U-Pick Anything Volume 2 Game Thread (Day 4 )

[Timsup2nothin]

@Maple give me a good reason why we should chop Bob and save you for tomorrow.

The reason I'd give is that they're probably a KP role, while I'm not.

Are you trying to make me suffer for another 72 hours?

Yeah, that's what I thought.

I see no way out for me, so, yeah actually torture may be a valid option here.

[DaisyCloud]

Apparently I think if iaafr is telling the truth he will have to be killed at some point especially if ephemeral ends up being the last evil left of the game would never end.

Need to get to bed soon

I think you said that already or someone else said that exact thing.

and yeah

I don't think I said this exact same thing. Before this I didn't know his role. I just thought he was sus. Now I realized that an evil can't flip until he dies.

oh, okay. hmm, idk who said it then. maybe I misremembered. but I was thinking this so maybe I meant to say something like this . but I swear I read a post kinda like yours.

so, yeah they will have to be resolved somehow at some point.

im still trying to figure out what are top priorities is supposed to be tho so idk

[Timsup2nothin]

So we have two people claiming killing Ted yeah?

I think? ColonialBob is I think claiming Ted and Awesome O...Awesome O being about as lock town as we had. Using stolen power of Rej.

Rej has died.

Spoiler: show

Rej was Victor Steinberg from No Guns Life. Each night you target two players. If those two players are the same alignment they survive. If they are of different alignments, they both die.

Town.

If he could steal a power why steal one that kills town?

I'm all in for killing Bob I think.

[Maple]

So we have two people claiming killing Ted yeah?

I think? ColonialBob is I think claiming Ted and Awesome O...Awesome O being about as lock town as we had. Using stolen power of Rej.

Rej has died.

Spoiler: show

Rej was Victor Steinberg from No Guns Life. Each night you target two players. If those two players are the same alignment they survive. If they are of different alignments, they both die.

Town.

If he could steal a power why steal one that kills town?

I'm all in for killing Bob I think.

It's an insanely powerful role, I'd back it up. But those targets are absolutely unbelievable.

[iaafr]

why does wolf me go to bat for sloonei like that?

(going to bat being a relative term, it's not like i yelled at people on his wagon, just said some stuff why i thought he was town. iirc it was part of a convo with jumpluff, not unprompted.)

these are townposts imo and i dont wanna kill bob

[iaafr]

probably dont listen to maple still lmfao

[Maple]

probably dont listen to maple still lmfao

I think we're both batting in the same ballpark as far as numbers go.

[iaafr]

Also, I don't know if this has been said, but Nutella flipping mafia probably makes Sloonei town.

Also, I don't know if this has been said, but Nutella flipping mafia probably makes Sloonei town.

Oh wait, Sloonei is one of the people that died. nvm

it unsettles me that epi + wilgy are scumreading hyena as strongly as they do but idk i still dont feel like hyenas my blindspot...?

[iaafr]

probably dont listen to maple still lmfao

I think we're both batting in the same ballpark as far as numbers go.

no the part where you could still easily be scum

[Maple]

Also, I don't know if this has been said, but Nutella flipping mafia probably makes Sloonei town.

Also, I don't know if this has been said, but Nutella flipping mafia probably makes Sloonei town.

Oh wait, Sloonei is one of the people that died. nvm

it unsettles me that epi + wilgy are scumreading hyena as strongly as they do but idk i still dont feel like hyenas my blindspot...?

Hyena's claim feels legit, they've also been pretty solvy

Makes epi's tunnel odd, seeing that they dont seem to be claiming mech info

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

So we have two people claiming killing Ted yeah?

I think? ColonialBob is I think claiming Ted and Awesome O...Awesome O being about as lock town as we had. Using stolen power of Rej.

Rej has died.

Spoiler: show

Rej was Victor Steinberg from No Guns Life. Each night you target two players. If those two players are the same alignment they survive. If they are of different alignments, they both die.

Town.

If he could steal a power why steal one that kills town?

I'm all in for killing Bob I think.

I mean they’re weird targets, yeah

Makes most sense to check against me imo sense I won’t die if it’s different but

[Timsup2nothin]

So we have two people claiming killing Ted yeah?

I think? ColonialBob is I think claiming Ted and Awesome O...Awesome O being about as lock town as we had. Using stolen power of Rej.

Rej has died.

Spoiler: show

Rej was Victor Steinberg from No Guns Life. Each night you target two players. If those two players are the same alignment they survive. If they are of different alignments, they both die.

Town.

If he could steal a power why steal one that kills town?

I'm all in for killing Bob I think.

I mean they’re weird targets, yeah

Makes most sense to check against me imo sense I won’t die if it’s different but

Would that kill the maf side without killing you? That would be pretty remarkable...

[Maple]

So we have two people claiming killing Ted yeah?

I think? ColonialBob is I think claiming Ted and Awesome O...Awesome O being about as lock town as we had. Using stolen power of Rej.

Rej has died.

Spoiler: show

Rej was Victor Steinberg from No Guns Life. Each night you target two players. If those two players are the same alignment they survive. If they are of different alignments, they both die.

Town.

If he could steal a power why steal one that kills town?

I'm all in for killing Bob I think.

I mean they’re weird targets, yeah

Makes most sense to check against me imo sense I won’t die if it’s different but

Or better yet yolo checks between 2 PoE people. Either you turn some poe chump into a suicide bomber, or you get a same check.

[iaafr]

see idk drwilgys iso kinda feels like a town who really susses hyena more than a scum iso too

[mention]DrWilgy[/mention] you there? i mean no rush but

[Timsup2nothin]

Also, I don't know if this has been said, but Nutella flipping mafia probably makes Sloonei town.

Also, I don't know if this has been said, but Nutella flipping mafia probably makes Sloonei town.

Oh wait, Sloonei is one of the people that died. nvm

it unsettles me that epi + wilgy are scumreading hyena as strongly as they do but idk i still dont feel like hyenas my blindspot...?

If Hyena is handing out bulletproof vests to high profile town I gotta give him a pass, eh?

[iaafr]

So we have two people claiming killing Ted yeah?

I think? ColonialBob is I think claiming Ted and Awesome O...Awesome O being about as lock town as we had. Using stolen power of Rej.

Rej has died.

Spoiler: show

Rej was Victor Steinberg from No Guns Life. Each night you target two players. If those two players are the same alignment they survive. If they are of different alignments, they both die.

Town.

If he could steal a power why steal one that kills town?

I'm all in for killing Bob I think.

I mean they’re weird targets, yeah

Makes most sense to check against me imo sense I won’t die if it’s different but

it only kills town in 1:! trades with scum most of the time tho so... its not a bad role...

[Timsup2nothin]

A'ight, killing Bob maybe not great. Leash him and worst case he kills one for one and that's affordable...

But that's all IF he is claiming true in the first place. He could be responsible for one (or more) of the janitored kills and this whole claim could just be bullshit.

[Maple]

A'ight, killing Bob maybe not great. Leash him and worst case he kills one for one and that's affordable...

But that's all IF he is claiming true in the first place. He could be responsible for one (or more) of the janitored kills and this whole claim could just be bullshit.

He's either the role as claimed or scum and the claim is irrelevant

[iaafr]

btw reading poison iso made me even more distrustful of tim and jpic

she sussed them both early and also claimed 95% accurate reads d1

i feel compelled to sheep her because of her powerful aura and my endless guilt

[Timsup2nothin]

why does wolf me go to bat for sloonei like that?

(going to bat being a relative term, it's not like i yelled at people on his wagon, just said some stuff why i thought he was town. iirc it was part of a convo with jumpluff, not unprompted.)

these are townposts imo and i dont wanna kill bob

Rabbit you can find a couple towny posts from anybody...even me...but there's gotta be some wolves somewhere, yeah?

[iaafr]

yea but im not gonna not townread somebody because i cant find wolves

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

So we have two people claiming killing Ted yeah?

I think? ColonialBob is I think claiming Ted and Awesome O...Awesome O being about as lock town as we had. Using stolen power of Rej.

Rej has died.

Spoiler: show

Rej was Victor Steinberg from No Guns Life. Each night you target two players. If those two players are the same alignment they survive. If they are of different alignments, they both die.

Town.

If he could steal a power why steal one that kills town?

I'm all in for killing Bob I think.

I mean they’re weird targets, yeah

Makes most sense to check against me imo sense I won’t die if it’s different but

Would that kill the maf side without killing you? That would be pretty remarkable...

I would assume so, since, you know, I cannot die

[Timsup2nothin]

btw reading poison iso made me even more distrustful of tim and jpic

she sussed them both early and also claimed 95% accurate reads d1

i feel compelled to sheep her because of her powerful aura and my endless guilt

She got over the suss Rabbit...and I got over sussing her...not like lock clear over but over enough...that's why SHE WASN'T ON THE LIST.

I'm actually not pissed about you shooting off the list as much as I am about all the people who shot on the list and missed and YOU have to get our hit. WTF?

[Timsup2nothin]

So we have two people claiming killing Ted yeah?

I think? ColonialBob is I think claiming Ted and Awesome O...Awesome O being about as lock town as we had. Using stolen power of Rej.

Rej has died.

Spoiler: show

Rej was Victor Steinberg from No Guns Life. Each night you target two players. If those two players are the same alignment they survive. If they are of different alignments, they both die.

Town.

If he could steal a power why steal one that kills town?

I'm all in for killing Bob I think.

I mean they’re weird targets, yeah

Makes most sense to check against me imo sense I won’t die if it’s different but

Would that kill the maf side without killing you? That would be pretty remarkable...

I would assume so, since, you know, I cannot die

I was kinda thinkin' that maybe they wouldn't either is the problem. I dunno tho. Worth trying maybe.

[iaafr]

but poison specifically said her d1 reads are good and that implies that her reevaluations are bad

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

So we have two people claiming killing Ted yeah?

I think? ColonialBob is I think claiming Ted and Awesome O...Awesome O being about as lock town as we had. Using stolen power of Rej.

Rej has died.

Spoiler: show

Rej was Victor Steinberg from No Guns Life. Each night you target two players. If those two players are the same alignment they survive. If they are of different alignments, they both die.

Town.

If he could steal a power why steal one that kills town?

I'm all in for killing Bob I think.

I mean they’re weird targets, yeah

Makes most sense to check against me imo sense I won’t die if it’s different but

it only kills town in 1:! trades with scum most of the time tho so... its not a bad role...

Not questioning the choice of role to take, just the use of it.

[Timsup2nothin]

yea but im not gonna not townread somebody because i cant find wolves

Okay, but what do we do then? Eventually you can't find wolves so you just shoot someone in a random fit of paranoia, probably me.

[Timsup2nothin]

So we have two people claiming killing Ted yeah?

I think? ColonialBob is I think claiming Ted and Awesome O...Awesome O being about as lock town as we had. Using stolen power of Rej.

Rej has died.

Spoiler: show

Rej was Victor Steinberg from No Guns Life. Each night you target two players. If those two players are the same alignment they survive. If they are of different alignments, they both die.

Town.

If he could steal a power why steal one that kills town?

I'm all in for killing Bob I think.

I mean they’re weird targets, yeah

Makes most sense to check against me imo sense I won’t die if it’s different but

it only kills town in 1:! trades with scum most of the time tho so... its not a bad role...

Not questioning the choice of role to take, just the use of it.

That was me...I was a little slow on the uptake there.

[iaafr]

Tim wolf. Maple wolf.
JPIC wolfy.

Liberal / Hyena 3P/scum/lover role.

Sheep is weird and it's a non AI weird.

Ted is Null. He can be like this as either alignment.

Tim wolf. Maple wolf.
JPIC wolfy.

Liberal / Hyena 3P/scum/lover role.

Sheep is weird and it's a non AI weird.

Ted is Null. He can be like this as either alignment.

Can you explain the maple read?

Yes. She is awkward. I don't like her progressions. Her posts are not necessarily towny or wolfy but the later is more true than the former. + my intuition says it's her.
And my Day 1 intuitions are around 95% accurate as it always have been. Would definitely ISO her when on my PC. Also I did not like her responses either.

I wonder why she caught my eyes rather than a lot of player who could have when I'm active along with them.

she reacted so much to jpic and tedxtr early too

[iaafr]

yea but im not gonna not townread somebody because i cant find wolves

Okay, but what do we do then? Eventually you can't find wolves so you just shoot someone in a random fit of paranoia, probably me.

im gonna sheep poison the god

[VOTE: justplayingitcool] aubergine

[Timsup2nothin]

That reminds me...

[VOTE: ColonialBob] aubergine

[Timsup2nothin]

I had already done that but for the thread.

[iaafr]

why is jpic town?

I don’t know who that is.

@Justplayingitcool who did you target last night? self-resolve pls

this sequence by bob feels towny af too

[Timsup2nothin]

why is jpic town?

I don’t know who that is.

@Justplayingitcool who did you target last night? self-resolve pls

this sequence by bob feels towny af too

You Rabbit are the most conf biasing person I have ever encountered I think.

[iaafr]

in comparison, colin's iso strikes me as scummier

[iaafr]

bob is more reactive to things happening around him

colin's stances feel more like... having stances for the sake of having stances and repeating them when they're relevant

colin has absolutely nothing resembling bob's push for jpic to self resolve as jpic promised

i mean ofc they're different players but bob just feels... solvier in process? colin just has reads

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I’ll ask joe if it’ll work. If it does bob should check jpic against me tonight probably.

Or we’ll make a small pool maybe.

[iaafr]

yea if bob can check you against people that'd honestly be sick

though my suggestion would be for him to check colin

[mention]colonialbob[/mention] have you considered using your power to check ppl against nanook

for example nanook/colin

[Timsup2nothin]

I’ll ask joe if it’ll work. If it does bob should check jpic against me tonight probably.

Or we’ll make a small pool maybe.

I like this but I'm still at the possibility the entire claim is jank and his actual role is "space alien vaporizer" and maybe he killed JackofHearts or one of the other numerous unaccounted for dead.

[Timsup2nothin]

bob is more reactive to things happening around him

colin's stances feel more like... having stances for the sake of having stances and repeating them when they're relevant

colin has absolutely nothing resembling bob's push for jpic to self resolve as jpic promised

i mean ofc they're different players but bob just feels... solvier in process? colin just has reads

FWIW I agree that Bob seems townier than Colin.

BTW, has Colin ever claimed anything about his role?

Also BTW, have you considered looking at my ISO?

[Maple]

yea if bob can check you against people that'd honestly be sick

though my suggestion would be for him to check colin

@colonialbob have you considered using your power to check ppl against nanook

for example nanook/colin

Agreed

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I mean we’re not killing bob today, so making a night plan for his action as if he’s town makes sense to me

[iaafr]

bob is more reactive to things happening around him

colin's stances feel more like... having stances for the sake of having stances and repeating them when they're relevant

colin has absolutely nothing resembling bob's push for jpic to self resolve as jpic promised

i mean ofc they're different players but bob just feels... solvier in process? colin just has reads

FWIW I agree that Bob seems townier than Colin.

BTW, has Colin ever claimed anything about his role?

Also BTW, have you considered looking at my ISO?

1. idk

2. why do you ask? if its to townread you, im curious what you think in the iso is towny enough to overcome my fear

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Oh man we should actually have him check rabbit if it works

Confirmed rabbit would be dope

[iaafr]

i feel like im already a decently high nk priority but idk

[Timsup2nothin]

bob is more reactive to things happening around him

colin's stances feel more like... having stances for the sake of having stances and repeating them when they're relevant

colin has absolutely nothing resembling bob's push for jpic to self resolve as jpic promised

i mean ofc they're different players but bob just feels... solvier in process? colin just has reads

FWIW I agree that Bob seems townier than Colin.

BTW, has Colin ever claimed anything about his role?

Also BTW, have you considered looking at my ISO?

1. idk

2. why do you ask? if its to townread you, im curious what you think in the iso is towny enough to overcome my fear

Mostly because i think it would be funny. My ISO probably has 200 really super towny posts in it...and probably fifty or so that would set your little Rabbit ears on fire. If you made it all the way through you'd have flip flopped so hard so many times you might actually be just inert.

[Timsup2nothin]

Oh man we should actually have him check rabbit if it works

Confirmed rabbit would be dope

I know the fact that I'm always thinking like a wolf really bothers people, but if I were a wolf with all the janitored kill power they seem to have this would end really badly.

[iaafr]

i mean youre probably just town

just not sure i trust the poe other than colin

maybe beeboy idk [mention]beeboy[/mention] pls come back

[Maple]

Give a pool of targets instead of a specific target. A framer would turn a green check into a kill

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Yeah we're obviously using a pool lol