[Game Over] Three-Day Day 1 Mafia

[dunya]

When do I get my rolecard?

you should have signed up

[Marmot]

I'm phone posting because I don't wanna get out of bed

What are you going to post?

[Quin]

Spoiler: show

I'm phone posting because I don't wanna get out of bed

What are you going to post?

I didn't think that far ahead. What do you think I should post?

[dunya]

DrWilgy has been lynched. He was

Spoiler: show

Vanilla Townie.

Congrats to

Spoiler: show

the scum team, Marmot and Quin!

sorry for your loss, townies and hope ya'll play again.

[dunya]

thanks everyone for posting relatively more than usual on a day 1 phase. It was awesome to see 8 people actually active and contributing. a shame more people couldn't be around for eod, but the drwilgy lynch was almost unanimous.

thank you [mention]juliets[/mention] for modding this game on short notice, too <3

congrats to INH for being the only one to have a vote on a scummie despite the drwilgy scenes.

I've never seen a wacky gambit like DrWilgy's and I was surprised everyone was quick to call him scum for it (easy for me to say, sitting on my high horse with the role cards, I know). Why would scum have claimed mason when no attention was on him, after 2 people already claimed masons? not a rhetorical question, genuinely curious what people thought was happening. unsure what I would have done in the circumstances.

[Marmot]

Yay team! High five Quin!

[Quin]

I did it mum

[Turnip Head]

I dunno dunya, why would Wilgy do that?

This was fun tho

[Turnip Head]

Quin and Marmot were my original suspects before wilgy went all wilgy on us, so at least I can lean on that

[dunya]

Quin and Marmot were my original suspects before wilgy went all wilgy on us, so at least I can lean on that

tru, you nailed them both. shoulda listened to your gut, turnip ;p

[Marmot]

Over the last 6 months:

My mafia record when I post more than 150 times: 0-7
My mafia record when I post less than 50 times: 2-0

I think I'm noticing a trend here.

[Quin]

Quin and Marmot were my original suspects before wilgy went all wilgy on us, so at least I can lean on that

I pretty much just ignored you all game for this reason

[Golden]

When do I get my rolecard?

you should have signed up

I was just about to when it went into actual game you snooze you lose I guess.

[Marmot]

Thanks for the game dunya! Everyone looking at and voting Wilgy really helped us out on this one, taking any pressure off of the possibility of lynching inh, Quin or myself.

This could have been a reeeally fun game if Quin and I both claimed Mason too.

[Golden]

Over the last 6 months:

My mafia record when I post more than 150 times: 0-7
My mafia record when I post less than 50 times: 2-0

I think I'm noticing a trend here.

I keep telling people to lynch quiet marmot.

I knew that the Wilgy thing was driving the town off a cliff. I remember wilgy's "I'm a doctor with a red peek" day one lie as town, and never again canI see it as alignment-indicative when he does something insane.

[Marmot]

Over the last 6 months:

My mafia record when I post more than 150 times: 0-7
My mafia record when I post less than 50 times: 2-0

I think I'm noticing a trend here.

I keep telling people to lynch quiet marmot.

I knew that the Wilgy thing was driving the town off a cliff. I remember wilgy's "I'm a doctor with a red peek" day one lie as town, and never again canI see it as alignment-indicative when he does something insane.

I should clarify, that is not my record as mafia, but rather my overall mafia record.

[dunya]

This could have been a reeeally fun game if Quin and I both claimed Mason too.

but knowing you and quin, i think people would have more likely trusted sprityo and kyle in this scenario

[Epignosis]

Over the last 6 months:

My mafia record when I post more than 150 times: 0-7
My mafia record when I post less than 50 times: 2-0

I think I'm noticing a trend here.

I keep telling people to lynch quiet marmot.

I knew that the Wilgy thing was driving the town off a cliff. I remember wilgy's "I'm a doctor with a red peek" day one lie as town, and never again canI see it as alignment-indicative when he does something insane.

I should clarify, that is not my record as mafia, but rather my overall mafia record.

Protip: Capital letters are your friend.

Mafia = game
mafia = faction

[dunya]

i flipped a coin to see if every role should be in the game, and it came down to 1 cop, 1 mayor and 2 masons.

it really fucks people up when the game has 1 mason, or no cop and scum take a gambit and claim cop.

if more people are interested, i'll run another one of these some time in the future. (:

[Golden]

Over the last 6 months:

My mafia record when I post more than 150 times: 0-7
My mafia record when I post less than 50 times: 2-0

I think I'm noticing a trend here.

I keep telling people to lynch quiet marmot.

I knew that the Wilgy thing was driving the town off a cliff. I remember wilgy's "I'm a doctor with a red peek" day one lie as town, and never again canI see it as alignment-indicative when he does something insane.

I should clarify, that is not my record as mafia, but rather my overall mafia record.

That's not fair, I want more marmot in my life.

Technically "you" posted more than 150 times in hydra mafia and won.

[Marmot]

That's not fair, I want more marmot in my life.

Technically "you" posted more than 150 times in hydra mafia and won.

But we all know you did all the heavy lifting and I just popped in at LYLO.

[Marmot]

I found Kyle the scariest player to go up against in this game. The other folks that were confirmed town were much less active. Kyle was motivated and gunning pretty hard.

[sprityo]

Damnit I knew Quin was being way too cagey

But I can’t say I agree with how wilgy played his own hand and it forced my own

[Quin]

Damnit I knew Quin was being way too cagey

But I can’t say I agree with how wilgy played his own hand and it forced my own

and here i thought i was mimicking my meta quite well

[Quin]

if I were town I'd have called people out on their shit a lot more than I did when it came to Wilgy's claim. I was bad and I still did. In the end it kind of looked like town just wanted to lynch wilgy and pin the blame on him if they were wrong.

[Turnip Head]

I disagree that town played poorly re: wilgy tbh. Pretty much every townie tried to give wilgy some sort of benefit of the doubt at some point or another. His gambit felt half baked cuz he didn't really follow through on it

[DrWilgy]

i flipped a coin to see if every role should be in the game, and it came down to 1 cop, 1 mayor and 2 masons.

it really fucks people up when the game has 1 mason, or no cop and scum take a gambit and claim cop.

if more people are interested, i'll run another one of these some time in the future. (:

Yeah I like the format. Good game Dunya. Thank yee thank ye.

[Turnip Head]

[mention]dunya[/mention] yes plz moar plz ty

[insertnamehere]

GOT EM

Well, not really. I actually was planning on making a case against Marmot today, but then my morning got busy, and I told myself that I'd do it in the afternoon, and I forgot that the friggin' game was about to end.

Bleh.

After DrWilgy's performance in Blue Velvet, a game I hosted, where he did some bizarre, inscrutable role claim that made literally no sense for him to do, and caused his mislynch, I feel like he cannot be trusted whenever he claims a damn thing. Meanwhile, Marmot was giving me baddie vibes out the wazoo.

Is it better or worse to be wrong and lose, or to be right and lose? Probably the latter.

[insertnamehere]

GOT EM

Well, not really. I actually was planning on making a case against Marmot today, but then my morning got busy, and I told myself that I'd do it in the afternoon, and I forgot that the friggin' game was about to end.

Bleh.

After DrWilgy's performance in Blue Velvet, a game I hosted, where he did some bizarre, inscrutable role claim that made literally no sense for him to do, and caused his mislynch, I feel like he cannot be trusted whenever he claims a damn thing. Meanwhile, Marmot was giving me baddie vibes out the wazoo.

Is it worse to be wrong and lose, or to be right and lose? Probably the latter.

EBWOP

sentences are hard

[Kylemii]

alright so what the actual fuck

[Kylemii]

I found Kyle the scariest player to go up against in this game. The other folks that were confirmed town were much less active. Kyle was motivated and gunning pretty hard.

stop saying things like that if people get that sort of impression of me then I'm gonna have to start working hard :\

[Kylemii]

my biggest mistake was underestimating wilgy's wildcard nature and tunnelling on him instead of looking at everyone else

I think quin is tied with me now :\

[Quin]

my biggest mistake was underestimating wilgy's wildcard nature and tunnelling on him instead of looking at everyone else

I think quin is tied with me now :\

huehueehuhueueuheuheeuuhueue

[Marmot]

I found Kyle the scariest player to go up against in this game. The other folks that were confirmed town were much less active. Kyle was motivated and gunning pretty hard.

stop saying things like that if people get that sort of impression of me then I'm gonna have to start working hard :\

I wouldn't say I generally have that impression of you. I am not used to you supatowning so hard, and you were the most proactive about it.

[ColinIsCool]

Dag, yo. I thought Quin looked different from his town meta early on but the Wilgy stuff distracted me and I was in no condition to solve anything yesterday. I hope this doesn’t hurt my re-election bid.

[Epignosis]

So...

...if you're lucky enough to be bad you just need to survive Day one?

Seems like an easy win.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

So...

...if you're lucky enough to be bad you just need to survive Day one?

Seems like an easy win.

I'd say it's easy in the same way a Burglary is easy -- it just happens quickly.

This game is designed to run in one day phase though. The bad guys lose all the time because of the role claiming dynamics.

[dunya]

So...

...if you're lucky enough to be bad you just need to survive Day one?

Seems like an easy win.

it's not easy at all. ask me and kyle. ;p

if wilgy hadn't wilgified the thread, marmot and quin were respectively top suspects for everyone. potentially clearing up to 5/8 players is what makes it tricky and scum often have to counterclaim to win.

[Epignosis]

So...

...if you're lucky enough to be bad you just need to survive Day one?

Seems like an easy win.

I'd say it's easy in the same way a Burglary is easy -- it just happens quickly.

This game is designed to run in one day phase though. The bad guys lose all the time because of the role claiming dynamics.

Losing because of one bad decision isn't for me I guess.

I get enough of that in real life.

[DrWilgy]

So here's my follow up questions.

Why did I do what I did?

What did everyone learn from this game?

Whomever wishes, please let me know.

[insertnamehere]

So here's my follow up questions.

Why did I do what I did?

What did everyone learn from this game?

Whomever wishes, please let me know.

[dunya]

So here's my follow up questions.

Why did I do what I did?

What did everyone learn from this game?

Whomever wishes, please let me know.

you did it for future meta reasons?

[DrWilgy]

So here's my follow up questions.

Why did I do what I did?

What did everyone learn from this game?

Whomever wishes, please let me know.

you did it for future meta reasons?

Absolutely not. I was playing to win. I wouldn't throw for meta. Meta is simpler than that lol.

[Marmot]

So here's my follow up questions.

Why did I do what I did?

What did everyone learn from this game?

Whomever wishes, please let me know.

If nobody is defending the unanimous lynch, then he's obviously civilian.

[DharmaHelper]

Absolute madman.