The Syndicate

Boogs is still the most suspicious to me.

But I could see llama being bold enough to fall back on a I-would-never-do-that-as-a-baddie argument. But I'm willing to wait that out.

:( And making vague statements about something going on is not going to pass for hunting baddies, Boogs. And I think I might be ready to bring up a llama suspicion again. Time to look back, but lets start with this exchange. If Mongoose had teemmates who knew she would survive a lynch (and knew that...

I've really been rethinking a lot of things, but I am still in the middle of that process. I could see Mongoose being bad, but I think it's best to stick to my previous suspicion.

*votes Boogs

[img]http://s1284.photobucket.com/user/kristinabenham/media/SDC11682_zpsbf8f99c8.jpg.html?filters[user]=140525192&filters[recent]=1&sort=1&o=0[/img] "Yay! I'm an Elf!" - A Self-Portrait. I basically just drew a goofy picture of me and added elf ears, because this is how excited...

If Mongoose had teemmates who knew she would survive a lynch (and knew that surviving a lynch would look suspicious, given our roles), wouldn't they just vote for her to look good? This is the point I was making as well. Ok, that post you quoted got me thinking, and I looked back over the Mongoose ...

RIPIYWG DP :( And I really hope that Dom isn't dead and will be back! Welcome TH again! So glad you're back! And I hope you are still good this time! Smaug just killed 2 nights in a row, and she didn't get lynched. I looked and it doesn't include any info when Smaug kills. But, I have a strong inkl...

I don't know what's going on, but I have one point to make: No one has suggested the possibility that the indy team could be aligned with the full-strength baddie team. If that is the case, we may be scwewed. I don't think anyone has suggested it because, first, it's ridiculously unlikely (it's onl...

here, here, and here.

Hopefully that works. If not, I'll have to wait until I get assistance from Alex or Annie.

Dang it. I'll try to fix that.

Oh my word, I did not intend for this fake silence discussion to keep going and going, but frankly it makes me more suspicious. Because I've pointed out over and over that it's turned into a conversation that is not at all what was originally discussed. Fake silence implies some thought out plan. W...

Oh my word, I did not intend for this fake silence discussion to keep going and going, but frankly it makes me more suspicious. Because I've pointed out over and over that it's turned into a conversation that is not at all what was originally discussed. Fake silence implies some thought out plan. Wh...

I'm for making a stand against the spiders.

Captain Bunny- I can see we are never going to agree on the subject that you will believe me. So it's not worth me trying to appeal to you or respond to you for the time being. So, I'm leaving it at you think I'm a liar right now etc. Onto more important things to talk about, I think again reading ...

It's illogical and makes no sense how I would want to fake being silent Day 2 in order to gain credibility after a Day 1 when I did nothing suspicious to "cover up" or anything to gain that early in the game. It would make perfect sense if someone were to fake being silent after a few day...

I am back (and not dead!), and my absence had nothing to do with wine. :mad: That was seriously the fishiest day/lynch poll I've ever seen. I don't know what's going on, but I have one point to make: No one has suggested the possibility that the indy team could be aligned with the full-strength bad...

Wow what a crazy lynch with no one dying and very interesting to ponder on... I caught up and saw I got some random votes with Lizzy and Hedgeowl... Not sure if those are genuine votes that they found me suspicious or because they were hoping to some how save Mongoose for alterior motives. Nonethel...

I am back (and not dead!), and my absence had nothing to do with wine. :mad: That was seriously the fishiest day/lynch poll I've ever seen. I don't know what's going on, but I have one point to make: No one has suggested the possibility that the indy team could be aligned with the full-strength badd...

I readily acknowledge that this explanation (directly below) is definitely plausable, so I am willing to look elsewhere for now (and need to just stop responding to these unless someone has a specific question). Thank you TH. I think I do almost always get misunderstood. Recently in X Men :/ The pos...

Sorry CBK, apparently I missed your detailed case on Boogs the first time. To me it looked like all the suspicion on him was based on what he was saying about the Wood Elf drink, but I see now you had raised some other points. Here are some of my responses to your post about Boogs. First of all, wh...

I thought DFaraday was among them, and he posted. Right?

Is there anyone out there who says they were silenced on the same day Boogs was silenced? If you were silenced do you know which entity silenced you? Is there anyone who claims the vintner targeted them instead of Boogs on the day he says he was targeted? I'm just trying to understand the boogs sit...

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Captain Bunny Killer wrote:What?
Just the Host' Night Post. You were the first one to visit the elves.

Nothing important.

Oh, haha, I thought you meant I voted, which I haven't.

Speaking of which, I think I'm going to refuse. Hopefully I won't regret that. I'm just a little afraid accepting.

What?

Wow. Good job to the Elo-voters! Hey, I'm actually with Boogs on this one. It looks like we have a choice, which I don't quite understand. If we have to take the one we didn't pack, we wouldn't have to decide whether or not to accept (per the host). But if we do decide, does it mean decide between f...

I going to have to cast my vote now. I have plans with a friend today, and I don't want to forget before I walk out the door. I'm sorry I couldn't contribute to the Elo discussion more. I can only chase one rabbit at a time. ;) And I think that case involves more examination time... that I don't hav...

I have two amendatory notes. 1) Apparently the Daisy suspicion wasn't original, since, as I observed later, you didn't even notice that in thread until MP was dead. 2) When I noted your comment on k4j's wacky post as being your possible thread evidence, I did not mean to say that there was no eviden...

I have a quick second to check in luckily. Okay, so because I decided to try Elohcin over Spacedaisy even though I said I suspect her as well, that makes me bad today? Interesting. Also, if the people who voted on me suspect me as bad, are you suggesting I am on the same Goblin team as MP? That's f...

I have to admit that the arguments for and against Elo (and for and against those who are for and against her :huh: ) are compelling, which means I really don't know at this point, and I'm probably not going to vote for her unless that changes. I've been kind of chasing other leads. I went back and...

I have to admit that the arguments for and against Elo (and for and against those who are for and against her :huh: ) are compelling, which means I really don't know at this point, and I'm probably not going to vote for her unless that changes. I've been kind of chasing other leads. I went back and ...

I am caught up. Now I need to sleep and think about things a little. I have no idea what to think about some of the popular targets (Elohcin and Mongoose). More reading to come...

hobbits can't swim Some hobbits can swim, actually! The Brandybucks in particular are seen as a bit odd by other Shire hobbits because they go so far as to make boats! :overreact: Frodo can because he lived in that area, I believe. Sorry if I'm being a know-it-all, I just couldn't resist dispelling...

hobbits can't swim Some hobbits can swim, actually! The Brandybucks in particular are seen as a bit odd by other Shire hobbits because they go so far as to make boats! :overreact: Frodo can because he lived in that area, I believe. Sorry if I'm being a know-it-all, I just couldn't resist dispelling...

A swing sounds fun, and hobbits can't swim , so swing it is. :) Yeah, but goblins can. Nice try, CBK, but you'll have to do better than that to pull the wool over my eyes! Considering the fact that I haven't read anything for pages and pages, I have no idea if/what you've accused me of. So, nice tr...

A swing sounds fun, and hobbits can't swim, so swing it is.

We had some people over for dinner last night, so now I have several pages to catch up on. Man, this is a chatty night!

Ok, I've been watching both k4j and FZ. Honestly, I am really torn. k4j, I want you to understand that it is not that your explanation is impossible. It's how the explanation was handled. It's that you can't see why it would look suspicious from the outside. Why would you even drop a mysterious hint...

Also, as a public service announcement, I am completely colorblind. I'll try to read between the lines, but feel free to just flat-out tell me if you're being sarcastic.

Before I make my vote. Does anyone but me think Reyway is acting very scummy? You know, the difficult thing about this whole you vs. k4j thing is that I find you more questionable. I mentioned you both last night but focused on k4j, because he was there to question me about it. You, on the other ha...

Yay, I'm caught up! :biggrin: It's been a distracting evening. And I tend to get bogged down in the details and never get around to sharing my thoughts. I found it amusing that k4j and FZ kind of went after each other a couple of pages ago, because I don't trust either of them. I think they both ha...

Yay, I'm caught up! :biggrin: It's been a distracting evening. And I tend to get bogged down in the details and never get around to sharing my thoughts. I found it amusing that k4j and FZ kind of went after each other a couple of pages ago, because I don't trust either of them. I think they both han...

Did anybody like my metal joke? Yes :) This makes sense to me, but I too would like to hear from Daisy. She's still at work and not supposed to be, which means we may not go to the gym and I don't know what's going on. :) I feel like all the distancing theories have included like half the players, ...

I think there might be something to the Daisy/MP thing, but I'd like to hear more from Daisy before coming to a conclusion....[/ot] She's at work and then we might go to the gym. I've been catching up after an exhausting weekend and thinking through everything. There are at least 3 baddie categorie...

Host, maybe this is obvious, but are we pming our guesses?

I chose drink. I would assume that water could be found along the way (and would have to be refilled anyway).

Wow, just got home. This is so INSANELY upsetting to me I can't even express it in words. I was looking forward to this game SO much. Now I won't be able to likely even play a big game on my own site before I start my PhD program. Apparently, I can't ever play without attracting a ton of suspicion ...

Well, I had to catch up and skim over a few of the later posts (and a few things I wanted to respond to, but I'm running out of time). It could just be my predisposition to suspect MP, but he just seems too opportunistic and all over the place and too Captain Obviousish. Then TH and Epi made good po...

Oh, one more thing! I'm going to vote for MP based on how many times he uses the word nefarious throughout this game. :feb: haha, I noticed the same thing :D MovingPictures07, The Nefarious, residing in the Misty Posts and bending all thoughts of suspicion upom Himself, dominating through self-dest...

Usually in big games like these, I sit back and watch for the first few cycles, and then presumably if I'm not eliminated, I start posting more and more. I like to get an idea of the dynamic of the game before I completely dive in. That being said, I agree with FZ. To me it looked like MP was just ...

MovingPictures07, Master Smith of the Eternal Posts of Suspicion

Search found 261 matches