Re: Arkham Mafia [Day 7]
Posted: Mon Mar 07, 2016 2:52 pm
Bullz, you've always been very wise and I will trust your judgement in this matter. Thank you.
is is someing at should just be e default response to anying I say tbhMatt wrote:Bullz, you've always been very wise and I will trust your judgement in this matter. Thank you.
Anyones points linking me to Sabie are untrue. Because I was not linked to Sabie. Since this is a game of hidden knowledge, it is easy to take almost any supposition and find a way to find evidence for it. But That does not make the case correct. Other people apparently judged it based on the content, and as the person who knows the truth of it, I judged it based on that truth.DharmaHelper wrote:I meant moreso my points not Goldens.
Are you aware of the points I am talking about? This seems like an awfully generic statementS~V~S wrote:Anyones points linking me to Sabie are untrue. Because I was not linked to Sabie. Since this is a game of hidden knowledge, it is easy to take almost any supposition and find a way to find evidence for it. But That does not make the case correct. Other people apparently judged it based on the content, and as the person who knows the truth of it, I judged it based on that truth.DharmaHelper wrote:I meant moreso my points not Goldens.
And there is no truth in it. And that is really all I can say about it. I can go through it point by point and say "Nope" to all of them if you like.
You'd have to ask either of them rather than me.S~V~S wrote:Good Luck with that
You, Golden & Glorfindel, I presume?
It depends on the circumstances. If there were a viable lynch train forming on someone else and it wouldn't look shady for me to vote with it (eg. if I hadn't expressed support for that person before), I might. Especially if Sabie were my only teammate remaining, though I suppose we don't know whether that is the case here.S~V~S wrote:Faraday, would you have tried? I am sure her real teammates did not try.
Dom, if you feel like I'm being hostile toward you, I am sorry. I am trying to be more direct in my posts now because I seem to be experiencing some difficulty in getting my points across. If I appear at all defensive it's because my elimination from this game cannot be good for my team. I don't of course know who of you out there is on my team (although I have a pretty good sense of it in some cases) but I don't see removing a fellow Townie from the game as being in our best interests, If I were an independent, I'd not care remotely as much and wouldn't be putting in the effort I am now to avert an outcome that will only favour our opponents.Dom wrote:I have a few points about this:Glorfindel wrote: You can deny it all you like Dom but your mind was made up. Your most recent post (above) proves that in spades. You've twisted circumstances (such as my availability and legitimate issues I was experiencing) to give credibility to a case that is frankly non-existent. I offerred my G2H reads and I gave them. I've done my best to support my lynch choices with some semblance of arguments but that has not any point been sufficient to quell your suspicions of me. Others have not cooperated with you anywhere near as much as I have and where is your scrutiny of them? As I said earlier, nothing I could say is ever going to convince you. I trust the remainder of the Town can exercise a little logic and objectivity for the vote this Day phase.
1) You've changed your tune from saying that you are grateful for my consideration and cooperation to saying that I am "twisitng circumstances" You only care that I stop pursuing you, not that I find a baddie.
2) I have other suspicions, so don't erase that. I am very suspicious of sprit who has done nothing to cooperate with me.
3) I have brought up and agree with many points against you that you are not even beginning to mention here:
--"obvious civvie"
--Playing the n00b card saying everyone's out to get you because you're new
Glorf, you have taken a quite hostile tone with me. Why?
@MP - my friend, you have gone from defending me at one point saying something to the effect that you would look suspiciously upon anyone who voted for me to advocating my lynching - and all of this seemingly based on a comparison between my playstyle in Star Wars and this game. I'm asking you now to explain what it is precisely that you identified in that comparison to lead you to such an apparent about face - it must surely have been something conclusive to have led you to such a change of heart.MovingPictures07 wrote:No problem, bud!
If you all disagree with me, that's totally fine with me; I'd be happy with a lynch of someone active too, particularly Glorfindel (he's increasingly seeming like his Star Wars self, and his lack of hunting is not convincing me otherwise) and sprityo (though, like others have speculated, it's very possible he's an inmate who's won). I just thought I'd throw my hat in the ring again this time for another inactive lynch. I may or may not go the same way tomorrow though. Just gotta see when I'll have some time to actually put more than a half-assed effort in the game at this point, since hosting is taking up a bunch of time.
Bullzeye wrote:Where are you seeing ree posting curses, DF? I don't ink I've seen any...
Not necessarily, my friend. Firstly, let me say that I'm unsure what you were asking of me earlier. You asked for why I would vote for you without stating any of Golden's case? I've already done that less than a couple of pages ago - you're welcome to go back and read it for yourself. I've slept on this vote overnight and I'm now considering if there might be better options this Day phase. As I've said earlier, I am feeling bad vibes over the Sprityo thing right now so my vote for you is by no means locked in at this point.S~V~S wrote:Good Luck with that
You, Golden & Glorfindel, I presume?
I'm sorry my friend, you have that wrong. The case for my lynching as proposed by MP, Typhoony now, et al has (as far as I can see) been solely not the basis of similarity of tone between My Star Wars game and this with only Juliets (as far as I recall stating that she couldn't see it - which given from the perspective of an outsider in that game I think says volumes). My point here is that it is others that have launched that argument, not me. It isn't true and I'm not going to sit idly by and have that untruth perpetuated unchallenged.S~V~S wrote:Also, you keep trying to reconstrue the points of the suspicion against you into being about your tone in here vs. Star Wars.
I really think it is about your content in this thread. From the time I thought you were being super selective about what you said regarding trusting Zebra and distrusting Matt, I have had you in the back of my mind. That had nothing to do with your tone, although you also tried at that time to say it was about your politeness and tone, and again, it was your content.
DH, I know S~V~S said it didn't matter which points you were talking about but I would like to know. I just reviewed Golden's case and don't know if your points about Sabie and SVS are coming from there or from other points. It would be helpful if you would point me or link me or just describe what bothers you about that subject.DharmaHelper wrote:Are you aware of the points I am talking about? This seems like an awfully generic statementS~V~S wrote:Anyones points linking me to Sabie are untrue. Because I was not linked to Sabie. Since this is a game of hidden knowledge, it is easy to take almost any supposition and find a way to find evidence for it. But That does not make the case correct. Other people apparently judged it based on the content, and as the person who knows the truth of it, I judged it based on that truth.DharmaHelper wrote:I meant moreso my points not Goldens.
And there is no truth in it. And that is really all I can say about it. I can go through it point by point and say "Nope" to all of them if you like.
DharmaHelper wrote:It's mad late and I promise I'll do the legwork of this at some point but check this shit out:
I bet if we cross reference the list of players who voted to go to locations other than the ones sabie went to with the list of say, Mac or Sprityo or w/e voter, we will end up with a pretty meaty case for her teammate(s).
Nah bro I'm voting Golden. He bad.MacDougall wrote:Typhoony u bitch vote for me son
With every post I am finding it increasingly hard to believe you are not bad yourself. This is a case in point from what I'd said earlier. Where is the case for this? What evidence (however thin) is there to support this?Typhoony wrote:Nah bro I'm voting Golden. He bad.MacDougall wrote:Typhoony u bitch vote for me son
If you're a logical player and Glorfindel is a gut player, I'm some sort of turnipy hybrid of the two. I like to play a logical game but at the end of the day I go with my gut. Maybe you see the merits in your case and are convinced by it, but my gut is telling me SVS isn't bad.Golden wrote:
In fact, I will *Vote Sprit* now because I got super bad vibes from him during his whole debacle wi Dom and his frankly bizarre comment about how he'd basically vote himself to save himself. When I said I was considering a vote for him earlier today his only concern was to correct my spelling of his name.Bullzeye wrote:I might vote for Sprit today mainly because his only response to my saying earlier I was inking about it (and possibly his only post today?) was to correct my spelling of his name. Didn't even ask me why I was inking about it - ough tbf I'd have directed him to my post from yesterday where I explained why I was looking at him, Glorf, or a no-show like eFloyd. I'm not 100% ough yet and I've got some time so I'll see how ings progress. Doing some research for a PhD proposal wi is read open in anoer tab so I should be around for a few more hours.
Linki - I wouldn't have tried to save Sabie.
I have not listened toany of them since the second. I know little about this theme, and they pretty much went over my head.DharmaHelper wrote:DharmaHelper wrote:It's mad late and I promise I'll do the legwork of this at some point but check this shit out:
I bet if we cross reference the list of players who voted to go to locations other than the ones sabie went to with the list of say, Mac or Sprityo or w/e voter, we will end up with a pretty meaty case for her teammate(s).
EBWOPBullzeye wrote:In fact, I will *Vote Sprit* now because I got super bad vibes from him during his whole debacle wi Dom and his frankly bizarre comment about how he'd basically vote himself if he didn't have to save himself. When I said I was considering a vote for him earlier today his only concern was to correct my spelling of his name.Bullzeye wrote:I might vote for Sprit today mainly because his only response to my saying earlier I was inking about it (and possibly his only post today?) was to correct my spelling of his name. Didn't even ask me why I was inking about it - ough tbf I'd have directed him to my post from yesterday where I explained why I was looking at him, Glorf, or a no-show like eFloyd. I'm not 100% ough yet and I've got some time so I'll see how ings progress. Doing some research for a PhD proposal wi is read open in anoer tab so I should be around for a few more hours.
Linki - I wouldn't have tried to save Sabie.
I kind of agree with thisMacDougall wrote:Glorfindel and Golden are mafia teammies
Maybe because of things like this:Golden wrote:
You think maybe?Golden wrote:
Town teammies.MacDougall wrote:Glorfindel and Golden are mafia teammies
S~V~S wrote:I have not listened toany of them since the second. I know little about this theme, and they pretty much went over my head.DharmaHelper wrote:DharmaHelper wrote:It's mad late and I promise I'll do the legwork of this at some point but check this shit out:
I bet if we cross reference the list of players who voted to go to locations other than the ones sabie went to with the list of say, Mac or Sprityo or w/e voter, we will end up with a pretty meaty case for her teammate(s).
Have you ever played a decoding game with me? I don't bother with that shit.Another reason I thought the whole "SVS & Sabie coordinated their night poll votes" to be kinda lulz.DharmaHelper wrote:S~V~S wrote:I have not listened toany of them since the second. I know little about this theme, and they pretty much went over my head.DharmaHelper wrote:DharmaHelper wrote:It's mad late and I promise I'll do the legwork of this at some point but check this shit out:
I bet if we cross reference the list of players who voted to go to locations other than the ones sabie went to with the list of say, Mac or Sprityo or w/e voter, we will end up with a pretty meaty case for her teammate(s).