The Syndicate

Wow, a guy goes Öb vacation and suddenly he's evil! I'm busy as have only phone access (and limited, at that) until Wednesday, as I stated. You can lynch me before then if you really want, or I can mount a defense when I get home. If you do lynch me, you'll understand why I can personally guarantee ...

YAY~!!! Never so glad to have been mistaken :) Well, what do you think, Elohcin next? And do you still feel like llama is bad as strongly as you did before, or does this change your opinion at all? I don't know what to think of Elo~ she certainbly sounded bad in that last post. And my reasons for s...

*Votes Epi*

Epi's theory seems pure nonsense to me because of MP having been dead at the time. From a guy whose posts have, as I said before, been rigorously logical, it doesn't fit. I feel a lot better voting Epi now than before (not that I felt very bad about it before, anyway).

Hahaha oops. I misquoted I believe.

That's what I get for doing it by hand. Nap time! I hope more people weigh in, I'm going either Epi or Eloh but it'd be nice to get a little more consensus on who we should try to get first.

Yeah exactly. I can confirm what MP said, but don't know the answer to your follow-up question: "So a not civvie thing not a vote thing?"

As I said, doubt I could comment if I did know, but I don't. Sorry!

1. No one has demonstrated that ship was bad or house was good because we cannot talk about prizes. I firmly know that house was good and that you were supposed to die. I can vouch for this, though I know I lack MP's level of cred. Doubt I can say more. I know someone asked. Ahhh, my brain hurts! J...

Well Epi's defense there seemed pretty solid. MP is absolutely trustworthy, but he could have it wrong I guess...But if that is the case, where should we be looking for baddies? I do t have any other leads, and I refuse to condone randomizations on day 2. Also, so everyone knows, I'll be on a mini v...

Oh! And I was gonna say, MP being a civvie adds a ton of weight to his case. Good to be able to trust someone for sure this game. Any ideas on how to keep him around this time? Assuming MPs theory is correct, any preliminary thoughts on who the fourth could be? I realize it's early to worry about th...

Wow, what a bunch of posts. I feel exhausted after reading all of that. MP, you make a lot of sense with your case on Epignosis. I agree, we should lynch him today and go from there. I'm still not totally convinced that llama is not his team mate and the lynch was switched away from both of them, b...

Ambray wrote:Oh, I meant Russ, not Ruff. xD

So..

PS. Russ, do I know you by another name? xD

Nope! This I'd my third mafia game, and first forum. Nice to meet you though!

Wow. RIP, MP. Boogs, I think your remark about vote manipulation was astute, but to me a lynch switch seems much more likely because MP only had 2 votes and being able to manipulate votes that much seems unlikely to me. Regarding switches, if it was a baddie switch to save Epi it was probably a poo...

Going to bed now but I wasn't really here at the end i was watching The Dark Night. Amazed I wasn't lynched but glad I'm not. Never thought MP or Epignosis were bad but hard to tell. Not convinced Llama is bad either. Had to decide between voting He Man and reywaS and chose the latter. Snow Dog, my...

Oh and I wanted to ask Snow Dog, why such a late vote for rey? If what he posted is correct you hadn't mentioned him before. Furthermore, it was pretty clearly a throwaway. Did you feel strongly that the top 2 candidates, Epi and llama, were civ, did something rey said make you absolutely certain he...

Wow. RIP, MP. Boogs, I think your remark about vote manipulation was astute, but to me a lynch switch seems much more likely because MP only had 2 votes and being able to manipulate votes that much seems unlikely to me. Regarding switches, if it was a baddie switch to save Epi it was probably a poor...

Haha linki with MP....I guess I'll elaborate a tiny bit, but I reeeeally have to go to bed. llama is my #1 suspect for today. MP, your day 0 poll behavior seemed mostly to me to be trying to look at it from all angles, which is what a good civvie should do. That said, you are one clever baddie, and ...

Ugh, so much going on....

*Voting llama* because his vote for DP without responding to my concern about his train of thought pinged me like crazy. I think a number of the other suspicions going around have merit, but for now that was what got me the most.

Wow! There is so much going on; this will be a tough lynch choice, but not for lack of options. Most vocal Day 1 I've been a part of, anyway. Just to weigh in on Snowie, having read him again, my gut is saying possibly civ. I think if he were a baddie, maybe he'd be getting "coached" to be...

Hmm, as I think more, voting low posters seems less insidious than voting no-shows. I still won't be doing it on day 1, but if someone has checked in there's a somewhat better chance they're flying low instead of just unaware the game is happening.

Also look my post count is going up. It's not about quantity it's about quality. I could spam the thread and get a 100 posts hmm I'm sure I did that in MOTU and I was bad. Anyways looking at the low posters russ IMO has been making some sense and his posts seem ok with me albeit a few. I can't acco...

He-Man, I agree with your point that most day 0 polls are likely useless. However, we do know that done people had info on this one, so isn't it an exception to that idea? I for one think this particular poll could end up being useful, even if it isn't enough to base a vote on at this point. I think...

So far nothing about Roxy's attitude or style has pinged me, and I've seen llama's posts so far more as snark than bad intentions. Not that I'm leaning civvie on either yet, I'm just not leaning baddie either. Snow Dog I feel a bit more negative about, because of the vehemence of his ship argument a...

The discussion about active players is a pretty interesting one, I think. As I said last game, I'm against voting no-shows really early in case they haven't checked in. That said, reywaS point about saying anything giving you a higher chance of getting suspicion made me think, it's not really fair t...

Great discussion so far! Epi, I loved your analysis of our options. :haha: I think S~V~S's info about there being two possible types of polls was pretty useful. Being a relative newcomer, I didn't know whether there were possibilities beyond what I had seen in my first 2 games. So thanks for that! I...

Wow, so everything that could have gone wrong for the civs did go wrong. Juliets, it may have been painful for you but you played a masterful baddie game, especially in the BTSC rooms. You were the player I thought was least likely to be bad. However, it does seem like my original instincts were mor...

This sounds really fun! I'm in :-)

Ouch. Thanks so much for the game, S~V~S! It was a lot of fun. I was thinking playing a smaller one was helping me get a feel for mafia, but that seems to have not been the case at all.

NOOOOOOO!! And to think llama (who it seems was Swiss) was my next biggest suspect. So, how and when did Penny get recruited? And how did MacGyver become her minion? And what were Snow Dog's win conditions? I never did like Dex's lists of names, but could never find anything else to pin a suspicion ...

Oh! And it's purely ceremonial now, but voting FH, if only for solidarity. Hope we're right...

And sorry about yet another triple post. I'll try not to let those become my thing.

By the way, I think if FH does flip bad BWT is a likely teammate. I'll bother posting why if that does prove to be the case after this lynch.

Sweet baby Jesus I'm nervous about this one! As I said, it may decide the game.

Hi everyone. I was hoping to post before the concert I just went to, but as is probably clear I didn't manage (sorry juliets, and everyone else for that matter). Looks like I'm the last one. Here are some things I believe: Kate and llama have had BTSC since last Sunday. If you read through Kate's po...

EBWOP: I meant Dex instead of He-Man, He-Man being obviously dead and all. RIP, by the way, He-Man.

Well, I kind of hope we can get a lot of discussion today. Definitely seems like a good time to take a step back, regroup, and come up with some fresh ideas. I know that both FH and llama have been mentioned by multiple people as possible suspicions, and though I've read both of them I'd be interest...

This feels like a mess now.

ALF is clearly the cheesiest! I mean, the others are cheesy, but a puppet alien of indeterminate species who interviews celebrities? Come on!

Yeah that's really bad news. Sorry for having a hand in your second demise, LT. RIP

For the record, I do agree that llama is not looking good either right now (as I hope is clear from my post). Personally LT seemed most suspicious to me, but a llama lynch would sit ok with me as well.

Linki with FH

I also think (as I've been saying for days) that LT needs to go. Sorry boo, but nothing either you or she has said has made me look at this any differently. BWT, I still think your earlier posts were suspicious, and I'll keep an eye on you, but I and many others have been voicing suspicion of LT for...

Yeah your posts are pretty readable to me, Dex. I'm not totally convinced BWT is bad; but since he's come back he hasn't impressed me. I definitely buy that RL got in the way at the beginning, but since then his contributions have been 1) defending himself 2) agreeing with MP about Dex's list of nam...

RIPIYWG rey. Pretty sure you were. Now I'll really be frustrated if what you were trying to say was important. Poor Reywas RIP my friend -odd choice for the kill no one could understand the poor kid! Looks like Dex won't be a problem to understand. His words are are just jumbled almost easy as pie c...

I think it's really impressive that a 10-year-old put all of this together! Andrew really is talented

Lots of linki. Whatever Rey is trying to say, it seems he's trying pretty darn hard. Rey, can you try typing something shorter, or throw an equal sign between 2 letters if it is a substitution code? Possible better idea: try typing in "My name is reywaS." Maybe if we know how a certain sen...

Yeah, all the capital B's make it pretty unintelligible. So it seems clear from SVS's post that the theory about recruitment is spot on and that team's recruit isn't dead. Thus worries me, partly because the roles state that all baddie powers are cyclical, so both baddie teams could theoretically do...

Wow, what a great result! Vomps was starting to convince me at the end there; good to get him when we did. S~V~S, to add to Dex's question, if a baddie team has been eliminated, does their NK go away? I'll be looking hardest at LT2 right now, but I think now is a perfect time to do a reread and look...

Ugh! The first version of this got deleted. Shorter version: No longer sure how to feel about Vomps. All the voting evidence says baddie, and a bandwagon is most likely civ-led since civs outnumber everyone. I also didn't like his role hint/out-poor form there. On the other hand, his zany, quirky st...

Actually, He-Man wrote "nice catch Rey" right after that post, so there was some support for the idea. I partially retract my apology. I further put forth that it seems vomps may be grasping at straws, as his suspicion of me seems to have come from nowhere (he never mentioned me before tod...

While it is tempting to trust the A-Team, I would like to point out that I was the first to vote for MP, and you all were happy to follow me to lynch his wicked self. Also, I wanted to point out that the bit of Science info about MP being creepy was correct, so if one of the pieces of information i...

I think Dex's point just now is a good one, vomps seems to have taken being on that list pretty personally. That if nothing else makes me nervous about him. Are people pretty sure now that llama was faking insanification? If that's true I think he needs to go, and better sooner than later. I still d...

Haha thanks He-Man.

EBWOP: Great that we avoided another night kill!

boo and LT: my initial reaction is really wanting to believe you both, but you have to realize neither of you has offered any actual evidence or reasons to believe you, at least not that someone in my position would understand. Boo, is the secret evidence you mentioned really something you don't wan...

Search found 2062 matches