The Syndicate

Trice and JJJ? That's awesome to read. Considering how the Wilgy lynch looks in the polls... do you think Boomslang is likely a civ, then? If I picture a baddie team with JJJ, and trice who voted B2B, it looks like that day's lynch was a gimme for them. Boomslang is the Only Person Left Alive I Fee...

Epi is the easy shot here. The same point has been made around twenty times. What answer do you people want epi to give? It's like a rhetorical question and you are hanging him on volume. It's not as though epi gave the reason why ap wasn't bad shortly before the deadline. He did it on day 2. The s...

His only reason for suspecting either me or JJJ is that we are criticizing his baddie-like behavior Am I Bad? I think yes The Tricycle Could Interact With Me in One of Several Ways- He Could Ask Me to Clarify Something, Expound Upon Something, Offer Alternative Explanations for My Observations, or D...

Epig, all people want out of you, and I don't get why you don't get this, are some alternatives. I mean, I said just like you dI'd that many of the cases yesterday were problematic. But that's where it ended for you. You are stubbornly refusing to take the lead in finding better choices and until y...

Way to Characterize My Contributions in a 50 page game you can only point to 3 counterexamples, my characterization stands completely I Have Accurately Pegged Three Civilians in Three Days And Pleaded Against Their Deaths: How Are You Doing? No, you voted to lynch a civilian on day 2. Boomslang is ...

Epignosis wrote: Way to Characterize My Contributions

in a 50 page game you can only point to 3 counterexamples, my characterization stands completely

MovingPictures07 wrote:It would be nice for Epi to do some mafia hunting, even if he's been giving plenty of insightful reasons to find players town.

insightful reasons like "don't lynch boomslang, I'm warning you" and "don't vote AP, I'm warning you"

No One Ever Listens You are in no position to say this. You didn't vote and you didn't offer up a case on anyone. You can stick your thoughts-from-up-on-high somewhere else, man. This is the least helpful and the most sanctimonious I have ever seen you. This, also posts like this don't help in the ...

RIP :\ it would have been nice if he were actually playing the game

Yes but the seems to be a move again. Ap has contributed nothing to the game. MM has contributed in a goofy way that hasn't been very effective. If ap is at 3 votes and mm at 0, why suddenky go for him when ther is no way to say that ap is more worthy to see sick around. It's a word time to start c...

Golden and JJJ both got insanified, we don't know for certain the alignment of insanifiers. Most popular opinion is that there is a good one and a bad one, which would mean that somebody good thinks one of those two is bad (and could be 100% wrong of course), and the other one should be either good...

Also quick note before I go one of the top posters (JJJ, Sloonie, Golden, and MP) is most likely bad, I just have no clue which one it is. :P well sloonei got silenced and we know for certain the silencing role is baddie. So unless it was a baddie self-silence on night 1 (possible but IMO unlikely,...

I'm pretty sure I've played with him before, I want to say Star Wars but not 100% sure, and while AP was a low poster he was present and giving some amount of context. So we have three posts N1 then nothing until Day 3. I could vote here. Somebody linked all his past games here and they all have at...

Here's the complete list of players who posted during night 1 but not night 2: A Person scotty A Person, Epignosis and Lorab missed the night 2 poll (though Lorab posted once and Epignosis posted 7 times). Scotty voted in it. So in the possible situation that Alfothad's kill isn't activated yet and ...

My personal belief, and it seems most likely, is that
1. night 1 kill was from Moya
2. night 2 kill(s?) was/were blocked by rockets fall or static or other powers

50% of his posts**

it also has occurred to me that we have two killing groups, the mafia and the SK. I don't think from the night 1 kill we can tell who performed that action and since one player submits the kill for mafia it could be that the kill submitter was absent. Or we could have had an afk SK, which A person ...

The problem is that he's basically trolling at this point. He's offered literally nothing of relevant in-game value. I'd preferred that he get replaced if he has no interest in playing the game. playing at an infrequent pace is one thing if he's going to try to provide some relevant content, but th...

what does GTH stand for

timmer wrote:Can someone remind me about A Person's usual M.O.? When he's taking on votes and getting eyed does he normally just pop in and post fluff like this?

I don't know but I'm voting for him until I see at least an attempt at finding mafia members

if we were "chatting about it in a back room" I would have just told him to post a correction, because I'm not an idiot

Trice appears to have helped Sig defend his indefensible position simultaneous to Sig defending his own position. (@MM, any thoughts on the timing here? No? Didn't think so, you go on with your bad self) I read trice as directly helping Sig out in real time, as if they were chatting about it in a b...

I'm about to run out the door but I'll post the examples here when I get back

I seriously doubted that timmer would actually get lynched in the phase. :ponder: still doesn't rule out One possible reason I can see for boomslang to vote timmer is if they are teammates, he knows timmer is unlikely to lynched, and wants to dissociate with him. And What Would Rule That Out? a rea...

Boomslang wrote:I seriously doubted that timmer would actually get lynched in the phase.

still doesn't rule out

triceratopzeuhl wrote: One possible reason I can see for boomslang to vote timmer is if they are teammates, he knows timmer is unlikely to lynched, and wants to dissociate with him.

At any rate I don't think anybody has taken a close look at dom's posts since you did on day 1

Wow, of all the days for me to be screwed by traveling. So... two theories. One, my Sig hunch from Day 0/1 may be true. His late actions were scummy as hell. Two, MM is bad and we may have a vote forcer. This is a big hunch, but there is something so freaking odd about Boomslang's vote on me. It ma...

What if, e.g., Sunshine + Gasoline's secret is that night powers targeting one will affect both of them? Or if something in Mladic role (I believe he is probably the mafia insanifier) says "if you target one of a btsc pair it affects both of them" or something along those lines? Maybe. I ...

Who Is Assuming My Judgment is Sound? I already answered this when MP asked Do you think his posts aren't being held to appropriate scrutiny? I think some of them weren't in day 2, yes, though on re-reading I'm having trouble finding specific responses to him - it's more just all the people moving ...

3) I also think that epi's reasoning for AP is ok, but not a slam dunk. Trice said it well. There are three baddies, and the idea that APs voice would decide who was killed doesn't mesh for me. In fact, killing vomps and then moaning about load players is a good way to 'clear yourself'. Nobody Said...

Here's what I'm referencing above: Epi, re-reading sloonei just now I see very little content directed at JJJ. Sloonei has posted about (starting from most recently) Lorab, Scotty, metalmarsh (sort of, retracted later), dom, INH, whilgy. Why specifically did you mention JJJ there? besides that you'r...

MP - several people changed votes off both A Person and Boomslang at Epi's prompting, as far as I could tell to add a point, epi posts in a manner that suggests certainty, I'm just pointing out that what he says deserves as much scrutiny as anybody else. It wasn't even a main point of my post I don...

triceratopzeuhl wrote: MP - several people changed votes off both A Person and Boomslang at Epi's prompting, as far as I could tell

to add a point, epi posts in a manner that suggests certainty, I'm just pointing out that what he says deserves as much scrutiny as anybody else. It wasn't even a main point of my post

@ric at least one mistake I can see in the poll results posted here is that I voted for A Person before changing to boomslang (after either Lorab or Metalmarsh, I forget exactly) just an fyi to anybody using the votes thread that the day 2 results snapshot, as ric says, "is subject to errors&qu...

or it's a passive ability and they were targeted by Golden/Jay. I hadn't thought of that, could be. Speaking of epignosis, he seemed strongly against lynching either A Person or boomslang, and then ended up voting for a civ. This means either his judgments haven't been as sound as some of us have a...

love the host recording though

RIP, looks like I've got some re-evaluating to do

welcome back sloonei, anything you really wanted to say during that day phase?

Also moving over to boom I don't like the case on Wilgy or Mp's last minute switch But...You Don't See the Case on Boomslang............................Your Words what he actually said was that he didn't agree with the case on boomslang, OR the case on wilgy, OR the case on a person (if I read righ...

lol at that 2 line post taking 3 minutes to write because of all the linki

Wow, I missed a lot in a mere 1-2 hours. What's the scoop? Well there's 4 minutes and it seems drwilgy will be the lynch target, due to a few reasons that make sense to me (I haven't changed my vote (yet?) but I think wilgy might flip mafia) linki alex - fair, I didn't remember that. I'm probably w...

What if, e.g., Sunshine + Gasoline's secret is that night powers targeting one will affect both of them? Or if something in Mladic role (I believe he is probably the mafia insanifier) says "if you target one of a btsc pair it affects both of them" or something along those lines? Possible....

triceratopzeuhl wrote:what does ISO stand for?

What if, e.g., Sunshine + Gasoline's secret is that night powers targeting one will affect both of them?

Or if something in Mladic role (I believe he is probably the mafia insanifier) says "if you target one of a btsc pair it affects both of them" or something along those lines?

This is the worst post I've seen from drwilgy: I'm not going to pretend that I've read all of Epi's posts, but what I have read I gut read as bad. but also the fact that sloonei posted suspicions of him yesterday and ended up silenced today could be telling And again? You've not even spoken of me a...

Better than AP's vote train, JJJ faking a curse, or voting for MP for his 927391723th explosion. Because I see several really terrible reasons for vote so far today. MP is the only person who has voted for MP today :P Why did you abandon voting for me or AP? I initially voted for AP, but thought th...

This is the worst post I've seen from drwilgy: I'm not going to pretend that I've read all of Epi's posts, but what I have read I gut read as bad. but also the fact that sloonei posted suspicions of him yesterday and ended up silenced today could be telling And again? You've not even spoken of me at...

sorry I keep accidentally writing whilgy instead of wilgy, makes it a nightmare to search the thread

What's the case behind whilgy? Is there anything more substantial than him jumping on my epignosis vote despite the reason I voted for epi going away? I wish somebody other than the 2 insanified posters had voted for him

linki epi - why are you going to keep it to yourself?

I have to say, if boomslang "wins" (loses) the lynch vote and turns out to be part of a civ btsc pair I'm gonna be pissed. But I still think it's a compelling case against him (and I DON'T think "that would have been a terrible move for baddie boomslang" is a counterargument, nob...

the one sock gif moving out of sync in golden's sig is driving me crazy

Search found 702 matches