Bonk Mafia (TOWN WINS)

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Theres one vote on you my dude

Nope, the rest of y'all are gonna fuck this up and vote me out Day 1 despite the fact that I'm obvious town.

If you can't see this and you're town you're overrated as hell apparently.

Sure hope I'm not, most people don't think I'm that good!

[Lime Coke]

Theres one vote on you my dude

Nope, the rest of y'all are gonna fuck this up and vote me out Day 1 despite the fact that I'm obvious town.

If you can't see this and you're town you're overrated as hell apparently.

Sure hope I'm not, most people don't think I'm that good!

They must be right then.

Fuck off

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Dude take it down a notch please, its just a mild scumread, I genuinely do not understand why you're making this so personal? I dont believe i insulted you or said anything denigrating?

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I get you might be frustrated at being scumread if you think you're obvious town or cause of your power situation or whatever but like

That doesn't make it ok to be a dick lol

Take a step back, talk to jules or fingers, and stop being an ass please

[Syn]

Lime Coke is no longer in the game. A substitute is being sought.

[MacDougall]

Mac 90
Lime 65

Mac read is largely dependent on the lime read tbh

I'm allowed to be wrong lol

If I get flipped I want your head on the guillotine on Day 2.

Live and die by that read.

so you think my read on you is scum indicative? really? what exactly is wrong with it?

[MacDougall]

@MacDougall @NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME

Literally both of you read my fucking iso this game and compare my reads this game to Buckets. I'm actually getting reads here and trying to solve the game. Both of you are being incredibly unfair with reading me here.

You're both looking at me talking to Dunya but look past that shit, I'm literally going through reads.

I made a single rvs read that was meant to be funny moreso than accurate. Yeesh. Learn to handle sus.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Mac 90
Lime 65

Mac read is largely dependent on the lime read tbh

I'm allowed to be wrong lol

If I get flipped I want your head on the guillotine on Day 2.

Live and die by that read.

so you think my read on you is scum indicative? really? what exactly is wrong with it?

[MacDougall]

@RondoDimBuckle can you believe this shit?

lol fuck

[MacDougall]

Theres one vote on you my dude

Nope, the rest of y'all are gonna fuck this up and vote me out Day 1 despite the fact that I'm obvious town.

If you can't see this and you're town you're overrated as hell apparently.

I accept that I am very overrated but given I am my only real fan that doesn't mean much beyond I have a lot of self esteem.

[tutuu]

Lime Coke is no longer in the game. A substitute is being sought.

[MacDougall]

Theres one vote on you my dude

Nope, the rest of y'all are gonna fuck this up and vote me out Day 1 despite the fact that I'm obvious town.

If you can't see this and you're town you're overrated as hell apparently.

Sure hope I'm not, most people don't think I'm that good!

They must be right then.

Fuck off

Gosh golly we are adults playing a kids game bruh

[MacDougall]

[VOTE: EnderWiggin] aubergine

[RondoDimBuckle]

Mac 90
Lime 65

Mac read is largely dependent on the lime read tbh

I'm allowed to be wrong lol

If I get flipped I want your head on the guillotine on Day 2.

Live and die by that read.

so you think my read on you is scum indicative? really? what exactly is wrong with it?

Actually laughed out loud

[VOTE: EnderWiggin ] aubergine

[tutuu]

fuck 1 post left only

[VOTE: Lime Coke] aubergine

i think that has to be mafia. doesnt feel real. i played with town lime coke / bradland like last year, he was chill af even when getting scumread. on his homesite

it just almost looks as if he's joking, i dont think that that anger was real at all. and doing that thing is a very common epic mafia scum playstyle from what i seen

[tutuu]

no i have 2 left

he also changed his vote pretty fast to as to not interfere with the poll. to "no vote". im looking at it rn. its like, if he was town and he was as mad as he was presenting himself to be, does he comply with everything so obediently? if i was as mad as he was expressing i'd be like "fuck yall" and close my tabs and don't do shit what anyone tells me to. i dunno. i think he's mafia and he's a chill dude and it was a misunderstanding - he wanted to look towny and thought it's just fair gameplay to talk like he talked

[MacDougall]

probs still wanna just chopperoo the only rondorooni tbh

[RondoDimBuckle]

probs still wanna just chopperoo the only rondorooni tbh

Multiple people read me as town but I wont stop you, you do you mate

[MacDougall]

probs still wanna just chopperoo the only rondorooni tbh

Multiple people read me as town but I wont stop you, you do you mate

that doesn't mean you are town tho right?

[MacDougall]

Then again no

[RondoDimBuckle]

76%+/- chance of town, if you trust Dunya and Nanook they think I am town lock then either you see something they dont or you just tin foil me. Either way I dont mind just positing a counter argument for myself because no one else will.

[MacDougall]

Bruh I just said then again no

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

82 is decidedly not lock town lulz

[RondoDimBuckle]

82 is decidedly not lock town lulz

more lock than LC [at the moment]

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

82 is decidedly not lock town lulz

more lock than LC [at the moment]

I mean sure you're closer to lock than that slot but you're still pretty far from lock lol

[RondoDimBuckle]

82 is decidedly not lock town lulz

more lock than LC [at the moment]

I mean sure you're closer to lock than that slot but you're still pretty far from lock lol

I misspoke, EBOWP. -lock

[motel room]

Nanook is tentatively in the town pile to me for the % town\scum bit. I know it could just be a bunch of bullshit but interactions off it felt legit.

[motel room]

fuck 1 post left only

[VOTE: Lime Coke] aubergine

i think that has to be mafia. doesnt feel real. i played with town lime coke / bradland like last year, he was chill af even when getting scumread. on his homesite

it just almost looks as if he's joking, i dont think that that anger was real at all. and doing that thing is a very common epic mafia scum playstyle from what i seen

Wasn't someone earlier saying that town lime coke hates pressure?

[motel room]

Also lime plz chill fam i dont think anyone went overboard scumreadin u and shiet the atmosphere is chill af lets keep it that way

Didn't Limey let us known in advance that he gets all aggro as town being misread?

And look, he's getting all sweary and stuff.

Guess this guy must be town.

Yeah, see, this ^

Not that I'm saying it makes him town. Just that he was very determined to act that way and when someone replaces him we're still going to have to figure this position out.

In fact tutuu gave an example of chill town lime so

[motel room]

Motel's slim ISO is not towny IMO



Nice to know that he TR's Scotty tho...

[VOTE: Motel] aubergine

This is the dodgiest out of the votes for me.

Dunya's usually good at reading tone and genuine-ness so I assume she'll get off me, but lets see.

Neither dunya or myself are voting for you. Why are you preoccupied with votes on you, instead of hunting scum?

I am hunting scum ding dong, I only know me at the moment and they way people might opportunistically vote for me.

Isn't dunya still voting for me? I better drop a [VOTE: NO VOTE] aubergine

Do you have reads outside of people who've voted for you?

Yep, my good list atm is
Mizery, scotty, tutuu - maybe\probably Mac - I have tonystarkprime as good for a reason I cant recall

I honestly cant go either way on dunya and lime coke love in.

Potential bads are you rondo dyson and notanaxehole

Can you flesh out your scum reads for us? We don't have much to go on from your ISO Why are you scum reading Rondo, NAA, Dyson and myself? What posts are sticking out to you?

I could. Which of my reads other than you do you disagree with?

[fingersplints]

Just a reminder that @juliets and I are available to talk to. Mafia is a stressful game, and we all have a better time playing it if we don’t vent that stress in the thread.
Have fun everyone.

[Master Radishes]

Huh.

[Master Radishes]

it's true, dyson is a true euro unlike MR who is a north american living in europe...i mean asia. shit. this is getting confusing.

It's tough being a non-American/non-European living in not-America/not-Europe.

[Syn]

@Lime Coke has been replaced by @JaggedJimmyJay.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Hahaha people were going to chop this slot and now they can't hahaha

Hi folks. I've read nearly nothing. Tell me what I should care about. I'll have a look around too.

[RondoDimBuckle]

[VOTE: JJJ ] aubergine

[Syn]

@Lime Coke has been replaced by @JaggedJimmyJay.

JJJ will be granted a limit of 50 posts for D1.

[motel room]

JiggedyJay!

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Let's have a look at my voters first.

Spoiler: show

I think scotty is town for messing up the chronology of events

Will consider listening to mac on lime

Lime going straight for the shield and pocket on Dunya is basically just what he did to Honey in the first game I played with him (mafia) and then Alexa in the second (mafia). Until such times as I see that simping for cute girls that are good at mafia is non alignment indicative of him, I choose to presume that it is mafia indicative.

Mac's vote for my slot is fine. This is the kind of meta read that is way too specific to ever mean anything (I strongly suggest throwing this strategy in the bin before next game, with no slight intended. I have had to learn that lesson myself), but it's also the kind that town are inclined to make.

Spoiler: show

Mac 90
Lime 65

Mac read is largely dependent on the lime read tbh

Just grabbing this post to stand in for any posts relating to Nanook's vote for my slot. I don't know why Nanook has suspicions, and that's par for Nanook. I think I can understand why Nanook might sustain suspicions after they started (e.g. Lime Coke not helping his case by screaming in caps lock). I'm not clear on the starting point. This doesn't tell me anything about Nanook either way.

Spoiler: show

I think scotty is town for messing up the chronology of events

Will consider listening to mac on lime

Town:
Tutuu
Mizery
Radish
Scotty
Axehole
Lime
Uhhh music symbol guy

Gut town:
TSP
Dunya
Island. Motel?

Null:
Mac
Nook

Gut scum:
Monkey
Dyson
Falcon

fuck 1 post left only

[VOTE: Lime Coke] aubergine

i think that has to be mafia. doesnt feel real. i played with town lime coke / bradland like last year, he was chill af even when getting scumread. on his homesite

it just almost looks as if he's joking, i dont think that that anger was real at all. and doing that thing is a very common epic mafia scum playstyle from what i seen

tutuu's read on this slot is all over the place, and I cannot claim to understand it. That doesn't necessarily have to be a problem, but it's not "good" either. If any of these votes is a bad vote, this would be it just by sheer opportunism. tutuu only has one post left and cannot easily respond I understand, but oh well.

In terms of how authentic the suspicion appears: Mac > Nanook > tutuu

Summary: None of them screams EVIL at me. Mac's is distinctly town in appearance. Nanook's tells me nothing at all. tutuu's could tell me nothing but it might tell me something worse.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

It might be irresponsible to have 10 townreads in 24 hours?


Might be?


How about you explain how it's A) responsible and B) possible

Not irresponsible, but instead appropriate (at least in general; I cannot speak for Lime Coke's reads in this specific instance).

Not only possible, but sometimes simple.

This is the way, falcon45ca. It is the next step in your journey. Let me show you.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

dunya's first move into this game was to see something that disturbed her legendary gut and suspect/vote/pressure it. I would tend to expect a more measured "make a friend and then find something to suspect" mafia approach, even if equally active in its delivery by post count and word count if dunya is mafia. dunya is a town read. General receipt standing in for numerous posts:

Spoiler: show

I’m pretty sure there’s actually good mech stuff to do in this setup but I haven’t thought enough

I skimmed the OP, looks like it's got moving parts that don't involve me (yet), so I'll cross that bridge when I come to it.


TSP, long time no see (rhymes are fun)

If only I could watch the entire movie of Shrek in gif form right now.

Sacrilege.


Shrek is meant to be enjoyed in HD, full length format w/ surround sound.


Also, how are you? How's your summer been?

@tutuu

i got small talk, pocketing / "im super friendly because im townie" vibes from these tbh.

I don't know that I personally share that gut reaction to falcon, but I won't question it either. At least not given my current limited understanding of the game.

[MacDougall]

I am genuinely excited. It's been a while since I was in the field of battle with Jay.

[MacDougall]

Jay we discussed this. You are meant to play completely off meta as an experiment.

[MacDougall]

@dunya is Jay wolfing yet?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Jay we discussed this. You are meant to play completely off meta as an experiment.

I strongly considered that and still might yet, but I am cursed with "respect for the game" and won't engage in goofery if it'll just murder my slot given the current conditions. Radishes said somewhere that he was thinking of trying hard since he's sick of his own meta. I might yet be able to provide a chance for a role reversal. But for now the game needs me to be me.

[MacDougall]

LC and now Jay both taking my simp meta read as more than glorified reaction testing is hitting me right in the colon.

[MacDougall]

Jay we discussed this. You are meant to play completely off meta as an experiment.

I strongly considered that and still might yet, but I am cursed with "respect for the game" and won't engage in goofery if it'll just murder my slot given the current conditions. Radishes said somewhere that he was thinking of trying hard since he's sick of his own meta. I might yet be able to provide a chance for a role reversal. But for now the game needs me to be me.

I dunno man. This is a Nanook/Mac game. We kind of have a pretty good hit rate doing the opposite.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

@dunya is Jay wolfing yet?

I haven't seen a reason to say so yet. I'm "catching up" through ISOs. The only player for whom I have felt any moment of clear "suspicion" is Mizery for reasons I'll share later. I'm looking for town. Looking for mafia generally isn't a winning play.

[RondoDimBuckle]

I am still trying to decide if this was a tacticool sub

[MacDougall]

Like all I really need you to do is solve Nanook and maybe Tutuu and we gucci beyond that.