Amdibals at the Zoo! [END]

#1601

Oh right didn’t Colin TMI himself as town

#1602

ColinIsCool wrote: ↑Sat Aug 15, 2020 8:25 am
Amy wrote: ↑Fri Aug 14, 2020 9:05 pm
MacDougall wrote: ↑Fri Aug 14, 2020 9:02 pm
112 wrote: ↑Tue Aug 11, 2020 10:14 am Town
tutuu
Amy
Urist
Mac

112 wrote: ↑Tue Aug 11, 2020 10:17 am Carote can be town too
This is not scum reading scum ever imo.

Also 112 spewed Proto town I forgot about that.
is 3 town/1 scum in a townpool something that 112 is inclined towards

i feel like it's the level 1 wolf readslist but idk if 112 would be more likely to just rattle off a bunch of Actual Villagers or smth
I think most players would put at least one teammate in that list, and if it’s any of them Urist is the only one that makes sense. Mac might already be deep but I’m not gonna entertain that yet

No but it was a good Hope from me

#1603

Probably makes Colin/Carot AND Colin/Tutuu not work though. More sure on the latter.

#1604

C’mon guys do something

#1605

I mean a bunch of people voting TSP.

I don't really see it.

#1606

MacDougall wrote: ↑Wed Aug 19, 2020 9:05 amWhy

I’m not sure I buy you thinking I may be scum so far. Idk

#1607

Town: ted, Carote, Wilgy, tutuu

Prob town: Alison, Mac

I don’t think TSP is bad but I neef to reassess. Unfortunately I probably won’t have time before EOD to do that

#1608

[VOTE: proto] aubergine sorry Alison!

#1609

Might pop in closer to EOD so if ya got a compelling argument for me changing that to someone else holla at me

#1610

ColinIsCool wrote: ↑Wed Aug 19, 2020 5:02 pm Town: ted, Carote, Wilgy, tutuu

Prob town: Alison, Mac

I don’t think TSP is bad but I neef to reassess. Unfortunately I probably won’t have time before EOD to do that

There’s technically an inconsistency here with the post I quoted earlier but I think it’s a townie inconsistency

#1611

Seriously people stop voting for me I’m obviously town

#1612

tutuu wrote: ↑Wed Aug 19, 2020 12:57 pm alison: "as scum im too eager to bus, so i put the cart before the horse, i want to justify my read fast"
tutuu: "outside of the game she has mentioned that her scum game relies on bussing and focusing on reaching the conclusion that someone is scum rather than naturally getting around to making the read"

i dont think its that hard to piece together what i was referring to. that your intent is to reach the conclusion that someone is scum, and not that you intend to be perceived as someone who is trying to reach the conclusion that someone is scum fast.

why do you think scolding me and commanding me to never to attempt to meta read u and telling me my line of reasoning has been terrible and always will be over this slight miscommunication about a few words is an okay and justified thing to tell someone?

or are you telling me all of this because you think im scumreading you, after ive explictly told u im not scumreading u when i talked about that snippet u've told me about yourself?

"im not antagonizing you tutuu but your line of reasoning is terrible, which has been proven by how bad u've played this game" when im literally sheeping you and voting your top scumread TSP against my own reads. On day 3. which was preceeded by my day 2 vote on Urist who was my top townread d1, again, as a result of sheeping you and other consensus towns.

day 1 you said you were bothered by half a dozen people who were wrongly meta reading u and refusing to engage on your terms and you said "ppl who dont explain themselves shouldnt play mafia". ud rather tell 6 other ppl that they shouldnt play mafia rather than listen to the pleas to stop being so aggressive.

dont even get me started on how u treated turnip head by calling them useless and a troll and anti-town despite their pleas to leave them alone

every single time ive received a bell notification from u its has been about chewing me on something, even for the tiniest stuff like "wow, a tier 1 temur adventures deck beat boros cycling? what a shock tutuu!!!!"

you're bringing me a tremendous amount of stress after ive apologized for tunneling u and i dont rly have the energy to tolerate it considering my irl situation. im putting u on ignore and im never signing mafia with you again. getting rid of toxic friends is something thats very hard and its always filled with self-blame and doubts of whether or not im overreacting, but i dont think its normal to feel afraid of your own friends, and to have to walk on eggshells around them, or risk getting scolded and being made to feel bad

(i am treating you as lock town so you dont have to worry about your precious mafia game)

"My scum game has a tendency to overbus" =/= "my scum game relies on bussing". "i have this unfortunate tendency as scum to do X and that is a scumtell for me" =/= "as scum I focus on doing X". I think you are misrepping my meta and I have said so - you read me as probably bussing nutella and this was proven very wrong, and you should take that into consideration when I point out that other meta reads you've made are wrong. I haven't made personal attacks on you, gone outside the game to attack you, harassed you in-game or responded with any vitriol beyond "you are wrong and should stop being wrong". Not sure how you expect me to communicate that concept more civilly than I already have.

I'm sorry that I've invoked negative feelings in you but nothing I've said has crossed any lines and it hasn't for any of the other people I've argued with this game as well. Do speak with the moderator on duty if you continue to have issues with my conduct - it's what they're there for.

Re: TH - their slot has become immensely better in terms of content since Day 1. I told them that they were acting in an anti-town way by not contributing much of substance to the game, which is true. I kept my attacks to them as a player by questioning their alignment and in-thread contributions - by necessity I can't lift pressure on players who ask me to stop questioning those things just because they beg me to leave them alone, because otherwise any mafia in the world can get me off their back for free. I don't think I ever went beyond things purely related to alignment and gameplay while discussing TH.

This game is about social deception and social conflict. Kindly be aware that your alignment might be called into question and that you might be told firmly that you are wrong and should stop making certain reads by other players when you sign up. If this is unacceptable, the moderator on duty is there for you to express your concerns to.

#1613

Right, back to the game. Colin can you talk to me about your read on proto over TSP a bit more? TSP's posting this day phase has been erratic at best and I don't understand why people are lifting pressure off him for it. At any rate I really think proto is town and you should probably take that into consideration if you think I am town too.

TSP - I'm having a really hard time tracking where you're at in the game because you keep giving player word salad where you just toss out one or two names at random and call them aligned/unaligned. Can you please at least give me a POE or something so we can talk about it instead of breadcrumbs and snatches of mafia teams you're theorizing about on and of?

#1614

I do think Mac and TSP have strong partner equity - Mac only attacked TSP in circumstances whereby it was unlikely to get TSP exed (because Urist was alive) and then reversed his read the next day after TSP became the top wagon contender. The "TSP's post was a splash of cold water" line felt like a planned line to me, where they both abruptly stop thunderdoming each other and move onto other people after establishing distance from each other. TSP has (I think?) largely stopped considering Mac worlds as well, and has moved onto Carotte, Colin etc.

#1615

Fine.

POE:
Kill: Carotte

Sort out:
Ted
Nanook

Probably town but hmm:
Proto

Town until I decide otherwise:
Mac
Alison
Tutuu

Actually town:
10k
Colin

And I’m missing a name. They’re probably in the sort out pile

#1616

What an incredible take Alison. Remarkable.

#1617

I’m glad I’m slanking this game tbh

#1618

Nanook’s slanking and Mac and Alison are TMIing me as town and people are still voting me smh

#1619

TonyStarkPrime wrote: ↑Wed Aug 19, 2020 6:53 pm Nanook’s slanking and Mac and Alison are TMIing me as town and people are still voting me smh

It’s an incredible world we live in ain’t it

#1620

10k hasn’t even reared their head

#1621

Wilgy hasn’t either

#1622

I feel like TSP would be trying harder if he were scum

#1623

Why is 10K town TSP?

#1624

I thought the non vote on day 2 was townie, my guess was a scum partner would have coached against.

#1625

TonyStarkPrime wrote: ↑Wed Aug 19, 2020 7:59 pm I thought the non vote on day 2 was townie, my guess was a scum partner would have coached against.

Do you think 10K would have listened to their scum buddy's coaching if they were scum?

#1626

Day 3 has ended.

Heavily distracted host flavor goes here!

TonyStarkPrime has been chopped. He was:

Spoiler: show

Night 3 is underway and will last 24 hours. THREAD IS LOCKED.

#1627

[mention]Long Con[/mention] is replacing [mention]TenThousandCalories[/mention]. Please do not discuss replacement actions. Thank you.

#1628

Night 3 has ended.

Spoiler: show

Day 4 is underway and will last 48 hours. Gimme a sec to put the poll up.

#1629

Tutuu kill unsurprising.

Shame she spewed herself town. Would have been way more interesting to see if Alison died in the night.

Can we vote Mac today though?

#1630

Also long con can you start spamming the thread so we can sort your slot? From memory we working with like four posts so far.

#1631

#1632

Heyyyy, I am replacing into a town role. Scary perhaps, but I'm nice.

#1633

What does it mean that Alison is town because she looked good on both wagons? I think I read that.

#1634

Long Con wrote: ↑Thu Aug 20, 2020 9:16 pm What does it mean that Alison is town because she looked good on both wagons? I think I read that.

Not sure I follow that.

Who said it and when?

I'm living in an Alison town world atm because otherwise game is too hard. They seem towny (although generally always does irrespective of alignment).

After day 1, we have just hammer town after town. There has been no good wagons, except the one on 112. Every wagon after that has been bad.

I'd really like to flip Mac today. Anyone else interested in this today? If not why not.

#1635

tedxtr wrote: ↑Sun Aug 16, 2020 5:22 amalison soft cleared just based on wagons

This is what I meant.

#1636

Team is just Alison and Proto. Don't care which goes.

#1637

MacDougall wrote: ↑Fri Aug 21, 2020 12:10 am Team is just Alison and Proto. Don't care which goes.

And again please can we just kill Mac now?

#1638

[VOTE: macdougall] aubergine

#1639

protocultures wrote: ↑Thu Aug 20, 2020 10:25 pm
Long Con wrote: ↑Thu Aug 20, 2020 9:16 pm What does it mean that Alison is town because she looked good on both wagons? I think I read that.
Not sure I follow that.

Who said it and when?

I'm living in an Alison town world atm because otherwise game is too hard. They seem towny (although generally always does irrespective of alignment).

After day 1, we have just hammer town after town. There has been no good wagons, except the one on 112. Every wagon after that has been bad.

I'd really like to flip Mac today. Anyone else interested in this today? If not why not.

I am uninterested in that because I am town. If you wanna yeet me the onus is on you to convince people, not people to say why not. You don't just pick the most towny player in the game and decide to yeet them and demand answers as to why you shouldn't. It's dumb as hell.

#1640

protocultures wrote: ↑Fri Aug 21, 2020 12:11 am
MacDougall wrote: ↑Fri Aug 21, 2020 12:10 am Team is just Alison and Proto. Don't care which goes.
And again please can we just kill Mac now?

Option 1 - Your idea of how I play mafia is terrible
Option 2 - You are mafia

#1641

To everyone;

I know Proto well enough to know that if he is town that he is just going to badly tunnel everything I do from now on. If you think he's town it's whatever. I'm not going to bother trying to convince him I am town.

Moving on. I would very much like to see more effort on day 4. Day 3 was ridic tbh. I slanked. So did most people. We need more effort. The mafia are just coasting probably.

#1642

tutuu wrote: ↑Wed Aug 19, 2020 8:45 am proto is only scum with alison. if she is town please trust that he's town too. if u think he's scum he shouldn't be the first yeet. i think this is the same with colin

Tutuu was killed by Alison. Pretty obvious. Nobody else really has a reason to kill her.

[VOTE: Alison] aubergine

I'll sheep this.

#1643

ISO = Ted = Result = Can be mafia

#1644

Nah Alison is <rand town probably tbh

#1645

That's meant to say >rand

In range but also there are a few townslips particularly in her engagement with town tutuu

#1646

Wrong tree. I am alive because my reads are wrong.

#1647

Tedxtr is probably the most likely to flip mafia I think

#1648

Carotenoid wrote: ↑Tue Aug 11, 2020 4:49 pm ColinIsCool have you played with tutuu before? How can you scumread her, she's like flowing town pureness for anyone that played with her before. Same goes for TenThousandCalories.

This could be TMI spew

#1649

I think I have a good reevaluation happening. Other people try to solve please. If you don't I'll be sad. I need more content.

#1650

[mention]NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME[/mention] I particularly need some input from you

Day 6 Chop