Dethy Game

[Lunalee]

but speed's assessment i can back. it sounds the most logical out of everything.

idk sprit, I think you're scum.

oh?

IF the mafia were faking cop checks, they would want to chose at least someone to read as mafia. Not sure if two is a good idea though, but maybe you thought it was.

But we have a role that necessitates evil checks. Nobody else can be the paranoid cop except for Epi. And if Epi is the paranoid cop, then who is the insane cop?

Epi only checked you. that is not enough data to call him the paranoid cop. you could very easily just be mafia, and epi was the real cop.

[Lunalee]

[VOTE: speedchuck] aubergine

[sprityo]

epi - insane
sprit - para
speed - mafia
luna - naive
soneji - town

i mean........ yeah? it could work

speed "solved" the game too so it could be him driving the town?

If Epi's insane and I'm scum, how did he check me as scum? (Which he indirectly said that he did, by saying he was possibly the paranoid cop and not the naive cop)

!!!! doh! youre right!

i for some reason was thinking of something else

i think it's solved then theres no way epi isnt the paranoid cop

[sprityo]

too many what ifs. this has to be the correct alignment

[VOTE: luna] aubergine

[Lunalee]

sprit, read my last posts, please don't be stupid.

[speedchuck]

but speed's assessment i can back. it sounds the most logical out of everything.

idk sprit, I think you're scum.

oh?

IF the mafia were faking cop checks, they would want to chose at least someone to read as mafia. Not sure if two is a good idea though, but maybe you thought it was.

But we have a role that necessitates evil checks. Nobody else can be the paranoid cop except for Epi. And if Epi is the paranoid cop, then who is the insane cop?

Epi only checked you. that is not enough data to call him the paranoid cop. you could very easily just be mafia, and epi was the real cop.

THEN WHO WAS THE OTHER PARANOID/INSANE COP? You? Nope. Soneji? Nope. Me? Clearly not.

[sprityo]

sprit, read my last posts, please don't be stupid.

speed's right? whos the insane cop? thats the key to solving this

[Lunalee]

fine, if sprit is going to vote me, than my only chance at winning is to [VOTE: sprityo] aubergine

[sprityo]

under your eyes epi has to be paranoid or sane cop which doesnt match up

[sprityo]

time?

[sprityo]

i want luna to present me the list of roles

then i will vote for speed

[Dragon D. Luffy]

time?

A blink.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

speed - luna
luna - sprityo
sprityo - luna

Lunalee - 2
sprityo - 1

[Lunalee]

i want luna to present me the list of roles

then i will vote for speed

i'll try, hang on

[sprityo]

[DharmaHelper]

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Lunalee was lynched. She was:

Spoiler: show

A Civilian Cop

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Speedchuck was killed.

Sprityo (Mafia Goon) won the game!

Thanks for playing!

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Roles:

Lunalee - sane
Soneji - insane
Speedchuck - naive
Epignosis - paranoid
sprityo - mafia

[sprityo]

"how boring...."

[speedchuck]

I have no idea how I missed that possibility.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

I have no idea how I missed that possibility.

My take is that you read "civilian cop" in soneji's flip and assumed he was sane but I'm not sure either.

[sprityo]

quite sorry you guys, i had the game solved by night 1 and knew i had to pit you against eachother

i already knew epi was the paranoid and soneji was insane so i had to remove them to make this work

thank you epi for helping me with that. on top of epi wouldve solved the game had i not killed him

[DharmaHelper]

tfw I would've rolled mafia cop if I got in 2 minutes sooner

[sprityo]

I have no idea how I missed that possibility.

someone's sleeping on the couch tonight

[speedchuck]

That was like the one other possibility, and everything would have to fall perfectly in place for it to come true. 95% chance that I was right.

But chances don't matter.

Well-played, I guess, though I wasn't actually hunting. If I had, maybe I would have done better.

[Lunalee]

I think I got it, but game over now.
option if sprit is scum:
correct cop speed
inverse cop soneji
always civ luna
always scum epi

[speedchuck]

I have no idea how I missed that possibility.

My take is that you read "civilian cop" in soneji's flip and assumed he was sane but I'm not sure either.

I think I misremembered who he checked.

[sprityo]

I think I got it, but game over now.
option if sprit is scum:
correct cop speed
inverse cop soneji
always civ luna
always scum epi

yes! you and speed are interchangeable actually

[sprityo]

I have no idea how I missed that possibility.

My take is that you read "civilian cop" in soneji's flip and assumed he was sane but I'm not sure either.

I think I misremembered who he checked.

IT. WAS. ME!!!!

[Dragon D. Luffy]

That was like the one other possibility, and everything would have to fall perfectly in place for it to come true. 95% chance that I was right.

But chances don't matter.

Well-played, I guess, though I wasn't actually hunting. If I had, maybe I would have done better.

I never do probabilities in dethy.

I just run scenarios and try to confirm people.

[Lunalee]

good game sprit

[sprityo]

That was like the one other possibility, and everything would have to fall perfectly in place for it to come true. 95% chance that I was right.

But chances don't matter.

Well-played, I guess, though I wasn't actually hunting. If I had, maybe I would have done better.

I never do probabilities in dethy.

I just run scenarios and try to confirm people.

correct. the biggest surprise was how no one checked me n1. so the only thing to guess my alignment off of was sonejis town claim and my own claims which naive and paranoid are the easiest to claim

[sprityo]

good game sprit

thank you thank you you guys did super well

[speedchuck]

I have no idea how I missed that possibility.

My take is that you read "civilian cop" in soneji's flip and assumed he was sane but I'm not sure either.

I think I misremembered who he checked.

IT. WAS. ME!!!!

Clearly.

I had it in my head that it was Epi or something. IDK. I screwed up the logic, which is just a great situation to be in.
Happens every time I try to lead town.

[Lunalee]

I have no idea how I missed that possibility.

My take is that you read "civilian cop" in soneji's flip and assumed he was sane but I'm not sure either.

I think I misremembered who he checked.

wait, you mean you didn't make a spread sheet to keep up?

[Epignosis]

quite sorry you guys, i had the game solved by night 1 and knew i had to pit you against eachother

i already knew epi was the paranoid and soneji was insane so i had to remove them to make this work

thank you epi for helping me with that. on top of epi wouldve solved the game had i not killed him

You're welcome, but I really wouldn't have.

This is just another notch in my belt of not sticking with my initial vote. Had I done so, this game would have ended Day 1.

[sprityo]

I have no idea how I missed that possibility.

My take is that you read "civilian cop" in soneji's flip and assumed he was sane but I'm not sure either.

I think I misremembered who he checked.

IT. WAS. ME!!!!

Clearly.

I had it in my head that it was Epi or something. IDK. I screwed up the logic, which is just a great situation to be in.
Happens every time I try to lead town.

dont beat yourself up speed. you even said so yourself that people try to mislead you. I think you got it in your head you had it solved and stopped considering the other way it could go. in this setup all possibilities should be considered

[Epignosis]

The next time I see someone say "GEE EPI YOU'RE NOT HELPING TOWN" I will vote you until Jesus comes back to kill you forever.

[speedchuck]

I have no idea how I missed that possibility.

My take is that you read "civilian cop" in soneji's flip and assumed he was sane but I'm not sure either.

I think I misremembered who he checked.

wait, you mean you didn't make a spread sheet to keep up?

Nope. Clearly that was the mistake. I was in the middle of preparing a document for something else.

I have no idea how I missed that possibility.

My take is that you read "civilian cop" in soneji's flip and assumed he was sane but I'm not sure either.

I think I misremembered who he checked.

IT. WAS. ME!!!!

Clearly.

I had it in my head that it was Epi or something. IDK. I screwed up the logic, which is just a great situation to be in.
Happens every time I try to lead town.

dont beat yourself up speed. you even said so yourself that people try to mislead you. I think you got it in your head you had it solved and stopped considering the other way it could go. in this setup all possibilities should be considered

I tried to consider it, but didn't keep track of everything. I'm pretty beating myself up right now.

Though, to be fair, if I had figured out the one other possibility, I'm not sure which way I would have gone.

[DharmaHelper]

The next time I see someone say "GEE EPI YOU'RE NOT HELPING TOWN" I will vote you until Jesus comes back to kill you forever.

Challenge accepted.

[sprityo]

The next time I see someone say "GEE EPI YOU'RE NOT HELPING TOWN" I will vote you until Jesus comes back to kill you forever.

hee hee hee

if you had just gone along with my plan i wouldve been out of luck for being so active you played yourself this time

[Dragon D. Luffy]

That was like the one other possibility, and everything would have to fall perfectly in place for it to come true. 95% chance that I was right.

But chances don't matter.

Well-played, I guess, though I wasn't actually hunting. If I had, maybe I would have done better.

I never do probabilities in dethy.

I just run scenarios and try to confirm people.

correct. the biggest surprise was how no one checked me n1. so the only thing to guess my alignment off of was sonejis town claim and my own claims which naive and paranoid are the easiest to claim

Epi did.

But he was para so this wouldn't have solved the game. At most would have confirmed him maybe.

[speedchuck]

And lesson learned, I guess.

I need to stop freaking playing burglaries.

[Soneji]

Scumreading>mechanics. Just based off tone in one post I figured out the scum disregarding my results.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

I love how the roles reflect what actually happened.

Soneji called sprityo bad and wanted to lynch him. But nobody listened to him cuz he was clearly insane.

Epi, the paranoid villager, brought the torches and pitchforks and lynched him.

Luna, he sane one, was the only one who knew what was happening.

But Speedchuck, the naive one, was too easily fooled and allowed sprityo the baddie to win.

[Epignosis]

The next time I see someone say "GEE EPI YOU'RE NOT HELPING TOWN" I will vote you until Jesus comes back to kill you forever.

hee hee hee

if you had just gone along with my plan i wouldve been out of luck for being so active you played yourself this time

Your lack of punctuation disturbs me.

[sprityo]

Scumreading>mechanics. Just based off tone in one post I figured out the scum disregarding my results.

which post was that?

[sprityo]

The next time I see someone say "GEE EPI YOU'RE NOT HELPING TOWN" I will vote you until Jesus comes back to kill you forever.

hee hee hee

if you had just gone along with my plan i wouldve been out of luck for being so active you played yourself this time

Your lack of punctuation disturbs me.

im the Turncoat, not the English Teacher

[Epignosis]

I love how the roles reflect what actually happened.

Soneji called sprityo bad and wanted to lynch him. But nobody listened to him cuz he was clearly insane.

Epi, the paranoid villager, brought the torches and pitchforks and lynched him.

Luna, he sane one, was the only one who knew what was happening.

But Speedchuck, the naive one, was too easily fooled and allowed sprityo the baddie to win.

Fun stuff, but not my cup of tea really. I was sitting here trying to figure out how in the world mafia ever wins these things.

At least I now have an answer: speedchuck