Return to “Radiohead Mafia [GAME OVER]”
even if they couldn’t claim i think they would have alluded to it if either were town
yea but there are other ways kills could be stopped. there’s too many unknowns for me to treat him as lock. he doesn’t have the thread presence for it. but i do doubt he’s scum. he’s just not like in the lock tierTimsup2nothin wrote: ↑Sat Sep 05, 2020 4:10 pmRadishes is an uncountered doc claim on a night with no kill though. I kinda have to put him pretty high.
yea dizzy will often just open-3p when he rands itMaster Radishes wrote: ↑Sat Sep 05, 2020 4:33 pm You guys can have this one for free: I believe Dizzy hates being 3P and one time I loosely watched a game where he openly claimed what he was then just sort of slanked till he met his wincon.
well i think we’ll find out about the post capper soon because it very likely can only be nook or jpic. if we find out its neither of them it means it was an undetectable ability. i don’t see the point of thinking too hard about it nowTimsup2nothin wrote: ↑Sat Sep 05, 2020 4:34 pmInterestingly, you provide the perfect example. I've considered "post cap could be a side effect of being watched" and I know you are claim restricted...but I also trust that you'd have said things like "let's not get so wound up in this post cap thing" or supported people saying that it could be just a side effect.Hally wrote: ↑Sat Sep 05, 2020 4:28 pmeven if they couldn’t claim i think they would have alluded to it if either were town
and i don’t think it can be a fake report. that’s not what a report is really. report is like from an investigative i think. sprit was like a tailor basically as far as i can tell
I don't think the wolves sent two people to Mac. I think they sent one and the 3P is the post capper and that the post cap is also a mark for later destruction.
idk it’s not worth thinking about right now. it’s just speculationTimsup2nothin wrote: ↑Sat Sep 05, 2020 4:39 pmTrue. The flip side is that no one has pushed him. If you were a doc (or jail keeper) who protected someone and might also have prevented the kill I know you wouldn't necessarily want to just out for a claim war, but wouldn't you at least be probing in Radishes direction here? Near as I can tell everyone just said, "oh, okay, so that's where the kill went, makes sense" and got on to other business.Hally wrote: ↑Sat Sep 05, 2020 4:30 pmyea but there are other ways kills could be stopped. there’s too many unknowns for me to treat him as lock. he doesn’t have the thread presence for it. but i do doubt he’s scum. he’s just not like in the lock tierTimsup2nothin wrote: ↑Sat Sep 05, 2020 4:10 pmRadishes is an uncountered doc claim on a night with no kill though. I kinda have to put him pretty high.
:cheers:Timsup2nothin wrote: ↑Sat Sep 05, 2020 4:42 pmI know. I also volunteered my song title which probably makes me vulnerable to who knows what, and have attracted a number of tunnelers that may well include a town vig that imagines themselves as the hero that stopped Tim's evil master plan so I expect to be having cocktails with you in spec chat where we can really laugh about it.
evennow we’re getting somewhere
this is a good list in the sense that im very confident all scum are in the bottom tier and would happily nuke that entire list tbhstaypositivefriend wrote: ↑Sat Sep 05, 2020 5:42 pm lock town: (i will never vote for these people)
hally (self-explanatory)
mac (self-explanatory)
alison (self-explanatory)
juliets (interactions w/nutella clear her, i don't read her as 3p)
strong town lean:
tutuu - (conviction on her read on me felt incredibly genuine, i doubt she would have this approach as scum/3p)
oddmerta - (frustrating/overly stubborn reads but tonally very pure and good interactions w/the flipped wolves)
poison - (incredibly pure tone and great interactions with the flipped wolves)
weaker town leans:
master radishes - (interactions with sprit imply that they arent teamed, the rest of their game has been invisible to me)
samu - (incredibly pure tone and that's basically it)
tonystarkprime/colin - (pretty good interactions with nutella)
dyachei - (tbh i don't find them that towny but some of their interactions with nutella are indicative of them not being partnered and everyone with meta on dyachei is saying this is their town game)
scummy:
drwigly - (weak interactions w/the flipped wolves and hasn't towntold)
Dyslexicon - (bad interactions & bad tone, would not surprise me if they were a wolf or 3p)
herm - (bad interactions with nutella. like, really bad)
JPIC - (seems transparent to me that this is scum that claimed to investigate mac because they realized they got caught visiting. i have no idea why anyone is townreading him)
nanook - (i actually find this tone slightly more towny than JPIC's but i feel obligated to put him in this tier because of the visit)
long con - (comparatively less scummy than the other people in this tier but hasn't made an impression on me whatsoever)
ted - (this one is probably unpopular but i cant think of a single thing ted has done this game that i would call towny. he just hasn't and i dont understand why he'd be so demotivated as town)
tim: - (i dont love his pushes and a lot of his posts feel like scum aggressively flailing. i do not tr him)
if i had to rank that bottom tier from least scummy to most scummy, it'd be:
long con
ted
dyslexicon
nanook
herm
tim
drwigly
JPIC
ilydyachei wrote: ↑Sun Sep 06, 2020 11:28 am i don't know that i believe wilgy's claim. I do think if a claim like that exists, it can exist alongside my role (and hally's - miss you @Hally )
i don't like that he initially said jpic went nowhere then changed his result
how does that work into the meta mac?
