[GAME OVER] Friends Mafia

[Hugh Jass]

Also, are you okay with leaving the game's final decision to... Nora?

[Phoebe Buffay]

[VOTE: Monica Geller] aubergine
Because I'm the queen here.

What do you think of Rachel's posts?

Her posts are fluffy, and she never expresses a strong opinion. Almost too careful. I don't like Rachel.
Or Monica.

[Phoebe Buffay]

Also, are you okay with leaving the game's final decision to... Nora?

You are welcome to switch your vote as well, Ross. The fact that Monica and Rachel are both voting for each other leads me to believe they are the bad team, and have agreed that whoever doesn't get lynched will gain our trust from their vote on the other.

[Hugh Jass]

Also, are you okay with leaving the game's final decision to... Nora?

You are welcome to switch your vote as well, Ross. The fact that Monica and Rachel are both voting for each other leads me to believe they are the bad team, and have agreed that whoever doesn't get lynched will gain our trust from their vote on the other.

Im just worried that you are so confident in this read of yours that you are ignoring the fact that if you are wrong and Nora aka the person with nearly no contribution is bad, we are doomed.

So if only one of Rachel or Monica is bad and the other is honestly hunting her, we are screwed.

[Hugh Jass]

And that's not even covering the fact you might be bad too (tinfoils).

But point is, whoever we vote for, we better get to a consensus on them.

[Phoebe Buffay]

Also, are you okay with leaving the game's final decision to... Nora?

You are welcome to switch your vote as well, Ross. The fact that Monica and Rachel are both voting for each other leads me to believe they are the bad team, and have agreed that whoever doesn't get lynched will gain our trust from their vote on the other.

Im just worried that you are so confident in this read of yours that you are ignoring the fact that if you are wrong and Nora aka the person with nearly no contribution is bad, we are doomed.

So if only one of Rachel or Monica is bad and the other is honestly hunting her, we are screwed.

That would be unfortunate. Why are you so convinced Rachel is bad?

[Phoebe Buffay]

And that's not even covering the fact you might be bad too (tinfoils).

But point is, whoever we vote for, we better get to a consensus on them.

Take that tinfoil off, it makes you look silly.

[Hugh Jass]

This is her most contributive post in the game:

Rachel Green - Whined about having votes placed on her on day one, and was the sole voter of Janice. Could be scum.

Girl why you got to be lying like that, no one even voted me d1. I was crying because you guys lynched my BFF Joey!

Vote : Phoebe

Oh? Okay. My bad. Who do you think is bad besides me, because that opinion is wrong.

You might be onto something with Chandler, he might have framed Janice to escape her clutches. I'm going to forgive you for not including me in your alliance and trust you here.

Vote : Chandler

[Hugh Jass]

It's mindless sheeping. She is not doing any work, she's just following you.

And when she's not following others, she is basing her votes on OMGUS.

Either she's bad or a really lazy and irresponsible civ.

[Hugh Jass]

Like, I'm not saying this is a perfect tell, but there is a bar for "is actually trying to solve the game", and only you and Monica are currently clearing that bar.

Nora and Rachel aren't, but Nora at least is showing some sincere apathy. Rachel is hiding behind roleplaying, and when she's not she's making votes that don't actually look sincere.

[Phoebe Buffay]

Like, I'm not saying this is a perfect tell, but there is a bar for "is actually trying to solve the game", and only you and Monica are currently clearing that bar.

Nora and Rachel aren't, but Nora at least is showing some sincere apathy. Rachel is hiding behind roleplaying, and when she's not she's making votes that don't actually look sincere.

That makes sense. We can lynch Rachel today, and if she flips scum, I recommend going after Monica tomorrow.

[Phoebe Buffay]

[VOTE: Rachel Green] aubergine

[Hugh Jass]

THanks, Pheebs.

Hope the wolves are not you and Nora all along, lol.

[Rachel Green]

Guys I think this Ross is an imposter, the real Ross was abducted the night after Monica's attempted poisoning! He is accusing me of terrible things and using strange words!

Don't worry honey I'll rescue you from whatever bathroom Nora has you locked in!

[Quokka]

Also, are you okay with leaving the game's final decision to... Nora?

Swinging both ways is part of my charm

[Quokka]

Okay 3 votes on Rachel seems a lil fishy at this point

[Hugh Jass]

Okay 3 votes on Rachel seems a lil fishy at this point

All the girls are mesmerized by my magnetism.

Wait... actually it's just my sister and Pheebs.

[Rachel Green]

I'm doing my best to figure things out based on what I know of you guys but I don't want to think bad of any of you! No one has been poisoned since, if it was even poison, so Monica seems to have done all this for attention!

[Hugh Jass]

Okay 3 votes on Rachel seems a lil fishy at this point

Not necessarily. The only way we can win is if all three civs happen to vote for a baddie, or if the baddies vote for each other (in case Monica and Rachel are the baddies). If anything, baddies might prefer to wait for civs to vote wrong so they can pile up their votes together. 3 votes on someone are good for us.

Now, if Phoebe is bad, we are screwed, because she can change her vote at the last time to pick whoever isn't bad. Same thing if I'm bad (which I know I'm not, but I'm not writing this just for me).

If you are bad, we are only screwed if Rachel is a civ. If Rachel is bad you'll have to convince me or Phoebe to save her.

We could make a different poll with a different 3-2, but we would end with a whole different list of "we are screwed" scenarios. Yeah, the civs' situation in this game is atrocious. So we gotta get things absolutely right and it's gotta be now.

[Hugh Jass]

I'm doing my best to figure things out based on what I know of you guys but I don't want to think bad of any of you! No one has been poisoned since, if it was even poison, so Monica seems to have done all this for attention!

It's Day 4 Lylo and you are making reads based on Day 0 host post flavor.

How do you want me to believe you are actually playing the game of mafia at hand?

[Hugh Jass]

If Rachel is a civ she's throwing the game and we deserve to lose.

[Hugh Jass]

I'm sorry for being rude guys but I was asked to replace on a 3v2 lylo that had 5 pages and no baddie lynches.

This game is a disaster so if I even mean to win this, I might as well come throwing shit at everyone and making people unconfortable. I'm not sure if I have the magical scumhunting skills to flip this thing around, but I might as well try.

[Rachel Green]

The only thing I'm certain of is that one of Phoebe and Nora are bad for getting rid of Chuck! Monica didn't think it weird how they teamed up to vote him out after we had a night of peace and quiet.

[Phoebe Buffay]

The only thing I'm certain of is that one of Phoebe and Nora are bad for getting rid of Chuck! Monica didn't think it weird how they teamed up to vote him out after we had a night of peace and quiet.

I'm not bad, only stupid.

[Phoebe Buffay]

I'm sorry for being rude guys but I was asked to replace on a 3v2 lylo that had 5 pages and no baddie lynches.

This game is a disaster so if I even mean to win this, I might as well come throwing shit at everyone and making people unconfortable. I'm not sure if I have the magical scumhunting skills to flip this thing around, but I might as well try.

Ross, you are the savior we needed. *swoon*

[Rachel Green]

I'm doing my best to figure things out based on what I know of you guys but I don't want to think bad of any of you! No one has been poisoned since, if it was even poison, so Monica seems to have done all this for attention!

It's Day 4 Lylo and you are making reads based on Day 0 host post flavor.

How do you want me to believe you are actually playing the game of mafia at hand?

There's always a twist in murder mystery novels so my guess is as good as any, imposter Ross!

[Phoebe Buffay]

THanks, Pheebs.

Hope the wolves are not you and Nora all along, lol.

Definitely not. Nora though, I'm not so sure of.

[Phoebe Buffay]

I'm doing my best to figure things out based on what I know of you guys but I don't want to think bad of any of you! No one has been poisoned since, if it was even poison, so Monica seems to have done all this for attention!

Put that shovel down, Rachel. You're hole is deep enough. If you were actually good, I should hope you would have something better to defend yourself with.

[Rachel Green]

Gunther wanted to get rid of Nora or Ross before he got thrown out. Everyone also knows he would never vote me out. This is an effort by Nora/Ross to kill two birds with one stone by ousting my barista in fancy clothes, so they can vote me out!

[Phoebe Buffay]

Gunther wanted to get rid of Nora or Ross before he got thrown out. Everyone also knows he would never vote me out. This is an effort by Nora/Ross to kill two birds with one stone by ousting my barista in fancy clothes, so they can vote me out!

Perhaps Nora is your teammate then?

[Hugh Jass]

Gunther probably got killed because he looked civ. It's not like they had many different options.

I don't trust night kill analysis like this. Not everything is a deep conspiracy.

[Hugh Jass]

If Nora and Ross are bad then why are you voting for Monica?

What are your reads, Rachel? Who is civ and who is bad?

[Rachel Green]

The only thing I'm certain of is that one of Phoebe and Nora are bad for getting rid of Chuck! Monica didn't think it weird how they teamed up to vote him out after we had a night of peace and quiet.

I'm not bad, only stupid.

The culprits couldn't convince the police of him caring enough to frame him so they got rid of him for being a dick! Nora would vote him out no matter the situation so you come off worse here!

Maybe I should have stuck with firsties besties!

Vote : Phoebe

[Hugh Jass]

And in the post above you say you are sure it's one of Phoebe and Nora.

WTF?

[Hugh Jass]

Is it Phoebe and Nora, Ross and Nora, or Monica?

[Rachel Green]

Is it Phoebe and Nora, Ross and Nora, or Monica?

I don't have all the answers imposter Ross! I don't think the baddies would vote Richard out together, so only one of Nora and Phoebe. If Phoebe is bad we can look for clues as to who else is bad.

Who am I supposed to be doing these mean things with?

[Rachel Green]

Probably you in that case though, which is why Gunther is gone!

[Hugh Jass]

Probably you in that case though, which is why Gunther is gone!

So your theory is that the last 2 baddies are me and you.

Okay.

[Rachel Green]

Probably you in that case though, which is why Gunther is gone!

So your theory is that the last 2 baddies are me and you.

Okay.

You and Phoebe, why you got to be twisting things!

[Rachel Green]

The real Ross and I would be the greatest team but we'd never tear our friends group apart!

[Phoebe Buffay]

Probably you in that case though, which is why Gunther is gone!

So your theory is that the last 2 baddies are me and you.

Okay.

You and Phoebe, why you got to be twisting things!

I don't know what to think here. If Rachel were actually bad, why wouldn't she throw shade at Monica or Nora, who already look a bit sketchy (IMO). But she goes after me and Ross, who right now are super-towning and acting desperate to win this thing against the odds. Who is she trying to convince? Why not take the easier way out? This action makes Rachel look like either a not-so-smart bad guy, or a genuine good guy.

[Quokka]

Phoebe is my towniest read which means I've got one other friend between Monica, Ross and Rachel. There's also at least one baddie on the Rachel wagon right now. That's all I've got atm

[Quokka]

Probably you in that case though, which is why Gunther is gone!

So your theory is that the last 2 baddies are me and you.

Okay.

You and Phoebe, why you got to be twisting things!

I don't know what to think here. If Rachel were actually bad, why wouldn't she throw shade at Monica or Nora, who already look a bit sketchy (IMO). But she goes after me and Ross, who right now are super-towning and acting desperate to win this thing against the odds. Who is she trying to convince? Why not take the easier way out? This action makes Rachel look like either a not-so-smart bad guy, or a genuine good guy.

She's thrown shade at me though. She kinda looks like she's scrambling a lil

[Hugh Jass]

Regardless of Rachel's alignment it does seem like she is just trolling.

[Hugh Jass]

Where is Monica?

[Quokka]

How I picture Ross 2.0

[Rachel Green]

All alone here on Phoebe and she is at least being considerate towards me not being bad.

Vote : Monica

[nutellaphant]

Where is Monica?

Not everyone gets to make a fortune studying animals that don't exist anymore. Some of us have to do useful things, like feed people.

[nutellaphant]

Nora, what the hell?

[nutellaphant]

Like, I'm not saying this is a perfect tell, but there is a bar for "is actually trying to solve the game", and only you and Monica are currently clearing that bar.

Nora and Rachel aren't, but Nora at least is showing some sincere apathy. Rachel is hiding behind roleplaying, and when she's not she's making votes that don't actually look sincere.

That makes sense. We can lynch Rachel today, and if she flips scum, I recommend going after Monica tomorrow.

I can't recommend that recommendation.