The Syndicate

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:

Choutas wrote:How could you idly name the mafia team if you didn't put the connections and the interactions together? You could have said the six scummiest players but no you said the mafia team which implies some kind of methodology used to tie those six together. OK admit you can't name the mafia team in a GTH manner.

You're probably right, I doubt I got them all.

But I tried anyway. In the space of less than one minute. You failed the GTH test and you hate it.

MacDougall wrote:

Epignosis wrote:

MacDougall wrote: I found out you were the serial killer

Now

MacDougall wrote:And you riding that reason like a crutch makes me even more sure.

I think it's more likely, by sheer weight of numbers, that the SK intentionally failed to send in their kill. There are only 1, or 2 at most posters that I could see having forgotten to or not bothered from apathy. If the SK is any one of the remainder of the game then it was intentional and the only person who had any reason to withhold their kill would have been you and it was exactly so you could defend yourself this way.

Come on people. How would he find out I was the serial killer if I intentionally failed to send in my kill?

How does that make me scum?

My conviction in you being the serial killer is based on in thread evidence I presented a long time ago.

What occurred last night is not what I initially interpreted it as, so my rationalisation of how you being the serial killer and the result has changed when I came to terms with the fact that I was incorrect. I still believe you are the serial killer despite this. "I'd never forget to send in a PM" is no defence to the evidence I had already presented, nor is the unlikeliness of the recent case I presented against you an indictment of the initial evidence.

linki: Strawhenge, it's not a good look for you to just put your vote nowhere. You must have an opinion on Diiny and myself. And if you don't, you most certainly have time to come up with one.

Strawhenge wrote:Jay, keej, it's quite noble that you're trying to save your scumbuddy right now, but I'm not buying it.

Choutas wrote:

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:

Choutas wrote:How could you idly name the mafia team if you didn't put the connections and the interactions together? You could have said the six scummiest players but no you said the mafia team which implies some kind of methodology used to tie those six together. OK admit you can't name the mafia team in a GTH manner.

You're probably right, I doubt I got them all.

But I tried anyway. In the space of less than one minute. You failed the GTH test and you hate it.

The glass is broken, there are shards everywhere. You think Mac is town but you seem quite relaxed about his lynch. WAY TOO RELAXED. You said winning this game is very important to you, you were screaming that we're losing and that we can't afford to lynch another townie. Yet you sit idly and seem accepting of a Mac lynch despite calling him a townie.
I am not a vocal townie I can't be bothered. But you... You should have acted way differently.


linki @Straw: Straw follow your heart. Search deep inside you and vote either of them. Don't let others make decisions for you. Btw bro MM won't happen today just sayin'
linki 2 @Straw: It could be townies also. We just believe Mac is town.

Choutas wrote:The glass is broken, there are shards everywhere. You think Mac is town but you seem quite relaxed about his lynch. WAY TOO RELAXED.

Choutas wrote:You said winning this game is very important to you, you were screaming that we're losing and that we can't afford to lynch another townie. Yet you sit idly and seem accepting of a Mac lynch despite calling him a townie.
I am not a vocal townie I can't be bothered. But you... You should have acted way differently.

Strawhenge wrote:Why? You want me to vote for who you want me to vote for. Who's not a town read again?

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

Choutas wrote:

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:

Choutas wrote:How could you idly name the mafia team if you didn't put the connections and the interactions together? You could have said the six scummiest players but no you said the mafia team which implies some kind of methodology used to tie those six together. OK admit you can't name the mafia team in a GTH manner.

You're probably right, I doubt I got them all.

But I tried anyway. In the space of less than one minute. You failed the GTH test and you hate it.

The glass is broken, there are shards everywhere. You think Mac is town but you seem quite relaxed about his lynch. WAY TOO RELAXED. You said winning this game is very important to you, you were screaming that we're losing and that we can't afford to lynch another townie. Yet you sit idly and seem accepting of a Mac lynch despite calling him a townie.
I am not a vocal townie I can't be bothered. But you... You should have acted way differently.


linki @Straw: Straw follow your heart. Search deep inside you and vote either of them. Don't let others make decisions for you. Btw bro MM won't happen today just sayin'
linki 2 @Straw: It could be townies also. We just believe Mac is town.

Mac is town or scum?

Or are you just saying that Jay is scum?

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:

Strawhenge wrote:Jay, I can't find the post I'm referencing wert you. I tried.

I'll help. I know me.

If I can figure out which one you're looking for.

Strawhenge wrote:Why? You want me to vote for who you want me to vote for. Who's not a town read again?

Choutas wrote:linki: Will you shed the fake tears after the lynch? Should I get popcorn? I hardly believe you were that hardcore in keeping him alive. If someone could have deterred that lynch that was you. You started a counterwagon way too late. YOU HEAR ME WAY TOO LATE. Ah yeah there is a smilie for that let me find it. Here

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:

Strawhenge wrote:Why? You want me to vote for who you want me to vote for. Who's not a town read again?

Not only do you refuse to make a decision that will impact the actual lynch result in any meaningful way, you're throwing vague shade at the people who have.

There's zero town in that post. Please show me I'm wrong.

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:Likely 6 mafia left and definitely 1 SK. 15 vs 6 vs 1, I believe, which is dire.

Can't afford any more bullsuit. One easy way to ensure cooperation is to state who we don't have any interest in lynching on Day 6. Process of elimination based on consensus, modified individually as necessary based on who everyone trusts and doesn't trust.

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:It's not like I built a huge case on Black Rock and then repeatedly called for her lynch throughout the day phase or anything. It's not like I literally wrote my dissertation on The Case Against MacDougall in response to Ricochet or anything.

Everything you're accusing me of is exactly the opposite of what has happened in this thread.

Strawhenge wrote:

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:

Strawhenge wrote:Why? You want me to vote for who you want me to vote for. Who's not a town read again?

Not only do you refuse to make a decision that will impact the actual lynch result in any meaningful way, you're throwing vague shade at the people who have.

There's zero town in that post. Please show me I'm wrong.

Here's where I'm standing:

1. I vote for the person I think is scummiest.

2. The vote is between two people who may be scum, but I'm not sure of yet.

3. I start getting a lot of pressure to change my vote in order to save a guy who I'm not sure about.

Of course I'm going to start think I'm being manipulated. I've never been pressured to change my vote against someone who wasn't leading in votes before, nor can I remember any player receiving such pressure. I don't trust it.

Strawhenge wrote:Here's where I'm standing:

1. I vote for the person I think is scummiest.

2. The vote is between two people who may be scum, but I'm not sure of yet.

3. I start getting a lot of pressure to change my vote in order to save a guy who I'm not sure about.

Of course I'm going to start think I'm being manipulated. I've never been pressured to change my vote against someone who wasn't leading in votes before, nor can I remember any player receiving such pressure. I don't trust it.

Strawhenge wrote:

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:It's not like I built a huge case on Black Rock and then repeatedly called for her lynch throughout the day phase or anything. It's not like I literally wrote my dissertation on The Case Against MacDougall in response to Ricochet or anything.

Everything you're accusing me of is exactly the opposite of what has happened in this thread.

So why aren't you still rallying for Black Rock's lynch? Why are you trying to get people to lynch Diiny, if you think Black Rock is scum?

Choutas wrote:linki: and you voted for Diiny last. OK bro let's see when the game ends who was right.

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:

Strawhenge wrote:Here's where I'm standing:

1. I vote for the person I think is scummiest.

2. The vote is between two people who may be scum, but I'm not sure of yet.

3. I start getting a lot of pressure to change my vote in order to save a guy who I'm not sure about.

Of course I'm going to start think I'm being manipulated. I've never been pressured to change my vote against someone who wasn't leading in votes before, nor can I remember any player receiving such pressure. I don't trust it.

You might have the power to decide who gets lynched this phase. There are two options, and you're more suspicious of one than the other.

You're not totally sold on either. Neither am I.

But I am going to pick a side and pursue a lynch result most in line with my reads.

Why aren't you?

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:

Choutas wrote:linki: and you voted for Diiny last. OK bro let's see when the game ends who was right.

What?

I put Diiny high enough in the tally to make the possibility of saving Mac a reality. How in the world does that suggest I wasn't interested in saving Mac?

You're making no sense.

Strawhenge wrote:Because I'm not sure about either of them! And I've been wrong about everybody in this fucking game!

Choutas wrote:

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:

Choutas wrote:linki: and you voted for Diiny last. OK bro let's see when the game ends who was right.

What?

I put Diiny high enough in the tally to make the possibility of saving Mac a reality. How in the world does that suggest I wasn't interested in saving Mac?

You're making no sense.

By putting you vote early you're putting much more pressure than just calling mac a townie. If you had put it earlier things could have been different

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:

motel room wrote:alrighty, Black Rock

I'd recommend keeping your finger near the trigger in case it doesn't happen.

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:

Strawhenge wrote:Because I'm not sure about either of them! And I've been wrong about everybody in this fucking game!

Nobody is sure about either of them except for the mafia team. If you're more suspicious of Diiny than Mac and have the opportunity to possibly lynch Diiny instead of Mac, it's hard to understand why you wouldn't take that opportunity.

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:

Choutas wrote:

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:

Choutas wrote:linki: and you voted for Diiny last. OK bro let's see when the game ends who was right.

What?

I put Diiny high enough in the tally to make the possibility of saving Mac a reality. How in the world does that suggest I wasn't interested in saving Mac?

You're making no sense.

By putting you vote early you're putting much more pressure than just calling mac a townie. If you had put it earlier things could have been different

I DID. I VOTED FOR DIINY BEFORE YOU DID.

Then motel room and I tried again to generate a Black Rock lynch and got her up to 3 votes. It didn't work out. We both moved back to Diiny. That was the plan all along. Here:

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:

motel room wrote:alrighty, Black Rock

I'd recommend keeping your finger near the trigger in case it doesn't happen.