The Syndicate

I was 99% sure SVS was Stevie. I really need to re read and think who to lynch now :/

Hope everything is ok Kate - sending good vibes your way <3

So Skeleton killed MP? Seems as though maybe spaghetti wasn't mafia.
I did however note that Herobrine did not kill last night so woo-hoo for that.
Seems Stevie may have made yet another bad decision

RIP MP and Spaghetti iywg!

Is Hero dead since there was no kill? Maybe people will start to believe me I wasn't bad or Hero

I don't know boogs. Maybe they decided a kill wasn't in their best interests and everyone would assume the role is dead - something I will not assume until I know it is a fact.

Even if Herobrine is dead you can still be a mafia. You did not vote for DP last lynch. As a matter of fact you didn't listen or wait for discussion you just voted Teeth. Maybe you were hoping to help remove the spotlight from DP. Idk. I am at a loss this morning.

Hope you get better soon Kate. Don't apologize, you do this so that we can have fun and appreciate your efforts, so I'm not complaining by any means when you can't show up. I know that things come up

Roxy wrote:I don't know boogs. Maybe they decided a kill wasn't in their best interests and everyone would assume the role is dead - something I will not assume until I know it is a fact.

Even if Herobrine is dead you can still be a mafia. You did not vote for DP last lynch. As a matter of fact you didn't listen or wait for discussion you just voted Teeth. Maybe you were hoping to help remove the spotlight from DP. Idk. I am at a loss this morning.

If you re ready posts, I said I thought DP and BWT were bad. The reason I voted for BWT over DP was because he voted for me first. DP voted for me later on that evening after my vote was already cast. I was not preferring one over the other, I wanted them both out.

Sorry I meant to keep typing lol. RIPIYWG MP & SE, I didn't think either of you were.

I'm kind of shocked that the game isn't over with both of them dead.

Okay EBWOP: I re looked and DP cast his vote right before I voted. Sorry about that. But still, I did say i wanted them both out. I feel I was still onto something because MP voted for him too, but then again I may have been right with him being recruit or Hero could be alive and just not killed.... But I doubt he wouldn't kill because why wouldn't he take one of us out?

RIPIYWG SE and MP. The first I don't think so, but the second I think definitely was.

Regardless of the events from last night, I am still leaning towards a vote for Boogs. So he will probably get my vote once again today. And if he game still isn't over by then, then I will have to find somewhere else to look at. Probably leaning toward BF on that one.

Also, after last night, I highly doubt MP was recruited.

EBWOP: No Boogs. I have definitive proof that MP was not a recruit. And hopefully today you will finally die.

Wait, skeleton is still alive? Doesn't that have to mean that Elohcin wasn't bad? Because Creeper has been doing the kills. Maybe spaghetti was Creeper and blocked Herobrine last night?

Or Herobrine is dead and was rey? If Herobrine is dead it has to be someone who died Night 4 which would be rey, Ambray, or SVS. Both SVS and Ambray were targeted for kills by Herobrine, so unless something wacky happened, they really couldn't be that role. I hope rey was Herobrine!

But Skeleton still being alive throws a wrench into things. And I think it puts the possibility of llama and BWT being bad back on the table...maybe. Except that llama did help us lynch DP.

Ugh, this isn't good for the civvies I don't think. Especially with MP dying. RIP btw! Oh, wait, another possibility for no Herobrine kill last night is that MP protected the right person.

RIPIYWG spaghetti. Finding out Skeleton is still alive has me suddenly very worried that you were good.

Get well soon Kate! I'm so sorry to hear that you're sick!

@BWT: Do you think Herobrine is dead and Boogs is mafia?

I think BWT is my #1 choice for last baddie. If he's not, then I hate to admit it but #2 choice would be Boogs, sorry baby. I really really think I know what his role is though, so I'm not really entertaining it until I'm forced to. BWT I was kind of blindly trusting llama. I would be looking at llama too, except for he helped us lynch DP.

There are 2 possibilities i think FH:
Either MP protected the right person to help us and Hero didnt kill anyone and is still lurking along with Skeleton,
Or MP was Hero was MP or SE and just Skeleton (hopefully) is still lurking.

The reason I put hopefully is: the only confirmed baddies we had were Epi and DP? We assumed and all still hope to believe Elochin was bad so there would only be 1 remaining Baddie. But my fear is, Skeleton and Creeper are both alive. (creeper can block so maybe they blocked Hero?)

Lets just hope there is only 1 Baddie left.
BWT: I am not surprised you are still after me but lets hope you are the one to go, Skeleton

And Just a thought: I know this is my first game, but why wouldn't a Baddie vote for their own teammate to try to keep suspicion off and win? (Llama voting for DP)? I think that is a possibility being overlooked

Well it has been done so I'm not discounting it Boogs, but it is a numbers game. Once the mafia are equal in number to the civvies, they win. So if there were two of them at this late point in the game, I think they would have been both trying to survive but thats just my opinion.

Boogs wrote:There are 2 possibilities i think FH:
Either MP protected the right person to help us and Hero didnt kill anyone and is still lurking along with Skeleton,
Or MP was Hero was MP or SE and just Skeleton (hopefully) is still lurking.

The reason I put hopefully is: the only confirmed baddies we had were Epi and DP? We assumed and all still hope to believe Elochin was bad so there would only be 1 remaining Baddie. But my fear is, Skeleton and Creeper are both alive. (creeper can block so maybe they blocked Hero?)

Lets just hope there is only 1 Baddie left.
BWT: I am not surprised you are still after me but lets hope you are the one to go, Skeleton

And Just a thought: I know this is my first game, but why wouldn't a Baddie vote for their own teammate to try to keep suspicion off and win? (Llama voting for DP)? I think that is a possibility being overlooked

EBWOP: (I need for read my stuff because autocorrect kills me) Or Hero was MP or SE and just Skeleton (hopefully) is still lurking

If llama was DP's teamie than why not vote BWT and save your partner this close to the end? Maybe it could happen nothing is impossible in mafia. Except I do not think llama or Teeth are bad. If your lynch does not end the game then I would srsly look at bf. Sorry bf. I do hope it does not come to that.

I'm not sure about which specific role is which anymore. This is what I think though: If SE was bad, then Boogs is probably Hero. If SE wasn't bad (and I'm starting to think there's a possibility he wasn't), then Boogs is bad and I would lean toward BF as the other possible baddie or Hero. But as to which is which, I think Boogs is Hero and BF is mafia.

I think we definitely need to lynch Boogs today. I think that will, at the very least, eliminate one of the kills.

EBWOP: No, llama and I are both quite civvie. I'm tired of this baloney coming from both of you.

@BF: If we lynched Boogs and he flipped baddie, then who would you suspect afterward?

That should be "Linki", not "EBWOP". Sorry!

Why do you suddenly think SE was good, Roxy? I am really nervous about this lynch, since it will probably be our last chance to get a baddie. I have been leaning towards Boogs, but I really don't want to make a mistake.

llama - my wording wasn't the best there. While I do feel strongly that spaghetti was bad I have to leave the door open that I am wrong. Until we lynch boogs. If boogs comes back baddie or Herobrine and the game isn't over then I would look to bf.

I do quite enjoy FH's possibility that Rey was Herobrine and that Stevie pulled off a great kill. I hope thats true tbh!!

No sense in me holding my vote off when I'm not going to be changing my mind. Boogs it is, and if we're lucky the game will end with him gone. If not, then I think BF is the next place to look.

Votes Boogs

I , too, am nervous llama. Its just down to the wire and the thread now. All signs point to boogs so here is hoping we are right!

Bf - would you be willing to vote boogs today? Why Teeth over boogs for you?

Just to clarify I will not be voting Teeth today.

No, I'm not willing to vote boogs today, I don't think he's bad. I'm not willing at this point to trust llama's judgement of BWT, even though I think llama is good.

I will be voting BWT. BWT, the answer to your question is that I would still be suspecting you if we lynched boogs today, since I dont suspect him to be the last mafia to begin with.

Sorry BWT I misread your question. If we lynched boogs and he flipped baddie I don't think I'd suspect anyone, because I think finding the last baddie will end the game.

Guys, we have to stick together on this vote. If we divide, the mafia control the vote and we are sunk.

I see no reason to wait. While boogs posts always make me wonder what if? I still feel most strongly that he is the baddie we are looking for.

FH - do you see any reason to wait?

Not really, just more chance to be manipulated. *Votes Boogs*

bf - I am disappointed you wouldn't actually list the reasons why Teeth is more likely a baddie than boogs. I was hoping we could discuss it more but I guess you feel sure enough that discussion wouldn't have changed your mind.

Linky - I am with you FH *votes boogs* with fingers crossed!

Well you guys have apparently made up your minds about me. I will try to take Hero out and tie up the votes if Llama joins me. If I get lynched, you will see more clearly how I knew about my suspicions. It's going to make sense and hope you guys survive Hero and the last Baddie Good luck baby on seeing who's been lying to you since I couldn't tell you

Well, I'm the last vote, and I trust BWT, so I guess Boogs it is. Here's hoping.

I'm think Boogs and BF must both be bad. There's no other explanation for BF's vote. If one of them is the skeleton, his vote counts double, so it would explain Boogs' comment about wanting to tie the votes. Fortunately, even with the extra skeleton vote, Boogs is still leading by a point. I feel confident we will see a baddie lynch in the morning.

See. I said Boogs ages ago.

I blocked boogs btw. You're welcome everyone.

YES! Go civvies!! Nice job, guys! Shame I couldn't have won it with you.

Andrew, one of the signs of a well written game is it coming down to the wire. This one could have gone either way. I am very proud of you for writing this so well and thinking things out and for creating the villager role, which is made of pure awesome. Your first original contribution to the mafia world! I love you!

Oh Alex. I was the cow. I resurrected your butt and YOU got me killed with your silly theories. :P Eat socks!

Elohcin wrote:Oh Alex. I was the cow. I resurrected your butt and YOU got me killed with your silly theories. :P Eat socks!

Quoted for truth!

I had a feeling I would be lynched early on, so I tried to take as many civilians down with me.

By the way, Mr. Andrew, I lost sleep over your game. Well done sir! I had a really good time.

Elohcin wrote:Oh Alex. I was the cow. I resurrected your butt and YOU got me killed with your silly theories. :P Eat socks!

I didn't follow the crowd. I never believed you were bad. But I suffered the same fate of course

Ugh, never trusting boogs again.

I almost made it Good job i enjoyed my first game

I will be working on banners on my next couple days off here. Well done Andrew! Great game!

Yippee for the civvies! Nice little fun game that drove me batty thanks for putting it together and hosting Andrew and Kate <3

Kate or Andrew any way we can know who was who in the game?

I had a ton of fun playing - so sorry Elohcin for killing you