
Posts in topic: 733
Posts: 39908
Joined: Tue May 12, 2015 11:42 pm
Location: United States
Gender: Man
Preferred Pronouns: He/him/his/himself
Aka: Jay | JJJ | J3 | 3J | jagged | Jimmy | KOFM
Contact:

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2396

Post by JaggedJimmyJay »

Hi. I'm here. Focus me.
Spoiler: show
Overall: 75-57 (.56) | Town 50-42 (.54) | Mafia 19-11 (.63) | Independent 6-4 (.60)

The Syndicate: Town 23-27; Mafia 11-5; Indy 5-1 | RateYourMusic: Town 14-13; Mafia 5-4; Indy 0-3 | Mafia Universe: Town 7-0; Mafia 1-0 | Student Doctor Network: Town 2-1; Mafia 1-0 | HeroClixRealms: Town 1-0; Mafia 0-1 | Bulbagarden: Mafia 0-1; Indy 1-0 | 2+2 POG: Town 1-0 | Naruto Forums: Town 0-1 | Personality Café: Town 1-0 | Vendetta Strada: Town 0-1 | Mafia451: Town 1-0 | Wintreath: Mafia 1-0

Awards:

Spoiler: show
The Syndicate

ImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImage

Student Doctor Network

ImageImageImageImageImage

Rate Your Music

Best Townie, Maffies 4, 8 and 9
Best Scum, Maffies 3
Best Moderator, Maffies 8 and 9
Most Valuable Player, Maffies 7 and 9
Best Roleplay, Maffies 4 and 6
Spirit Award, Maffies 9
Hall of Fame inductee, Maffies 4

Mafia Universe

Mafia Championship Finalist, 2015 and 2020
Best Town Player, 2020

Hosts:

Spoiler: show
ImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImageImage[-Mass Effect Mafia banner-]ImageImageImageImage
User avatar
Quin
Indecent Bastard
Posts in topic: 555
Posts: 10900
Joined: Fri Feb 19, 2016 1:08 am
Location: The Future

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2397

Post by Quin »

Jackofhearts2005 wrote:
juliets wrote:I haven't read INH. I know he built a case on Dyslexicon which I read and found to be lacking. Is the case abasing him that he argued a case that went against Marmot? Is there anything else to consider?

linki - nutella i see your point about him not showing up today

more linki
There's nothing else INH has done but pursue Dizzy.

Even if he's wrong on Dizzy and Marmot, he's not playing like a townie.
Why is INH not playing like a townie?
Lunalee wrote: Thu Nov 01, 2018 9:13 amQuin's ISO is full of posts that are actually trying to be helpful to the game. This doesn't look like town Quin.
ImageImageImageImage
User avatar
juliets
Dancing Pancake
Posts in topic: 253
Posts: 16423
Joined: Mon Dec 24, 2012 3:16 pm
Location: Moobyworld
Gender: Female
Preferred Pronouns: she/her/hers
Aka: jules
Contact:

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2398

Post by juliets »

Jackofhearts2005 wrote:
juliets wrote:I haven't read INH. I know he built a case on Dyslexicon which I read and found to be lacking. Is the case abasing him that he argued a case that went against Marmot? Is there anything else to consider?

linki - nutella i see your point about him not showing up today

more linki
There's nothing else INH has done but pursue Dizzy.

Even if he's wrong on Dizzy and Marmot, he's not playing like a townie.
Are you saying he's not playing like a townie because he's not considering alternatives? I'm not arguing the point, just trying to clarify.

linki
JaggedJimmyJay wrote: Sat Aug 21, 2021 3:24 pm Always good to remember that there is no such thing as a Mafia circumstance that is worth real human emotion. Sometimes it will naturally come out, but it can be contained if we just remember that this is a game on a message board forum that 99.99% of the population of the Earth has never heard of before. No matter how successful anyone is, it means just about nothing.

Spoiler: show
ImageImageImage
ImageImageImageImage
ImageImageImageImage
ImageImage
ImageImage
User avatar
speedchuck
Knight of No Renown
Posts in topic: 321
Posts: 10958
Joined: Wed Jan 25, 2017 11:43 am

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2399

Post by speedchuck »

Quin wrote:
Jackofhearts2005 wrote:
juliets wrote:I haven't read INH. I know he built a case on Dyslexicon which I read and found to be lacking. Is the case abasing him that he argued a case that went against Marmot? Is there anything else to consider?

linki - nutella i see your point about him not showing up today

more linki
There's nothing else INH has done but pursue Dizzy.

Even if he's wrong on Dizzy and Marmot, he's not playing like a townie.
Why is INH not playing like a townie?
Because he's not town?
SIGNATURE:
Spoiler: show
Speedchuck wins the "Jack Torrance Has Always Been The Caretaker" award.
ImageImageImageImage
ImageImageImageImage
ImageImage
User avatar
Quin
Indecent Bastard
Posts in topic: 555
Posts: 10900
Joined: Fri Feb 19, 2016 1:08 am
Location: The Future

Re: Phenon Mafia: Day 3 - Karma

#2400

Post by Quin »

speedchuck wrote:
Quin wrote:
Jackofhearts2005 wrote:
juliets wrote:I haven't read INH. I know he built a case on Dyslexicon which I read and found to be lacking. Is the case abasing him that he argued a case that went against Marmot? Is there anything else to consider?

linki - nutella i see your point about him not showing up today

more linki
There's nothing else INH has done but pursue Dizzy.

Even if he's wrong on Dizzy and Marmot, he's not playing like a townie.
Why is INH not playing like a townie?
Because he's not town?
oh ok thanks
Lunalee wrote: Thu Nov 01, 2018 9:13 amQuin's ISO is full of posts that are actually trying to be helpful to the game. This doesn't look like town Quin.
ImageImageImageImage
Post Reply

Return to “Previous Jobs”