Then apparently I'm confused too?Kylemii wrote: ↑Tue Dec 05, 2017 12:38 amThat's not actually what happened. Quin was confused (or I was?) about which instance of Quin being asked to name suspects that we were talking about.colonialbob wrote: ↑Tue Dec 05, 2017 12:16 amBecause it's stuff like misrepresenting the context of what Quin was responding too to make his Kyle/Eloh answer sound suspicious/bad,
I thought he was lying and using sloonei to gain civvie cred. My mistake was asking him directly instead of questioning his claims in general. Also, I was apparently wrong anyways.[/quote]or saying Jack wouldn't answer his questions when they were a) dangerously close to asking him to break the rules and b) not alignment indicative.
I still don't understand what you were trying to get out of that questioning, and feel you were using Jack's refusal to answer as evidence he was bad without actually listening to why he was refusing to answer.
who did you hear that from?[/quote]And from what I read of pirates, he was better at making cases than this.
Me, when I told it to myself after replacing into that game.
probably true, but I haven't had to experience it yet.[/quote]allegedlyIf he's been off for a while, I can absolutely see him struggling to make townie-sounding cases as mafia,
it was a pointed question. I asked it that way on purpose.and his response to your "I'm always sincere no matter my alignment" post points that direction as well.
[/quote]what? Quin didn't ask a question, he said "I am very sincere when I play mafia" and you responded with "well you must not ever say people are bad when you're mafia then" which a) is silly and b) seems to support an inability to make authentic-feeling cases when you're mafia.