The Syndicate

Awesome! I can only guess this means we got that role block we needed. We're still on very thin ice, though.

Dang! I have no idea how BWT could have been civ. We are really in trouble now. I think as Mata said, the fact that BWT died and not llama indicates that Ben has definitely been recruited. I was SHOCKED last night when I came to vote 4 minutes before the poll close and was only the second one there!...

I think Russ has some good points here: I think BWT is a MUCH better candidate than either me or Vomps, and here's why. He voted for 2 people who either were civs (Nev) or almost certainly were (Mata) at the time he voted them. Here http://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=136&...

Well, I suppose I have to vote. Going with my conscience and covering BWT, even if it does get me killed. I've done all I can...

I have to go to dinner (unfortunately, given my situation). I'll probably just be back to vote later on. I'm very much leaning BWT over Vomps right now, especially if any others share my thoughts on him.

Vomps, I'm glad to hear I'm not entirely crazy for suspecting him. I could get on board with us both voting BWT today. Llama makes a good point though; we also have a recruit who didn't kill last night and, most importantly, BOB, who is set to recruit again tonight. Frankly, if Kate and S~V~S are bo...

If I were to say hypothetically that something odd occurred overnight related to you. Woyld you have any idea what i was referring to? I would not. I suppose you can't be any more specific, but with the details you provided I have no idea what that "something" could even be. And thanks, l...

I'm a little surprised no one shares my thoughts on BWT, but that being what it is I'm happy to talk about myself as well. Defending oneself in mafia seems to present pretty few possibilities, but if anyone has any concerns, thread-based or otherwise, that they'd like me to address I'll be more than...

RIP, Snow Dog. I can't see any reason the baddies would kill a teammate, so I'm assuming you were good. I am, he pops in and pops out. Enough to be "here", but not enough to leave an impressionm good or bad. yeah, i would consider him I'm not sure how this is a reason to consider me. I ten...

Anyway, I don't object to people disagreeing with my plan, I object to the fact that nobody (except for you now, and maybe Snow Dog) is addressing the points I'm making, but are instead just saying "OMG you want to leave seven uncovered, that's crazy!" which I find suspicious. I addressed...

I'm confused by the assumption that each recruit gets their own NK. I was reading that power as they get a communal NK instead, what makes you guys think they could have 2?

Hmmm. Well at least I understand all the hints Mata dropped now (I think). So we're on Night 3 now, right? When does tonight end? And is anyone sure about when BOB recruits? Kate, it did also seem to me like it happens at the end of even day periods (so, for example, not today but tomorrow). Whether...

Does anyone else feel really stupid right now? I have absolutely no clue what she's getting at. Is the timing particularly important somehow?

I'm so jealous I can't get one!

Actually, missing a vote could be a baddie tactic. The less votes are out there the less the civs are protected, and missing means avoiding explaining your vote

Ugh, I don't have a good feeling about this either. I really hope llama's instincts on Matahari are right. And a but nervous about 4 uncovereds. Why didn't BWT and Matahari ever check in?

Where's everyone else, by the way? We still have 6 votes to get in, right?

And this is unrelated to the current lynch, but how is it that Vomps can just drop votes however he pleases? I realize "it's his style" and "he's always quiet", but every other player is held to the standard of being able to write some kind of reason for every vote, and usually ...

Sorry for the multi-post monologue here. That's what I get for getting up at 6 and playing from my phone. Actually, I'm gonna go ahead and vote SVS . I don't think further discussion will sway me, and for the reasons listed above I feel considerably worse about her than I did yesterday, when she als...

Even though no one asked, at this point I'm leaning pretty strongly civ on both Snowie and llama. I'm not sure about Kate, SVS, and Matahari. Of those 3 I feel best about Matahari. Between SVS's vote on Day 2 and misremembering now and Kate's lead of a civ lynch yesterday I think they should be cove...

EBWOP: I have no idea if llama checked things in the order he says, but the sequence of posts and poll changes is correct.

Just to set the record straight, this is the sequence of events as I remember them: 1. SVS posts that she is voting for Snow Dog. 2. I check the poll and see that she has in fact voted for SNow Dog and that her vote order is 2, INH having voted the host option already. I make a note of this in my s...

And I am getting a bit fed up with you evading that 50% thing :) Voting Snowy That seems impulsive to me. He didn't have a vote last night and there was no night kill. Do you think he would pass up the opportunity to kill to maintain his cover when his team are only a couple of kills/conversions aw...

We have to presume someone else was possesed last night. Now we have two players under Bob's thrall and Bob himself. There are eight of us. That's 5 - 3. We really need to lync one of these guys. If you were Bob Llama who do yuou think you would have recruited? Wow, I hadn't done the math yet. So f...

It's really hard for me not to vote for the One-Armed Man, but from an investigative standpoint I think talking to Laura's mom makes more sense right now.

votes Sarah Palmer

Thanks llama, but I don't agree with Mata. And Mata I knew she was dropping hints right away, as soon as Nevin did the info thing, she got so mad. Also not sure how you missed our back and forth, me freaking about BWT not voting and her insisting I vote for Nevoin as the plan called for. Having pla...

Was there a visible waiting list? The speed with which BF got replaced might suggest that he had a pivotal role, and that he worked out a replacement with the host before leaving. Russ and Roxy were signed up as replacements in the sign up thread. You mean Roxy and Mata? Russ was an original player...

Llama, I'll be happy to have the alibi if you do vote me so that's fine. I actually think it's inconvenient to forget such easily verifiable facts though. Even if you have that vote alibi there is nothing to say one won't be recruited the next day or that Ben will remove the vote. It's tricky. It's...

Llama, I'll be happy to have the alibi if you do vote me so that's fine. I actually think it's inconvenient to forget such easily verifiable facts though. Even if you have that vote alibi there is nothing to say one won't be recruited the next day or that Ben will remove the vote. It's tricky. It's...

Llama, I'll be happy to have the alibi if you do vote me so that's fine. I actually think it's inconvenient to forget such easily verifiable facts though.

But as Nev pointed out, whether Ben had a vote on him is moot, right? He didn't NK which means he can't have been recruited yet. Leaning SVS for my vote right now. I'm not sure yet whether I should believe her about her vote, and it can't hurt to have one vote on her in case it blocks a kill. Oh, an...

Russ, I said it was next best to random. We wanted to spread it out, so I voted for someone I had no opinion on. Ok, fair enough. Thanks for the clarification. Anyone has any feelings at all who may be Bob? I don't have any hunches yet. Unfortunately, as you said, BOB may not even have BTSC with hi...

Bye bf! Sorry to see you go, especially if it's because you felt discriminated against. Welcome, Matahari! Could she be being manipulated by Ben or another? I thought you and Kate had established that Ben changed a player's vote after they posted it and that the change wouldn't be visible to us? If ...

Sorry I have been MIA guys. I was out of town with minimal internet. Catching up now. I read Nevinera vs. Kate as Civ on Civ, since I know a thing or two about his play style and I would expect it to ping people early (much as my own does.) I do think the plan of spreading out once there is a clear...

Sorry I have been MIA guys. I was out of town with minimal internet. Catching up now. I read Nevinera vs. Kate as Civ on Civ, since I know a thing or two about his play style and I would expect it to ping people early (much as my own does.) I do think the plan of spreading out once there is a clear...

So just so I'm sure I've got it clear, the plan is to run it like a normal lynch until getting the most suspicious person is more or less assured, and then for the last few people to vote probable civs? I think that's a very sound plan, since the baddies constitute a pretty small voting block right ...

Oh no! I didn't even think of that. It would be incredibly unlucky for us if Ben had been recruited though, out of 11 possible people. It seems like a very outside chance. I guess we'll know by morning though.

Kate has a good point on the Log Lady, I think. She seems pretty crazy and hard to understand so far, but if she really knows who the murderer is maybe she'll give us some sort of clue, at least. Hopefully we catch her at a more or less clear moment. Linki with MP: I think spreading the votes a fair...

Wow, that seems like a surprisingly good result! I guess Ben Horne made a good decision. Not sure at all who should be voted for on this poll. Anyone have an idea what a poll like this could be? Perhaps it confers a (dis)advantage on the player chosen?

Remember, Ben Horne can change one vote. He could change the vote for himself to whoever he chooses. Just food for thought. Does this mean Ben Horne is deciding this lynch? If so I really hope he/she has some good instincts. By the way, I think Snowie's theory about dead people coming back in the b...

Sorry for thinking bad thoughts toward Rustti Take it easy, Roxy! That was quite a freakout about me not checking in, considering there were still hours to go on the poll. I was at a party last night and had basketball today. And as Snowie said, if you're not bad then you have nothing to fear from ...

Holy cow, what a complex game and ending! Congrats to FH, and go civvies! This was a really fun introduction to mafia, even though I was completely lost. 3 of my 4 Night Powers were used to block civvies (sorry, guys!).

This is going to be crazy hard. Every other day, BOB gets a new teammate, so we have to have a better than 50% accuracy on our lynches or they will quickly outnumber us. And on the first day we are almost sure to lynch a civvie because BOB will not have recruited yet. I see. This answers my questio...

Just because he hasn't gottena vote yet and I feel bad for him, I vote Bobby Briggs.

Hi everyone!

Thanks for the quick summary, Kate. I think I'll go with high school, there are a lot of people at the high school. Hopefully that means lots of leads to follow. And nothing bad can happen at a high school, right?

Russ, you playing? Thanks for asking :hugs: I dunno! It sounds really fun, but I think I'll be pretty busy for the next week or so and I don't want to make the mistake of signing up for a game I can't give my full attention to again. How about if you have 11 and want to get started today you count ...

I actually felt really bad about my post mentioning Boogs after I had posted it...I definitely violated some posting rules there and was really guilty when FH brought up my post. MP, to answer your question I figured out Epi was Zombie exactly how I said I did in the thread. I deduced that if he had...

Wow, what a game! Thanks a lot for hosting, Andrew and Kate!

MP's insanifier was amazing, thanks for all the joy that gave me Kate and Andrew!

I am feeling a bit nervous about this lynch because it seems like a nice bandwagon has formed on Russ, but for lack of a stronger candidate, I will vote for him as well. It makes me a little nervous as well. The baddie team either just completely gave up on Russ or they are laughing their asses off...

Search found 2062 matches