1984 Mafia [TOWN WINS]

[MacDougall]

I decided that creature was town at some point, and I am not likely to go back on that, given the scarcity of reads in this game.

Fine. Creature will live.

[Long Con]

I have been pinged by everyone in the game at some point except for Creature and LoMo. The two played with actual (albeit lame) reasons to be scumread.

Esooa has been efforting hard but apparently didn't even read the OP properly. I guess that's kinda townie.

@Made @Long Con @falcon45ca reads on each other?

I feel better about Falcon than made.

[Esooa]

1) Made - voted me, tied me to top wagon, said I was mafia, then was like "lol I never thought Esooa was scum I was baiting people" day 1. I don't know why he does this fps as scum. Lowest town read
4) falcon45ca - he's an easy tone read. Believable derp clear, excited to find mafia, play, etc, which I don't see from him as scum
5) Long Con - mostly an easy tone/demeanor read off day 1 attitude
7) Gavial - would be more inclined to do some dumb fps stuff as mafia? Maybe. He also gave a read on players early into day 1. Comparing to Fallout where he couldn't contribute except mostly fluff
8) lost monkey - if this slot is scum then lol
9) Creature - stated above

[MacDougall]

I forgot about Gavial. Thoughts on Gavial?

[Long Con]

I decided that creature was town at some point, and I am not likely to go back on that, given the scarcity of reads in this game.

Fine. Creature will live.

I'll take that one. That one's on me.

How can you ever know anything for sure about the gavial?

[Esooa]

Esooa has been efforting hard

what..?

[MacDougall]

I decided that creature was town at some point, and I am not likely to go back on that, given the scarcity of reads in this game.

Fine. Creature will live.

I'll take that one. That one's on me.

How can you ever know anything for sure about the gavial?

I'm prone to thunderdoming Gavial and Made here.

[MacDougall]

Esooa has been efforting hard

what..?

comparatively

[MacDougall]

Which of gavial and made have had the more towny reads and attempts to solve?

Gavial right?

[Creature]

I think this game has delved into: who we don't want to win as traitor?

[Esooa]

Which of gavial and made have had the more towny reads and attempts to solve?

Gavial right?

yes

[MacDougall]

@lost monkey why did you vote creature d2?

@Esooa why have you ignored Gavial pushing you?

[Esooa]

well if you're town mafia is proibably lomo or no one

why is LC, Creature etc. etc. etc. town?

easy tone reads. Only thing creature has done is show up EoD1 and actually care. The rest are just easy reads though tbh

Whaaaat. How is this ever real?

you got a problem?

[Esooa]

@lost monkey why did you vote creature d2?

@Esooa why have you ignored Gavial pushing you?

do you think I give a single fuck about any gavial reads lol

[MacDougall]

I think this game has delved into: who we don't want to win as traitor?

its a consideration but if that's what it becomes we will lose to the real one

[MacDougall]

@lost monkey why did you vote creature d2?

@Esooa why have you ignored Gavial pushing you?

do you think I give a single fuck about any gavial reads lol

why do you ignore an agent of chaos trying to string you up?

[Creature]

I think atp I'm fine allowing any of Esooa, Mac, LC and LoMo to win if one of them is a traitor. That should leave Made, falcon and Gavial?

[Esooa]

@lost monkey why did you vote creature d2?

@Esooa why have you ignored Gavial pushing you?

do you think I give a single fuck about any gavial reads lol

why do you ignore an agent of chaos trying to string you up?

do you know Gavial?

[MacDougall]

well if you're town mafia is proibably lomo or no one

why is LC, Creature etc. etc. etc. town?

easy tone reads. Only thing creature has done is show up EoD1 and actually care. The rest are just easy reads though tbh

Whaaaat. How is this ever real?

you got a problem?

Part of me considers you the most suspect person by far and the other part considers you as worthy of just letting skate.

[Creature]

I think atp I'm fine allowing any of Esooa, Mac, LC and LoMo to win if one of them is a traitor. That should leave Made, falcon and Gavial?

Meh, looking at this list maybe it is indeed traitorless

[MacDougall]

@lost monkey why did you vote creature d2?

@Esooa why have you ignored Gavial pushing you?

do you think I give a single fuck about any gavial reads lol

why do you ignore an agent of chaos trying to string you up?

do you know Gavial?

dodged my question two times in a row

yes I do. what of?

[MacDougall]

I think atp I'm fine allowing any of Esooa, Mac, LC and LoMo to win if one of them is a traitor. That should leave Made, falcon and Gavial?

Meh, looking at this list maybe it is indeed traitorless

is that so sir? articulate.

[Esooa]

btw mac if you believe in any capacity that you pushing Crichard is towny you probably should consider that I am literally the reason Marluxion is dead

[Esooa]

@lost monkey why did you vote creature d2?

@Esooa why have you ignored Gavial pushing you?

do you think I give a single fuck about any gavial reads lol

why do you ignore an agent of chaos trying to string you up?

do you know Gavial?

dodged my question two times in a row

yes I do. what of?

no further comments necessary

[Long Con]

I think atp I'm fine allowing any of Esooa, Mac, LC and LoMo to win if one of them is a traitor. That should leave Made, falcon and Gavial?

Why are you ok with allowing LoMo to win as traitor? Isn't that the biggest slap in the face that we could receive?

[Creature]

I think atp I'm fine allowing any of Esooa, Mac, LC and LoMo to win if one of them is a traitor. That should leave Made, falcon and Gavial?

Meh, looking at this list maybe it is indeed traitorless

is that so sir? articulate.

idk, even between my PoE everyone seems uncommited to be traitor

[Creature]

I think atp I'm fine allowing any of Esooa, Mac, LC and LoMo to win if one of them is a traitor. That should leave Made, falcon and Gavial?

Why are you ok with allowing LoMo to win as traitor? Isn't that the biggest slap in the face that we could receive?

If he is traitor that will become a reason to punish any slanker indiscriminately in future games.

[MacDougall]

I think ignoring someone like Gavial coming at you is kinda scummy. You know he's prone to just dropping it cuz he's chaotic. Engaging him just feeds him and is risky. Ignoring him runs the risk of him being mafia though so there is a tendency there. Engaging Gavial when he suspects you is townie because doing so aligns to your town wincon. Ignoring him aligns to a scum one.

[Esooa]

I am town

[MacDougall]

But you are such a hectic omgusser as town....

[Esooa]

But you are such a hectic omgusser as town....

I play however I want binch

[Esooa]

you realize that I have done those exact things as scum and that they actually make scum easier to play. So this entire point is moot

[MacDougall]

the fact that you are doing so bad at convincing me you are town makes me think that you are

[Esooa]

I am town

[falcon45ca]

Also if I am the traitor I just lazily pushed someone actually carrying a town read on me when I probably could have just had whomsoever I wanted chopped including you.

How do we know Esooa is town though?

TBH, we don't know if anyone's town.


There's not 1 single player this game I'd guarantee are town.


Disagree? Agree?

[Gavial]

Also if I am the traitor I just lazily pushed someone actually carrying a town read on me when I probably could have just had whomsoever I wanted chopped including you.

How do we know Esooa is town though?

TBH, we don't know if anyone's town.


There's not 1 single player this game I'd guarantee are town.


Disagree? Agree?

Yes

[Made]

I have been pinged by everyone in the game at some point except for Creature and LoMo. The two played with actual (albeit lame) reasons to be scumread.

Esooa has been efforting hard but apparently didn't even read the OP properly. I guess that's kinda townie.

@Made @Long Con @falcon45ca reads on each other?

After the nk

[Gavial]

Falcon is Town

[Creature]

Is it my time to go?

[Alison]

Start of Day 3

Creature is Thought Police. Flavor coming soon.

[Alison]

Sleep has been enabled.

[Esooa]

[MacDougall]

@Alison you have to update the poll deadline

[Alison]

Done.

[MacDougall]

[VOTE: sleep] aubergine

[falcon45ca]

[VOTE: VOTE SLEEP] aubergine

[Long Con]

Just rolling over like that, eh? Ok, let's see if we can get some redemption from that all-town G-Man game. [VOTE: sleep] aubergine

[Long Con]

I'll just note that a Creature nightkill is more Traitor-indicative.

[falcon45ca]

I'll just note that a Creature nightkill is more Traitor-indicative.

I will take that note.

[VOTE: UNVOTE] aubergine

[falcon45ca]

[VOTE: VOTE MADE] aubergine