The Syndicate

S~V~S wrote:Um, what?

DH, you were right about LT, but srsly, you need to at least try to explain instead of getting all *sigh* when people want explanations. Especially with a lor of people who don't know you.

I was giving boats a friendly hug, not sighing that nobody is listening. You are listening which I appreciate. I think Droopy's been recruited either by Ziltoid or by way of Zappa/Resident combo.

BoatsBoatsBoats wrote:

S~V~S wrote:Right, so its subjective.

He could have another BS chart. I'd like to see that, even though I don't agree with what he's saying.

Probably.

Except he's probably recruited.

Not voting for Droopy this "lynch" as he's probably recruited.

I don't trust any of you :P

Your list includes people who did not have votes yesterday... I dunno if you get to call out reasoning flaws :P

S~V~S wrote:Aces
DP
Juliets

Are the three people on n=both lists (plus BWT who revealed the secrets, sooo....)

DH, why did you remove JC from your list?

Epig didn't put himself on his own list? Go figure :P

Also I already explained why I removed JC, didn't I? The person she replaced was not very active on nights that Herman was still killing.

Epignosis wrote:Don't forget:

We can now suspect these people of being Herman the Planet Smasher.

AceofSpaces
birdwithteeth11
Boomslang
DisgruntledPorcupine
Dom
Jokreher
juliets

Look at Herman's power: If he receives a single vote, he cannot harm us! Let's make sure all of these people receive at least one vote.

Wrong Epig :P


As the only person on that list to receive a vote Day 6, and since Herman didn't kill Night 6, that makes you Herman.

Sorry, I confused the two of them.

BWT is removed then, leaving DP, Aces, Epig.

S~V~S wrote:

DharmaHelper wrote:So in theory that leaves

Aces
BWT
Epig


And if Herman kills tonight, that leaves Aces and BWT. Fifty fifty shot, in theory.

Why did you remove DP? Did I miss something?

He has the red book. So the theory is he can't be herman because he revealed Herman's power which would only make him more vulnerable.

So in theory that leaves

Aces
BWT
Epig


And if Herman kills tonight, that leaves Aces and BWT. Fifty fifty shot, in theory.

Though actually seeing benthayer's participation before being replaced I guess I can cut JC from that list as well.

juliets wrote:

DharmaHelper wrote:AceofSpaces
birdwithteeth11
DisgruntledPorcupine
Epignosis
juliets -- replaced Benthayer15 - Night 3


All have the potential of being Herman The Planet Smasher based on my research. Which I will not get into because you all seem to hate research.

Point being, if Herman is blocked tonight, statistically speaking Epignosis is probably Herman

Well, I don't hate research and like you, am accustomed to an explanation when I'm brought up as suspicious. What is it that causes you to throw my name out as potentially being Herman?

You've not gotten a vote.

birdwithteeth11 wrote:

DharmaHelper wrote:AceofSpaces
birdwithteeth11
DisgruntledPorcupine
Epignosis
juliets -- replaced Benthayer15 - Night 3


All have the potential of being Herman The Planet Smasher based on my research. Which I will not get into because you all seem to hate research.

Point being, if Herman is blocked tonight, statistically speaking Epignosis is probably Herman

You really think all of them have the potential?

Hint: Who has the red book DH? :P

I suppose that limits your potential slightly. But it could be a double bluff.

Also Boomslang received a vote from Devin on a Day before one of Herman's kills, so it can't be him.

Joke's last post was around Night 3, Herman's been killing up to at least Night 5.

Epignosis wrote:Given the knowledge regarding Herman the Planet Smasher, I went through the past votes. I therefore suspect that these are the only people who can be Herman the Planet Smasher:

AceofSpaces
birdwithteeth11
Boomslang
DisgruntledPorcupine
Dom
Jokreher
juliets

Look at Herman's power: If he receives a single vote, he cannot harm us! Let's make sure all of these people receive at least one vote.

Additionally, I was wondering about why I got targeted by a Residents member but then my name didn't appear in the summary. I went through the roles:

The Sinister Exaggerator – Loves to exaggerate! (Secrets)

Maybe we should compare what is said in the post to what is said in the summary.

I cut out Dom because he replaced Roxy, and I cut out Jokreher because He hasn't posted at all as far as I can see.

AceofSpaces
birdwithteeth11
DisgruntledPorcupine
Epignosis
juliets -- replaced Benthayer15 - Night 3


All have the potential of being Herman The Planet Smasher based on my research. Which I will not get into because you all seem to hate research.

Point being, if Herman is blocked tonight, statistically speaking Epignosis is probably Herman

Well dang nabbit.

Portal 4 is where the party's at. True story.

I'm 100% serious.

Voted for the 4th portal.

I really think Droopy has been recruited.

Voted for Epig as his recent behavior has been rather iffy at best.

reywaS wrote:

DharmaHelper wrote:Droopy is weird, yo.

What are you thinking for this lynch?

Dunno, LT gassed me out, lol. I'd be willing to sit back a bit and listen to everyone else.

Droopy is weird, yo.

S~V~S wrote:

juliets wrote:Wow a lot of things sure do happen here at night in this game.

Illy welcome back, I wasn't here when you left I subbed in for someone whose name started with Ben...And I also hope you are good cause i voted for you.

Kate, Kate, Kate. I had good feelings about you though I can never know for sure or at least until the game ends. :cryingsmilieplease:

Trice, I don't know what to think about your death. RIPIYWG. It almost seemed like Illy's rezz took your life. Dunno though.

Boomslang I don't know whether its good or bad you dodged death

Welcome back accidentally frozen rabbit.

Why do you think Illys rezz took Trices life, but not Kates?

The pairity of the Illy/Trice portion of the posts. and the fact that Herman was the one that killed Kate. If I had to guess.

Why'd you vote for me Aces? What are your thoughts on LT flipping Grey 1?

• Frank Zappa – As a master composer and bandleader, Zappa attempts to find new high-quality musicians to jam with and thus selects one player of his choice every night. If the player he finds is a non-musician, nothing happens. If the player he finds is a musician, something happens. If the player he finds is specifically Captain Beefheart, Zappa and Beefheart additionally gain BTSC for the remainder of the game. If the player he finds is a member of the Residents, something bizarre happens. (Secrets) Zappa is unaware of what actually occurs when he finds a musician, but he does know they are both too busy jamming that night to be concerned or bothered with anything else. If he finds a member of the Residents, a coin is flipped. If tails, nothing happens. If heads, the Residents are made aware that Zappa has come into contact with them and they can choose recruit him or kill him. If they recruit him, Zappa loses all role powers and gains BTSC with the Residents; he naturally switches to their win condition. If they kill him, they all gain automatic lynch protection the subsequent day and automatic night protection the subsequent night. In reality, any time Zappa finds a musician, he protects both himself and that musician from nightkills that night, but inadvertently also role blocks the musician.

• Captain Beefheart – Now abandoned by his entire magic band, all that Captain Beefheart has at his disposal are his rotten fish heads. He throws a fish head at any player of his choice other than himself every night, causing them to stink the entire subsequent day period. He gains BTSC with Frank Zappa if found by him. (Secrets)


If Zappa can get BTSC with the Residents and recruited, and Beefheart can get BTSC with Zappa, it says nothing about Zappa losing BTSC with Beefheart if he's recruited. So is it possible, Mr. Droopy made a slip here, and Beefheart has been recruited to the residents?

MovingPictures07 wrote:

DharmaHelper wrote:Can we take a quick vote to unfreeze rabbit?

Vote=Unfreeze

There is no vote because rabbit is the only option to choose from. I would have held a night poll otherwise, FYI.

Ah ok.

Can we take a quick vote to unfreeze rabbit?

Vote=Unfreeze

Mr. Droopy Cash wrote:Droopy chooses to vote Chaindeath to bring back, as he misses reading chaindeath's posts very much! Droopy wishes more players would participate in third-person chat.

Droopy apparently forgot the whole "Chaindeath is definitely a baddie" discussion.

I'd vote for Illy to come back.

I dunno, really my INH stuff is starting to look a bit insignificant.

I'm quite frightened about picking someone to rezz.

Timmer might be the Mysterious Voice
I'm not quite sure how the -1 poker thing affected votes against me. (Might have been -1 instead of +1 every time someone voted for me, for example)
Might have been a switch involved
Rey's smashing LT in the Night Post might have been a hint at something


These are just a few thoughts as to what might have gone on.

Trice and Epig already voted for Chaindeath

So people asking for chaindeath's rezz then.... thoughts on that?

So does that mean chaindeath was the Blue Eyeball?

I think Frozen Rabbit just can't post or vote or use night powers, but is still technically alive.

I remember someone asking for opinions on that, so there you go.

Also @Dom I agree LT's vote for Rey is odd.

juliets wrote:

Epignosis wrote:

DharmaHelper wrote:Going to go to bed, but before I do I just want to say that my methods may seem whacked out but, obviously, they work.

Luckily =/= obviously.

Is now a good time to remind you DH about how you unmercifully attacked me in West Wing for the whole game even though i was a civv?

Sometimes I'm on point. Sometimes I'm not.

I dunno if luck had anything to do with my LT suspicion Epig.

Anyway, overall pleased with today's result and hopeful that it will lead to a nice result on Day 6.

Going to go to bed, but before I do I just want to say that my methods may seem whacked out but, obviously, they work.

Does anyone know if Boats voted?

Epignosis wrote:

DharmaHelper wrote:Must...exercise...restraint...

You made longwinded arguments that I did not buy into. Sorry. I tried.

But you are safe, are you not? We FINALLY successfully lynched a bad person, and we have more information.

Not restraint against you, restraint against my desire to do a big ol' "Told ya so" dance.

So, I hate to ask for this but does anyone have a vote order?

Must...exercise...restraint...

Epignosis wrote:

DharmaHelper wrote:Did anyone who voted for me apart from INH give a reason, btw?

I voted for you. I did not give a reason.

Would you like one?

It wouldn't hurt.

Did anyone who voted for me apart from INH give a reason, btw?