Vault Hunt [Game Over]

[MacDougall]

This would be the order to lynch in imo.

jackofhearts2005
sabie12
Epignosis
muugen
Sloonei
sprityo
Neverwhere
novaselinever
Spacedaisy
nutella

[Sloonei]

[VOTE: Jackofhearts] aubergine

Why?

Oh the handful of players that I’ve interacted with directly, he seems the most full of poop. Plus he’s on Mac’s compatibility list.

He moved the goal posts on his shading of me in just a couple of posts, and it felt as though he was more concerned with painting me in a negative light than actually developing a read.

Is he on your compatibility list?

Who else is full of poop?

I don’t have such a list

I’ve interacted with like 4 people. Jack was the only one whose presence suggested poop to me.

[Neverwhere]

I was holding out to see if more players would check in and make their votes before I went to bed because we need that majority vote. Like I said in my other posts, I'm going to go on Mac with this one and see if he comes through.

Vote Jack of Hearts.

Why?

I've given my opinion on who I'm feeling slightly scummish on, I've also made it clear that I am interested in what Mac is saying. He's pretty convinved that he will be killed tonight for claiming a role, and I've liked what he's had to say today, if what he says doesn't happen tonight then he's outed himself and we lynch him tomorrow.

I don't think you're understanding Mac's info correctly. Mac has no info on Jack, nor Sabie. He has info on Luna being a Witch, so I'm not sure why would you justify your vote as trusting his info and what he's saying.

Linki - Lol

I'm in a different timezone, so I am running out of time for a vote. It's almost midnight here, so I need to vote now. Out of the two players who seemed to be getting votes, Jack and Sabie, I picked Jack because I'm not totally sure about Sabies guilt and I was suspicious of a few people choosing to vote for her. Since we need a majority, Jack made the most sense. It wouldn't make sense for me to put one vote on someone else and fuck up the majority. Unfortunately, I can't be more helpful than that because my sleep is more important.

[novaselinenever]

[VOTE: Jackofhearts] aubergine

Why?

Oh the handful of players that I’ve interacted with directly, he seems the most full of poop. Plus he’s on Mac’s compatibility list.

He moved the goal posts on his shading of me in just a couple of posts, and it felt as though he was more concerned with painting me in a negative light than actually developing a read.

Is he on your compatibility list?

Who else is full of poop?

I don’t have such a list

I’ve interacted with like 4 people. Jack was the only one whose presence suggested poop to me.

"The most full of poop" implies a presence of poop elsewhere.

[novaselinenever]

I was holding out to see if more players would check in and make their votes before I went to bed because we need that majority vote. Like I said in my other posts, I'm going to go on Mac with this one and see if he comes through.

Vote Jack of Hearts.

Why?

I've given my opinion on who I'm feeling slightly scummish on, I've also made it clear that I am interested in what Mac is saying. He's pretty convinved that he will be killed tonight for claiming a role, and I've liked what he's had to say today, if what he says doesn't happen tonight then he's outed himself and we lynch him tomorrow.

I don't think you're understanding Mac's info correctly. Mac has no info on Jack, nor Sabie. He has info on Luna being a Witch, so I'm not sure why would you justify your vote as trusting his info and what he's saying.

Linki - Lol

I'm in a different timezone, so I am running out of time for a vote. It's almost midnight here, so I need to vote now. Out of the two players who seemed to be getting votes, Jack and Sabie, I picked Jack because I'm not totally sure about Sabies guilt and I was suspicious of a few people choosing to vote for her. Since we need a majority, Jack made the most sense. It wouldn't make sense for me to put one vote on someone else and fuck up the majority. Unfortunately, I can't be more helpful than that because my sleep is more important.

What makes you hesitant about Sabies guilt?

[novaselinenever]

We'll need 1 vote on one of them for me to hammer btw. Just me voting puts them as 5.

[Sloonei]

I do not deny the possibility of poop in Neverwhere’s responses to me, for example, but at the same time I am not ready to allege poop against them. I would merely suggest its possibility. I allege poop against Jack.

[Neverwhere]

I was holding out to see if more players would check in and make their votes before I went to bed because we need that majority vote. Like I said in my other posts, I'm going to go on Mac with this one and see if he comes through.

Vote Jack of Hearts.

Why?

I've given my opinion on who I'm feeling slightly scummish on, I've also made it clear that I am interested in what Mac is saying. He's pretty convinved that he will be killed tonight for claiming a role, and I've liked what he's had to say today, if what he says doesn't happen tonight then he's outed himself and we lynch him tomorrow.

I don't think you're understanding Mac's info correctly. Mac has no info on Jack, nor Sabie. He has info on Luna being a Witch, so I'm not sure why would you justify your vote as trusting his info and what he's saying.

Linki - Lol

I'm in a different timezone, so I am running out of time for a vote. It's almost midnight here, so I need to vote now. Out of the two players who seemed to be getting votes, Jack and Sabie, I picked Jack because I'm not totally sure about Sabies guilt and I was suspicious of a few people choosing to vote for her. Since we need a majority, Jack made the most sense. It wouldn't make sense for me to put one vote on someone else and fuck up the majority. Unfortunately, I can't be more helpful than that because my sleep is more important.

What makes you hesitant about Sabies guilt?

Honestly, Sabie has posted very little, so there's not much to go on. She's just had it out from Mac, which I'm not 100% sure I get seeing as it' pretty much the start of the game and there has been so little to go on. He/she hasn't even mentioned anyone else, scum or otherwise.

Doing another read, I suppose the only other thing Sabie did do is try to lead us away from Luna yesterday, and I suppose Mac was being difficult, so he was an easy target. Damn it, now I've confused myself again. I've actually talked myself into Sabie being scum, which means I need to re-evaluate other people as that was the only reason I didn't put a vote there.

Curse you, I shall never sleep. >.<

[Neverwhere]

Re-reading both sabie and jacks posts, I'm changing my vote to sabie purely based on if luna was scum, sabie tried to steer us away while jack did mentioned her as possible scum once. Also sabie not posting much could be mafia skating.

[novaselinenever]

I'll hammer Sabie I believe unless we can get 4 on Jack

[Sloonei]

Doesn’t it take 6 to hammer today?

[novaselinenever]

I have 2 votes.

[Sloonei]

Just realized the deadline is upon us so I switched to sabie to facilitate a lynch.

[Sloonei]

I have 2 votes.

Well whatever!

[novaselinenever]

2 straight days and Spacedaisy hasn't voted. Unfortunate or...

[Spacedaisy]

Fuuuuuuuuuuuuu

[Sloonei]

2 straight days and Spacedaisy hasn't voted. Unfortunate or...

I would expect timid voting patterns to be less likely as a scum tell in this game compared to standard setups.

[novaselinenever]

2 straight days and Spacedaisy hasn't voted. Unfortunate or...

I would expect timid voting patterns to be less likely as a scum tell in this game compared to standard setups.

Basically everything should be thrown out of the window for this setup

[Spacedaisy]

I looked up at the clock and realized I did it again. He worst part is I wasn’t even doing a damn thing!

[novaselinenever]

Except those awkward in thread exchanges "Oh we're definitely not a private chat together *evil laugh*"

[Spacedaisy]

Except those awkward in thread exchanges "Oh we're definitely not a private chat together *evil laugh*"

What is this in reference to?

[novaselinenever]

Except those awkward in thread exchanges "Oh we're definitely not a private chat together *evil laugh*"

What is this in reference to?

What do you mean?

[Epignosis]

WHO WAS THE SKAGSACK THAT SENT JULIETS TO THE RESPAWN STATION?

Poll ended at Sat Apr 13, 2019 7:10 pmPlease note that if you vote, your vote will be visible.

Epignosis
0
No votes


Voters: None

jackofhearts2005
1
8%


Voters: MacDougall

Macdougall
1
8%


Voters: muugen

Sloonei
0
No votes


Voters: None

muugen
0
No votes


Voters: None

Neverwhere
0
No votes


Voters: None

novaselinever
0
No votes


Voters: None

nutella
0
No votes


Voters: None

sabie12
6
50%


Voters: novaselinenever, Epignosis, sprityo, Sloonei, Neverwhere, nutella

sprityo
0
No votes


Voters: None

Spacedaisy
0
No votes


Voters: None

Professor Nakayama!! (Host/Mod/NP)
4
33%


Voters: leetic, JaggedJimmyJay, speedchuck, juliets


Total votes: 12

[novaselinenever]

Sloonei, is reading back on D1 something you see yourself doing down the line?

[Neverwhere]

Oh. The poll end time showed up in my time zone. I assume it was US time and that this would be going on till 5 am my time. That is nice to know.

[Sloonei]

Sloonei, is reading back on D1 something you see yourself doing down the line?

Unlikely. I’ll likely piece things together if I stick around long enough though.

[Spacedaisy]

Except those awkward in thread exchanges "Oh we're definitely not a private chat together *evil laugh*"

What is this in reference to?

What do you mean?

I don’t know a more straightforward way to ask that question.

The post I quoted, what were you talking about?

[Sloonei]

Oh. The poll end time showed up in my time zone. I assume it was US time and that this would be going on till 5 am my time. That is nice to know.

You can correct this in the User Control Panel so that the site displays your desired timezone.

[Neverwhere]

Oh. The poll end time showed up in my time zone. I assume it was US time and that this would be going on till 5 am my time. That is nice to know.

You can correct this in the User Control Panel so that the site displays your desired timezone.

Yeah, I know. I meant that I thought I hadn't set this up, so when the poll said it was closing at 12.10 am I assumed it would be 5.10 am my time. I just wanted to clarify, as all of my recent posts were talking about me needing to get my vote in quickly before bed and not being able to see how it all unfolded at the end with possible last minute changes etc. I assumed I would be asleep.

[speedchuck]

NIGHT TWO

Sabie rolled for defense~!



Oh.

Uh.

Sabie was lynched!

NIGHT TWO HAS BEGUN, AND WILL LAST FOR 23-ish HOURS.

CERTAIN NIGHT ACTIONS DEPEND ON OTHER NIGHT ACTIONS, SO YOU NEED TO GET YOUR NIGHT ACTIONS LOCKED IN AS SOON AS POSSIBLE. THANKS.

[novaselinenever]

Except those awkward in thread exchanges "Oh we're definitely not a private chat together *evil laugh*"

What is this in reference to?

What do you mean?

I don’t know a more straightforward way to ask that question.

The post I quoted, what were you talking about?

The no flip making most indicators obsolete.

[novaselinenever]

Another witch down, good job guys

[Epignosis]

I was holding out to see if more players would check in and make their votes before I went to bed because we need that majority vote. Like I said in my other posts, I'm going to go on Mac with this one and see if he comes through.

Vote Jack of Hearts.

Why?

I've given my opinion on who I'm feeling slightly scummish on, I've also made it clear that I am interested in what Mac is saying. He's pretty convinved that he will be killed tonight for claiming a role, and I've liked what he's had to say today, if what he says doesn't happen tonight then he's outed himself and we lynch him tomorrow.

I don't think you're understanding Mac's info correctly. Mac has no info on Jack, nor Sabie. He has info on Luna being a Witch, so I'm not sure why would you justify your vote as trusting his info and what he's saying.

Linki - Lol

I'm in a different timezone, so I am running out of time for a vote. It's almost midnight here, so I need to vote now. Out of the two players who seemed to be getting votes, Jack and Sabie, I picked Jack because I'm not totally sure about Sabies guilt and I was suspicious of a few people choosing to vote for her. Since we need a majority, Jack made the most sense. It wouldn't make sense for me to put one vote on someone else and fuck up the majority. Unfortunately, I can't be more helpful than that because my sleep is more important.

This doesn't make a damn lick of sense. sabie had four votes and Jack one or none when I looked.

[Epignosis]

I was holding out to see if more players would check in and make their votes before I went to bed because we need that majority vote. Like I said in my other posts, I'm going to go on Mac with this one and see if he comes through.

Vote Jack of Hearts.

Why?

I've given my opinion on who I'm feeling slightly scummish on, I've also made it clear that I am interested in what Mac is saying. He's pretty convinved that he will be killed tonight for claiming a role, and I've liked what he's had to say today, if what he says doesn't happen tonight then he's outed himself and we lynch him tomorrow.

I don't think you're understanding Mac's info correctly. Mac has no info on Jack, nor Sabie. He has info on Luna being a Witch, so I'm not sure why would you justify your vote as trusting his info and what he's saying.

Linki - Lol

I'm in a different timezone, so I am running out of time for a vote. It's almost midnight here, so I need to vote now. Out of the two players who seemed to be getting votes, Jack and Sabie, I picked Jack because I'm not totally sure about Sabies guilt and I was suspicious of a few people choosing to vote for her. Since we need a majority, Jack made the most sense. It wouldn't make sense for me to put one vote on someone else and fuck up the majority. Unfortunately, I can't be more helpful than that because my sleep is more important.

What makes you hesitant about Sabies guilt?

Honestly, Sabie has posted very little, so there's not much to go on. She's just had it out from Mac, which I'm not 100% sure I get seeing as it' pretty much the start of the game and there has been so little to go on. He/she hasn't even mentioned anyone else, scum or otherwise.

Doing another read, I suppose the only other thing Sabie did do is try to lead us away from Luna yesterday, and I suppose Mac was being difficult, so he was an easy target. Damn it, now I've confused myself again. I've actually talked myself into Sabie being scum, which means I need to re-evaluate other people as that was the only reason I didn't put a vote there.

Curse you, I shall never sleep. >.<

You talked yourself into nothing. You are her teammate.

[novaselinenever]

Why?

I've given my opinion on who I'm feeling slightly scummish on, I've also made it clear that I am interested in what Mac is saying. He's pretty convinved that he will be killed tonight for claiming a role, and I've liked what he's had to say today, if what he says doesn't happen tonight then he's outed himself and we lynch him tomorrow.

I don't think you're understanding Mac's info correctly. Mac has no info on Jack, nor Sabie. He has info on Luna being a Witch, so I'm not sure why would you justify your vote as trusting his info and what he's saying.

Linki - Lol

I'm in a different timezone, so I am running out of time for a vote. It's almost midnight here, so I need to vote now. Out of the two players who seemed to be getting votes, Jack and Sabie, I picked Jack because I'm not totally sure about Sabies guilt and I was suspicious of a few people choosing to vote for her. Since we need a majority, Jack made the most sense. It wouldn't make sense for me to put one vote on someone else and fuck up the majority. Unfortunately, I can't be more helpful than that because my sleep is more important.

What makes you hesitant about Sabies guilt?

Honestly, Sabie has posted very little, so there's not much to go on. She's just had it out from Mac, which I'm not 100% sure I get seeing as it' pretty much the start of the game and there has been so little to go on. He/she hasn't even mentioned anyone else, scum or otherwise.

Doing another read, I suppose the only other thing Sabie did do is try to lead us away from Luna yesterday, and I suppose Mac was being difficult, so he was an easy target. Damn it, now I've confused myself again. I've actually talked myself into Sabie being scum, which means I need to re-evaluate other people as that was the only reason I didn't put a vote there.

Curse you, I shall never sleep. >.<

You talked yourself into nothing. You are her teammate.

Sprit and Epi are front-runners for scum compatibility with a potential witch Luna.

Explain why you think this?

In her iso reads post, the Sprit read is extremely tame when she has ammunition to fake a scum read there and dig on him. She isn't taking a stance there and just narrating what he has said so far. He was also present during d1 and I don't think he commented on the suspicions on her and the wagon (she was a popular scum read). He avoided it unless I'm remembering wrong.

Epi had a little interaction with her that stroke me as contrived. Same as her calling him lazy and her read on him, and that's actually what led to the interaction. He seemed to shade her for it and he ended up calling her a witch for one of her posts in my interaction with her. He ended up voting Mac.

There are no flips in this game.

I repeat, there are no flips in this game.

Let you think on how my strategy as a witch would change knowing that.

[novaselinenever]

I was holding out to see if more players would check in and make their votes before I went to bed because we need that majority vote. Like I said in my other posts, I'm going to go on Mac with this one and see if he comes through.

Vote Jack of Hearts.

Why?

I've given my opinion on who I'm feeling slightly scummish on, I've also made it clear that I am interested in what Mac is saying. He's pretty convinved that he will be killed tonight for claiming a role, and I've liked what he's had to say today, if what he says doesn't happen tonight then he's outed himself and we lynch him tomorrow.

I don't think you're understanding Mac's info correctly. Mac has no info on Jack, nor Sabie. He has info on Luna being a Witch, so I'm not sure why would you justify your vote as trusting his info and what he's saying.

Linki - Lol

I'm in a different timezone, so I am running out of time for a vote. It's almost midnight here, so I need to vote now. Out of the two players who seemed to be getting votes, Jack and Sabie, I picked Jack because I'm not totally sure about Sabies guilt and I was suspicious of a few people choosing to vote for her. Since we need a majority, Jack made the most sense. It wouldn't make sense for me to put one vote on someone else and fuck up the majority. Unfortunately, I can't be more helpful than that because my sleep is more important.

This doesn't make a damn lick of sense. sabie had four votes and Jack one or none when I looked.

It was 3 for Sabie against 2 for Jack, I believe.

[Neverwhere]

My initial vote for jack made it 3-3.

Also, epi, if i were scum i wouldnt have posted all that reasoning. it would draw unnecessary attention to me. Up unitl that point I had people either ignoring me entirely or saying they had me as a town read.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Choosing to be unhelpful at this juncture is a very bad look.

I don’t know what you’re going through and I’ve put minimal thought into this game or its setup. Do what you think is best. You don’t need my input.

I asked for it though. I perceive it as a critical moment for the civilian win con and want a discussion.

Or we can trust you and lynch your suspect without having you claim. That you’re prepared to claim at all might be enough for me.

What's stopping a witch from fake-claiming an info? No flips, counter-claim get soup-killed.

I'll trade one townie for one wolf all day every day.

Optimistic.

If there is a counter claim, one is a wolf. That’s not optimistic. It’s a fact.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Looks like I was almost lynched while out catching bagons.

[Epignosis]

Folks, I'm just doing things.

[Jackofhearts2005]

[novaselinenever]

I don’t know what you’re going through and I’ve put minimal thought into this game or its setup. Do what you think is best. You don’t need my input.

I asked for it though. I perceive it as a critical moment for the civilian win con and want a discussion.

Or we can trust you and lynch your suspect without having you claim. That you’re prepared to claim at all might be enough for me.

What's stopping a witch from fake-claiming an info? No flips, counter-claim get soup-killed.

I'll trade one townie for one wolf all day every day.

Optimistic.

If there is a counter claim, one is a wolf. That’s not optimistic. It’s a fact.

That's if there is one. There might no be one with the night kills being janitored. And even if there is one, there are so many variables due to the no flip that makes not a 1-1 trade.

Labelling witches incentives for fake claims as something one would take every day (twice on sunday? ) is optimistic.

[novaselinenever]

Folks, I'm just doing things.

We all are. We got 2 witches already

[Jackofhearts2005]

I asked for it though. I perceive it as a critical moment for the civilian win con and want a discussion.

Or we can trust you and lynch your suspect without having you claim. That you’re prepared to claim at all might be enough for me.

What's stopping a witch from fake-claiming an info? No flips, counter-claim get soup-killed.

I'll trade one townie for one wolf all day every day.

Optimistic.

If there is a counter claim, one is a wolf. That’s not optimistic. It’s a fact.

That's if there is one. There might no be one with the night kills being janitored. And even if there is one, there are so many variables due to the no flip that makes not a 1-1 trade.

Labelling witches incentives for fake claims as something one would take every day (twice on sunday? ) is optimistic.

You put forth a hypothetical where a counterclaim got soupkilled.

[novaselinenever]

Or we can trust you and lynch your suspect without having you claim. That you’re prepared to claim at all might be enough for me.

What's stopping a witch from fake-claiming an info? No flips, counter-claim get soup-killed.

I'll trade one townie for one wolf all day every day.

Optimistic.

If there is a counter claim, one is a wolf. That’s not optimistic. It’s a fact.

That's if there is one. There might no be one with the night kills being janitored. And even if there is one, there are so many variables due to the no flip that makes not a 1-1 trade.

Labelling witches incentives for fake claims as something one would take every day (twice on sunday? ) is optimistic.

You put forth a hypothetical where a counterclaim got soupkilled.

It's preceded by "no flips", which is basically the main thing that the game revolves around.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Those fingers are aimed at Nova and Mac but in a loving way.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Another witch down, good job guys

So I just need to find the last wolf tomorrow and this will end. Awesome.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Ya’ll won’t believe this but it’s the honest to mod truth. I was replying to a Sabie post when my wife texted me about community day starting (I was on babysit sick kid duty while she was with our 4 year old at a birthday party). I was like “I’ll finish this later” and didn’t come back until after Sabie was dead. Don’t worry though [mention]sabie12[/mention], it doesn’t matter now anyway. Cause you’re dead.

[Jackofhearts2005]

I will put info in here in 5 minutes unless I hear a good reason why I shouldn't.

Soup?

You say “Idk, Mac” several times but you also said “Don’t do it, Mac” here.

It’s not about knowing the setup. It’s about having a position that I disagree with and then walking it back and shrugging instead of supporting it.

He specifically asked for arguments to the contrary. Does “Soup?” strike you as an impassioned argument?

You are technically correct and I’ll allow it because I feel for that point of view even if it felt bad in the context of my initial read.

[Sloonei]

Looks like I was almost lynched while out catching bagons.

Jack is Nazgul, confirmed