Survivor: Mafia [Day 1-3: Mamana Tribe]

#201

I'm guessing it has to do with the day poll. Fishing gets us food (or maybe foraging for coconuts and whatnot?) Winning rewards will get us food too. Going to the well and having a fire gives us water. Resting up (naps in the shelter eg) might give us energy. Just a guess.

Anyone got an idea on this poll?

#202

Elohcin wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:Does anyone think they'll end up too Hungry/Tired/Thirsty to compete tomorrow?
I am guess I will be fine for Day 2. However, I PMed the host earlier about this subject and he won't tell me how we gain energy and what not. Do any of you have a clue?

My guess is our performance in the polls (fire/food/shelter) helps. Which is fine since we got a good fire and some decent shelter. For the record if it were up to me I would have caught more fish. :P

#203

Golden wrote:I'm guessing it has to do with the day poll. Fishing gets us food (or maybe foraging for coconuts and whatnot?) Winning rewards will get us food too. Going to the well and having a fire gives us water. Resting up (naps in the shelter eg) might give us energy. Just a guess.

Anyone got an idea on this poll?

Possible it's just a placeholder. Also possible that it gives boons/bonuses to stats or to the next challenge.

#204

DharmaHelper wrote:
Elohcin wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:Does anyone think they'll end up too Hungry/Tired/Thirsty to compete tomorrow?
I am guess I will be fine for Day 2. However, I PMed the host earlier about this subject and he won't tell me how we gain energy and what not. Do any of you have a clue?
My guess is our performance in the polls (fire/food/shelter) helps. Which is fine since we got a good fire and some decent shelter. For the record if it were up to me I would have caught more fish. :P

If it were up to me I would have caught some fish. Perhaps we need to be smarter about our actual game characters and their skills, I dunno.

#205

Elohcin wrote:Would anyone like to share if they gained BTSC with someone and who those BTSC teams are?

I didn't gain BTSC with anyone.

#206

insertnamehere wrote:
Elohcin wrote:Would anyone like to share if they gained BTSC with someone and who those BTSC teams are?
I didn't gain BTSC with anyone.

Seems I whiffed on both of my BTSC picks as well, so to remedy that I have a solution:

Every King worth his salt listens carefully to his subjects. As your King, that's what I intend to do. So starting next BTSC cycle, I'd like to make a proposal. I will hold Court on a first come first serve basis, to hear the concerns of my people. If you wish to come before the King and speak your mind, you may do so.

To ensure that I can speak with you, I'd ask that anyone interested in this offer say so in the thread. I will take two names per night and make them my picks for BTSC. All you have to do is name me as one of your picks, and boom. The line of communication is open.

#207

I whiffed as well. Is there any problem with agreeing an approach to btsc? I'd really like to get btsc with some of our newbies.

#208

Golden wrote:I whiffed as well. Is there any problem with agreeing an approach to btsc? I'd really like to get btsc with some of our newbies.

When I asked, I was told it was kosher to coordinate.

#209

I wouldn't mind having BTSC with you, DH, and with anyone else who requests it of me.

Mainly, I'm just lonely.

#210

Oh to be a fly on the wall at tonight's Tribal Council

#211

DharmaHelper wrote:Oh to be a fly on the wall at tonight's Tribal Council

#212

Marmot wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:Oh to be a fly on the wall at tonight's Tribal Council

Yall please put all the juicy parts in the night post.

#213

DharmaHelper wrote:Oh to be a fly on the wall at tonight's Tribal Council

That would be a good reward.

#214

Golden wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:Oh to be a fly on the wall at tonight's Tribal Council
That would be a good reward.

Wooo-boy, the kind of fun I would have getting a seat at one of their tribals.

#215

It dawns on me that Jeff didn't tell us we have fire....so, are we sitting in the dark and possible cold, with no way to cook or boil water to make it drinkable?

#216

LoRab wrote:It dawns on me that Jeff didn't tell us we have fire....so, are we sitting in the dark and possible cold, with no way to cook or boil water to make it drinkable?

He did, he said a spark turned into a roaring flame.

Oy, Jeff, did we get flint for winning the first challenge too? That's normal on the show. The other tribe gets flint when they get fire at tribal council.

#217

LoRab wrote:It dawns on me that Jeff didn't tell us we have fire....so, are we sitting in the dark and possible cold, with no way to cook or boil water to make it drinkable?

We're good on the fire. From a host post:

Elo and Wilgy worked on the fire, and barely eeked out a spark which grew into a nice fire!

#218

Golden wrote:
LoRab wrote:It dawns on me that Jeff didn't tell us we have fire....so, are we sitting in the dark and possible cold, with no way to cook or boil water to make it drinkable?
He did, he said a spark turned into a roaring flame.

Oy, Jeff, did we get flint for winning the first challenge too? That's normal on the show. The other tribe gets flint when they get fire at tribal council.

You did not receive flint.

#219

I'm bored and thinking about the Tribal Council vote. It would be a tragic miscalculation if they voted for anyone other than DFaraday, but I can't shake the feeling that we might see a shocker. Would they be so bold as to vote out MP?

#220

insertnamehere wrote:I wouldn't mind having BTSC with you, DH, and with anyone else who requests it of me.

Mainly, I'm just lonely.

I'll pencil you in for Night 2.

#221

DharmaHelper wrote:
LoRab wrote:It dawns on me that Jeff didn't tell us we have fire....so, are we sitting in the dark and possible cold, with no way to cook or boil water to make it drinkable?
We're good on the fire. From a host post:

Elo and Wilgy worked on the fire, and barely eeked out a spark which grew into a nice fire!

Totally missed that. Thanks.

DharmaHelper wrote:I'm bored and thinking about the Tribal Council vote. It would be a tragic miscalculation if they voted for anyone other than DFaraday, but I can't shake the feeling that we might see a shocker. Would they be so bold as to vote out MP?

I mean, we don't know what's happened in conversation in their thread. But, it does seem likely that DF will go, based on what we know.

#222

Alright, excellent job all around! I may not have understood what was going on, but I do understand winning, and I do know how important momentum is to Survivor. Now that we have the advantage, we should press it—we'll have the opportunity to rest a player every day, so we should use the more energy-intensive options in future challenges.

Speaking of energy, voting sustenance in the poll. That's what you need to achieve anything else in life.

#223

Boomslang wrote:Alright, excellent job all around! I may not have understood what was going on, but I do understand winning, and I do know how important momentum is to Survivor. Now that we have the advantage, we should press it—we'll have the opportunity to rest a player every day, so we should use the more energy-intensive options in future challenges.

Speaking of energy, voting sustenance in the poll. That's what you need to achieve anything else in life.

Hope you're ready to step up next challenge man.

#224

DharmaHelper wrote:
Boomslang wrote:Alright, excellent job all around! I may not have understood what was going on, but I do understand winning, and I do know how important momentum is to Survivor. Now that we have the advantage, we should press it—we'll have the opportunity to rest a player every day, so we should use the more energy-intensive options in future challenges.

Speaking of energy, voting sustenance in the poll. That's what you need to achieve anything else in life.
Hope you're ready to step up next challenge man.

Speaking of stepping up, how's about you explain what happened with the puzzle, like you said you were going to do several pages ago?

#225

Boomslang wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:
Boomslang wrote:Alright, excellent job all around! I may not have understood what was going on, but I do understand winning, and I do know how important momentum is to Survivor. Now that we have the advantage, we should press it—we'll have the opportunity to rest a player every day, so we should use the more energy-intensive options in future challenges.

Speaking of energy, voting sustenance in the poll. That's what you need to achieve anything else in life.
Hope you're ready to step up next challenge man.
Speaking of stepping up, how's about you explain what happened with the puzzle, like you said you were going to do several pages ago?

#226

Boomslang wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:
Boomslang wrote:Alright, excellent job all around! I may not have understood what was going on, but I do understand winning, and I do know how important momentum is to Survivor. Now that we have the advantage, we should press it—we'll have the opportunity to rest a player every day, so we should use the more energy-intensive options in future challenges.

Speaking of energy, voting sustenance in the poll. That's what you need to achieve anything else in life.
Hope you're ready to step up next challenge man.
Speaking of stepping up, how's about you explain what happened with the puzzle, like you said you were going to do several pages ago?

*overly dramatic shocked face*

#227

Boomslang wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:
Boomslang wrote:Alright, excellent job all around! I may not have understood what was going on, but I do understand winning, and I do know how important momentum is to Survivor. Now that we have the advantage, we should press it—we'll have the opportunity to rest a player every day, so we should use the more energy-intensive options in future challenges.

Speaking of energy, voting sustenance in the poll. That's what you need to achieve anything else in life.
Hope you're ready to step up next challenge man.
Speaking of stepping up, how's about you explain what happened with the puzzle, like you said you were going to do several pages ago?

I'd be glad to. I was thinking we might go to tribal so I was saving it for that event, but Now that we're not, and you asked so politely:

I asked a question to get clarification on the parameters of the puzzle that was answered imprecisely, so I was working to solve a puzzle that I had incomplete information on, and as a result I got caught up in the wrong path.

Fortunately I had the good sense to pull back.

#228

DharmaHelper wrote:
Boomslang wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:
Boomslang wrote:Alright, excellent job all around! I may not have understood what was going on, but I do understand winning, and I do know how important momentum is to Survivor. Now that we have the advantage, we should press it—we'll have the opportunity to rest a player every day, so we should use the more energy-intensive options in future challenges.

Speaking of energy, voting sustenance in the poll. That's what you need to achieve anything else in life.
Hope you're ready to step up next challenge man.
Speaking of stepping up, how's about you explain what happened with the puzzle, like you said you were going to do several pages ago?

I'd be glad to. I was thinking we might go to tribal so I was saving it for that event, but Now that we're not, and you asked so politely:

I asked a question to get clarification on the parameters of the puzzle that was answered imprecisely, so I was working to solve a puzzle that I had incomplete information on, and as a result I got caught up in the wrong path.

Fortunately I had the good sense to pull back.

Lovely, thanks much for the clarity. Always nice to see the proper level of humility from those who would establish themselves as leaders.

#229

I can see how that would happen.

I immediately asked a number of questions as well. Then I realised I didn't need the answers to any of them. Scotty had given all the information I needed, but it wasn't immediately apparent (especially since I didn't know what a 'quart' was.)

It so happened that I was very familiar with the type of puzzle, as well. I had no issues with how I would go about solving it, but if I hadn't come across it before, it would have been much harder.

#230

Who wants my second Night 2 BTSC slot?

#231

DharmaHelper wrote:Who wants my second Night 2 BTSC slot?

I mean, if no one is going to claim it....

#232

DharmaHelper wrote:Who wants my second Night 2 BTSC slot?

I mean, if no one is going to claim it....

#233

Episode 2: “Just a Leg Up On the Competition”

After a mostly relaxing night filled with congratulations and high hopes, Mamana learned through Treemail of the other team’s upheavel.

Sig was the first player voted out of Survivor: Mafia!

He was:

Spoiler: show

It is now Day 2. Day will end in 24 hours at Midnight, EST.

#234

Challenge #2: Let’s Rock [Willpower]

Team REWARD, no immunity

One random player will have to go twice today on the tribe with 8 people. I have randomly drawn for this person and it is Quin.

For each round, one player will square off against a player on the other team. Players are playing for cumulative rewards- you leave with what you win.

Each player is given 2 rocks- yellow and black- to choose from and place in a bucket. The yellow rock stands for unity and sharing, while the black rock stands for opportunism and selfishness. Players PM the host (or post in their team thread) which rock they wish to place in the bucket.

If a player places a black rock in the bucket while the opponent places a yellow rock in the bucket, the player with the black rock receives 1 point as well as +1 food for him/herself and the player with the yellow rock receives nothing. If both players place their yellow rock in the bucket, both players will return with +1 food for each other person on the tribe (but not themselves), and both will score a point. If both players place their black rock in the bucket, they receive nothing, and score no points for their team. If you do not submit a PM in time, you forfeit your turn, and point automatically goes to the opponent. If neither PM me, neither get a point.

The team with the most points wins fishing gear.
If neither team scores a point, no team will win reward; if both teams become tied with 1 or more points, I will toss a coin for winner. Either way, players leave with any acquired food from the challenge.

Note: you may not share the food you receive in this challenge.

I have drawn for matchups:

DFaraday v Golden
Quin v Boomslang
Sorsha v Opt_Outside
SVS v DrWilgy
Long Con v DharmaHelper
Epignosis v insertnamehere
not sawyer v Elo
MP v speedchuck
Quin v LoRab

Please PM me your choice of rock.

#235

Haha, are you fucking kidding me?

#236

@HOSTS - Do we all PM our choices *now* or are we meant to wait in line?

#237

DharmaHelper wrote:@HOSTS - Do we all PM our choices *now* or are we meant to wait in line?

Also, does this mean no tribal the next night?

#238

Alright, everybody gather 'round while your King gives his decree

First off, what the hell? They voted out sig over the guy that literally cost them the competition? It's obvious to me I was right to assume there's some kind of power play going down. Something is rotten in the state of Denmark my friends, and I for one want no part in it.

This challenge is your typical prisoners dilemma. One option rewards cooperation and compromise, the other punishes greed and aggressiveness.

I urge every last one of you to pick yellow rocks. It may seem like a disadvantage, but I find it very unlikely that the enemy tribe will risk picking black rocks.

That is, if each decision is revealed beforehand, pick all yellow rocks. If we get to see how each person picked as the rounds tick over, we might have to adjust that strategy.

If this isn't a situation in which Tribal Council is at risk, picking all yellow rocks does us no harm.

What do you all think? What do we think about sig's ouster? is Dfaraday some kind of scheming genius or are they all just foolish enough not to punish weak performance?

#239

Although, another fun option might be just to pick all black rocks which would force a coin flip at worst and give us a shitload of points and food at best. His Majesty is willing to take input on this strategy.

#240

I urge every last one of you to pick yellow rocks. It may seem like a disadvantage, but I find it very unlikely that the enemy tribe will risk picking black rocks.

To extrapolate on this:

Their team is down 1 player, gassed, and more than probably experiencing a great deal of conflict at the moment. If you were in their shoes, would you risk losing out on much needed food by picking black rocks?

#241

DharmaHelper wrote:@HOSTS - Do we all PM our choices *now* or are we meant to wait in line?

You may PM me at any point today. The sooner the better, for my records. Those buckets ain't gonna fill themselves!

DharmaHelper wrote:Also, does this mean no tribal the next night?

Tribal council will go as scheduled tonight.

#242

Hmm. No immunity but still tribal. That's ominous.

DharmaHelper wrote:Although, another fun option might be just to pick all black rocks which would force a coin flip at worst and give us a shitload of points and food at best. His Majesty is willing to take input on this strategy.

We could also do half and half.

At any rate, I think we should agree to a strategy.

I also think we should all agree to post our choices in the thread and not do them by PM, to make sure we are all being honest.

#243

Man... with no chance to talk to the other team, this gets very difficult very quickly. Consider the following: they're probably angry at us for winning immunity yesterday, and picking black rocks would be a way for them to get revenge. On the other hand, they have fewer people to gather food, and so may hope to boost their chances by getting food from the challenge.

We have the numbers advantage now; we need food handouts less than they do. If they go all black, and we pick even one yellow rock, we get nothing. Given the lack of ability to establish trust, I'd vote to go all black.

But wait: Scotty, are picks revealed one by one in thread?

#244

Also, I see out glorious leader is idol-hunting. What kind of follower would I be if I didn't follow his lead?

#245

DharmaHelper wrote:
I urge every last one of you to pick yellow rocks. It may seem like a disadvantage, but I find it very unlikely that the enemy tribe will risk picking black rocks.
To extrapolate on this:

Their team is down 1 player, gassed, and more than probably experiencing a great deal of conflict at the moment. If you were in their shoes, would you risk losing out on much needed food by picking black rocks?

My thought too. I was going to say we all vote yellow. I will PM a yellow unless the team decides we ought to do different.

As for the poll....I'll be honest...I need energy so I will take a nap. I am guessing that is how I get it. I must have been awake all night. I promise I was not hanky pankying with Epignosis. I'm loyal to my tribe.

Oh, and anyone want btsc with me tonight? I'm a fun girl.

#246

I'll BTSC with you, Elo. You can tell me what's actually going on with Epi :P

#247

Boomslang wrote:Man... with no chance to talk to the other team, this gets very difficult very quickly. Consider the following: they're probably angry at us for winning immunity yesterday, and picking black rocks would be a way for them to get revenge. On the other hand, they have fewer people to gather food, and so may hope to boost their chances by getting food from the challenge.

We have the numbers advantage now; we need food handouts less than they do. If they go all black, and we pick even one yellow rock, we get nothing. Given the lack of ability to establish trust, I'd vote to go all black.

But wait: Scotty, are picks revealed one by one in thread?

Picks will not be revealed until the End of Day. I would still like to get your picks in on the earlier side, however.

I also made a few mistakes with the poll, so instead of deleting it, I'll just tell you: "Attempt to start a fire" should read as "stoke the fire" and there should be no "attempt to build a shelter". Your shelter is currently built

#248

Boomslang wrote:I'll BTSC with you, Elo. You can tell me what's actually going on with Epi :P

I'll send in your name when I send in my yellow/black choice.

#249

Elo I'll BTSC with you too!

Anyone else want to chat with me tonight?

#250

I'll chat with you, Opt!

YAY FRIENDSHIP

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

There's a box of colored rocks at treemail! (Pick one per person please)