Murder, Mayhem, and Mafia
https://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/
Doesn't that seem unnecessarily risky of Made?Long Con wrote:I could see a Juliets and Made team where he intentionally didn't get the vote in... but what happened here Made?Made wrote:Also, My vote didn't go through for Juliets?
The vibe I get is town but I always seem to be wrong about him. I said he was indie late in a game recently and people believed me and he was bad and the civs lost. I have been reluctant to call him good ever since that instance.MovingPictures07 wrote:Is there any reason you feel more unclear about LC than the rest?juliets wrote:Glory - civ
MP - civ
sig - civ
made - mafia
MM - mafia
LC - I'm unclear, sorry
I dont do real well on GTH. Its one of the reasons I don't play much anymore.
Why should I read you as town?juliets wrote:Oh, my vote felt contrived. Well, hard to argue that other than to tell you it was not. Someone had brought up earlier that he wasn't around during the night.MovingPictures07 wrote:The reason is included right in that post.
everyone can't be town Glorf.Glorfindel wrote:MM: Town
Juliets: marginal Town
LC: marginal Mafia
MP: marginal Town (just don't like his vote on Juliets)
Sig: marginal Town
Made: Jury's out
Well, that's as goshdarned as all get-out.Metalmarsh89 wrote:Maybe my memory is just gone done toasted.Made wrote:I always remember you lasting forever.... anywhozieMetalmarsh89 wrote: Maybe I remember incorectly because I tend to get lynched before her anyway...
Glorfindel - Iffy
juliets - Mafia
Long Con - Town
MM- Iffy
MP07- Town
sig - Town
that was supposed to be orange :rip thanks for the game.sig wrote:everyone can't be town Glorf.Glorfindel wrote:MM: Town
Juliets: marginal Town
LC: marginal Mafia
MP: marginal Town (just don't like his vote on Juliets)
Sig: marginal Town
Made: Jury's out
No, I don't believe she is (correct me if I'm wrong juliets). You are a game-solver MP. I am sometimes a game-solver. But on the other hand, there are some people who just don't play transparently and wish to look at every player at once.MovingPictures07 wrote:Do you believe juliets is not a game solver?
How does that impact your read of her in this game?
That's all fair. How do you read her?Metalmarsh89 wrote:No, I don't believe she is (correct me if I'm wrong juliets). You are a game-solver MP. I am sometimes a game-solver. But on the other hand, there are some people who just don't play transparently and wish to look at every player at once.MovingPictures07 wrote:Do you believe juliets is not a game solver?
How does that impact your read of her in this game?
That doesn't impact my read. That's just not how I perceive her.
I'm a little bad, for spice.sig wrote:everyone can't be town Glorf.Glorfindel wrote:MM: Town
Juliets: marginal Town
LC: marginal Mafia
MP: marginal Town (just don't like his vote on Juliets)
Sig: marginal Town
Made: Jury's out
Because I have posted genuinely without regard to what my posts may look like. I also have posted through the night on both nights.MovingPictures07 wrote:Why should I read you as town?juliets wrote:Oh, my vote felt contrived. Well, hard to argue that other than to tell you it was not. Someone had brought up earlier that he wasn't around during the night.MovingPictures07 wrote:The reason is included right in that post.
I imagine Jay set up the tracker role to be "I track X" and then sig would find out who X targeted that Night, if anyone.Long Con wrote:I'm a little bad, for spice.sig wrote:everyone can't be town Glorf.Glorfindel wrote:MM: Town
Juliets: marginal Town
LC: marginal Mafia
MP: marginal Town (just don't like his vote on Juliets)
Sig: marginal Town
Made: Jury's out
RIP sig, our tracker! Is a tracker like a rolechecker, and can we get any info from his posts posthumously?
At the end, he suspected juliets primarily, then offered myself and Made as alternatives.MovingPictures07 wrote:Is it possible that sig had information on a killer?
MovingPictures07 wrote:Doesn't that seem unnecessarily risky of Made?Long Con wrote:I could see a Juliets and Made team where he intentionally didn't get the vote in... but what happened here Made?Made wrote:Also, My vote didn't go through for Juliets?
I voted thoMade wrote:Putting my vote on Juliets before I forget. The forgetting MP was in this game is plausible, but still feels off to me.
That's fair. I'll leave you alone a bit for now. I don't want to tunnel too hard.juliets wrote:Because I have posted genuinely without regard to what my posts may look like. I also have posted through the night on both nights.MovingPictures07 wrote:Why should I read you as town?juliets wrote:Oh, my vote felt contrived. Well, hard to argue that other than to tell you it was not. Someone had brought up earlier that he wasn't around during the night.MovingPictures07 wrote:The reason is included right in that post.
Without digging into his posts, I'd say it's unlikely he had information, but I'm not sure I'd double down on that assessment.Metalmarsh89 wrote:At the end, he suspected juliets primarily, then offered myself and Made as alternatives.MovingPictures07 wrote:Is it possible that sig had information on a killer?
What do you make of that?
Thanks for double checking.Long Con wrote:Ugh, it just looks like sig was accusing Quin after night 1.
I keep waiting for the HA-HA HA!JaggedJimmyJay wrote:REMINDER THAT ALL VOTES MUST BE IN CAPS LOCK TO ENSURE I SEE THEM.
My perception was he changed his read on me as the day went on as opposed to coming out of the night suspecting me.Metalmarsh89 wrote:At the end, he suspected juliets primarily, then offered myself and Made as alternatives.MovingPictures07 wrote:Is it possible that sig had information on a killer?
What do you make of that?
What makes Made more suspicious than everyone else?Glorfindel wrote:VOTE MADE - this is a gut feel, literally a shot in the dark (like Kevin Costner in the Body Guard...)
Gotta be ALL CAPS or JJJ will miss it. I missed it dude!Made wrote:MovingPictures07 wrote:Doesn't that seem unnecessarily risky of Made?Long Con wrote:I could see a Juliets and Made team where he intentionally didn't get the vote in... but what happened here Made?Made wrote:Also, My vote didn't go through for Juliets?I voted thoMade wrote:Putting my vote on Juliets before I forget. The forgetting MP was in this game is plausible, but still feels off to me.
What do you make of LC and Glorf?Metalmarsh89 wrote:VOTE MADE
^^I am making the above vote with caps lock turned off.
MovingPictures07 wrote:What makes Made more suspicious than everyone else?Glorfindel wrote:VOTE MADE - this is a gut feel, literally a shot in the dark (like Kevin Costner in the Body Guard...)
Weren't MM and Glorf the only ones defending Made?
One of you guys is fishy.Isn't there literally anything you can point me to that makes you feel kinda yucky or unsure about him?Glorfindel wrote:MovingPictures07 wrote:What makes Made more suspicious than everyone else?Glorfindel wrote:VOTE MADE - this is a gut feel, literally a shot in the dark (like Kevin Costner in the Body Guard...)
Glorfindel wrote:MovingPictures07 wrote:What makes Made more suspicious than everyone else?Glorfindel wrote:VOTE MADE - this is a gut feel, literally a shot in the dark (like Kevin Costner in the Body Guard...)
Both of these votes are no-u, I feel personally attacked.Metalmarsh89 wrote:VOTE MADE
^^I am making the above vote with caps lock turned off.
I agree. I don't think he had any information to offer us. (Sorry sig).juliets wrote:My perception was he changed his read on me as the day went on as opposed to coming out of the night suspecting me.Metalmarsh89 wrote:At the end, he suspected juliets primarily, then offered myself and Made as alternatives.MovingPictures07 wrote:Is it possible that sig had information on a killer?
What do you make of that?
I like Glorfindel this game. This is the most proactive I've seen him in a game.MovingPictures07 wrote:What do you make of LC and Glorf?Metalmarsh89 wrote:VOTE MADE
^^I am making the above vote with caps lock turned off.
Ok, I think we're having a nice Gut Day Three, so I'll go Glorf.MovingPictures07 wrote:LC, what do you think? Who should die and why?
Not right now, no.MovingPictures07 wrote:Isn't there literally anything you can point me to that makes you feel kinda yucky or unsure about him?Glorfindel wrote:MovingPictures07 wrote:What makes Made more suspicious than everyone else?Glorfindel wrote:VOTE MADE - this is a gut feel, literally a shot in the dark (like Kevin Costner in the Body Guard...)
Do you believe either or both of those votes is an opportunistic baddie? If so/not, why?Made wrote:Glorfindel wrote:MovingPictures07 wrote:What makes Made more suspicious than everyone else?Glorfindel wrote:VOTE MADE - this is a gut feel, literally a shot in the dark (like Kevin Costner in the Body Guard...)Both of these votes are no-u, I feel personally attacked.Metalmarsh89 wrote:VOTE MADE
^^I am making the above vote with caps lock turned off.
They did? Are you sure LC? I don't feel I have time to look back. My gth had made and mm as bad from poe (and you as unsure).Long Con wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:Long Con! Come justify that townread of you that I have.
<-- that's me dude