Nanook is a Bastard Town Win!

[Long Con]

I should've just shut up

why?

I just meant bringing up the points about chard and you. If I hadn't this chaos wouldn't have ensued

But maybe the chaos was good? We don't know yet unless you do lol

[Marmot]

chard should have cared enough to be here

I dunno if that's the problem

it's a problem for him because he got yeeted.

I hope it's not a problem for the town.

I meant that being in thread at EOD isn't always a viable option.

[TonyStarkPrime]

??

[Long Con]

no one's claiming victory so

A very good sign.

[Long Con]

chard should have cared enough to be here

I dunno if that's the problem

it's a problem for him because he got yeeted.

I hope it's not a problem for the town.

I meant that being in thread at EOD isn't always a viable option.

yeah but 15 hours

[Marmot]

chard should have cared enough to be here

I dunno if that's the problem

it's a problem for him because he got yeeted.

I hope it's not a problem for the town.

I meant that being in thread at EOD isn't always a viable option.

Our bastard host should've cared enough to be here too

[Long Con]

Also, the game might be over but the wolves are being cautious with victory dances because of possible bastardry.

If chard dies and is town, then there's 100% something really fishy going on.

[Long Con]

( if the game continues)

[Marmot]

I just think that TSP and chucks jump to chard at the last moment looked opportunistic

[Marmot]

I'll stop talking now and let the host resolve.

[Long Con]

I'm going to have a shower. Good luck, and I promise I am not a wolf.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Chardonnay (3): Chuck, TSP, LC
TSP (2): marmot, Chardonnay

Oh man, the thread has been locked for a few minutes, I guess that means the game is probably over?

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Lucky for you it just means the host got distracted. @chardonnay dies and is mafia, get me night actions ASAP!

@Long Con
@Marmot
@speedchuck
@TonyStarkPrime

Post caps are these +40

721048EA-D540-445D-A389-A1472B9FBDE7.jpeg (126.72 KiB) Viewed 1342 times

[speedchuck]

yeet

[Long Con]

Yes!

[speedchuck]

I'm going to go get my work done.

[Long Con]

Good work out there

[Marmot]

...

I don't know if this makes me look good or bad, but good work everyone and thanks for not listening to me LC.

[Long Con]

...

I don't know if this makes me look good or bad, but good work everyone and thanks for not listening to me LC.

I think I listened to you and then stopped several times in a few minutes.

[Marmot]

Ok, I'm glad I did the work to look into chardonnay, even if I didn't actually vote there.

I'm also really glad that I didn't just hammer TSP when I had the chance. If this doesn't officially clear me, I don't know what does. Regardless, I'm sure I'm getting NK'd anyway.


I hope that I was right in that LC is the partner here. My primary reasons for suspecting TSP/speedchuck was their handling of each other. That said, I don't think this cfd makes sense for either speedchuck or Long Con to do as partners, or at least, it makes more sense for TSP to bus a teammate over himself than it does for a speedchuck or Long Con to swap from a civilian to a teammate.

[TonyStarkPrime]

hmm

[speedchuck]

Reading over Tony's last posts and looking at votes... I think he still be scum.

First, the votes:

Chardonnay - 3 Voters: speedchuck, TonyStarkPrime, Long Con
TSP - 2 Voters: Marmot, chardonnay

If TSP is town, then myself or LC could have easily won if we were scum by just throwing a vote on him. We were there, and it wasn't that chaotic or one-sided.
That leaves Marmot and, of course, TSP. TSP couldn't have switched like LC and I could, or it'd be too obvious who both scum are. And Marmot stayed on TSP. Ergo, scum is between TSP and Marmot. That I'm sure of.

Then, after narrowing it down, we can look at posts. Marmot's... aren't bad. But he DID have the chance to hammer TSP, and didn't, so that's good. And his opposition to the Chard wagon even when it would be less dangerous to bus char looked pretty good. The 'Char isn't even here!' argument is almost a so-bad-it's-good sort of thing. It's too blatant to be a teammate defense, maybe. And his waffling between me and tsp looks genuinely uncertain I think.

Tony's posts look more like a built-up bus as he realized what was going on. He was quick to link me in with a Char/Speed callout (I recognize that Marmot did something similar, but given that he was completely wrong and less pushy about it it feels less calculated.) Combined with his earlier resignation and his constant pushing toward the easiest target (My relative absence from this game combined with Marmot's refusal to hammer TSP earlier makes me an EZ clap) I think pushed him over the top. Then there's the fake 'Is the game over yet?' stuff. One post of that is okay, maybe, depending. TSP posted that sentiment more than once, in an 'IDK if the game is over or not guys' kinda move.

This may be kinda obvious to everyone but obvious cases are the best kind. If anyone but TSP was the other scum, the game would be over (LC/Speed switch or marmot hammer). GG scumteam if I'm right, scum deserves the win if I'm wrong, and where tf are the bastard mechanics?

[speedchuck]

I have finally posted enough times for a full day/night phase.

40 posts per phase was more than enough thank you.

[Long Con]

Reading over Tony's last posts and looking at votes... I think he still be scum.

First, the votes:

Chardonnay - 3 Voters: speedchuck, TonyStarkPrime, Long Con
TSP - 2 Voters: Marmot, chardonnay

If TSP is town, then myself or LC could have easily won if we were scum by just throwing a vote on him. We were there, and it wasn't that chaotic or one-sided.
That leaves Marmot and, of course, TSP. TSP couldn't have switched like LC and I could, or it'd be too obvious who both scum are. And Marmot stayed on TSP. Ergo, scum is between TSP and Marmot. That I'm sure of.

Then, after narrowing it down, we can look at posts. Marmot's... aren't bad. But he DID have the chance to hammer TSP, and didn't, so that's good. And his opposition to the Chard wagon even when it would be less dangerous to bus char looked pretty good. The 'Char isn't even here!' argument is almost a so-bad-it's-good sort of thing. It's too blatant to be a teammate defense, maybe. And his waffling between me and tsp looks genuinely uncertain I think.

Tony's posts look more like a built-up bus as he realized what was going on. He was quick to link me in with a Char/Speed callout (I recognize that Marmot did something similar, but given that he was completely wrong and less pushy about it it feels less calculated.) Combined with his earlier resignation and his constant pushing toward the easiest target (My relative absence from this game combined with Marmot's refusal to hammer TSP earlier makes me an EZ clap) I think pushed him over the top. Then there's the fake 'Is the game over yet?' stuff. One post of that is okay, maybe, depending. TSP posted that sentiment more than once, in an 'IDK if the game is over or not guys' kinda move.

This may be kinda obvious to everyone but obvious cases are the best kind. If anyone but TSP was the other scum, the game would be over (LC/Speed switch or marmot hammer). GG scumteam if I'm right, scum deserves the win if I'm wrong, and where tf are the bastard mechanics?

Solid. This is the way.

[speedchuck]

Potential for mod lies!

The only lie:

Possibly bastard!

[Long Con]

Potential for mod lies!

The only lie:

Possibly bastard!

This is my belief as well.

[TonyStarkPrime]

Reading over Tony's last posts and looking at votes... I think he still be scum.

First, the votes:

Chardonnay - 3 Voters: speedchuck, TonyStarkPrime, Long Con
TSP - 2 Voters: Marmot, chardonnay

If TSP is town, then myself or LC could have easily won if we were scum by just throwing a vote on him. We were there, and it wasn't that chaotic or one-sided.
That leaves Marmot and, of course, TSP. TSP couldn't have switched like LC and I could, or it'd be too obvious who both scum are. And Marmot stayed on TSP. Ergo, scum is between TSP and Marmot. That I'm sure of.

Then, after narrowing it down, we can look at posts. Marmot's... aren't bad. But he DID have the chance to hammer TSP, and didn't, so that's good. And his opposition to the Chard wagon even when it would be less dangerous to bus char looked pretty good. The 'Char isn't even here!' argument is almost a so-bad-it's-good sort of thing. It's too blatant to be a teammate defense, maybe. And his waffling between me and tsp looks genuinely uncertain I think.

Tony's posts look more like a built-up bus as he realized what was going on. He was quick to link me in with a Char/Speed callout (I recognize that Marmot did something similar, but given that he was completely wrong and less pushy about it it feels less calculated.) Combined with his earlier resignation and his constant pushing toward the easiest target (My relative absence from this game combined with Marmot's refusal to hammer TSP earlier makes me an EZ clap) I think pushed him over the top. Then there's the fake 'Is the game over yet?' stuff. One post of that is okay, maybe, depending. TSP posted that sentiment more than once, in an 'IDK if the game is over or not guys' kinda move.

This may be kinda obvious to everyone but obvious cases are the best kind. If anyone but TSP was the other scum, the game would be over (LC/Speed switch or marmot hammer). GG scumteam if I'm right, scum deserves the win if I'm wrong, and where tf are the bastard mechanics?

Solid. This is the way.

no bad

[TonyStarkPrime]

Like examine the interactions between me and Char and try to come to that conclusion. Yes, from mechanics, it appears that Speed,LC,Marmot can't be wolves but that neglects that EOD was insane and it's possible that any of the players who made the votes that they did were unaware of other options.

[TonyStarkPrime]

The only person who's truly cleared in my mind is Marmot, it's easy to imagine Speed or LC missing an opportunity to win, especially given that it was 3/2 char speed and 3/2 char LC at various points in the last few minutes. Everyone who wasn't marmot had at least 2 votes on them in the last 5 minutes

[TonyStarkPrime]

ok not sure if LC had two votes

[speedchuck]

The only person who's truly cleared in my mind is Marmot, it's easy to imagine Speed or LC missing an opportunity to win, especially given that it was 3/2 char speed and 3/2 char LC at various points in the last few minutes. Everyone who wasn't marmot had at least 2 votes on them in the last 5 minutes

I think you're exaggerating. LC and I were just hopping back and forth between you and Char, mostly. I think you got Marmot to vote me with you for a bit, and I voted LC as a one-off at some point, but that was more like last 3 hours, not last 5 minutes.

[Marmot]

The only person who's truly cleared in my mind is Marmot, it's easy to imagine Speed or LC missing an opportunity to win, especially given that it was 3/2 char speed and 3/2 char LC at various points in the last few minutes. Everyone who wasn't marmot had at least 2 votes on them in the last 5 minutes

Chard didn't appear to be around though to be able to come drop a hammer on anyone.


I dunno, I do think you're the most likely partner. On one hand, you did entertain the notion of chard/chuck all day, and even put chard before chuck in that preference every time. But counterpoint to that, you were the main wagon all day, so it might've spewed you as a non-partner if you flipped mafia there.

[Marmot]

Also, LC and chard did have a chance to last-second switch to TSP and didn't. These are arguments that they are town.

[Long Con]

The only person who's truly cleared in my mind is Marmot, it's easy to imagine Speed or LC missing an opportunity to win, especially given that it was 3/2 char speed and 3/2 char LC at various points in the last few minutes. Everyone who wasn't marmot had at least 2 votes on them in the last 5 minutes

I think you're exaggerating. LC and I were just hopping back and forth between you and Char, mostly. I think you got Marmot to vote me with you for a bit, and I voted LC as a one-off at some point, but that was more like last 3 hours, not last 5 minutes.

This is how I remember it.

[Long Con]

Also, LC and chard did have a chance to last-second switch to TSP and didn't. These are arguments that they are town.

You mean LC and speed, right? I guess chard always had the chance as well.

[Long Con]

Like examine the interactions between me and Char and try to come to that conclusion. Yes, from mechanics, it appears that Speed,LC,Marmot can't be wolves but that neglects that EOD was insane and it's possible that any of the players who made the votes that they did were unaware of other options.

I will take a look at those interactions.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

@Marmot dies in the night, he was town.

D4 ends February 13 at 4pm EST or when someone receives two votes

@Long Con
@speedchuck
@TonyStarkPrime

Postcaps are these +80

2853442B-BBEF-473D-B03D-3E200DC63EC9.jpeg (127.95 KiB) Viewed 1269 times

[Long Con]

RIP Marmot.

So it's up to me, huh?

[speedchuck]

I'm fine with immediately voting but I'll hold off in case we wanna chat.

Weekend is starting for me, so, uh... got things to do.

[speedchuck]

I mean, if LC is scum, game would have ended 26 hours ago, so...

But I'll be nice and wait.

[Long Con]

Ok I decided to [VOTE: TSP] aubergine.

[Long Con]

I hope speedchuck isn't slam-dunking on my head. Great acting out there, if so. Kudos!

[speedchuck]

[VOTE: TSP] aubergine ok

@NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Game over, town wins!

Mac was a parity cop with a random N0 on Chuck, everyone else was vanilla. Will release spec/dead and scum chats in a bit

@chardonnay
@Esooa
@Long Con
@MacDougall
@Made
@Marmot
@MartinGG99
@speedchuck
@TonyStarkPrime

[MacDougall]

Wow hard carry. I thought town was doomed. That's a real good effort.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Scum chat https://discord.gg/2Hd9jUdWah

Dead/spec chat https://discord.gg/v7a7RUAC6J

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

If I remember at some point I’ll release all the “roles,” they were all anecdotes of me being a varying level of dick in a mafia game

[Alison]

i predicted a scum sweep at one point in spec chat, great comeback by town!

[Marmot]

Oh wow we did it! I'm still amazed!!!

Sorry for almost blowing it

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Oh uh TSP was mafia

I guess I should still give a flip