The Syndicate

S~V~S wrote:I think it depends on where you live. Lynching accountants in Republican districts would be frowned up moreso than lynching Accountants in Democratic districts. I think before you attempt to lynch an accountant, you check local regulations, and determine who is is in power in your local assembly.

I needed that

Thanks host!

Well carp! I thought the poll lasted until 10:47. I was going to vote Russ, for what it's worth. I remember now, host ran the lynch post early yesterday, didnt he.

yeah, she was my renegade hero in that game!

One time when SVS got recruited and she didnt want to be, she made it obvious that she wasnt going to play ball. I laughed over that. I dont know know if that happens all the time, or if it was a one-time thing. But it doesn't seem to have happened here. I don't think.

I dont know Kate. I thought someone said in the thread that there was definitely a day o recruit, because they read it somewhere. But I havent seen it.

Mainly not one question has been answered by the host to help clear anything up, so civvies can at least know the odds. I mean, we dont even know when Bob recruits. We should know one or the other at least so we could make some kind of educated guess, but no questions were ever answered. So I'm ready to give up, so to speak. Not quit, just give up. I'm a sheep now, hurry up and lead me to the slaughter.

your plan to go ahead and take russ out might be for the best, if Bob doesnt get to recruit again until night 6. I just dont think that could be true if he had a day 0 recruit.

its a weird game, and it has been fun because of how different it is. But, I am growing weary of all the guessing, and the deck being stacked against the civs from the start. The civ roles dont have a killer among them to keep some balance, not criticizing anyone's game here, it is just my feeling on the matter. It was a challenging set-up, but its making me kind of tired, is what I mean. So i'm down for whatever plan we can accomplish, as long as something final happens one way or the other.

Sounds good to me.

I would still rather lynch bob and cover the two minions with a vote if its possible. But I don't see how Russ or mp could possibly be coerced into voting how want

So I'll wait to hear from the guilty and then go with the best plan possible.

I'm agreeable to what everyone decides, but if SVS is agreeable to throw a vote on either Russ or mp, then I'd like to hear from her.

Russti had votes yesterday. There was only one kill. Mp had no votes. I'd guess he is bob.
Yes tell us gut feeling then a case.

So four votes on mp, 1 vote on russti, and 1 vote on the other minion after we figure out who it is?

Some of us are gonna die tonight.

double

ok thanks, so that takes care of that theory then.

oh wait, yesterday Roxy kind of emphatically replied to someone that somebody was NOT Catherine Martell. So that would only mean one of two things. In relation to theory above, Roxy would have to be on that team as well, and I'm not sure she is.

New theory time. What if BWT was actually a possessed Catherine Martell? That would mean that SVS and Russti were on a team with him, and russti or MP or SVS is actually a recruited disco role? But since BWT got lynched their team is down 1 member, so its not game end. How does any of that sound?

SVS, if it was 4/4 yesterday, and I think it must have been, then as soon as a kill is turned in, it will be over, unless roleblocker is really good at his job. Or if it goes into a reset of some kind-

ok, so someone please straighten me out here. Does this mean that MP, Rox, Russti and SVS are bad? Or substitute Vomps for SVS? And why isnt the game over?

well, it would be something if right at the last minute, we find out that the baddies all along were SVS, Russti, Vomps, and Kate, and theyve just been using reverse psychology to get llama out and come out victorious. but no more worrying. voting Llama now.

Kate, I must have missed that as definite proof. So far I havent seen anything that was something to take to the bank. I suspected Roxy earlier in the game, briefly, but then started looking at others. Then I thought you and MP were working off each other, but all the weird things I've noticed, Llama sticks out the most. I gotta go there. Its just too late to rehash everything.

I really hate that minions will be left unvoted, but that was fixed by llama and vomps this mornng, cant do anything about it now.

Kate wrote:

Matahari wrote:You see, it doesnt really matter now anyway. If Llama was Bob, with 5 votes on him, the game won't end. There will still be at least 2 minions unvoted now, so 2 civs will die tonight regardless. I dont see much chance for us to survive. I did think that if the game was going to have a restart, it might be due to killing Bob, but its too late now to win, I'm thinking. And ultimately, it comes down to Vomps and Llama voting so early.

All I want now is to check with svs and see if we should take a chance with covering Vomps, or putting both votes on Llama.

Omg. At least try to cover someone. I didn't realize you were so far gone from where I was hoping. Ok then.


Glad you came back.

Good game baddies. Ill get ya next time!

Glad you nudged me!


But I dont feel good about that post

I'm debating... I should go ahead and vote llama tonight, because I seldom get up early. Then svs could do whatever she thinks is right. I think she said earlier that she wasnt going to trust the players who killed BWT, so maybe she'll put the 5th vote on llama. But I'll wait a bit longer.

You see, it doesnt really matter now anyway. If Llama was Bob, with 5 votes on him, the game won't end. There will still be at least 2 minions unvoted now, so 2 civs will die tonight regardless. I dont see much chance for us to survive. I did think that if the game was going to have a restart, it might be due to killing Bob, but its too late now to win, I'm thinking. And ultimately, it comes down to Vomps and Llama voting so early.

All I want now is to check with svs and see if we should take a chance with covering Vomps, or putting both votes on Llama.

sorry guys, but the people who voted incredibly early today did more to help baddies than the players who waited. so I'm either voting Vomps or llama. Thats my semi-final answer.

Ok, this is my decision. I'm putting a vote on Vomps. Llama or Russ only needs on more vote, right? I'm going to let svs decide who is lying and who isnt. OK?

oddly, I just dont see MP screwing up so much when he is civvie. Plus, after having to miss so much time at the start, he was remarkably well informed and posting all that analytical manure when he came back.... only to start making mistakes?

I really think MP needs a cover vote, and Vomps as well.

ok, I'm going to wait and see what svs makes of the protection hint.

I dont like the mp/roxy vote happening like it did. great staging there, possibly.

But I dont like how llama has mysteriously disappeared to let others speak for him either. And I cant make heads or tails out of that hint. If SVS can see a way that Kate would know *protection* clears llama, I'm ready to listen.

ok, scratch all that.
I'm starting to think one of the voted is not a recruit or Bob either.

ok, if i had to put a cover vote between vomps and kate, and svs had to put a cover between you and rox,
I DONT KNOW. WHY AM I YELLING?

I wish I had been a civvie ninja in this game. You'd all be 6 feet under.

I think MP, Roxy, Kate or Vomps needs a vote. I'll wait to see what SVS thinks. This is now a Kate/Vomps against Roxy/MP duel going and I'm not sure at al what to think-

Protection, Kate? How is that even possible?

Kate give a hint of what it is. It doesnt really matter now anyway.

I'm probably going to have to vote tonight. Late sleeper, if there is not a plan in place I'll just go random or something. I don't know I'll figure something out.

Kate wrote:

Matahari wrote:Since the big push is on to save Llama, I'm going with Bob for him after all. I dont know how, but everyone so far has been trying to save him. If Bob is lynched, its pretty much game over for the baddies. If we dont lynch Bob, then its definately game over for the civvies.

Omg I'm not trying to save llama. I'm not. But there are too few votes to split. Why can't you see that! I ink Russ is a better bet. Mata. Please. Think why I might be reconsidering since the night passed. I think Russ is a better bet. Please. You have asked me to think in this game now I'm asking you.

I'm literally harming my health over this game. Svs can vouch for that whether she is good or bad. I trust No one.

you might have missed my last post Kate.

thellama73 wrote:You mean I've shown my innocent, helpful hand?

I'm envisioning you twirling your mustache right now

How would this work out? Out of the 5 remaining voters, two more votes go on Russti, one on Vomps, one on MP, and one on Kate.

The baddies have already figured out a plan to save Llama, but at least this way, all the question mark players are covered with a vote, and if Ben has been recruited, moving one vote off Russti wont really help him, will it?

thellama73 wrote:

Matahari wrote:Since the big push is on to save Llama, I'm going with Bob for him after all. I dont know how, but everyone so far has been trying to save him. If Bob is lynched, its pretty much game over for the baddies. If we dont lynch Bob, then its definately game over for the civvies.

Not at all true. If you lynch BOB tonight, you have potentially three NKs coming to you. A better strategy is to lynch a recruit, so you only have 2 nks to worry about. Then get Bob after his recruits are whittled down.

Not following your train at all here. Obviously one of us will now be forced to put a vote on vomps, to take care of all the possible known night killers. We just have one more possible baddie, and I'm torn between it being Kate or MP. And this is going to be rather difficult since you 3 have already blatantly shown your hand.

Roxy wrote:I think Vomps and llama are a likely recruited pair. They went from suspecting each other to voting and thinking the same. I am beginning to think they are either throwing a partner under the bus for civ cred or are tying to get us to lynch another civ. I do not trust anything llama is saying or vomps.

MP - I asked that purely to see what llama would say - did you read his response? LOL it was kinda funny.

Linky llama - <3

Linky agains

honestly, the only thing making me really mistrust Russti in with that unholy trio is that he has not tried to defend himself well, and was quite happy to vote the way we suggested. At this point, I'm fairly sure that Kate got recruited, and she is sort of covering for Llama. Unless....one of those weird sub-theories in my head is correct.

Since the big push is on to save Llama, I'm going with Bob for him after all. I dont know how, but everyone so far has been trying to save him. If Bob is lynched, its pretty much game over for the baddies. If we dont lynch Bob, then its definately game over for the civvies.

This is Kate who voted Llama yesterday talking?

kate, I'm having such a hard time buying this about-face.

all the strongest suspects have voted, that leaves 5 of us still to vote and one of the five (maybe 2, depending on whether Russ is bad or isnt) is either a recruit or Bob. Very curious to see how this is going to go

I think that too Roxy, but you know how my mind works. I have all kinds of less strong theories going thru my head. But this late in a game, I guess its always best to stick with the most obvious suspicions.

And, I would love to hear from SVS too, I want to hear her take on things. After that, I want to hear how everyone who hasnt voted yet, thinks the vote should go-

there is no way any of them have survived this long if they had no btsc. they all know who each other are.

thellama73 wrote:Hey, can I just take a moment to say how well everyone is playing this game? Whoever the bad guys are have really excelled at seeming credible. Give yourselves a round of applause.

agreed. there has been some really good play going on, and alot of smooth talking.

Roxy wrote:Idk why llama - it's just a vibe thing - it's how I play. You have been coming up with these wild lynch plans that no one agrees with except Vomps. You kept saying I was a recruit when it was quite impossible. You tried so hard to throw suspicion at Kate after Nev's lynch. Shall I continue?

No Mata I think MP is Bob

I'm glad someone else feels antsy about MP.

well, Vomps has proved that he is bad, thats established. And it proves that Llama is bad, because vomps is trying to protect him. which is making me believe that somehow, some way, Llama is Bob.

I agree, we're right about Llama, Vomps, and probably Russ as well. Unless someone got protected, or roleblocked last night, I'm guessing all 3 of them are bad. Now to ferret out who the newest recruit is.... and decide which one seems likeliest to be Bob.

thellama73 wrote:

Matahari wrote:

Vompatti wrote:

Matahari wrote:

Vompatti wrote:If it's certain that Russ is a recruit I'm not going to vote for anyone but him.

its equally as certain that Llama is a recruit. Are you against forming a voting plan with the rest of us?

How is it equally as certain?

he and russti both had votes yesterday. That makes it an equal chance.

Not really. I explained how multiple recruits could have voted for the same civvie, who was protected. There is no logical reason for Vompatti to doubt Russ' baddieness, however.

Linki: Yes, but if you think we are both equally likely to be bad, why are you insisting on lynching me when Russ already has a vote and it looks like he will soon have two?

Because you and Russ both need a vote, and Vomps also needs a vote.

Then the other not so suspicious players need to decide who to vote after that.

linki- and yes, I hope everyone but your teammates will ignore you.