Nanook is a Bastard Town Win!

[Long Con]

i think that LC, and Martian are more town looking then Speed, and Tony.

im not sure what else i have to say atm, will probably have to reconsider somethings tomarrow.

Did you skip my name since you're going to kill me tonight?

except clearly I will die tonight.

^^Mafia listen to this guy

wait no it's reverse psychology

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

In the night! @MartinGG99 dies. He flips town. D3 ends february 10 at 4pm EST, hammer is at 4 votes

@chardonnay
@Long Con
@Marmot
@speedchuck
@TonyStarkPrime

Post caps are these +80

DA67E07B-5A40-4DFA-9C01-27AD8AE525AB.jpeg (112.82 KiB) Viewed 1945 times

[TonyStarkPrime]

Someone wasn’t paying attention

[Marmot]

Someone wasn’t paying attention

What do you want to do today?

[Long Con]

Damn you Martin. Why'd you have to go and leave me here?

Let's yeet someone bad. Tony? Chard? Speed?

[speedchuck]

Damn you Martin. Why'd you have to go and leave me here?

Let's yeet someone bad. Tony? Chard? Speed?

I read this as you having a town read on Marmot?

[Long Con]

Damn you Martin. Why'd you have to go and leave me here?

Let's yeet someone bad. Tony? Chard? Speed?

I read this as you having a town read on Marmot?

I went for Marmot earlier, it didn't take, I'm taking it as a sign and dropping him.

[TonyStarkPrime]

If I hit post count limit maybe the mafia will kill me and I won't be in f3

[TonyStarkPrime]

or maybe I'll lose now and end that madness

[Long Con]

This game is suffering from going alongside Spiderman and Champs.

[VOTE: chardonnay] aubergine

[chardonnay]

IF YOUR TOWN THAT IS A HORRIBLE MISSPLAY

unvote!

[chardonnay]

Oh, it was a fake vote

[chardonnay]

I was going to reread EoD yesterday, but i feel pretty lost

[chardonnay]

This game is suffering from going alongside Spiderman and Champs.

[VOTE: chardonnay] aubergine

What was the point of this btw?

[chardonnay]

Actually @TonyStarkPrime & @speedchuck

what do you think of LC's movement away from SRing Marmot recently?

[chardonnay]

Oh and I would like to emphasize one thing:

Long Con should be lock-town IMO, his whole progression for D2 feels very genuine, and while perhaps a scum could replicate it at certain points I really don't think that's plausible.

hmm, ok, this points against LC scum.

I dont think anybody else was TRing LC as hard as Martin was yesterday. That'd be a weird kill to make.

[chardonnay]

Moving my vote back to [VOTE: speedchuck] aubergine

I noticed there was two+ a couple hours left in the day when this vote was made.

I already had a vote there so this put speed to two votes vs made's three votes. Thats a risky maneuver for scum to make. Since a Speed scum flip would make made look clean, me look clean, and LC as well. So Marmot was really limiting long term option if he were scum with Speed.

I think i can rule them out as a team then.

[chardonnay]

I will look at viability of TSP x Marmot, and TSP speed chuck tomarrow night when i get off from work.

-/-/-/-

Ideally the consensus scum read of town should lead with their vote in Elo. Problem is im not sure who to pick for that yet. What do you guys think?

[Long Con]

Not trying to mess around , just forgot to vote in the poll, Chard.

Now I'd rather vote for Tony, based on your last few posts.

[VOTE: Tony] aubergine

And now, to the poll!

[TonyStarkPrime]

Actually @TonyStarkPrime & @speedchuck

what do you think of LC's movement away from SRing Marmot recently?

it's good

[TonyStarkPrime]

Not trying to mess around , just forgot to vote in the poll, Chard.

Now I'd rather vote for Tony, based on your last few posts.

[VOTE: Tony] aubergine

And now, to the poll!

no bad

[TonyStarkPrime]

IF YOUR TOWN THAT IS A HORRIBLE MISSPLAY

unvote!

ugh

[TonyStarkPrime]

I will look at viability of TSP x Marmot, and TSP speed chuck tomarrow night when i get off from work.

-/-/-/-

Ideally the consensus scum read of town should lead with their vote in Elo. Problem is im not sure who to pick for that yet. What do you guys think?

you clearly have a pick smh

[speedchuck]

Actually @TonyStarkPrime & @speedchuck

what do you think of LC's movement away from SRing Marmot recently?

I don't like it. "It didn't take" is a terrible reason for town to drop a scumread.

[Long Con]

I will look at viability of TSP x Marmot, and TSP speed chuck tomarrow night when i get off from work.

-/-/-/-

Ideally the consensus scum read of town should lead with their vote in Elo. Problem is im not sure who to pick for that yet. What do you guys think?

you clearly have a pick smh

Yeah I caught that too.

[speedchuck]

So, uh.

LC has had a vote on TSP for 3 hours. Assuming two scum, we're sitting with a viable hammer. If we risk this much longer, it will become apparent that either:
LC is scum.
TSP is scum.
Scum can't coordinate worth a damn/marmot is scum and hasn't shown up.

I mean, it's not apparent yet, but the bait is there. If it stays, eventually the above will be proven, or we'll lose the game. It's not a lot, but it's something.

[speedchuck]

Does anyone recall Martin/Marmot feeling anti-aligned on D2, just with the back and forth that was going on? Or was that just me?

[speedchuck]

Oh and I would like to emphasize one thing:

Long Con should be lock-town IMO, his whole progression for D2 feels very genuine, and while perhaps a scum could replicate it at certain points I really don't think that's plausible.

hmm, ok, this points against LC scum.

I dont think anybody else was TRing LC as hard as Martin was yesterday. That'd be a weird kill to make.

I say it's a good point Martin made. Dunno if the kill has anything to do with it.

[speedchuck]

Wait, I forgot, there's an obvious reason TSP is town.

Did we ever figure out what that was?

[Long Con]

Not to my knowledge. If it exists, this is probably a really good time to reveal it. I think Tony forgot about it? Which doesn't look great.

I'll stay on Tony, speedchuck. I am Town, and so I like your logic about it being more likely Tony is bad as time goes on.

[Long Con]

I guess that kind of forces a town member to take a leap of faith on MY alignment over even Tony's?

Or, Tony's hypothetical partner steps up to bus to try and get that sliver of towncred?

Or, Chard and Marmot are bad, and just haven't been here yet.

[speedchuck]

I'll watch.

[speedchuck]

I guess that kind of forces a town member to take a leap of faith on MY alignment over even Tony's?

Or, Tony's hypothetical partner steps up to bus to try and get that sliver of towncred?

Or, Chard and Marmot are bad, and just haven't been here yet.

It's not super clear cut.

For example, if I were scum, I'd still need Char or Marmot here at the same time to hammer TSP with me. So nothing is proven yet, I think.

Tony's partner could step up and bus, yeah, but it'd be dangerous to do so. One vote on TSP is a test. The second would be an invitation.

Or you're scum, which... yeah, leap of faith is a good word. I always find it really hard to read people in a game with no scumflips.

[TonyStarkPrime]

So, uh.

LC has had a vote on TSP for 3 hours. Assuming two scum, we're sitting with a viable hammer. If we risk this much longer, it will become apparent that either:
LC is scum.
TSP is scum.
Scum can't coordinate worth a damn/marmot is scum and hasn't shown up.

I mean, it's not apparent yet, but the bait is there. If it stays, eventually the above will be proven, or we'll lose the game. It's not a lot, but it's something.

hammer at 4

[Long Con]

Or we are all town and something crazy like the first or last person to talk in a day gets killed that night.

[TonyStarkPrime]

Not to my knowledge. If it exists, this is probably a really good time to reveal it. I think Tony forgot about it? Which doesn't look great.

I'll stay on Tony, speedchuck. I am Town, and so I like your logic about it being more likely Tony is bad as time goes on.

definitely forgot.
But more seriously, I think nk analysis points away. marmot not dying d1 points away. Marmot was on the ride or die chop TSP train and when mafia chose death they didn't kill marmot. And maybe I towntold somewhere and don't remember.

[Marmot]

I guess that kind of forces a town member to take a leap of faith on MY alignment over even Tony's?

Or, Tony's hypothetical partner steps up to bus to try and get that sliver of towncred?

Or, Chard and Marmot are bad, and just haven't been here yet.

I have been here. I asked Tony what he wanted to do today and he ignored me.

[Marmot]

I'll make a case later. I still firmly believe that chuck/Tony interactions point to a team there, but it's LYLO, so I'll look at other options.

[Marmot]

Or is it LYLO? I'm just assuming it is, but @NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME hasn't said so (nor would I expect him to)

[Long Con]

or TMI

[TonyStarkPrime]

I guess that kind of forces a town member to take a leap of faith on MY alignment over even Tony's?

Or, Tony's hypothetical partner steps up to bus to try and get that sliver of towncred?

Or, Chard and Marmot are bad, and just haven't been here yet.

I have been here. I asked Tony what he wanted to do today and he ignored me.

i did not I thought I said something

[Marmot]

I guess that kind of forces a town member to take a leap of faith on MY alignment over even Tony's?

Or, Tony's hypothetical partner steps up to bus to try and get that sliver of towncred?

Or, Chard and Marmot are bad, and just haven't been here yet.

I have been here. I asked Tony what he wanted to do today and he ignored me.

i did not I thought I said something

You said something about post count, but it didn't feel like an answer.


I admit my question was a little vague, but I don't really know where your head is at and I wanted a better idea.

[speedchuck]

So, uh.

LC has had a vote on TSP for 3 hours. Assuming two scum, we're sitting with a viable hammer. If we risk this much longer, it will become apparent that either:
LC is scum.
TSP is scum.
Scum can't coordinate worth a damn/marmot is scum and hasn't shown up.

I mean, it's not apparent yet, but the bait is there. If it stays, eventually the above will be proven, or we'll lose the game. It's not a lot, but it's something.

hammer at 4

... no?

Even if there is somehow only one mafia, no. Hammer is at three.

[speedchuck]

Not to my knowledge. If it exists, this is probably a really good time to reveal it. I think Tony forgot about it? Which doesn't look great.

I'll stay on Tony, speedchuck. I am Town, and so I like your logic about it being more likely Tony is bad as time goes on.

definitely forgot.
But more seriously, I think nk analysis points away. marmot not dying d1 points away. Marmot was on the ride or die chop TSP train and when mafia chose death they didn't kill marmot. And maybe I towntold somewhere and don't remember.

Which is why you wanted someone else to say it, I guess. If a person extols their own innocence due to NK analysis, it's pretty much bunk.

[TonyStarkPrime]

In the night! @MartinGG99 dies. He flips town. D3 ends february 10 at 4pm EST, hammer is at 4 votes

@chardonnay
@Long Con
@Marmot
@speedchuck
@TonyStarkPrime

Post caps are these +80

DA67E07B-5A40-4DFA-9C01-27AD8AE525AB.jpeg

[TonyStarkPrime]

I guess that kind of forces a town member to take a leap of faith on MY alignment over even Tony's?

Or, Tony's hypothetical partner steps up to bus to try and get that sliver of towncred?

Or, Chard and Marmot are bad, and just haven't been here yet.

I have been here. I asked Tony what he wanted to do today and he ignored me.

i did not I thought I said something

You said something about post count, but it didn't feel like an answer.


I admit my question was a little vague, but I don't really know where your head is at and I wanted a better idea.

currently on lc/char

[TonyStarkPrime]

why not speed? you ask? well, I don't believe that speed would be the kind of person to fake derps. simple enough.

[Marmot]

why not speed? you ask? well, I don't believe that speed would be the kind of person to fake derps. simple enough.

That's not really a derpclear, it's not like that information was available outside of that post.

[TonyStarkPrime]

it's a derpclear in the sense that if he thought it was 3 and were a wolf he would have acted on it, no?

[TonyStarkPrime]

so maybe his partner told him it was 4 and he figured he had to carry on in the thread idk