[Game Over] Better Off Ted

[Creature]

what is creatures like normally? in normal games

Dunno, has someone played with me before on one of the other two communities I regularly play on? It's quite a travel...

Would that affect how your current interactions are being viewed?

Would drastically affect the way you see my playstyle here atleast.

[Creature]

also alphabetical order looks like a mafia tell.

Question - is this really a thing? Putting a list in alphabetical order is a Mafia Tell?

I usually do that because I fear players would try to read my order if it's non-alphabetical.

Why does if a list is alphabetical or not play any part on if someone is a civvie or baddie?

I find alphabetical lists more likely to come from mafia considering it gives less to read on after they flip mafia. While non-alphabetical lists are more likely to come from town as they have one order of strength or something.

[Creature]

I think either one of them could be bad

We're both town

[Epignosis]

my reasoning is that he seems anxious, he made posts about how there's been nothing going on and how it's bothered him but hasn't made much personal effort to stir discussion up himself. he's made offhand comments but no running comments until basically an hour ago. that's not to say he's the only one in that boat but he sticks out to me because of that/ it seems disingenuous.

Damn, I think this community is primitive if this would be treated as an actual case.

And here I was thinking I would share my Honey Roasted Cave Bear with everyone. None for you!

No thanks. I've heard bear meat is quite oily.

I've had bear sausage and it was quite delicious.

[Creature]

MacDougall, sabie12, Sokoth, maybe indiglo if we decide to follow Epi.

Am fine doing any of these.

[Epignosis]

FWIW I do feel like Creature has contributed a lot without contributing a lot. Looks just like a lot of fluff to me.

Oh right, I forgot pointing out Sokoth's jumpy reaction is fluff.

Who's a fluffer?

[Kylemii]

I think either one of them could be bad

We're both town

can you expand on why you think i'm town

[Epignosis]

my reasoning is that he seems anxious, he made posts about how there's been nothing going on and how it's bothered him but hasn't made much personal effort to stir discussion up himself. he's made offhand comments but no running comments until basically an hour ago. that's not to say he's the only one in that boat but he sticks out to me because of that/ it seems disingenuous.

Damn, I think this community is primitive if this would be treated as an actual case.

And here I was thinking I would share my Honey Roasted Cave Bear with everyone. None for you!

No thanks. I've heard bear meat is quite oily.

I've had bear sausage and it was quite delicious.

FWIW I do feel like Creature has contributed a lot without contributing a lot. Looks just like a lot of fluff to me.

Oh right, I forgot pointing out Sokoth's jumpy reaction is fluff.

Who's a fluffer?

I hope to God nobody notices the juxtaposition of these two posts.

[Creature]

I think either one of them could be bad

We're both town

can you expand on why you think i'm town

I don't think you would come up with that as mafia.

[sabie12]

I think either one of them could be bad

We're both town

See that's a weird thing to say unless you're townie teammates or something how would you know you're both town? Unless you're both bad and kyle is distancing from you.

[Creature]

how would you know you're both town?

[birdwithteeth11]

Just that kyle seemed so sure creature is bad and took awhile to explain where that thought came from. And creature thinks kyle is some other person. It was weird. Also hi LC! People actually do call me sabbz haha.

Idk maybe kyle is just trying to put pressure on creature and get some conversation going

Still waiting on an actual response here and not just going with the flow.

did you want a response from me or sabie

Sorry, I meant sabie. Should have clarified that better.

[sabie12]

Just that kyle seemed so sure creature is bad and took awhile to explain where that thought came from. And creature thinks kyle is some other person. It was weird. Also hi LC! People actually do call me sabbz haha.

Idk maybe kyle is just trying to put pressure on creature and get some conversation going

Still waiting on an actual response here and not just going with the flow.

did you want a response from me or sabie

Sorry, I meant sabie. Should have clarified that better.

Did my clarification suffice or were you looking for more information?

[birdwithteeth11]

my reasoning is that he seems anxious, he made posts about how there's been nothing going on and how it's bothered him but hasn't made much personal effort to stir discussion up himself. he's made offhand comments but no running comments until basically an hour ago. that's not to say he's the only one in that boat but he sticks out to me because of that/ it seems disingenuous.

Damn, I think this community is primitive if this would be treated as an actual case.

And here I was thinking I would share my Honey Roasted Cave Bear with everyone. None for you!

No thanks. I've heard bear meat is quite oily.

I've had bear sausage and it was quite delicious.

I'm really curious now what you're planning on cooking for us in July.

[nutella]

Ok I don't care about most of these arguments (seriously what is the big deal with putting names in alphabetical order if you feel equally about them??) And everyone who's actively arguing feels townish to me rn so I'm joining epi on [VOTE: indiglo] aubergine. Sorry I don't have more time to get involved, I didn't expect this game to blow up so much and I didn't realize when the phase was ending.

[birdwithteeth11]

MacDougall, sabie12, Sokoth, maybe indiglo if we decide to follow Epi.

Am fine doing any of these.

I would be fine with sabie12 or indiglo. Why Sokoth or MacDougall though?

[SokothQultuq]

MacDougall, sabie12, Sokoth, maybe indiglo if we decide to follow Epi.

Am fine doing any of these.

Love the misdirection you did there Creature. You get accused and voted. I jump in to try and clarify why, someone has a good enough reason to make me doubt that they are the bad guy and present somewhat of a case, it comes full circle to you now, so you just dump that off on me now. Very nice. LOL

[Creature]

MacDougall, sabie12, Sokoth, maybe indiglo if we decide to follow Epi.

Am fine doing any of these.

I would be fine with sabie12 or indiglo. Why Sokoth or MacDougall though?

MacDougall's way of getting reads seem to come more likely from mafia.

Sokoth seemed opportunistic earlier and now seems to be avoiding the thread.

[birdwithteeth11]

I think either one of them could be bad

We're both town

See that's a weird thing to say unless you're townie teammates or something how would you know you're both town? Unless you're both bad and kyle is distancing from you.

Why would a baddie teammate need to distance from a teammate on Day 1? That feels awfully forced.

[Creature]

I hope sabie12 doesn't genuinely think I claimed info that Kyle is town.

[birdwithteeth11]

MacDougall, sabie12, Sokoth, maybe indiglo if we decide to follow Epi.

Am fine doing any of these.

Love the misdirection you did there Creature. You get accused and voted. I jump in to try and clarify why, someone has a good enough reason to make me doubt that they are the bad guy and present somewhat of a case, it comes full circle to you now, so you just dump that off on me now. Very nice. LOL

Now that he's come back and responded a bit more, I don't think so. Unless teammates distancing on Day 1 is somehow a common occurrence in mafia now, I think kyle and creature are both civs at this point.

A response like this on the other hand feels like someone attempting to misdirect a non-misdirection.

[Spacedaisy]

@Spacedaisy the poll doesn't appear to have an end time ((

Awe shit. 6pm EST was my goal y'all so we're closing this puppy down in 15 minutes to stay close to that.

[birdwithteeth11]

Just that kyle seemed so sure creature is bad and took awhile to explain where that thought came from. And creature thinks kyle is some other person. It was weird. Also hi LC! People actually do call me sabbz haha.

Idk maybe kyle is just trying to put pressure on creature and get some conversation going

Still waiting on an actual response here and not just going with the flow.

did you want a response from me or sabie

Sorry, I meant sabie. Should have clarified that better.

Did my clarification suffice or were you looking for more information?

It sufficed in a way. I'm currently between you, Sokoth, or Indiglo for a vote today.

[birdwithteeth11]

@Spacedaisy the poll doesn't appear to have an end time ((

Awe shit. 6pm EST was my goal y'all so we're closing this puppy down in 15 minutes to stay close to that.

Aw crap. Need to decide pretty soon then...

[birdwithteeth11]

I hope sabie12 doesn't genuinely think I claimed info that Kyle is town.

I don't think she is. But her facepalm-inducing reaction came off as someone trying to make a whole lot out of nothing. Same with Sokoth tbh.

[Creature]

Okay, I'll feel bad if I'm wrong on Sokoth because I think he justified that jump on Kyle and it could still come from town anyway, but he still seems meh to me.

[sabie12]

I understand the suspicion on indigo as their only post said they were going to read things carefully and then they haven't been here since.

[Spacedaisy]

I'm guessing the poll closes at 7:18pm EST.

Bound to be a lot of missing votes, which isn't good.

Let's go with this to give everyone time since I messed up the poll end. And I'll get it back on track wth the night post.

[Kylemii]

I think either one of them could be bad

We're both town

can you expand on why you think i'm town

I don't think you would come up with that as mafia.

but we just met. we don't know each other at all yet.

was there any point where you thought i might be mafia trying to fuck someone over for effort credit or whatever

[SokothQultuq]

So I've got nothing to go on for Indi and not enough time to read into that, but I'll be looking into Indi for next round.
Kyle - Following the conversation which I originally was concerned with made a case and then caused creature to react and build a case against himself in my opinion.
Creature on the other hand has been all over the place, I feel like he's been misdirecting now once the pressure shifted to him. He's back on his heels trying to save face in my opinion. Even went as far as to throw me under the buss after trying to essentially defend his position.
Since I have no one that really stands out to me at this time other than Creature.

[VOTE: VOTE: Creature] aubergine

[Creature]

I think either one of them could be bad

We're both town

can you expand on why you think i'm town

I don't think you would come up with that as mafia.

but we just met. we don't know each other at all yet.

I don't know anyone in this site tbh (save a few I must've played outside), but I still should try to read them somehow.

[birdwithteeth11]

Okay, I'll feel bad if I'm wrong on Sokoth because I think he justified that jump on Kyle and it could still come from town anyway, but he still seems meh to me.

So would you say he's more on the neutral side or on the potentially bad side? Because I'm still leaning the second one.

I think my vote is going to either to him or sadie at this point.

[sabie12]

I hope sabie12 doesn't genuinely think I claimed info that Kyle is town.

I don't think she is. But her facepalm-inducing reaction came off as someone trying to make a whole lot out of nothing. Same with Sokoth tbh.

No I just thought it was a weird way of saying things. Saying we're both town. Idk maybe that's what people say to say I have a town read on someone while also defending yourself and I've just never seen that before.

I'm willing to vote creature or indiglo.

[Creature]

Even went as far as to throw me under the buss

You know that assumes we're both mafia, right?

[Creature]

I hope sabie12 doesn't genuinely think I claimed info that Kyle is town.

I don't think she is. But her facepalm-inducing reaction came off as someone trying to make a whole lot out of nothing. Same with Sokoth tbh.

No I just thought it was a weird way of saying things. Saying we're both town. Idk maybe that's what people say to say I have a town read on someone while also defending yourself and I've just never seen that before.

Welcome to the higher tier of mafia players.

[Kylemii]

I think either one of them could be bad

We're both town

can you expand on why you think i'm town

I don't think you would come up with that as mafia.

but we just met. we don't know each other at all yet.

I don't know anyone in this site tbh (save a few I must've played outside), but I still should try to read them somehow.

but why assume i don't have lascivious intent

[Kylemii]

i guess maybe i should google words before i say them sometimes

[Creature]

I think either one of them could be bad

We're both town

can you expand on why you think i'm town

I don't think you would come up with that as mafia.

but we just met. we don't know each other at all yet.

I don't know anyone in this site tbh (save a few I must've played outside), but I still should try to read them somehow.

but why assume i don't have lascivious intent

There's always the offchance, but rn I'm heavily inclined to consider you town, specially considering plenty of sketchy players jumped on that.

[birdwithteeth11]

i guess maybe i should google words before i say them sometimes

[Creature]

Okay, I'll feel bad if I'm wrong on Sokoth because I think he justified that jump on Kyle and it could still come from town anyway, but he still seems meh to me.

So would you say he's more on the neutral side or on the potentially bad side? Because I'm still leaning the second one.

I think my vote is going to either to him or sadie at this point.

Considering he OMGUSed me, I wouldn't mind him dying.

[MacDougall]

I thought maybe Mac's thinking was that scum would be more likely to read the rules thoroughly and to want to be careful to avoid the extra vote thing. And I say this as a civilian who read the rules thoroughly but also I just voted early enough that it didn't matter lol.

Yeah

[Creature]

Do we have less than an hour?

[juliets]

Epi, I'm not sure what that second post is talking about - looks like it may be from the sign-up thread - but I take it this is your answer as to why you are voting Indi. For the dense among us (maybe thats just me) can you tell us why that post is vote-worthy? Or are you joking and it's really that she never came back and posted again?

Checking in, but very quickly. Welcome to all the new folks, and hello again to all the familiar faces!

I originally voted "Space" because it's clearly the best option, but after reading Daisy's post, I have changed to "Cars" because it needs more votes. I would encourage the extra "Space" voters to also change. Unless you really want your cubicle decorated with extra votes during Day 1. It looks like we're going to have to read Daisy's posts very carefully in this game!

Voting indiglo.

Can't tell if because of no-show or something else.

What the hell. I know nothing of this but I can kick all y'alls asses so hard you'd better get off my boy Ted.

so tempted to kick your ass.

I'm kicking it right now.

[SokothQultuq]

More time is good. I was going to step out now, but let me go back and look at Indi since we have a bit more time then.

[Kylemii]

There's always the offchance, but rn I'm heavily inclined to consider you town, specially considering plenty of sketchy players jumped on that.

alright, thank you for your patience and understanding

who do you think was the most opportunistic in the humping

[Kylemii]

JUMPING

[juliets]

Do we have less than an hour?

yes

[Epignosis]

Epi, I'm not sure what that second post is talking about - looks like it may be from the sign-up thread - but I take it this is your answer as to why you are voting Indi. For the dense among us (maybe thats just me) can you tell us why that post is vote-worthy? Or are you joking and it's really that she never came back and posted again?

Checking in, but very quickly. Welcome to all the new folks, and hello again to all the familiar faces!

I originally voted "Space" because it's clearly the best option, but after reading Daisy's post, I have changed to "Cars" because it needs more votes. I would encourage the extra "Space" voters to also change. Unless you really want your cubicle decorated with extra votes during Day 1. It looks like we're going to have to read Daisy's posts very carefully in this game!

Voting indiglo.

Can't tell if because of no-show or something else.

What the hell. I know nothing of this but I can kick all y'alls asses so hard you'd better get off my boy Ted.

so tempted to kick your ass.

I'm kicking it right now.

It isn't vote-worthy. It's a vote to have a vote up there and it's on someone who has one post.

[birdwithteeth11]

Do we have less than an hour?

About 50 minutes.

[Creature]

There's always the offchance, but rn I'm heavily inclined to consider you town, specially considering plenty of sketchy players jumped on that.

alright, thank you for your patience and understanding

who do you think was the most opportunistic in the humping

lmao