Radiohead Mafia [GAME OVER]

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

okay. there should be 5 mafia here not 4. im gonna believe ur derp clear cuz you probably won't reveal yourself anyway until its later

Oh I wasn’t counting myself

[tutuu]

Previous games and metas mean nothing to me

i agree, people usually completely change their personalities overnight. i too completely disregard meta, its just a crutch! real werewolf players fight with their bare hands and dont rely on meta like a bunch of sissies

[Timsup2nothin]

Spoiler: show

@tedxtr do you still have a townread on me amd what do you think about timsup2nothing's vote?

Why do you think, out of all the players, that Ted's opinion is the one worth asking for specifically?

Because he said he would rescind his townread on me if I happened to be an experienced player and I told him that I was an experienced player but I didn't see him rescind the townread

I thought you were asking him about my vote, which is currently on you.

I couldn't guess why out of everyone available to ask for an opinion regarding my vote, you asked Ted.

Did you expect Ted specifically to offer something you could build on?

I was looking for a connection between ted and yourself, he basically avoided answering my question about your borderline omgus vote wth flimsy reasoning behind it. That's connection enough for me

LOL...I'll give you another connection.

The last game I played with Ted he came out with a totally unsupported "Tim seems scummy" just like you have done here.

I voted for him then, just like I voted for you here.

He cried about it being a "borderline OMGUS vote with flimsy reasoning" just like you are doing here.

After some back and forth he sort of tucked his wolf tail and ran because I wasn't the easy mischop he was hoping for.

So, are you a wolf this game just like he was that game?

@tedxtr is any of this true?

Ted seems to have dipped, but there are plenty of players here who also played UPick2, so getting confirmation should be easy enough.

Why are you so focused on asking Ted stuff? Do you not care what anyone else thinks?

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Actual response: sauce?

[tutuu]

if you're asking me: most games have towns equal to 3 times the wolves + 1. there is mod confirmed 1 sk here too. so 16 town 5 mafia and 1 sk are perfect numbers

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Oh so it’s just your assumption, cool

My assumption is four mafia and an indie

[Timsup2nothin]

Oh so it’s just your assumption, cool

My assumption is four mafia and an indie

Just on numbers this seems kinda town sided. Of course closed setup and unknown roles can be used to offset a pretty large imbalance from numbers, so this is in the realm of pure speculation.

Fun though.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I mean it could easily be either

Four mafia feels right to me but syndicate loves scum siding so idk

[Alison]

Im silly for scumreading u after u literally said u purposely played scummy?

this is probably towny hypocrisy but i gotta say, im not surprised mafia wins game after game on the syndicate if this is how low the bar is set for the towngames of the goat wolves

To be fair this could well be ted's non-towngame so who knows

[tutuu]

Im silly for scumreading u after u literally said u purposely played scummy?

this is probably towny hypocrisy but i gotta say, im not surprised mafia wins game after game on the syndicate if this is how low the bar is set for the towngames of the goat wolves

To be fair this could well be ted's non-towngame so who knows

yea but in my experience when i have to make a decision between thinking two stuff, and one of the choices will lead me to feeling disappointed, and other will not, its correct to choose the choice that will make me disappointed, and that one tends to be correct more often than the other one

[tutuu]

throwing away early gut townreads. only care about logic and no feelings, just like ben shapiro.

townreads:

tutuu
macdougall
oddmerta
alison
JPIC
master radishes
nanook
poison chan
tedxtr
timsup2nothin

not townreads:

nutella
hally
dyslexicon
dyachei
staypositivefriend
drwilgy
colin
herm
long con
samu samu
spirityo
fallen prince

[Oddmerta]

Spoiler: show

Why do you think, out of all the players, that Ted's opinion is the one worth asking for specifically?

Because he said he would rescind his townread on me if I happened to be an experienced player and I told him that I was an experienced player but I didn't see him rescind the townread

I thought you were asking him about my vote, which is currently on you.

I couldn't guess why out of everyone available to ask for an opinion regarding my vote, you asked Ted.

Did you expect Ted specifically to offer something you could build on?

I was looking for a connection between ted and yourself, he basically avoided answering my question about your borderline omgus vote wth flimsy reasoning behind it. That's connection enough for me

LOL...I'll give you another connection.

The last game I played with Ted he came out with a totally unsupported "Tim seems scummy" just like you have done here.

I voted for him then, just like I voted for you here.

He cried about it being a "borderline OMGUS vote with flimsy reasoning" just like you are doing here.

After some back and forth he sort of tucked his wolf tail and ran because I wasn't the easy mischop he was hoping for.

So, are you a wolf this game just like he was that game?

@tedxtr is any of this true?

Ted seems to have dipped, but there are plenty of players here who also played UPick2, so getting confirmation should be easy enough.

Why are you so focused on asking Ted stuff? Do you not care what anyone else thinks?

It is strange that ted had no opinion of your vote on me and you say that this has all happened before in a previous game involving you and him specifically

And I do care what other people think

[tutuu]

I mean it could easily be either

Four mafia feels right to me but syndicate loves scum siding so idk

i dunno if syndicate loves to scumside setups but ppl consistently seem to like putting more effort as mafia than as town

[Alison]

Why do you townread ted, tutuu?

[Alison]

Spoiler: show

Because he said he would rescind his townread on me if I happened to be an experienced player and I told him that I was an experienced player but I didn't see him rescind the townread

I thought you were asking him about my vote, which is currently on you.

I couldn't guess why out of everyone available to ask for an opinion regarding my vote, you asked Ted.

Did you expect Ted specifically to offer something you could build on?

I was looking for a connection between ted and yourself, he basically avoided answering my question about your borderline omgus vote wth flimsy reasoning behind it. That's connection enough for me

LOL...I'll give you another connection.

The last game I played with Ted he came out with a totally unsupported "Tim seems scummy" just like you have done here.

I voted for him then, just like I voted for you here.

He cried about it being a "borderline OMGUS vote with flimsy reasoning" just like you are doing here.

After some back and forth he sort of tucked his wolf tail and ran because I wasn't the easy mischop he was hoping for.

So, are you a wolf this game just like he was that game?

@tedxtr is any of this true?

Ted seems to have dipped, but there are plenty of players here who also played UPick2, so getting confirmation should be easy enough.

Why are you so focused on asking Ted stuff? Do you not care what anyone else thinks?

It is strange that ted had no opinion of your vote on me and you say that this has all happened before in a previous game involving you and him specifically

And I do care what other people think

[mention]Timsup2nothin[/mention] come on. This is not a wolf trying to push some shady agenda. This is town who thinks they've found a lead and are suspicious that they're getting pushback on it. This is a townie response.

[tutuu]

Why do you townread ted, tutuu?

towny hypocrisy in posting that cringe gif at me for scumreading him, as if it was a gotcha moment

"haha tutuu u called me ridiculous for scumreading u, but look at u, YOU SCUMREAD ME URSELF, HAHA!" *cringe gif*

completely unabashed, unashamed, disregarding how he comes off as, as if he forgot he literally said he purposely played scummy

when i feel this kind of emotion towards a player they're usually town

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I mean it could easily be either

Four mafia feels right to me but syndicate loves scum siding so idk

i dunno if syndicate loves to scumside setups but ppl consistently seem to like putting more effort as mafia than as town

I don’t think that’s particularly true on a wide scale tbh

[Timsup2nothin]

Spoiler: show

Because he said he would rescind his townread on me if I happened to be an experienced player and I told him that I was an experienced player but I didn't see him rescind the townread

I thought you were asking him about my vote, which is currently on you.

I couldn't guess why out of everyone available to ask for an opinion regarding my vote, you asked Ted.

Did you expect Ted specifically to offer something you could build on?

I was looking for a connection between ted and yourself, he basically avoided answering my question about your borderline omgus vote wth flimsy reasoning behind it. That's connection enough for me

LOL...I'll give you another connection.

The last game I played with Ted he came out with a totally unsupported "Tim seems scummy" just like you have done here.

I voted for him then, just like I voted for you here.

He cried about it being a "borderline OMGUS vote with flimsy reasoning" just like you are doing here.

After some back and forth he sort of tucked his wolf tail and ran because I wasn't the easy mischop he was hoping for.

So, are you a wolf this game just like he was that game?

@tedxtr is any of this true?

Ted seems to have dipped, but there are plenty of players here who also played UPick2, so getting confirmation should be easy enough.

Why are you so focused on asking Ted stuff? Do you not care what anyone else thinks?

It is strange that ted had no opinion of your vote on me and you say that this has all happened before in a previous game involving you and him specifically

And I do care what other people think

I would be interested in Ted's take on your vote actually. Like, does he think your vote is actually similarly motivated to his vote from his first game with me?

I don't really understand how it happens, but in almost every game I play if there are players who don't know me and one rands wolf they vote me early. It's like I just smell of 'easy mischop' wolf bait. It seldom seems to work out well for the wolf.

[Alison]

Why do you townread ted, tutuu?

towny hypocrisy in posting that cringe gif at me for scumreading him, as if it was a gotcha moment

"haha tutuu u called me ridiculous for scumreading u, but look at u, YOU SCUMREAD ME URSELF, HAHA!" *cringe gif*

completely unabashed, unashamed, disregarding how he comes off as, as if he forgot he literally said he purposely played scummy

when i feel this kind of emotion towards a player they're usually town

This is more useful in confirming you as town than ted, but I think these are actual good points about ted.

[Timsup2nothin]

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

I thought you were asking him about my vote, which is currently on you.

I couldn't guess why out of everyone available to ask for an opinion regarding my vote, you asked Ted.

Did you expect Ted specifically to offer something you could build on?

I was looking for a connection between ted and yourself, he basically avoided answering my question about your borderline omgus vote wth flimsy reasoning behind it. That's connection enough for me

LOL...I'll give you another connection.

The last game I played with Ted he came out with a totally unsupported "Tim seems scummy" just like you have done here.

I voted for him then, just like I voted for you here.

He cried about it being a "borderline OMGUS vote with flimsy reasoning" just like you are doing here.

After some back and forth he sort of tucked his wolf tail and ran because I wasn't the easy mischop he was hoping for.

So, are you a wolf this game just like he was that game?

@tedxtr is any of this true?

Ted seems to have dipped, but there are plenty of players here who also played UPick2, so getting confirmation should be easy enough.

Why are you so focused on asking Ted stuff? Do you not care what anyone else thinks?

It is strange that ted had no opinion of your vote on me and you say that this has all happened before in a previous game involving you and him specifically

And I do care what other people think

@Timsup2nothin come on. This is not a wolf trying to push some shady agenda. This is town who thinks they've found a lead and are suspicious that they're getting pushback on it. This is a townie response.

The strange parallels continue. There were people saying almost this exact thing about Ted in Upick2. They were right, in that it was "a very townie response" from Ted then. The problem was that later we found out Ted was actually a wolf.

[Alison]

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

I was looking for a connection between ted and yourself, he basically avoided answering my question about your borderline omgus vote wth flimsy reasoning behind it. That's connection enough for me

LOL...I'll give you another connection.

The last game I played with Ted he came out with a totally unsupported "Tim seems scummy" just like you have done here.

I voted for him then, just like I voted for you here.

He cried about it being a "borderline OMGUS vote with flimsy reasoning" just like you are doing here.

After some back and forth he sort of tucked his wolf tail and ran because I wasn't the easy mischop he was hoping for.

So, are you a wolf this game just like he was that game?

@tedxtr is any of this true?

Ted seems to have dipped, but there are plenty of players here who also played UPick2, so getting confirmation should be easy enough.

Why are you so focused on asking Ted stuff? Do you not care what anyone else thinks?

It is strange that ted had no opinion of your vote on me and you say that this has all happened before in a previous game involving you and him specifically

And I do care what other people think

@Timsup2nothin come on. This is not a wolf trying to push some shady agenda. This is town who thinks they've found a lead and are suspicious that they're getting pushback on it. This is a townie response.

The strange parallels continue. There were people saying almost this exact thing about Ted in Upick2. They were right, in that it was "a very townie response" from Ted then. The problem was that later we found out Ted was actually a wolf.

Okay but Oddmerta isn't Ted and this isn't UPick 2 and this isn't an actual argument why Oddmerta is wolfing despite a townie response.

[Alison]

Tim, I think you're town but not everyone does. And you think Oddmerta is wolf but everyone else disagrees. I think you're super valuable to the town if you can get your way out of the POE and into the trusted list, so I'm going to shield you and use my clout to get people to trust you. And in return, I want you to trust me about my read of Oddmerta. If you're still convinced Odd is wolfing, fine. He must have buddies. Find those buddies.

[tutuu]

multiple people agree oddmerta is obvious town

Hello everyone, how do I change my avatar on this site?

macdougall believes hes obv town for posting this itt and not in wolf chat

timsup2nothing first post was trying to set the conditions for everyone else's reads and there was the whole "outed scum" bit in day 0 that looked like double bluffing to me

spf townreads him for the detailed / effort put in this read, despite it being impossible to figure out what he meant

Mac claims to be a master of "first post reads." His first post is crafted specifically to meet his own first post townie standards and therefore is probably just NAI.

Tim is lock town because he said "claims" instead of "is". Not pandering to me when he very easily could = lock town. Tim, you have been elevated. You are now Simeon, the Incredible Talking Half Banana Half Orangutan. Your job is to try not to get night killed or misyeeted while I townshield you and drag you to endgame somehow.

Are you sure you locktown this guy? Might be a bit early for that

i level 1 townread him cuz it just felt like a townie trying to be helpful idk

alison also town locked him dunno the reasons

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Yeah tim if you can’t find multiple mafia D1 are you even trying tbh

[tutuu]

Yeah tim if you can’t find multiple mafia D1 are you even trying tbh

all alison was doing is try to be diplomatic and defend oddmerta, "find the wolf buddies" wasnt a proactive request

i mean its not that big a deal but i feel like u posted this as if alison was snarky

[sprityo]

The only Radiohead song I like is karma police

Hello again everyone

ok this guy is mafia

Cranky because you dont like Karma Police do you?

[sprityo]

i fucked up the meme, just lynch me now

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Yeah tim if you can’t find multiple mafia D1 are you even trying tbh

all alison was doing is try to be diplomatic and defend oddmerta, "find the wolf buddies" wasnt a proactive request

i mean its not that big a deal but i feel like u posted this as if alison was snarky

No I posted it as if I was snarky

Which I am

[Alison]

Yeah tim if you can’t find multiple mafia D1 are you even trying tbh

all alison was doing is try to be diplomatic and defend oddmerta, "find the wolf buddies" wasnt a proactive request

i mean its not that big a deal but i feel like u posted this as if alison was snarky

In this context, "find the wolf buddies" means "back off the read on Oddmerta for now since I disagree with it and so does everyone else, and try to solve the rest of the game". I want Tim working with the rest of the town to solve the game and show off his towniness, not digging himself into a hole by extending a fruitless push on a widely townread player.

[tutuu]

Yeah tim if you can’t find multiple mafia D1 are you even trying tbh

all alison was doing is try to be diplomatic and defend oddmerta, "find the wolf buddies" wasnt a proactive request

i mean its not that big a deal but i feel like u posted this as if alison was snarky

In this context, "find the wolf buddies" means "back off the read on Oddmerta for now since I disagree with it and so does everyone else, and try to solve the rest of the game". I want Tim working with the rest of the town to solve the game and show off his towniness, not digging himself into a hole by extending a fruitless push on a widely townread player.

yes i showed that i understood that hence why i was defending u from nanook because i thought he's being snarky at ur expense

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I think the merta push is fine tbh but I’m not interested in leading or wrangling this game so

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I was being snarky at her expense! I’ll be snarky at anyone’s expense, I’m a snark shark

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

[mention]Poison Chan[/mention] if you still wanna chat better do it fast, I’m quickly falling asleep tbh

[Timsup2nothin]

Tim, I think you're town but not everyone does. And you think Oddmerta is wolf but everyone else disagrees. I think you're super valuable to the town if you can get your way out of the POE and into the trusted list, so I'm going to shield you and use my clout to get people to trust you. And in return, I want you to trust me about my read of Oddmerta. If you're still convinced Odd is wolfing, fine. He must have buddies. Find those buddies.

Well...no on pretty much all fronts here.

I think Oddmerta is worth conversing with further. That really isn't the same as "I think he's a wolf." I don't make that kind of committed judgement, either way, based on a quarter of a phase worth of mostly fluff posting in which not even all the players have started to participate. Mac is the one post reader, not me.

I similarly have very little interest in who does or doesn't think that I'm town at this point, because I know I haven't DONE anything yet. I've SAID stuff, but there is genuinely nothing I can say as town that I am somehow incapable of saying as a wolf. As Mac said while NOT one post reading me, I am an avocado. I have to produce results within a reasonable period of time or I should get sussed and chopped, but it won't be day one. So don't worry about "using your clout" or shielding me. Getting face to face, and in the face, of people who suss me is how I sort the misguided townies from the opportunistic wolves.

By the way, if by chance Oddmerta turns out to be a wolf, the most likely buddy looking person so far would have to be you. You do seem sort of protective.

[Alison]

Unfortunately for that theory, Oddmerta isn't a wolf and you're completely barking up the wrong tree. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Idk I’m kinda interested to see where it goes tbh

[Timsup2nothin]

Unfortunately for that theory, Oddmerta isn't a wolf and you're completely barking up the wrong tree. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

There seems to be an odd amount of certainty in this post.

[Alison]

Unfortunately for that theory, Oddmerta isn't a wolf and you're completely barking up the wrong tree. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

There seems to be an odd amount of certainty in this post.

Yeah.

[MacDougall]

Hey guys Sprityo and JPIC are naked mafia.

[DrWilgy]

I am sheeping Wilgy based on zero reasoning.

Maybe because I'm always right?

Yeah except when you're mafia.

I mean. I'd be even more right. You just wouldn't be alive to see it.

[DrWilgy]

Mac, those that entered talking about RadioHead are scum and ted? Why?

What the hell are you doing?

Wondering what the hell you are doing?

[Timsup2nothin]

Mac, those that entered talking about RadioHead are scum and ted? Why?

What the hell are you doing?

Wondering what the hell you are doing?

This is an interesting exchange, since I try to approach life with a sense of wonder myself...

[tutuu]

Hey guys Sprityo and JPIC are naked mafia.

after JPIC was being scumread and demanding explanation and noone entertained him he posted this

I am drinking coffee.

completely unashamed, with proper capitalization and punctuation. to make it as unashamed and in-your-face as possible

i thought it was towny trolling

what do u think

[MacDougall]

Mac, those that entered talking about RadioHead are scum and ted? Why?

What the hell are you doing?

Wondering what the hell you are doing?

Is that so mister is that so

[Alison]

Hey guys Sprityo and JPIC are naked mafia.

Sprityo has town energy tbh

[Alison]

Hey guys Sprityo and JPIC are naked mafia.

after JPIC was being scumread and demanding explanation and noone entertained him he posted this

I am drinking coffee.

completely unashamed, with proper capitalization and punctuation. to make it as unashamed and in-your-face as possible

i thought it was towny trolling

what do u think

I'm not Mac but this is NAI.

[MacDougall]

Hey guys Sprityo and JPIC are naked mafia.

after JPIC was being scumread and demanding explanation and noone entertained him he posted this

I am drinking coffee.

completely unashamed, with proper capitalization and punctuation. to make it as unashamed and in-your-face as possible

i thought it was towny trolling

what do u think

I've made posts like that as mafia. Many a time.

[MacDougall]

Hey guys Sprityo and JPIC are naked mafia.

Sprityo has town energy tbh

Citation needed

[Alison]

Hey guys Sprityo and JPIC are naked mafia.

Sprityo has town energy tbh

Citation needed

I think sprityo doesn't care that he's being scumread, but JPIC makes a show of not caring while actually caring. (See: "I better get a good reason why I'm being scumread" -> "screw you guys I'm drinking coffee and definitely not caring about the game".)

[sprityo]

Alright, I've decided I'm not going to get misexed again. Wolves, I hope you have your finger on the trigger to gun me down, because you sure as hell aren't getting rid of me any way else. I've worked hard to clear up my IRL distractions so I can focus on this game, and my WIM is pretty damn high right now.

Let's start with some raw facts.

The following players are town: DrWilgy, Dyslexicon, Hally, Herm, MacDougall, Master Radishes, Oddmerta, Poison Chan, sprityo, SPF and tutuu. You might be asking yourself how I've managed to confirm 10 people as town in 6 pages. If so, you didn't read the game. If you're skeptical about my reads, remember that in nearly half a dozen games on the Syndicate, I've only towncored 1 person wrong, ever. When I get killed N1 for my reads, remember this post and trust everyone I said to trust.

Skeptical indeed.

Hey guys Sprityo and JPIC are naked mafia.

When am I not mafia in your eyes Mac? At this point it's more of an inevitability you say something along those lines