The Syndicate

Went with Timmer... figure he got overanxious to try and divert Resident attention onto someone.

See, my thing with timmer is he pegged Epig as the Resident's Fanboy just to explain my fervor towards Epig and pin me as a Resident. Now, I'm forced to ask did he do this just to push attention towards someone else as being a resident? Surely (if he were a resident trying to divert attention) he would know he'd be tits up after pushing for a DH lynch that did not yield a resident, especially after using faulty intel.

I don't get it.

Dom wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:
Dom wrote:I'd like to hear DH's thoughts on who we should lynch. (:
I dunno. Timmer seemed pretty content to falsely label me as a Resident using sloppy logic, and sloppy logic is historically a baddie tactic, but there's the no u aspect of it so I doubt people will follow that.

INH also seems pretty close minded in considering me over everyone else. Is it genuine, or is he scared that I plucked him out in the early game and doesn't want me to go back to putting him under the microscope now that things are starting to slow down again. These are the questions.

I'd also take a look at Boomslang, and stuff.
Explain Boomslang.

Boomslang's not one of *my* suspects, I just meant I'd be willing to look at Boomslang should anyone bring anything substantial about him to the table (Epig for example I think was talking about Boom earlier)

He voted for *a* baddie.... In a game with many baddies.

Boomslang wrote:
timmer wrote:I've been pinged a bit by boomslang since I subbed into the game, but can't put my finger on why.

boats has also been a bit odd, but these are players I'm unfamiliar with, so I've been hesitant to pursue those leads until i get a better feel for them.

I lean more towards INH being a civ at this time. Generally he's more talkative and (forgive me, INH) sort of agitated as a baddie. Cool, more quiet inh tends to be good.
Maybe because I went after you based on the evidence accrued by your predecessor, CBK? I would like to point that I've called a lot of the lynches correctly; yeah, I went on the early bandwagons that got civs, but so did everyone.

Erm. Almost everyone.

Dom wrote:I'd like to hear DH's thoughts on who we should lynch. (:

I dunno. Timmer seemed pretty content to falsely label me as a Resident using sloppy logic, and sloppy logic is historically a baddie tactic, but there's the no u aspect of it so I doubt people will follow that.

INH also seems pretty close minded in considering me over everyone else. Is it genuine, or is he scared that I plucked him out in the early game and doesn't want me to go back to putting him under the microscope now that things are starting to slow down again. These are the questions.

I'd also take a look at Boomslang, and stuff.

insertnamehere wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:
insertnamehere wrote:Creepy silence is creepy. However, now we know that there are at the most 3 residents alive.

DH is making me look at him for being so sure that Epig was Herman.

How is that odd?

There was a significant amount of evidence pointing in that direction, IMO.
You persecuted and led a riot against a person who turned out to not be who you said he was.
I think that''s a bit odd.

So, I suppose everyone in this game who persecuted and led riots on say...Vompatti, or Droopy, are also mafia.

timmer wrote:But there are roles that block, and roles that redirect. You chose to ignore all of those possibilities. You made a grey situation black and white. it's not that you were wrong that makes me think you're bad, but that you refused to see the other facets of the Herman puzzle, you just flat out ignored them and stated unequivocally that it was Epig. For whatever reason it is, you needed us to be convinced it was him.

ETA: Oh. LOL, okay I clearly did not know that.

I refuse to see alot of things. Not because I'm a baddie, but because I'm an asshole.

Wait wait wait wait wait wait wait wait wait pump the MOTHER TRUCKIN EYE BROW PLUCKIN BATH TUB RUBBER DUCKIN CORN SHUCKIN BREAKS

viewtopic.php?f=2&t=62&p=3381#p3381

If thats how you want to frame things, go right ahead :P

Forget that Aces and DP did not recieve votes on nights Herman didn't kill, and Epig DID receive votes. Forget that Epig survived during the volcano event that seemed to help Herman. All In-thread evidence that stacked in my head to point me into thinking Epig was Herman. I was wrong, but that happens.

Oh Timmer

insertnamehere wrote:Creepy silence is creepy. However, now we know that there are at the most 3 residents alive.

DH is making me look at him for being so sure that Epig was Herman.

How is that odd?

There was a significant amount of evidence pointing in that direction, IMO.

I'm sorry Epig.

Epig did his whole "fine whatever vote for me" schtick during the volcano event and lo, even though to the best of my knowledge Epig had the votes, DP ends up featured in the post and having survived a lynch.

reywaS wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:Shocker that timmer sides with Epig yet again
Yes, his vote looks odd. Why not put a defense vote on Epig instead of making it a three way tie? He even said that one of the two HAD to be Herman. Why make it a tie with yourself involved rather than put Epig in the lead?

He made it a tie so he and Epig can get rid of DP like they tried to during the volcano event.

Shocker that timmer sides with Epig yet again

Epignosis wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:Show me the data that says you can't be Herman and I'll show you false data.
There are other possible Herman candidates, yet you set upon me, and have been set upon me, again on nothing more than circumstantial evidence.

And yet, even if I were lynched and shown not to be Herman, you admit you would still believe I was Herman. Incredible!

If you were lynched and shown not to be Herman, it'd be a trick.

Show me the data that says you can't be Herman and I'll show you false data.

As a side note, The Truth and rabbit were on the same team, Ziltoids. They were also grouped together in a voting group produced by my research.

How's that for "useless mumbo jumbo"

Would I believe myself? Yes.

My point is never.

reywaS wrote:
Epignosis wrote:Still unconvinced Dharma? What a pity.
what would have unconvinced him?

When the sun rises in the west and sets in the east, then I will be unconvinced.

Excellent vote Boats.

Also, I don't like my vote anymore.

I went with option 3.

I like Option 3

RIP Aces. I genuinely see no point in me holding my vote unless someone has a particularly shocking revelation.

Well.

RIP Me

DharmaHelper wrote:Also it says Johnny Cage silenced Epig...not Herman as indicated in the post.

Noob DH, Epig was silenced twice!

Also it says Johnny Cage silenced Epig...not Herman as indicated in the post.

A holographic version of Herman is not the same thing as Herman.

Three nights Herman doesn't kill, three days Epig gets at least one vote. Seems open and shut to me.

Voted portal 4 because in portal 3 the rent is too damn high.

Epignosis is Herman, I am 95% sure of it.

Voted Epig. Having computer issues :P

My fault, Dom replaced Roxy and I figured Roxy wouldn't be up to being active given her situation.

So yeah.

Anyway, I'm still 80% sure you're actually Herman, so there you go.

Boomslang and Dom got votes on days before Herman killed. Also BWT read the book and shared the info so it's unlikely he's Herman.

DharmaHelper wrote:P.S they are disqualified because on nights that Herman DID kill (i.e was not blocked) They did not receive a vote. Therefore, they are not Herman the Planet Smasher.

If you want to keep casting a wide net to distract from the fact that you are Herman be my guest, but it's not going to be easy if you use false logic.

I mean *they did recieve a vote.

They being everyone on your list except you Aces and DP.

P.S they are disqualified because on nights that Herman DID kill (i.e was not blocked) They did not receive a vote. Therefore, they are not Herman the Planet Smasher.

If you want to keep casting a wide net to distract from the fact that you are Herman be my guest, but it's not going to be easy if you use false logic.

If It looks like a duck, walks like a duck, quacks like a duck, its a duck.

AceofSpaces
birdwithteeth11
Boomslang
DisgruntledPorcupine
Dom

Again, of those people you mentioned only Aces and DP and YOU can possibly be Herman, based on prior voting.

Between the three of you, only one of you had a vote the two nights Herman did not kill. That would be you.

Not being dead is considerably more awesome than being dead.

So I voted for Epig that lynch to confirm if he was Herman or not.

If I die that was my thought process on voting for him because I figured if Herman were blocked Herman could not be blocked twice in a row, but he could be voted for twice in a row so there you go.

I am *THE* shit rey.

Portal 4 is the shit.
I am the shit.
I want to go to portal 4.

Voted for Epignosis.

It is so quiet.

I stick by "probable"

Ziltoid can search for a recruit, and who better to recruit than a confirmed civ? So thats one possibility. Possibility two is that either A) Frank Zappa got BTSC with Droopy and BTSC with the residents, recruiting Droopy by proxy, or B) Beefheart's secret is similar to Zappas and Beefheart is recruited by himself.

Search found 265 matches