Hogwarts Mafia - END

[MacDougall]

I don't trust the sorting hat tbh.

It just lets you go wherever you want if you ask it.

Yeah see. Shit hat.

[DharmaHelper]

We should lynch INH but we should also investigate the following leads:

1. Which assholes were trying to save LC in the lynch
2. Which assholes wanted to rezz INH because "Honka Tonka maybe INH was good wink wink"

[MacDougall]

Hey so why did the Mafia not kill Timmer?

[MacDougall]

We should lynch INH but we should also investigate the following leads:

1. Which assholes were trying to save LC in the lynch
2. Which assholes wanted to rezz INH because "Honka Tonka maybe INH was good wink wink"

Mate. As if I would have posted all that shit if I was going to just rezz him. I am obviously just a dumbass.

[DharmaHelper]

Also who is the Hufflepuff Death Eater.

[MacDougall]

Not to mention that given LC lynch was stopped saving him was rather unnecessary. So both your lines of thought are too basic.

Basic DH = scum?

[MacDougall]

Yep I am convinced DH is Mafia now. He is a veritable Peter fucking Pettigrew.

[DharmaHelper]

Not to mention that given LC lynch was stopped saving him was rather unnecessary. So both your lines of thought are too basic.

Basic DH = scum?

"I dont want this to sound like a No U but...."

Also fug-nugget, I built a case on LC because I'm scum why?

[MacDougall]

Not to mention that given LC lynch was stopped saving him was rather unnecessary. So both your lines of thought are too basic.

Basic DH = scum?

"I dont want this to sound like a No U but...."

Also fug-nugget, I built a case on LC because I'm scum why?

Because his lynch was bound to fail. So you could claim cred for it without needing to lynch him. Master plans.

All your premises in this game are way basic. You are being super basic. Constant basic bullshit

[DharmaHelper]

Yep I am convinced DH is Mafia now. He is a veritable Peter fucking Pettigrew.

I am and should be the single most town-read player in the game right now.

[MacDougall]

Since when do you ignore all the fun theories in favour of basic.

[MacDougall]

Yep I am convinced DH is Mafia now. He is a veritable Peter fucking Pettigrew.

I am and should be the single most town-read player in the game right now.

Only mafia aspire to be this.

[DharmaHelper]

Since when do you ignore all the fun theories in favour of basic.

I dunno.

[nutella]

Voted inh, hoping his team doesn't have another save handy.

[DharmaHelper]

Anyway tomorrow I'll find the last mafia you're welcome. Cash money.

[DharmaHelper]

Yep I am convinced DH is Mafia now. He is a veritable Peter fucking Pettigrew.

I am and should be the single most town-read player in the game right now.

Only mafia aspire to be this.

I don't mean to be rude but you should thank God for me every Night because I am the greatest mafia player of all time and without me there would be no sun or moon or stars to light your dark and perilous existence.

[Sloonei]

What are we supposed to do with a scum-firmed player in the game? Like do we lynch them again? Torture them to find who their teammates are? This has never happened to me before.

Lynch INH while ignoring everything he has to say and talking instead about everybody else in the game.

[nutella]

Anyway tomorrow I'll find the last mafia you're welcome. Cash money.

Last eh? Do you know how many there are?

[MacDougall]

So let's get this straight.

1. Multi wagon end of day.
2. Long Con lynched
3. Lynch failed
4. Outed vig not killed
5. Outed vig then does the obvious and kills near confirmed scum LC
6. Scum bring back another scum

And we are suspicious of people who tried to "save" LC? It seems like a convoluted plan to me. It is more rational to suspect those who drove the LC lynch initially in my opinion.

[Sloonei]

I’m going to reject off-hand the idea that each house has exactly one Death Eater or anything along such simplistic lines. Hosts don’t make games that easy. Not to say it couldn’t have happened by accident, but I’m not going to treat that as a rule. Unless of course it is a rule.

I haven’t read all the rules.

[MacDougall]

Anyway tomorrow I'll find the last mafia you're welcome. Cash money.

Last eh? Do you know how many there are?

[juliets]

I spent a lot of time during the night reading over nutella because I couldn't make up my mind about her. I found many of her thoughts matched what I thought about people (Mac and Jay excluded). Something I had noticed before that I noticed again is she come straight out about people she suspects and takes an assertive even aggressive tone. I don't think she would do that if she were bad. She also apologized for asking about the hallow because she thought that might have caused juliet 1's death. So, I am sorting her out of my POE. I will do a list today of who I've sorted out and who's still in.

a million linkis

[DharmaHelper]

Anyway tomorrow I'll find the last mafia you're welcome. Cash money.

Last eh? Do you know how many there are?

1 per house. I know I'm a genius but you guys aren't that dense.

[nutella]

Fwiw Mac moved up my rainbow a while ago. Not the strongest green but I don't actively suspect him anymore.

[DharmaHelper]

So let's get this straight.

1. Multi wagon end of day.
2. Long Con lynched
3. Lynch failed
4. Outed vig not killed
5. Outed vig then does the obvious and kills near confirmed scum LC
6. Scum bring back another scum

And we are suspicious of people who tried to "save" LC? It seems like a convoluted plan to me. It is more rational to suspect those who drove the LC lynch initially in my opinion.

What's convoluted about people trying to lynch someone other than their teammate

[DharmaHelper]

I’m going to reject off-hand the idea that each house has exactly one Death Eater or anything along such simplistic lines. Hosts don’t make games that easy. Not to say it couldn’t have happened by accident, but I’m not going to treat that as a rule. Unless of course it is a rule.

I haven’t read all the rules.

Says one of the more suspicious Hufflepuffs.

[MacDougall]

I don't think the LC lynch would have happened if the Mafia didn't want it to happen. It was tight enough to shenanigans it.

[Epignosis]

Hey, good news! I managed to catch up today!

[Sloonei]

I’m going to reject off-hand the idea that each house has exactly one Death Eater or anything along such simplistic lines. Hosts don’t make games that easy. Not to say it couldn’t have happened by accident, but I’m not going to treat that as a rule. Unless of course it is a rule.

I haven’t read all the rules.

Says one of the more suspicious Hufflepuffs.

Haven't you been paying attention? I town slipped 11 times.

[DharmaHelper]

INH - Gryffindor
Long Con - RavenClaw
Nova - Slytherin
??? - Hufflepuff

- Portrait: A talking portrait that can be used to block the entrance to a house. This will make it impossible for someone who doesn’t belong to their house to target them with any abilities during that cycle, unless it is a super-kill. 

I'm a god-tier mafia player but it doesn't take someone of my flawless brilliance to put together that, for balance reasons, each house has a mafia member.

[MacDougall]

So let's get this straight.

1. Multi wagon end of day.
2. Long Con lynched
3. Lynch failed
4. Outed vig not killed
5. Outed vig then does the obvious and kills near confirmed scum LC
6. Scum bring back another scum

And we are suspicious of people who tried to "save" LC? It seems like a convoluted plan to me. It is more rational to suspect those who drove the LC lynch initially in my opinion.

What's convoluted about people trying to lynch someone other than their teammate

Wow. Again with the basic!

Long Con was lynched and it didn't work. He was then "vigged" by Timmer who somehow wasn't killed in favour of Epi who wasn't even a threat. And to top it off a dead scum reappeared. This doesn't seem like a convoluted plan?

[MacDougall]

And DharmaHelper is here at dawn trying to mop up his town cred.

[Quin]

lol

[DharmaHelper]

We have three replacements. Everyone tell me about them.

Sloonei is town. Sprityo and speed2.0 haven't done anything yet. I have a reason to think that speed2.0's player slot is town. I don't have any reason to think sprityo is town.

Sloonei townslipped. Sprityo has said nothing. Speed 2.0 has suspicion of Glorf and nutella, which I think is pretty healthy. I see from his ISO that he is the one who already called out nutella's Player Salad post, and that puts him a little in the green, salad pun intended.

Oh look here's Long Con saying Sloonei townslipped lol thats fun.

[MacDougall]

No offence to Epi. I mean that he wasn't a threat because he has been busy and hardly contributing.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

INH - Gryffindor
Long Con - RavenClaw
Nova - Slytherin
??? - Hufflepuff

- Portrait: A talking portrait that can be used to block the entrance to a house. This will make it impossible for someone who doesn’t belong to their house to target them with any abilities during that cycle, unless it is a super-kill. 

That is absolutely not balanced.

I'm a god-tier mafia player but it doesn't take someone of my flawless brilliance to put together that, for balance reasons, each house has a mafia member.

[DharmaHelper]

So let's get this straight.

1. Multi wagon end of day.
2. Long Con lynched
3. Lynch failed
4. Outed vig not killed
5. Outed vig then does the obvious and kills near confirmed scum LC
6. Scum bring back another scum

And we are suspicious of people who tried to "save" LC? It seems like a convoluted plan to me. It is more rational to suspect those who drove the LC lynch initially in my opinion.

What's convoluted about people trying to lynch someone other than their teammate

Wow. Again with the basic!

Long Con was lynched and it didn't work. He was then "vigged" by Timmer who somehow wasn't killed in favour of Epi who wasn't even a threat. And to top it off a dead scum reappeared. This doesn't seem like a convoluted plan?

.....what's the plan there? You're just saying stuff that happened.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

That is absolutely not balanced.*

[DharmaHelper]

And DharmaHelper is here at dawn trying to mop up his town cred.

[Sloonei]

Speedchuck 2.0
Juliets2.0
Sloonei
poutanko

According to DharmaHelper one of these four people is definitely scum. Which one is it?

[DharmaHelper]

That is absolutely not balanced.*

What's not balanced about putting exactly one mafia member in each of the houses. that's...the definition of balanced....?

[Sloonei]

That is absolutely not balanced.*

What's not balanced about putting exactly one mafia member in each of the houses. that's...the definition of balanced....?

It allows town to just play the game as if checking off a list. It's not really scum hunting and it theoretically confirms ~4 people as town every time a single baddie is lynched.

[sprityo]

Why. would someone bring INH back to life?

[Quin]

That is absolutely not balanced.*

What's not balanced about putting exactly one mafia member in each of the houses. that's...the definition of balanced....?

kk so let's just lynch all the hufflepuff until we find 'em

sound balanced to you?

[Sloonei]

Why. would someone bring INH back to life?

Death Eaters had a resurrection, I assume.

[MacDougall]

Why is Epi dead and not Timmer?

[DharmaHelper]

That is absolutely not balanced.*

What's not balanced about putting exactly one mafia member in each of the houses. that's...the definition of balanced....?

It allows town to just play the game as if checking off a list. It's not really scum hunting and it theoretically confirms ~4 people as town every time a single baddie is lynched.

I dunno what to tell you fam. Each of the confirmed baddies are from a different house so the obvious answer is there is a baddie in Hufflepuff. Unless you're saying Hufflepuff is all town in which case Yun Qui my good sir.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

That is absolutely not balanced.*

What's not balanced about putting exactly one mafia member in each of the houses. that's...the definition of balanced....?

4 mafia members in a game of 24 players with full claiming and clearly vigilante(s) is the opposite of balanced. It’s also nonsense because your theory clears an entire house as soon as the mafioso dies.

There may be one in Hufflepuff because the randomizer said so. There has got to be more than just one more mafioso though.

[MacDougall]

So let's get this straight.

1. Multi wagon end of day.
2. Long Con lynched
3. Lynch failed
4. Outed vig not killed
5. Outed vig then does the obvious and kills near confirmed scum LC
6. Scum bring back another scum

And we are suspicious of people who tried to "save" LC? It seems like a convoluted plan to me. It is more rational to suspect those who drove the LC lynch initially in my opinion.

What's convoluted about people trying to lynch someone other than their teammate

Wow. Again with the basic!

Long Con was lynched and it didn't work. He was then "vigged" by Timmer who somehow wasn't killed in favour of Epi who wasn't even a threat. And to top it off a dead scum reappeared. This doesn't seem like a convoluted plan?

.....what's the plan there? You're just saying stuff that happened.

I don't need to be able to see the purpose of the scheme to see that one exists.

[speedchuck]

Hey so why did the Mafia not kill Timmer?

Real question is: Why did Timmer not kill Long Con?