Interesting. I didn't think I had a "constant low level protection" going on for Made, are you sure about that? It must be subtle, since I didn't make Made's list of people who support him.S~V~S wrote:I was waiting for someone to make this postLong Con wrote:S~V~S wrote:So, my theory is also about a role possibility. And the thing that kept popping into my head was DharmaHelper in the first recruitment game being a seemer role. He came up as a mystery civvie role; in that game, not all roles were revealed immediately. So a role no one ever heard of was a possibility. And it allowed the baddie team to claim a role that no one else had, so no one could dispute it. It also got his teammates tons of cred, as I recall it, although I could have that wrong.Ah, my Seemers.LoRab wrote:I also thought of the possibility of a seemer role. I had the first seemer role, so it always goes through my mind. But I'm not seeing how it's the case here. I'm also confused. You're speculating that Made might be a seemer-type role and baddie teammates switched the lynch and are possibly setting up for what role they've chosen? And would that have just meant they got lucky with who they chose for the lynch?The first Seemer was in Mafia: A World Apart (sequel coming soon!), and it was Lorab. I'm so happy with the role-type taking on the name. Someone should do a baddie team that are all different kinds of Seemer.
Well, S~V~S, I've had my share of suspicion of you, I think we can agree. Let me tell you what this sounds like to me, and let me know if I'm crazy to come up with this possibility.
In my scenario, you are a baddie, and you think it's more than likely Made will turn up Civvie... so you had better sow a seed of doubt a la Seemer into the mix. Then when you turn up with your fingerprints among the many others all over his lynch, we are supposed to think "Maybe he wasn't King Arthur/Sir Galahad/Sir Lancelot/whatever... he was probably a Seemer!"
S~V~S, I'm sure you can see that this conclusion isn't isn't overly intricate. I'm also sure that there's assumptions you will challenge to show the weaknesses in the idea. But there it is, so just don't be surprised that you're still one of the more prominent names on my lynch list. MAFIA, am I right?
What I am saying is we should NOT lynch Made; unless he flips bad, we learn nothing and spent the rest of the game arguing over a speculation. I think we should lynch someone in his circle of trust and see what happens. Becasue him being a Seemer is the best explanation I can come up with for that circle of trust. The same people keep coming in to shore him up; you, Enrique, Canuck. But why? That is what I am trying to solve for. I thought early in the game that he & Enrique had civ BTS, but both have pushed against each other, which civ BTS partners would not need to do. You have a fairly constant low level protection of him going on, and you & Canuck seem pretty simpatico. Then she is the biggest proponent of the Lovers thing. I was wondering which of the three of you would make this post. Not too surprised it was you.
Running late today. Not sure what I plan to do just yet, votewise, I had less time this cycle than I would have liked, that pesky family
I won't be voting for Made.
If you are actually a Civvie who believes Made is a Civvie, then maybe you should consider that Made retaining some suspicion on him is a good thing. However, if he were lynched and flipped Civvie, I disagree that "we learn nothing etc." like you just said. I don't think the idea that he's a Seemer is worth considering, because a) it's a lot more unlikely than likely, and b) it would involve a lot more ideal coincidence considering A Person's role, and the recent lynch. If he's lynched and flips Civvie, then I'm not going to spend the rest of the game on speculation that he was a Seemer.
I'm getting sucked back into The Made Show a bit here. We do need other talk, you're right.
I know that you will understand that my voting for you at this time only reflects my belief that you are a baddie in this one, all the while glad to have you as a friend. 
