The Syndicate

I feel the same way about MM

And I will do my best. Same goes for you!

fingersplints wrote:Voting for someone doesn't necessarily prove anything. In BoB everyone swore I wasn't on team Webber because of my votes and you know how that turned out

Re:SVS

fingersplints wrote:I think we need to look into other players than those three, so I don't think it is sidetracking.

I voted those three and Dom, because I feel least civvie about Dom outside of three still. I still feel that Golden is still likely a civvie, just wrong like a bunch of us about bass. I've been playing with Golden since his first Mafia game, and he can't fake that tone. I am more paranoid I am wrong about SVS with each passing day, but not enough to abandon that trust. And I still feel ok about MM. Sorsha is also still on my ok list from golden's vouch, but I have to also consider she could be the one he is wrong about.
Everyone else is leaning civvie/neutral/need to revisit
It's hard for me to articulate without rulebreaking. There is some out of thread stuff I need to mull over some.

Ditto on so many levels.

Sorsha wrote:Derp... Hit submit and didn't want to.

Anyway, if I am correct and if we lynch the player I believe to be the last cabal member that would turn the Gollum into a serial killer. Also, I think the player was able to trick Golden because this player is the trickster so if we do lynch the Gollum or the Trickster who knows what the lynch post will show.

I also know that this is totally side tracking from the Timmer, TH and Matt suspicions that everyone has.... I don't necessarily want to do that but I'm not sure what is more of a priority right now.

Interesting theory... I didn't want to see this either. But, tbh, I've held this possibility in the back of my mind for most of the game. You and Golden have my trust. If you think that is the case, it may be worth going after the Gollum first. It pains me to say this

Still, I think we should go after the other leads first. We, at least know how to avoid the Gollum's kill.

Oh and Matt, I can confirm that my role wasn't included in the lynch post. Like the others said, I don't think LC would make it that obvious.

More catching up later.

What a disappointing result

Sorry Bass.

Voting Timmer, TH, Matt, and myself. Gotta have my self-vote option

I've actually been considering a move to Bass. I, too, think the odds of him being bad are better than Matt's odds. Thinking over everything that's been said, of the 4 that have been mentioned (Timmer, Bass, TH, Matt F), I think Matt is the least likely to actually turn up bad. Still likely, though. Timmer definitely needs to go when the chance arrives. But I'd be willing to hold off on both Matt and TH.

Linki Matt:

Don't make me regret this Moving to Bass.
FWIW, my initial vote on Matt was both a placeholder and a show of my willingness to vote for him. I could still be convinced to move back to him today, but right now I'm just not feeling it.

Matt F.

Votes are changeable

I'm going on a spiritual journey i.e. food coma. I have delicious warm bread pudding in my belly and a smile on my face

I'm going to go with TIMMER again. I think his vote on TH was a bit too obvious and convenient. I'd suggest others do the same

MovingPictures07 wrote:
Draconus wrote:I'm awesome

Nub MP

MovingPictures07 wrote:Posting contests are fun.

No one asked you!!!

I'm more anxious to see the result of a Timmer lynch now that this whole list thing has come up. FWIW I had no knowledge of this list.

Accidentally hit submit early. One sec

Noooooooooo!!! This was not an option on the current poll, so I just picked No.

Interesting to see that no one died for this lynch. I think it's obvious why TH was up for the lunch, but why he survived is another question.
I'm anxious to see the result of a Timmer lynch

Sorsha wrote:
Draconus wrote:Voted B and A because Imma BA
No I'm not
We know :P

Suddenly I'm considering a vote for you

*Great timing*

Placeholder vote Timmer for now. There are a couple people I'd be willing to vote today. I've stated before why I'd be willing to vote Timmer, though

I also agree with MM on holding off on lynching the statue. I'd say we go for the people we suspect are original baddie team members first. Then go from there.

Also, re Tranq being off the poll: What timing you have

Voted B and A because Imma BA

No I'm not

Could be because I already placed my first vote (before LC fixed the poll) but I can't place a second vote.

Tranq wrote:Matt F, do you have any thoughts on MM voting Timmer or on Timmer in general?

Matt F wrote:So I'm going to want to lynch MM again tomorrow probably. Maybe another look at Lorab. And Dom, def Dom.

What does everyone think of Dom?
I had no read on Dom so i went through his posts. He suspects Bass and fingersplints, and is on the fence about most other players.

He went hard against juliets and to a lesser extent Floyd. I don't think he's Cabal.
No mention of Typhoony all game. Mentioned Wilgy a couple of times. Nothing hard that suggests he isn't Circle.

Dom and LoRab have 2 small interactions in the game, both of them agreeing with each other on Mac. Beyond that they don't mention or comment on each other's thoughts. Why not? What's going on with the two of you?

Spoiler: show
LoRab wrote:
MacDougall wrote:
LoRab wrote:i've read between the lines and i agree with dom.
On which point?
that you're bad.

LoRab wrote:
Dom wrote:
LoRab wrote:
MacDougall wrote:Just replying to sorsha and LoRab who seem to think I am some kind of bad guy. I am heaps civ.
Well, gee. That totes convinces me.

And pro-civ is not civ. Are you claiming indy now, too?
He's probably bad.
Yup.
Dom, what are your thoughts on LoRab?
LoRab, what are your thoughts on Dom?

Couldn't he have been recruited later on?

Voting B because no one has picked it yet

RIPIYWG Wilgy. Personally, I think the Trickster theory is likely to be correct here. And I assume if the Cabal were wiped out, we would have been told. So my bet is on Wilgy being a member of the Circle.

DrWilgy wrote:Hmm... Just realized... Whos bonfire should I join?

It appears you're the special guest. Have an apple

Bullzeye wrote:
Draconus wrote:
Bullzeye wrote:
Draconus wrote:RE: Feral Pixie, I'm reading that post as saying that she is a civ aligned indie or just a civ. This is very confusing to me because I now see her as being responsible for the beacon/explosion and Bullzeye's near death (the library trap).
I don't believe the Pixie is responsible for my failed death if she truly is a civ. A baddie must've stolen her ability or something. I definitely 100% think it was a baddie as opposed to an indy who left that note - either Floyd, Luke, JC or their remaining friend whose death I will help happen before this game is over.
You don't think the Pixie could have malicious intentions? What do you think about G9?
I don't think civs can have malicious intentions in general. Specifically, as I believe the note was placed by a member of the team that tried to kill me, then logically a civ cannot have been responsible for it. LC seems to have indicated that the Pixie is a civ. As for G9 I'm not sure of why you think she's responsible for that. Reminder?

I was referring to the Pixie as a potential indie. Obviously if it's a civ role, I don't believe she'd have mal intent.

Bullzeye wrote:
Draconus wrote:RE: Feral Pixie, I'm reading that post as saying that she is a civ aligned indie or just a civ. This is very confusing to me because I now see her as being responsible for the beacon/explosion and Bullzeye's near death (the library trap).
I don't believe the Pixie is responsible for my failed death if she truly is a civ. A baddie must've stolen her ability or something. I definitely 100% think it was a baddie as opposed to an indy who left that note - either Floyd, Luke, JC or their remaining friend whose death I will help happen before this game is over.

You don't think the Pixie could have malicious intentions? What do you think about G9?

LoRab wrote:Also votes can't be changed this round, it would seem.

Thanks for pointing this out. I didn't notice.

I will also be voting wilgy today. I agree with everything being said RE: his death and immediate rez when the night restarted. I can see him being on either team, but it seems more likely here that he would be on the decay team.

RE: Feral Pixie, I'm reading that post as saying that she is a civ aligned indie or just a civ. This is very confusing to me because I now see her as being responsible for the beacon/explosion and Bullzeye's near death (the library trap).

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Draconus wrote:Voting feral pixie. I'm most unsure of that one.

I may not be around much this weekend. I'll be spending time in the city today and then my roommate and I will be playing portal 2 all night. It never gets old
I've been wanting to play the co-op version of that game. I haven't gotten the chance yet.

Let me know what you think of it when you do. It's so good! I enjoy being a troll a little too much when playing with my roommate. I'm pretty sure he won't be playing coops with me for awhile

Voting feral pixie. I'm most unsure of that one.

I may not be around much this weekend. I'll be spending time in the city today and then my roommate and I will be playing portal 2 all night. It never gets old

Awesome! !
And sorry Floyd! Getting lynched as a baddie in your first 3 games is really rough. Please don't let that discourage you. We'd love to have you back

LoRab wrote:I actually find floyd more suspicious with his desire to be replaced. I feel like a newer player who was civ would go with the flow and argue that they weren't bad, but a baddie is more likely to not know how to defend, and steps out. I would consider changing a vote there.

I disagree with this reasoning. I've asked for a replacement several times as a civ in the past. Mostly because of being extremely busy, but also because of feeling disconnected from the game. Being a baddie used to keep me interested more so than being a civ.
Also, I believe Floyd was a baddie in both Talking Heads and Dune, and he didn't ask to be replaced in either of those (to my knowledge).

I figured. Just wanted my thoughts to be out there

I'd be willing to switch my vote back if there are enough others, of course.

Turnip Head wrote:You and SVS voting for Floyd "because he wants out" does not make me feel all warm and fuzzy either. When did we start lynching people because they want to be replaced?

I know this wasn't directed at me, but just wanted to put my side in there. I was comfortable switching to Floyd because I've been tunneling him for awhile now. The fact that he wants to be replaced actually makes it a little harder for me to vote for him. I'd like to see him come back. But I also think there is a baddie there to be lynched. Soooo yeah.

Switching my vote to Floyd. I'm sorry you've been having a rough time. Hopefully you'll get to relax a bit now.

I still think splints would be a good lynch candidate next. I'm convinced she placed that beacon there to lure people to the explosion.

fingersplints wrote:
Turnip Head wrote:
fingersplints wrote:Don't blame you. I haven't been around. I am a civvie though, and hope I am around long enough now to prove it to you.

The beacon sounds interesting

Ripiywg dfaraday and bye juliets. I'm taking a break after this game too so see you around soon
splints what was the purpose of the underlined? It feels like you're talking just to talk
Not talking just to talk. Just recapping a bit on everything I had just read. Idk what to make of it, and I wish I had a better term to describe it then that, but I like to use interesting I think that someone should check it out. Not sure how much there is to speculate on it until we can figure out more though.

"Someone should check it out" ?? Did you see the part where that space on the map blew up?
I'm starting to think that you put the beacon there

Hmm. In the spirit of continuing this instavote and multi-way tie, I'm voting fingersplints.

DF

FWIW I trust MM for map-based reasons and will vouch for what he's saying. Though I won't take it further than that

Also, voted west.

TheFloyd73 wrote:
Draconus wrote:
TheFloyd73 wrote:
Draconus wrote:
TheFloyd73 wrote:I apologise for not paying much attention. I'm voting Juliet's for the moment, but if someone wants to replace me, that's perfectly fine.
Well now I just feel bad
Why's that?
I've been tunneling you.

You doing alright?
I've got exams happening at the moment, having oppressed memories constantly and (song)writer's block.

So yeah, things aren't exactly great.

I'm sorry to hear that, Floyd. I really hope things turn up for you. You are allowed to take breaks from mafia, but we'd love to have you back when you get more free time

TheFloyd73 wrote:
Draconus wrote:
TheFloyd73 wrote:I apologise for not paying much attention. I'm voting Juliet's for the moment, but if someone wants to replace me, that's perfectly fine.
Well now I just feel bad
Why's that?

I've been tunneling you.

You doing alright?

TheFloyd73 wrote:I apologise for not paying much attention. I'm voting Juliet's for the moment, but if someone wants to replace me, that's perfectly fine.

Well now I just feel bad

I started a multi quote post but I lost 2 of my quotes, somehow D'X. I'll use the one that I kept and just reference the others.

DFaraday wrote:
Golden wrote: Why do people think Floyd is bad?
Affinity for Luke, vote for Nutella, Tranq's convenient death, coached-sounding comments...

Although I am starting to think there may be something to the Juliets case, if for no other reason than she's somehow gotten out of being lynched despite being the top discussion point for this long. Still, I feel more strongly about Floyd.

All around ditto.

I think the next quote I had was from Mac re: who he thinks is on what "team." I understand why he would think I'm on "team Juliets." A similar suspicion has been stated by Epi (I believe), and I don't think I could say anything that I haven't said already to defend myself there.

Next was a Dom quote: I, too, thought it was interesting that Mac listed 2 suspects in response to your question, and then places 4 other people (myself included) into baddie team categories

I still don't think a Mac vote is wise, but I'd like to hear more from him on this (keep in mind I haven't fully caught up yet). @Mac - where would you place Dr. W and (__InsertothersuspectherebcImmanubandforgot__) in those 2 team categories?

Next was an SVS quote: I also would like to see this situation move on, so I will be moving my vote to Juliets. NOTE: This is not an attempt to be blendy. This is an attempt to secure a successful lynch so that we can move on. I'd like to lynch Floyd eventually

Dom wrote:So are we gonna lynch Juliets today or nah?

Anyone would be better than voting for Mac again

Matt F wrote:Drac, do you think the person with the Obsidian Dagger killed Epig to frame you or juliets, or do you think you or juliets killed Epig?

I still think it's possible that Timmer killed Epi with the Dagger. Especially after spouting all of that stuff about items not being what they appear to be. I can't say what his thought process was regarding the kill, but he almost seemed apologetic about it

To answer your first question, I don't think anyone was being framed there. At least, I didn't feel framed.

RIPIYWG Typh.

Continuing my tunnel of Floyd

Interesting. I don't think I'll be voting Mac... ever. That shit's too crazy for me. I do feel Mac was genuine towards the end of the vote, re: wanting a few votes but not wanting to take Juliets out of the lead.

I'm a summer kind of guy so I'm voting there.
Linki. Lol

Tranq wrote:
TheFloyd73 wrote:No, I just have no clue what NK means.
NK is a symbol for the nanokelvin, an SI unit of temperature equal to 10−9 kelvins.

Why did you murder me?

Sorsha wrote:If I had two votes I'd go with Floyd. I trust that Tranq knows what he is talking about.
How about a triple lynch this time?

That would be ideal. Lol.

I'm pretty happy with where my vote is today.

Also, I'm sorry folks, I'm going to be even more absent today. I haven't been feeling well at all today, and being sick at work just sucks ass.

< This is about the same pale, sickly look I have right now.

Voting Floyd again.

juliets wrote:
MacDougall wrote:juliets if you were scum who would you defibitely not kill?
I can't even imagine being scum.

The correct answer here was "MacDougall. Because he's my teammate."

Epi

Sig

Canucklehead wrote:
Golden wrote:
Turnip Head wrote:
Canucklehead wrote:Am I supposed to be doing something in this tie-breaker?
Pray to whatever god you believe in.
Justin Trudeau?

This photo looks eerily like a former GM of one of our hotels. It made me chuckle. Lol

Search found 185 matches