Survivor: Mafia [Day 1-3: Mamana Tribe]

#301

DrWilgy wrote:Jeff, I'd like to fashion a spear out of w/e and use that to assist me in my fishing. Is that ok?

Whatever floats your boat, Rambo. It may not help you catch any more fish than usual, but you'll look damn intimidating, that's for sure.

#302

Golden wrote:
Opt_Outside wrote:Elo I'll BTSC with you too!

Anyone else want to chat with me tonight?
Me! I already picked you last night.

Ah shoot! I committed to INH and Elo. Unless Elo made other plans, want to do night 3?

#303

DharmaHelper wrote:I'm reluctant to change, but I think I will with the caveat that *everyone* agrees to go black rocks. As it's been said, black rocks'll give us at worst 50% chance of winning.

I'm down to push it to a coin flip if everyone else is.

I'm down to do all black rocks if everyone is in.

#304

Opt_Outside wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:At LoRab's suggestion, please copy/paste this list with your decision.

YELLOW
- Opt
- DharmaHelper
-
-

BLACK
-
-
-
-
-
Sounds good. I'll wait until we finalize the list to make sure there are no mistakes and then I'll PM yellow, Elo, and insertname to scotty

Okay, I am picking yellow and then Opt and Slang for BTSC.

#305

I'm good with whatever the majority thinks is best on this one.

#306

Elohcin wrote:
Opt_Outside wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:At LoRab's suggestion, please copy/paste this list with your decision.

YELLOW
- Opt
- DharmaHelper
-
-

BLACK
-
-
-
-
-
Sounds good. I'll wait until we finalize the list to make sure there are no mistakes and then I'll PM yellow, Elo, and insertname to scotty
Okay, I am picking yellow and then Opt and Slang for BTSC.

To be clear, you aren't backing the emerging strategy to pick all black rocks?

#307

Also to be clear, anyone who has PMed their picks can change them before the deadline as I just learned from Scotty.

#308

Opt_Outside wrote:
Golden wrote:
Opt_Outside wrote:Elo I'll BTSC with you too!

Anyone else want to chat with me tonight?
Me! I already picked you last night.
Ah shoot! I committed to INH and Elo. Unless Elo made other plans, want to do night 3?

I'm now booked up for night three.

#309

I haven't committed to switching yet, I want to be 100% sure everyone is on the same page whatever we decide to do. Once folks like Eloh/INH Check in again and give their thoughts on the black stone plan we can see where we go from there.

#310

Golden wrote:
Opt_Outside wrote:
Golden wrote:
Opt_Outside wrote:Elo I'll BTSC with you too!

Anyone else want to chat with me tonight?
Me! I already picked you last night.
Ah shoot! I committed to INH and Elo. Unless Elo made other plans, want to do night 3?
I'm now booked up for night three.

You mean you're booked including me or not including me?

#311

Opt_Outside wrote:
Golden wrote:
Opt_Outside wrote:
Golden wrote:
Opt_Outside wrote:Elo I'll BTSC with you too!

Anyone else want to chat with me tonight?
Me! I already picked you last night.
Ah shoot! I committed to INH and Elo. Unless Elo made other plans, want to do night 3?
I'm now booked up for night three.
You mean you're booked including me or not including me?

Excluding, I have dh and speed. I wonder if someone else is ok bumping?

#312

Golden wrote:
Opt_Outside wrote:
Golden wrote:
Opt_Outside wrote:
Golden wrote:
Opt_Outside wrote:Elo I'll BTSC with you too!

Anyone else want to chat with me tonight?
Me! I already picked you last night.
Ah shoot! I committed to INH and Elo. Unless Elo made other plans, want to do night 3?
I'm now booked up for night three.
You mean you're booked including me or not including me?
Excluding, I have dh and speed. I wonder if someone else is ok bumping?

You can bump me if you'd like.

Opt_Outside, would you be willing to talk with me for Day 3? Seems like an amicable compromise.

#313

DharmaHelper wrote:
Golden wrote:
Opt_Outside wrote:
Golden wrote:
Opt_Outside wrote:
Golden wrote:
Opt_Outside wrote:Elo I'll BTSC with you too!

Anyone else want to chat with me tonight?
Me! I already picked you last night.
Ah shoot! I committed to INH and Elo. Unless Elo made other plans, want to do night 3?
I'm now booked up for night three.
You mean you're booked including me or not including me?
Excluding, I have dh and speed. I wonder if someone else is ok bumping?
You can bump me if you'd like.

Opt_Outside, would you be willing to talk with me for Day 3? Seems like an amicable compromise.

Yeah that's great! So I've got INH and Elo tomorrow, DH and Golden day 3

#314

So I'm bumping DH to day 4?

The other option is that I do speedchuck on day two and someone else agrees to bump contact with him back to day three.

#315

Golden wrote:So I'm bumping DH to day 4?

The other option is that I do speedchuck on day two and someone else agrees to bump contact with him back to day three.

I Could pick you and Opt, and Opt can pick me and someone else?

#316

OK, I'll pick a black rock, Jeff

I'll switch to yellow if we don't all agree to go black.

#317

OK Jeff I'll pick a black rock for now

#318

DharmaHelper wrote:
Golden wrote:So I'm bumping DH to day 4?

The other option is that I do speedchuck on day two and someone else agrees to bump contact with him back to day three.
I Could pick you and Opt, and Opt can pick me and someone else?

I can't pick all of you, opt and speed on night 3.

But, problem solved if I go back to picking speed tonight. If speed can manage to negotiate bumping someone else back to day three.

I also still need another for tonight if I have speed. Any takers? LoRab? Elo?

#319

Golden wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:
Golden wrote:So I'm bumping DH to day 4?

The other option is that I do speedchuck on day two and someone else agrees to bump contact with him back to day three.
I Could pick you and Opt, and Opt can pick me and someone else?
I can't pick all of you, opt and speed on night 3.

But, problem solved if I go back to picking speed tonight. If speed can manage to negotiate bumping someone else back to day three.

I also still need another for tonight if I have speed. Any takers? LoRab? Elo?

What I mean is I can pick you and Opt, you can pick me and speed, and Opt can pick me and someone else.

#320

Okay, day 4 is still a ways away so tonight I've got Elo and insertname and I think let's just take it day at a time after that

#321

This is so complicated.

I've got LoRab and Wilgy set up right now. Let me know if I need to switch once you guys figure it out.

#322

I'm fine with going day-by-day to lessen confusion.

#323

Hey, LoRab, how about you go for me tonight instead of speedchuck. I'll go for speedchuck tonight as well, so I could relay back and forth.

#324

I'm willing to try a BLACK ROCK based plan.

Hopefully, it doesn't end with anyone getting blown up.

SWITCHING TO BLACK ROCK

#325

In the interests of transparency and clarity, if you can please add your name to this list:

Black Rock Plan
- DharmaHelper

--
Also, for *tonights* btsc, I've picked LoRab and INH

#326

DharmaHelper wrote:Also, for *tonights* btsc, I've picked LoRab and INH

For tonights btsc, I've picked LoRab and speedchuck. (I may strike out).

Black Rock Plan
- DharmaHelper
- Golden

#327

Golden and DrWigly for night chat

Switch my rock to black Unless the plan falls through.

#328

SOrry I messed this up guys....I posted without fully catching up. Let me catch up. I will take whatever the team thinks is best. I have a page and a half to read :O

#329

Black Rock List (Updated as much as I can remember)

- DharmaHelper
-INH
-Golden
-SpeedChuck
-Boomslang
-LoRab
-Opt

I think we just need Eloh and Dr. Wilgy to confirm they're picking black rocks and we're set. If you're on this list and you haven't already, please make it abundantly clear in the thread and via PM to the host that you're picking a black rock.

#330

Funny thing is...we are all talking about who we will have BTSC with when it doesn't really matter too much b/c we are all working together as it is in the thread. And it's not like the thread locks at night. This IS our BTSC

hehe. Anyway....I guess I am supposed to choose black. I just don't see that as profitable with me being set up with notsawyer.

#331

Elohcin wrote:Funny thing is...we are all talking about who we will have BTSC with when it doesn't really matter too much b/c we are all working together as it is in the thread. And it's not like the thread locks at night. This IS our BTSC hehe. Anyway....I guess I am supposed to choose black. I just don't see that as profitable with me being set up with notsawyer.

The strategy behind picking all black is to make it so that we're guaranteed a 50% or higher chance at the fishing gear. Worst case scenario is it goes to a tie (which would be a coin flip). If even one of them picks yellow whilst we've picked all black though, we've automatically gotten the gear.

#332

Elohcin wrote:Funny thing is...we are all talking about who we will have BTSC with when it doesn't really matter too much b/c we are all working together as it is in the thread. And it's not like the thread locks at night. This IS our BTSC hehe. Anyway....I guess I am supposed to choose black. I just don't see that as profitable with me being set up with notsawyer.

Also, you're the one who suggested we be open about BTSC in the first place

#333

We're making the right decision with all black rocks. If our team picks ALL black rocks and they do ANYTHING except pick all black rocks, we win. If both teams choose all black rocks, it's a coin flip. Even in that scenario, we'd still have made the right choice because if we took any yellow they would win and we wouldn't even get the food. It's the safest bet all the way around.

#334

I just reread the black/yellow stuff. I am going to go for black rock, and BTSC with Slang and Opt. Final Answer

linki: Haha, I know. I just thought if we are going to try to get BTSC we ought to be open so it actually works.

#335

Elohcin wrote:Funny thing is...we are all talking about who we will have BTSC with when it doesn't really matter too much b/c we are all working together as it is in the thread. And it's not like the thread locks at night. This IS our BTSC hehe. Anyway....I guess I am supposed to choose black. I just don't see that as profitable with me being set up with notsawyer.

Infodumping is allowed in this game, and we may not always be in a tribe like this. BTSC is a good time to make more strong alliances with the individual members of the tribe, as well as dropping any info as a symbol of good trust.

Even if you aren't angling for keeping malicious secrets, it can be useful probably.

#336

Elohcin wrote:Funny thing is...we are all talking about who we will have BTSC with when it doesn't really matter too much b/c we are all working together as it is in the thread. And it's not like the thread locks at night. This IS our BTSC hehe. Anyway....I guess I am supposed to choose black. I just don't see that as profitable with me being set up with notsawyer.

It's true, but BTSC is fun. It has a different air to it. You get to know people.

#337

Now the plan is basically hinging on Wilgy, right?

#338

I already PM'd our host :^(

Also, do know that the instructions for the rocks stated to message the Host.

#339

DrWilgy wrote:I already PM'd our host :^(

Also, do know that the instructions for the rocks stated to message the Host.

I asked Scotty, and you can change them.

#340

Hmmm... I don't wanna betray SVS, but I'll do it for the tribe.

#341

DrWilgy wrote:Hmmm... I don't wanna betray SVS, but I'll do it for the tribe.

#342

DrWilgy wrote:Hmmm... I don't wanna betray SVS, but I'll do it for the tribe.

It's okay, that's how I felt.

THIS IS SURVIVAL THOUGH

#343

DharmaHelper wrote:
DrWilgy wrote:Hmmm... I don't wanna betray SVS, but I'll do it for the tribe.

What? SVS is my friend. Why would she ever trust me again if I give her a Black Rock?

I'm submitting my rock change now.

#344

I bought a house

I've got five days to get my affairs in order, so please excuse me for posting at less than 15 posts a day for a bit.

#345

DrWilgy wrote:Hmmm... I don't wanna betray SVS, but I'll do it for the tribe.

I don't want to betray SVS either, but it's us vs them right now. We can beg for forgiveness later.

#346

DrWilgy wrote: What? SVS is my friend. Why would she ever trust me again if I give her a Black Rock?

I'm submitting my rock change now.

It's all good pal. We're all friends here.

#347

Golden wrote:I bought a house

I've got five days to get my affairs in order, so please excuse me for posting at less than 15 posts a day for a bit.

Ooh, exciting! I'll be taking that leap soon. Have fun with all of the new, exciting moving-in stuff!

#348

Golden wrote:
Elohcin wrote:Funny thing is...we are all talking about who we will have BTSC with when it doesn't really matter too much b/c we are all working together as it is in the thread. And it's not like the thread locks at night. This IS our BTSC hehe. Anyway....I guess I am supposed to choose black. I just don't see that as profitable with me being set up with notsawyer.
It's true, but BTSC is fun. It has a different air to it. You get to know people.

I totally agree. I love BTSC. Especially when people actually come in and talk to me

#349

Congrats on the home Golden don't worry I'll post plenty for the both of us

#350

Golden wrote:I bought a house

I've got five days to get my affairs in order, so please excuse me for posting at less than 15 posts a day for a bit.

Good for you, Golden!! I'm excited for you.

There's a box of colored rocks at treemail! (Pick one per person please)