The Syndicate

Long Con wrote:

Dom wrote:

Long Con wrote:

Dom wrote:Nice ones, rob!

Yeah, that's some seriously solid Paint skills, eh Dom?

i guess i should have used sarcastic orange.


You used to mentor me in design, remember? I was pretty not good.

I had to come in - Epi was feeling guilty for the credit. You remember packerswes? He became a moderately capable graphics guy despite my expectations.

Long Con wrote:

Dom wrote:Nice ones, rob!

Yeah, that's some seriously solid Paint skills, eh Dom?

sprityo wrote:

Dom wrote:

LoRab wrote:

Dom wrote:I think it's a time/interest thing for her.

When we cohost hamilton, we may be able to convince her to come back...at least for 1 game....

When we host it in like 2 years

*quietly waits two years to play my second mafia setup*

LoRab wrote:

Dom wrote:I think it's a time/interest thing for her.

When we cohost hamilton, we may be able to convince her to come back...at least for 1 game....

LoRab wrote:That's awesome.

Also, speaking of free styling, I kind of want to write Hamilton Mafia.

Golden wrote:

Dom wrote:

S~V~S wrote:I killed a bunch of lurkers in one game, and now whenever any low posters are NKed they al llook at me. I would like a bit more low poster killing around here. It's a public service, but I don't want a ridiculous "SVS kills low posters" conversation in every game.

Next game I don't play, someone kill low posters, K?

You understand why I didn't, right?

Although I think it was potentially just getting to the point where it might have been in your favour to. I think if I were you I might have considered killing them at that point.

S~V~S wrote:I killed a bunch of lurkers in one game, and now whenever any low posters are NKed they al llook at me. I would like a bit more low poster killing around here. It's a public service, but I don't want a ridiculous "SVS kills low posters" conversation in every game.

Next game I don't play, someone kill low posters, K?

DharmaHelper wrote:Did Epi ever post the riddle I gave Equivocate? No? Here:

"The answer to this riddle is the word green. Literally all you have to do is send the Hosts a PM with the word Green in it and you solved it."

DharmaHelper wrote:Us old schoolers been around the block our fair share. We are the Mount Olympus of mafia players.

S~V~S wrote:

Golden wrote:

MovingPictures07 wrote:

Dom wrote:Typh, thank you for the compliment, that really means a lot coming from you. You were one of the first people I watched play mafia and said, "damn he's good".

Same here.

I have never lost my reverence for Typhoony, Tranq and SVS. They are like this triumverate of awesome.

When I am on a team WITH one of them, yeah, otherwise there are other people I would put on that list.

But Thank You for putting me on yours

Linki @DH, yeah this was a pretty old school end game. Except the lurkers weren't dead

S~V~S wrote:

Typhoony wrote:

MovingPictures07 wrote:

Dom wrote:Typh, thank you for the compliment, that really means a lot coming from you. You were one of the first people I watched play mafia and said, "damn he's good".

Same here.

Thanks to you both. That means a lot and I really appreciate it .

Now I can go back into semi-retirement for a bit with a good feeling. Don't expect me to play any big games for a while, work doesn't allow me to keep up in the early stages of the game.

Look forward to seeing you now and then in the future, I am really glad you came back for a time and enjoyed it.

Have fun working xoxo

MacDougall wrote:Dom getting into a shitfight with me when he's bad is now a law.

S~V~S wrote:

Dom wrote:Matt, dom isn't retiring.

Maybe he confused Ricos Black & White avatar with yours? Rico did say HE was retiring.

And tbh, you were flawless this game. I was still a bit hesitant to vote you even with Bullz so sure. Had you been around more to defend the last half of the day, you might have pulled it out.

Typhoony wrote:I agree. You played really well Dom.

If I had been around at the end I would've pushed Lorab harder and defended you. I thought you were civ.

MovingPictures07 wrote:You better not. I think your performance in this game might be the best I've ever seen from you, at least in quite some time. And that says something.

MovingPictures07 wrote:Also, hell of a game played by Dom.

You were my first town read, but then you kept nagging at the back of my brain as if I made a mistake so I started questioning your motives, but then you would seem super genuine again, etc. I could never nail you down.

Bullzeye wrote:

Dom wrote:Wow! Amazing game! Thank you Epi for creating such a fun world. Civvies you kicked ass. Made it very hard for me to see a path to victory. Disappointing that I didn't win, but very good game.

Golden I think it's very clear why I felt so comfortable bussing my team.


DH awesome job with those riddles. My next guess was either gonna be eyeliner or a theater. I blocked you because I suspected you were the riddler but didn't want you to start killing as Epi has hinted might start happening.

I'm sorry you lost. I thought the info I had was pretty straightforward in saying you were Scarecrow. Basically what I was thinking was you, as the Scarecrow, would name a target and name the player they need dead. Then Batman redirects your target to you, and obviously you can't make yourself need yourself dead, so Epi and LC decided to make your target (me) need you dead instead of presumably MP. I just didn't want to be a dick about it so I waited for you to say something I could leap on.

bea wrote: Ya'll should chalk her play up this game as a case study of how a 'nilla civ should play. I kept trying to keep up but couldn't. svs is amazing.

Ricochet wrote:Isn't he like a baddie role magnet, lately?

sig wrote:Dom why did you guys kill me. After the moment we shared in Star Wars you should've let me live. :P


Also thanks for the game Epi and LC it was fun.

LoRab wrote:I am not scarecrow. I realize there is circumstantial evidence but it leads to the wrong conclusion. Dom, I was not throwing shade at you. I was questioning your thinking in order to further discussion. Your overreaction makes me wonder more about you.

Bullzeye wrote:There isn't a huge amount to it, hence the crazy, but I do find it suspicious that "Hey I was scarecrowed last night also anyone who says they've been scarcrowed probably isn't him". It's just a gut feeling mostly for now.

Bullzeye wrote:

Typhoony wrote:I went through LoRabs posts, mostly to see if she could be Falcone. But I hadn't seriously considered LoRab as scarecrow yet... and I think that makes more sense.

- It would explain why MP was scarecrowed later than his failed lynch. She was out of the country for the first couple weeks of the game so not a lot of time to keep up, it would make sense that she had not realized that MP basically outed himself until later on.

Not sure I understand this unless you mean why people weren't targeted to need MP dead? In which case I can't quite remember which day MP was outed so I dunno.

Typhoony wrote:- She never really mentioned any of the Scarecrowed peeps (Golden, Mac, Matt, MP, Bullz or Enrique) until today, when she says Enrique is her top Falcone suspect. She has not pushed this beyone the one post, however.

Well fair enough, this is a reasonable point. She has been something of a lower poster this game though and it's possible the same could be said of others.

Typhoony wrote:- Her top 3 list for Scarecrow on Day 10 was DH/Dom/me, all not scarecrowed at the time. Today, Dom has been scarecrowed, and her gut read for Scarecrow is DH. She seems to now waffle on Dom.

This is a good point.

Typhoony wrote:- There is quite a bit of circumstantial evidence (her saying she thinks Scarecrow is more likely to be a male player) but you could probably find that for anyone who's talked about the Scarecrow so I'm hesitant to look too much into that.

Strictly speaking any given role is more likely to be a male player but I know that's not the point. My argument that Dom is suspicious because of his comments regarding who is or isn't Scarecrow is pretty similar.

I see where you're coming from but I still feel more strongly about Dom.

LoRab wrote:

Dom wrote:The list of players who have not claimed to have been Scarecrow'd.

Bass_the_Clever
DharmaHelper
ekeknat
Equivocate
juliets
Lorab
S~V~S
Typhoony



Now, I think we agree that the inactives cannot be Scarecrow.
DharmaHelper
juliets
Lorab
S~V~S
Typhoony

Of those?
I'd lean DH?

Why limit the list to those names? I mean, I think a lot of scarecrows would either self-target or not use the power one night and claim to have targeted. I think it is very short sighted to limit the list to those who haven't been targeted. I actually think it's a lot more likely that scarecrow is someone who has been targeted (or reports having been targeted).

Clearly, scarecrow is a good player--I can't imagine that a person playing the role the way they have wouldn't make it seem as if they've targeted themselves in the process.

I'd actually say that completely from a probability standpoint (putting aside players and posts), it's probably one of the people who was targeted to have Robin be dead. I mean, 2 players, maybe, but 3? Seems unlikely. And poor strategy. If Robin were to die, then 3 players are off the hook. And I think it better strategy to mainly spread out who to try to have killed.

I think it is also informative to consider who would choose, as far as we know, civ roles to be targets. Scarecrow needs to be a player who would play it from a baddie perspective.

Trying to decide if Dom's comment is short sighted enough to be suspicious. I'm not there yet, but I'm processing.

And trying to think through all of the living players and figuring out who might fit.

DH is still a gut read for this, but for no reason other than gut. But, still.

DharmaHelper wrote:Just pointing out that one of the reasons we lynched a crooked cop last lynch was because there was a general consensus I am not the Scarecrow.

juliets wrote:Bullz - Night 8
DH
Enrique - Night 9
Golden - Night 1
juliets - no
LoRab - no
Mac - Night 4 (?)
Matt - Night 5
MP - Night 7 (?)
SVS - no
Typhoony - no
Dom - Night 10

MP re: your question about 2,3,6 etc. I think the missing ones might be dead people or even possibly the non-posters.

Typhoony wrote:Sure Dom, tell me.

Typhoony wrote:Would Dom not target anyone last night and then claim he's the latest scarecrow victim?
Is that something he thinks would help him?

I agree with svs, I don't think juliets is scarecrow anymore.

DharmaHelper wrote:

Dom wrote:DH?
Enrique?


I agree on that distinction.

What is your question?

Matt wrote:RIP no one.

As for what we should do this phase, I'd rather look for Scarecrow first but if town just wants to get on with it, whatever I guess. I don't suppose there's any way MP would request a mod kill on himself?

S~V~S wrote:Yay for no death. Boo that someone was Scarecrowed.

Do the Scarecrowed people feel comfortable saying which role they are scarecrowed for?

If possible I would rather free up peoples win conditions with a Scarecrow lynch.

I had a thought (that actually woke me up last night, I am so pathetic) but I have to pull some quotes and have to run out the door, so I will do it later.

If anyone has any other thought, now might be a good time to bring your craziest conspiracy theories to the table becasue I think we're talked ourselves into a corner.

LoRab wrote:Yay for no death!!!

Not sure if there is any inner meaning to that night post, but I'm not going to spend too much effort thinking about it.

So...Falcone...my gut is telling me Enrique. Mainly because he came in day 10 to encourage us all to vote scarecrow. This would be a great move for the teammate of Bubbles, who was a likely lynch victim from the outset. A great way to move the lynch direction elsewhere without having to actually defend a teammate.

Golden wrote:

Dom wrote:I think it was an Epi game where the serial killer started off vanilla and started killing after a team was gone.

Which role would be the serial killer here, do you think? I'm not sure I see it likely that this mechanic is in play here. I guess you never know for sure.