Re: [Day Eight] The Office Mafia
Posted: Tue Jul 19, 2016 11:52 pm
Thank you guys for the kind words. I really appreciate it after this game, because I doubted myself a ton on this one tbh.
Murder, Mayhem, and Mafia
https://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/
I got her lynched Day 2 in Doctor Who (we were both good, and then I got lynched, and subbed in as bad). That's the only time I can think of.JaggedJimmyJay wrote:Has juliets ever been lynched in her life?
You were most definitely a force to be reckoned with, and ironically I would qualify you as the civ MVP AND the Maria's MVP. You had no idea, and I'm terribly sorry I played you like that. Especially after I tried (and failed) to kill you. Kudos to your play this game, sir.DrumBeats wrote:Thank you guys for the kind words. I really appreciate it after this game, because I doubted myself a ton on this one tbh.
I concur. I don't normally name MVPs, but DrumBeats would definitely get the civ title here.Epignosis wrote:Ten times this.JaggedJimmyJay wrote:You did a great job, DrumBeats. It didn't all go your way, but shit happens. Town needed someone to step into the spotlight and try to lead the charge, and you were more than capable in that role. I hope you continue playing on The Syndicate with us, we can use your pro-civilian methodology. You're a fun guy to work with.
That's...hilarious, actually.Dom wrote:I concur. I don't normally name MVPs, but DrumBeats would definitely get the civ title here.Epignosis wrote:Ten times this.JaggedJimmyJay wrote:You did a great job, DrumBeats. It didn't all go your way, but shit happens. Town needed someone to step into the spotlight and try to lead the charge, and you were more than capable in that role. I hope you continue playing on The Syndicate with us, we can use your pro-civilian methodology. You're a fun guy to work with.
Leetic was Toby so Sorsha lost her power.
It really is. You're so far removed that you are no longer fighting for a particular side, and can take off the blinders.indiglo wrote:This was one of the most hilarious games to watch as a deadie. It was so obvious to me (once I got back from my trip & could pay attention to the game again, but then got killed) who the baddie team was. I was laughing hysterically when Scotty got rezzed. I could not believe it. But you know the thing about dead hindsight. It really is easier to see things when you're not in the thick of it. I'm not sure why, but it is. Plus, I knew Epi was lying about being silenced, because I never silenced him! That's one reason I was begging to come back - to call him out.
Drumbeats, I felt you were a gentleman all game, even when things went to pot. And that, to me, is the pinnacle of mafia. Bravo to you, sir.
That was me, bea.bea wrote:I was just always wrong then with all my increased votes?
who was the dundler mifflin rep?
I thought that was an interesting gambit. I wonder if you'll try it again. I think it was definitely worth trying at least once.JaggedJimmyJay wrote:At no point after my death did I regret publicly claiming my independence.
Until the resurrection poll.
Your votes had a 50% chance of being affected by the item. Your vote kept the game going in addition to Timmer's +1 hiding. You got espers lynched.bea wrote:I was just always wrong then with all my increased votes?
who was the dundler mifflin rep?
Oh, THAT was what happened. I thought it was timmer's +1 vote from the day before.Dom wrote:Your votes had a 50% chance of being affected by the item. Your vote kept the game going in addition to Timmer's +1 hiding. You got espers lynched.bea wrote:I was just always wrong then with all my increased votes?
who was the dundler mifflin rep?
Indi-- GLAD to hear it
I wish you luck in that endeavorGolden wrote:Oh, and also - to everyone...
Thanks for a completely drama free game. May the rest of my games as a mod be like my first. I really needed it to be easy right now, so I appreciated it.
Golden wrote:Oh, and also - to everyone...
Thanks for a completely drama free game. May the rest of my games as a mod be like my first. I really needed it to be easy right now, so I appreciated it.
I really didn't know how far I could go discussing items, but I did figure out it was you in there pretty easily. And you said the lanyard I sent you never did anything; I guess that one was a dud.Scotty wrote: The toughest cookie to crack was DFaraday. He didn't want to share anything with me in BTSC, which everyone else did so thoroughly (except timmer, who told me he was Michael and that lynching him would give him "power." So we made sure to not lynch him after that). I figured out DF was Darryl however right after I asked him about items and he answered in some weird metaphorical riddle about not possessing items that it just clicked.
No one ever checked him :/DFaraday wrote:I really didn't know how far I could go discussing items, but I did figure out it was you in there pretty easily. And you said the lanyard I sent you never did anything; I guess that one was a dud.Scotty wrote: The toughest cookie to crack was DFaraday. He didn't want to share anything with me in BTSC, which everyone else did so thoroughly (except timmer, who told me he was Michael and that lynching him would give him "power." So we made sure to not lynch him after that). I figured out DF was Darryl however right after I asked him about items and he answered in some weird metaphorical riddle about not possessing items that it just clicked.
Well I actually lied. I was under the impression that it was good, which is why I so confidently carried out kills, since my lanyard made me unblockable, or so it said. I have no idea if it worked or not, since stanley died so early.DFaraday wrote:I really didn't know how far I could go discussing items, but I did figure out it was you in there pretty easily. And you said the lanyard I sent you never did anything; I guess that one was a dud.Scotty wrote: The toughest cookie to crack was DFaraday. He didn't want to share anything with me in BTSC, which everyone else did so thoroughly (except timmer, who told me he was Michael and that lynching him would give him "power." So we made sure to not lynch him after that). I figured out DF was Darryl however right after I asked him about items and he answered in some weird metaphorical riddle about not possessing items that it just clicked.
I did that just to screw around. I was surprised nobody brought up the fact that I had even posted during the Day phase I claimed I was silenced. Some fun!indiglo wrote: Plus, I knew Epi was lying about being silenced, because I never silenced him! That's one reason I was begging to come back - to call him out.
Heh. No worries :P When I first got BTSC with you, I decided to trust you straight away, it was just easier that way. I did start having my doubts around the time that splints got lynched, but by that time the game already felt hopeless from my end - suspecting you just wasn't worth the energy :P I figured you had outplayed me by that point anyways.Epignosis wrote:Also, Turnip Head, sorry for the bullshit. You know it was just business. I still had a good time talking with you.
I should start listening to my own adviceTurnip Head wrote:Matt, Epi, Lorab, Scotty. Them's the suspects. Likely in that order.
In case I die tonight, I'm not Pam and I know nothing.
I got lynched in Sword of Truth (game by rabbit) because I was "too nice". (I was civ). Timmer led the lynch I think.Epignosis wrote:I got her lynched Day 2 in Doctor Who (we were both good, and then I got lynched, and subbed in as bad). That's the only time I can think of.JaggedJimmyJay wrote:Has juliets ever been lynched in her life?
We were counting on her to vote early since Quin did so to her the previous day. And she delivered. We were around waiting for her to do so and end the day.DFaraday wrote:So when SVS's vote was forced, why did she vote immediately? And baddies, did you just happen to be around at the moment that happened and improvised?
Little did you know I had an item so my vote really was worth more. No mad from me. I was too stressed Irl to have my head in this game.Scotty wrote:That was me, bea.bea wrote:I was just always wrong then with all my increased votes?
who was the dundler mifflin rep?
Please don't be mad at me. I feel horrible and manipulative and I would never behave like that outside of the game.
bea wrote:Little did you know I had an item so my vote really was worth more. No mad from me. I was too stressed Irl to have my head in this game.Scotty wrote:That was me, bea.bea wrote:I was just always wrong then with all my increased votes?
who was the dundler mifflin rep?
Please don't be mad at me. I feel horrible and manipulative and I would never behave like that outside of the game.
As Pam said repeatedly, Pam did not want to check statements about items. Pam wanted to find baddies telling lies.Quin wrote:Okay Dom, would Pam have been able to check my claim that items were in the game, even though I had no idea? Keep in mind it was structured as 'There are items in this game'LoRab wrote:Which is a statement of claim. Unlike the statements you were theorizing one could post to be checked. The quotes contain a factual statement that could be checked, that you knew the answer to, and weren't speculating about.Quin wrote:And you replied with...I'm really just trying to come up with something that hints the importance of not lynching me that can be backed up by a lie detector and also doesn't break the info dumping rule.
Would something like
'Alignment aside, if I am lynched, the mafia will be given a significant advantage over the town in the next night phase.' work?
Dom wrote:That's fine!
Although, Darryl must have been surprised that I guessed that. I honestly had no idea
Yeah, I was signalling Quin with that. And generally, I really DO do what Sorsha quoted, wait till the end. But I wanted Quin to know.Scotty wrote:We were counting on her to vote early since Quin did so to her the previous day. And she delivered. We were around waiting for her to do so and end the day.DFaraday wrote:So when SVS's vote was forced, why did she vote immediately? And baddies, did you just happen to be around at the moment that happened and improvised?
My team wanted to kill Quin the night before but I had this nagging feeling that we needed to lynch him instead. So that was a very pleasant feeling to get that one right.
Assuming that what you can see is all that there is is a fairly common mistake people new to our culture make. We do secrets/items/etc. and may not necessarily disclose them until endgame. So no worries, lol. It was an understandable assumption to make re my vote.DrumBeats wrote:Also, Dom, what happened with SVS's vote then? Was it not forced or was it an item or something?
Also, thanks for hosting Dom!
Oh, and I never had info on you. The only success I had was with Quin, when I checked one of Drums list statements & cleared him. I tried to check you and never succeeded. My opinion that you were bad was total gut. I thought you were incredibly obvious, but apparently I was the only oneEpignosis wrote:The timing and nature of your accusation against me made us think you were an info role, which is why we killed you. We could not risk you getting lynched, your role being revealed, and everyone going back and seeing you accused me.
I should have stuck with my original gut about him. I read him as bad early on, but then once JJJ died, it seemed clear to me that Epi was claiming to be Andy, and that jived with what he later told me in BTSC. I trusted him because the game would have been much more complicated if he was lying :PS~V~S wrote:I am amazed everyone did not know you were bad. I thought you were so obvious, lol. And yeah, I figured that you did not want to risk the reveal. That was why I was surprised more people were not skeptical when I was NKed, or considered discussing my suspects. But well played! I probably would have done the same
You were not the only one who thought Epi was incredibly obvious, lol. But, I mean, he was on my team, so....S~V~S wrote:Oh, and I never had info on you. The only success I had was with Quin, when I checked one of Drums list statements & cleared him. I tried to check you and never succeeded. My opinion that you were bad was total gut. I thought you were incredibly obvious, but apparently I was the only oneEpignosis wrote:The timing and nature of your accusation against me made us think you were an info role, which is why we killed you. We could not risk you getting lynched, your role being revealed, and everyone going back and seeing you accused me.
Thanks Dom, fun while it lasted, and again, congrats winners
You defending me was hilarious.LoRab wrote:You were not the only one who thought Epi was incredibly obvious, lol. But, I mean, he was on my team, so....S~V~S wrote:Oh, and I never had info on you. The only success I had was with Quin, when I checked one of Drums list statements & cleared him. I tried to check you and never succeeded. My opinion that you were bad was total gut. I thought you were incredibly obvious, but apparently I was the only oneEpignosis wrote:The timing and nature of your accusation against me made us think you were an info role, which is why we killed you. We could not risk you getting lynched, your role being revealed, and everyone going back and seeing you accused me.
Thanks Dom, fun while it lasted, and again, congrats winners
Seriously, though. Some of his posting was so overtly baddie, that I'm not sure I'd have believed he was bad if I were a civ in the game, if that makes sense. He isn't usually so blatant.
Also, it was nice being on a team with those who almost always accuse me of being evil, lol.
I got it loud and clear.S~V~S wrote:Yeah, I was signalling Quin with that. And generally, I really DO do what Sorsha quoted, wait till the end. But I wanted Quin to know.Scotty wrote:We were counting on her to vote early since Quin did so to her the previous day. And she delivered. We were around waiting for her to do so and end the day.DFaraday wrote:So when SVS's vote was forced, why did she vote immediately? And baddies, did you just happen to be around at the moment that happened and improvised?
My team wanted to kill Quin the night before but I had this nagging feeling that we needed to lynch him instead. So that was a very pleasant feeling to get that one right.
And such fun!!Epignosis wrote:You defending me was hilarious.LoRab wrote:You were not the only one who thought Epi was incredibly obvious, lol. But, I mean, he was on my team, so....S~V~S wrote:Oh, and I never had info on you. The only success I had was with Quin, when I checked one of Drums list statements & cleared him. I tried to check you and never succeeded. My opinion that you were bad was total gut. I thought you were incredibly obvious, but apparently I was the only oneEpignosis wrote:The timing and nature of your accusation against me made us think you were an info role, which is why we killed you. We could not risk you getting lynched, your role being revealed, and everyone going back and seeing you accused me.
Thanks Dom, fun while it lasted, and again, congrats winners
Seriously, though. Some of his posting was so overtly baddie, that I'm not sure I'd have believed he was bad if I were a civ in the game, if that makes sense. He isn't usually so blatant.
Also, it was nice being on a team with those who almost always accuse me of being evil, lol.
On night five?juliets wrote:Oh, I almost forgot and I apologize if someone already asked it but Dom what was the "event" that happened and why?