Pikachu Tribe - Day 9

[sprityo]

Then I'm down to lynch Wilgy next.

i second this because I believe DH, Epi and Myself to be town. so you guys can take the reins on this sloonei/scotty

[sprityo]

Here’s a very likely thing to note:
Strexcorp does not kill on even nights.

Marmot most definitely used his one-shot negation of night actions on N4, because not only was there no kill, Cecil didn’t post.

So either there was a protect of the NK target and someone blocked Cecil, or Marmot used his power on a night they didn’t kill. There is no reason to do so on a night that they would have had a chance to kill.

So therefore, if there are only 2 teams (Evil Evens and Strexcorp) then Evil Evens DO kill on even nights

i'd like to point out it's also possible cecil just straight up didnt submit anything for night 4. i dont think the hosts would come on and say "cecil didnt send anything in tonight"

Did he?

i'll just publicly ask that he confirms what happened in his post for tonight's phase

[DrWilgy]

Where the fuck am I?!?

0.o

WHO ARE YOU PEOPLE!

Thanks for your single contribution to the day, good doctor.

See, this is the kind of stuff we’ve been getting from Wilgy most the game.. I say most because it started off with very direct dialogue and purpose. But it’s been even sillier and ramped up since SpaceDaisy alluded to bad Wilgy harboring a more straight-forward serious approach. Is this civ play?

Fuck it, it's Day 8, in a GOC game. If people are gonna do that kind of stuff I'd honestly prefer lynching them

Do it. I ain't got time for this shit.

[Sloonei]

I've said this already, but just for the sake of clarity:
My top town reads in Cerberus were Kyle, spacedaisy, and Scotty. Those three all happened to be come along here. I find it unlikely that I could be swayed to vote for any of them at this time.
Marmot was my primary suspect for a while. We've lynched him on two consecutive days and that suspicion has been validated. Sweet.
DrWilgy is, as always, a wild card. I pegged him as a light green town read on my imaginary rainbow, but as the POE field is narrowed down, he sticks out as a good candidate to be lynched.

Epi and DH (along with Quin) were my town reads when I peaked in here on Night 3. Nothing about today's events have swayed me change my mind on them. If sprityo is Cecil, and Cecil is civilian, that leaves us (or me, at least) with wilgy and nobody else as a suspect. I uh guess I'll be inclined to vote for him tomorrow.

[DharmaHelper]

Where the fuck am I?!?

0.o

WHO ARE YOU PEOPLE!

Thanks for your single contribution to the day, good doctor.

See, this is the kind of stuff we’ve been getting from Wilgy most the game.. I say most because it started off with very direct dialogue and purpose. But it’s been even sillier and ramped up since SpaceDaisy alluded to bad Wilgy harboring a more straight-forward serious approach. Is this civ play?

Fuck it, it's Day 8, in a GOC game. If people are gonna do that kind of stuff I'd honestly prefer lynching them

Do it. I ain't got time for this shit.

I'll lynch you after I lynch Speedchuck's teammate, Epignosis.

[DrWilgy]

Godspeed you

[Sloonei]

For reference, the other tribe currently consists of:

Boomslang
colonialbob
Dom
Dragon D Luffy
insertnamehere
LoRab
nijuukyugou
Quin
sig
Speedchuck
S~V~S

[DharmaHelper]

This is speedchuck’s D1 rainbow. Posting for posterity.

speedchuck
Long Con
sprityo
S~V~S
Quin
Epignosis
nutella
Dragon D Luffy
Dharmahelper
colonialbob
dom

Readlist

I would expect if Speedchuck had a teammate on this tribe (which isn’t definite), the teammate(s) would lie somewhere in the middle-low range. Not too high, not too low. Epi certainly fits that bill, but so does DDL and DH

I still don't believe speedchuck was bad in his first incarnation.

Well then, there is that possibility.

I wouldn't take Speedchuck's rainbow list at face value. He didn't see to understand how they work.

[DharmaHelper]

Post-Script:

Speedchuck was bad in his first incarnation.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Adding to my posts

[DharmaHelper]

Nice quiet Night. Cool.

[juliets]

Night pms are due by 5:11 pm set, or approximately 1 hour and 50 minutes.

[Scotty]

[mention]Epignosis[/mention] I’m sorry if you answered this before but why are you deadset that nutella didn’t start as mafia?

[Scotty]

DH’s case is circumstantial and has a whole lot of projecting, for sure. BUt it could be something nonetheless.

I also have a good feeling about Epi before nutella blew up the game.

I still would rather speed get lynched in any case atm so I can look at LC/speed interactions when I have more time

Circumstantial how?

Epi and Chuck both fucked around with their votes, voting counter to their stated suspicions in order to save Speedchuck, and Speedchuck is bad. Where is the guess work there?

speedchuck's first role could have been a civilian role. You don't see too many mafia protectors (I had one in Mileena, but I can't recall ever having another one).

Nevermind. You were talking about Speedchuck.

I don’t think it would be a stretch to assume in a big game like this that there would be mafia doctors. There’s alfeady a bevy of vote manipulation roles all over the place.

It would certainly make me feel better about INH’s first role being civ, as a Doctor-lite

[Spacedaisy]

Where the fuck am I?!?

0.o

WHO ARE YOU PEOPLE!

Thanks for your single contribution to the day, good doctor.

See, this is the kind of stuff we’ve been getting from Wilgy most the game.. I say most because it started off with very direct dialogue and purpose. But it’s been even sillier and ramped up since SpaceDaisy alluded to bad Wilgy harboring a more straight-forward serious approach. Is this civ play?

No, good Wilgy plays jokey and shticky, but he actually has insight he puts out there if you are willing to sort out what he is saying. Civ WIlgy actually has a pretty good idea for baddies.

I just spent 7 days desperately trying to push a lynch across without success. Then I come here and actively try not to lynch, but it happens anyway.

More importantly, heck yeah.

LOL, well done Sloonster! You called it.

To the best of your ability, newcomers:

What did nijuukyugou do during Day 1 / Night 1?

Pretty much nothing except a soft defense of Boomslang when he came under suspicion early. And her response to nutella being revealed as her proton/electron BTSC partner seemed odd to some of us. But if you were bad, and you were NOT on a team with your electron/proton BTSC partner, it would make sense you wouldn't ask who they were, because you wouldn't want to know. So it makes sense if nutella didn't ask. But did Blooper literally say nothing as Nutella said? Because I thought Blooper said they had barely said anything. Meaning, I was under the impression she said something at least... When I asked about this before none of my previous tribe mates responded. Does anyone remember if Blooper said she hadn't said anything?

[Spacedaisy]

Boomslang was an early suspicion for me for a couple reasons:

He jumped on discussion about everyone outing whether or not they sent in a haiku once we were told anyone who did was unlynchable Day 1 and pushed for everyone doing this.

He voted for sig because of the previously mentioned 70% comment.

In the first case it looked to me like a Baddie trying to look like they are putting work into the game, without actually being helpful. I mean, if you were bad you would just lie about. All we would have been doing was wasting time talking about it that could be spent talking about who to lynch.

In the case of the second I could see no way a stupid comment like that would make sig bad. Why would a baddie say, "I think I might have sent a haiku in" when they know that doing so would have made them unlynchable? It only made sense as a silly civ moment. Later sig revealed he said it on purpose to see how people responded to it. It's too easy a thing to lie about and thereby discourage people from voting for you to be a Baddie slip up imo. And it made me really suspect him for it because it seemed like the logical explanation, so taking such an illogical stance seemed strange to me coming from Boom.

However, he feel off my radar completely since then. I don't know what opinion I currently have of him. I can't recall anything he said or did since then and that was Day 1 and 2...

[DharmaHelper]

Yall remember that one time bad Wilgy put a whole case together against me that was like, the funniest shit and he said he put it together in the shower.

[Scotty]

Even mafia will be hunting in this game (see Long Con) since there are more than one team, which throws a lot of metas into question

[Scotty]

Either Sloonei is the civviest of the civs (I’ve held that position basically all game) or he’s been bamboozling us all. He deserves to win if he and Marmot are aligned, which the right side of my brain is twitching to me right now.

Could be time for a lobotomy

[DharmaHelper]

Top Five List of Things People Think Matter In Mafia But Actually They Dont

5. Rainbow Lists
4. Meta
3. Adverbs
2. Rainbow Lists Again
1. Rainbow Lists a Third Time.

[Scotty]

Top Five List of Things People Think Matter In Mafia But Actually They Dont

5. Rainbow Lists
4. Meta
3. Adverbs
2. Rainbow Lists Again
1. Rainbow Lists a Third Time.

Epi would like to quickly have a word with you

[Golden]

ISOs up.

Scotty, you aren't getting an iso link of my posts because it is literally redundant. So there

[Sloonei]

Either Sloonei is the civviest of the civs (I’ve held that position basically all game) or he’s been bamboozling us all. He deserves to win if he and Marmot are aligned, which the right side of my brain is twitching to me right now.

Could be time for a lobotomy

I could be an evil even.

[Sloonei]

ISOs up.

Scotty, you aren't getting an iso link of my posts because it is literally redundant. So there

Not on mobile it's not.

[Scotty]

I feel as though things look bleak for me tonight with jack going buh bye last night. It’s the first time mafia have shown a desire to totally eliminate someone :/

[Golden]

ISOs up.

Scotty, you aren't getting an iso link of my posts because it is literally redundant. So there

Not on mobile it's not.

I can't possibly be seen to encourage such an inefficient way of playing.

[sprityo]

Me waiting for Day start

[sprityo]

fml

[Scotty]

ISOs up.

Scotty, you aren't getting an iso link of my posts because it is literally redundant. So there

Not on mobile it's not.

Thank you Sir Golden and yes, on mobile it’s a nightmare

[Golden]

Sorry for post lateness - incoming shortly.

[Golden]

MacDougall was frustrated. Not everyone had done the job that he hoped, and he didn’t take kindly to failure. He was concerned that the meddling of the Citadel Council was becoming problematic.

He had a clear vision for his next target, however. He sent the acolytes out with nunchucks. If you’re committing murder, you may as well do it in style.

Night 8 has ended. Sprityo has died. He was:

15: Cecil (Welcome to Night Vale). Each night, you can write a news article to be published in the thread via the host.

It is now day 9. It will last for 48 hours

[Golden]

From Cecil:

To confirm your question formally, Scotty

I did in fact miss the night 4 submission, was very busy that day. And a wonderful welcome to all the bidoof/Cerberus tribe members. Whatever you all call it. I see no reason not to trust all of you vocal members, afterall we lost 3 of the people we started the day with if you include the late JackofHearts2005. If the wacky Doctor has no objections to being removed I say we move forward in the operation. I wanted to iterate again that it’s most splendid that we got two mafia players out of the game yesterday.

I never really considered if the other tribe was receiving these messages, but in any case it wouldn’t hurt for me to remind them that Speedchuck is basically confirmed mafia with Nutella’s flip.

Let us move forward with a pep in our step and eyes shining bright, into a beautiful new day. Also Sprityo is most definitely Cecil just for your extra confirmation.
-Cecil

[DharmaHelper]

Ay lads so one of the new guys killed Cecil

[sprityo]

well there we have it

[Golden]

Thanks for the 'extra confirmation' of my host post, Cecil.

[Sloonei]

vote drwilgy aubergine etc.

[DharmaHelper]

Cecil survives ~8 or 9 days after I outted him in the thread with our original Pikachu tribe mates and the Night that the new guys get here and find out he's a gossiper role, he dies? Uh-huh

One of the Cerb people killed Cecil. Probably not Doc since he doesn't give a wet fart about the game it looks like

[Epignosis]

A role like Cecil's isn't a very powerful one though- not in the sense that it can protect civilians or block you or sic poison monkeys on you.

[DharmaHelper]

A role like Cecil's isn't a very powerful one though- not in the sense that it can protect civilians or block you or sic poison monkeys on you.

OK.

Who from Cerberus do you think would nightkill an outted gossip role? Not counting Doc

[Epignosis]

A role like Cecil's isn't a very powerful one though- not in the sense that it can protect civilians or block you or sic poison monkeys on you.

OK.

Who from Cerberus do you think would nightkill an outted gossip role? Not counting Doc

The value in killing him is in the removal of a "confirmed" (I use that term loosely) civilian voice. Nobody was ever going to lynch sprityo, so it doesn't surprise me to see him killed eventually, but not early. That's all I mean.

I think anybody would kill sprityo. It's just good strategy at this stage.

[Sloonei]

Cecil survives ~8 or 9 days after I outted him in the thread with our original Pikachu tribe mates and the Night that the new guys get here and find out he's a gossiper role, he dies? Uh-huh

One of the Cerb people killed Cecil. Probably not Doc since he doesn't give a wet fart about the game it looks like

I see no reason to dismiss wilgy on these grounds.

In vocaroo II he was bad and essentially made no posts in the thread, but was apparently active in BTSC the whole game. A public appearance of not caring does not mean wilgy doesn't care.

[Epignosis]

Cecil survives ~8 or 9 days after I outted him in the thread with our original Pikachu tribe mates and the Night that the new guys get here and find out he's a gossiper role, he dies? Uh-huh

One of the Cerb people killed Cecil. Probably not Doc since he doesn't give a wet fart about the game it looks like

I see no reason to dismiss wilgy on these grounds.

In vocaroo II he was bad and essentially made no posts in the thread, but was apparently active in BTSC the whole game. A public appearance of not caring does not mean wilgy doesn't care.

This is true.

[DharmaHelper]

A role like Cecil's isn't a very powerful one though- not in the sense that it can protect civilians or block you or sic poison monkeys on you.

OK.

Who from Cerberus do you think would nightkill an outted gossip role? Not counting Doc

The value in killing him is in the removal of a "confirmed" (I use that term loosely) civilian voice. Nobody was ever going to lynch sprityo, so it doesn't surprise me to see him killed eventually, but not early. That's all I mean.

I think anybody would kill sprityo. It's just good strategy at this stage.

Mkay. So...

Why do you think it took ~8 days to do the deed? Cerberus guys get here, and Sprityo gets popped. You're not willing to engage in a bit of kill theory here?

[DharmaHelper]

Cecil survives ~8 or 9 days after I outted him in the thread with our original Pikachu tribe mates and the Night that the new guys get here and find out he's a gossiper role, he dies? Uh-huh

One of the Cerb people killed Cecil. Probably not Doc since he doesn't give a wet fart about the game it looks like

I see no reason to dismiss wilgy on these grounds.

In vocaroo II he was bad and essentially made no posts in the thread, but was apparently active in BTSC the whole game. A public appearance of not caring does not mean wilgy doesn't care.

OK But lets assume it wasn't Doc.

[Sloonei]

It took like 6 nights for anyone from this tribe to be nightkilled.

[Sloonei]

Cecil survives ~8 or 9 days after I outted him in the thread with our original Pikachu tribe mates and the Night that the new guys get here and find out he's a gossiper role, he dies? Uh-huh

One of the Cerb people killed Cecil. Probably not Doc since he doesn't give a wet fart about the game it looks like

I see no reason to dismiss wilgy on these grounds.

In vocaroo II he was bad and essentially made no posts in the thread, but was apparently active in BTSC the whole game. A public appearance of not caring does not mean wilgy doesn't care.

OK But lets assume it wasn't Doc.

Then it was you or Scotty.

I assume it was Wilgy.

[DharmaHelper]

It took like 6 nights for anyone from this tribe to be nightkilled.

And you lot turn up and we start dying straight off.

[Sloonei]

It took like 6 nights for anyone from this tribe to be nightkilled.

And you lot turn up and we start dying straight off.

SVS died before we got here

[Epignosis]

A role like Cecil's isn't a very powerful one though- not in the sense that it can protect civilians or block you or sic poison monkeys on you.

OK.

Who from Cerberus do you think would nightkill an outted gossip role? Not counting Doc

The value in killing him is in the removal of a "confirmed" (I use that term loosely) civilian voice. Nobody was ever going to lynch sprityo, so it doesn't surprise me to see him killed eventually, but not early. That's all I mean.

I think anybody would kill sprityo. It's just good strategy at this stage.

Mkay. So...

Why do you think it took ~8 days to do the deed? Cerberus guys get here, and Sprityo gets popped. You're not willing to engage in a bit of kill theory here?

I just did. I'm sorry if you didn't like my conclusion.

"Kill theory" =/= "Agreeing with DH's theory"

[DharmaHelper]

It took like 6 nights for anyone from this tribe to be nightkilled.

And you lot turn up and we start dying straight off.

SVS died before we got here

SVS Wasn't a Cecil tho