The Syndicate

I deserve the blame for this loss. I got in my own head and pushed scotty when I should have trusted going after Splints. Sorry, team.

Oh phooey

If you don't want to post it in the thread, you can just PM it to me.

DFaraday wrote:
thellama73 wrote:
DFaraday wrote:All of the PMs are in so I'll end the night early.
Should I vote for Scotty, DH? I want your opinion.
DH isn't here, and I can't speak for him. :P

You know I meant DF. :P Come on, be honest. Is Scotty bad?

DFaraday wrote:All of the PMs are in so I'll end the night early.

Should I vote for Scotty, DH? I want your opinion.

All right, I've decided to vote for Scotty. Reading back on his posts, he always lists MM as a suspect, but always behind several other people. It's the classic baddie move to lightly attack a teammate without ever really putting them in jeopardy. As long as I or Greybonez or Elo was alive, he always had an excuse not to vote for MM.

Scotty wrote:If I had to pick the 3rd teammate of llama and greybonez, I'd probably pick MM. Just on a hunch.

Scotty wrote: But I see that you have agreed with my choices of GreyboneZ/Elo and possibly MM. So apparently we're on the same page there.

Scotty wrote: Also if I could place another vote it would have been for MM.

What does Sorsha think, I wonder?

Scotty wrote:
thellama73 wrote:Honestly Scotty, the extent to which you've stepped into a leadership role at the endgame has me worried. You seem excited. You have the air of someone about to pull off a desperate victory, and that makes me not trust you. I owe both you and Splints a reread today.
That's fair. Not disputing how excited I am, because I am sure we are close to winning.

Do you agree that the only possibilities of mafia at this point are me and splints? That's been my whole point.

Yeah, I do agree with that, and I am agonizing over which one of you to choose. Why isn't Splints defending herself like you are? Is she a lone baddie who has given up, or is she a bored civ who was never really that engaged?

Honestly Scotty, the extent to which you've stepped into a leadership role at the endgame has me worried. You seem excited. You have the air of someone about to pull off a desperate victory, and that makes me not trust you. I owe both you and Splints a reread today.

That's true about anyone though, Scotty. Not just you.

Scotty wrote:
DFaraday wrote:Day 7 - The Seventh Day

"I propose a game of billiards to solve this enigma," suggested Llama. After everything that's happened, billiards sounded wonderfully soothing. The crowd gathered and began a tournament, with the winner getting to use the ceremonial armour in the hall for defense against Sibella.

"So...one of us in this room is the killer..." said Scotty casually.

"I think it was Roxy!" exclaimed Sorsha.

"Yes, Roxy! Roxy, yeah! Roxy, indubitably!" agreed the crowd.

"You're making a terrible mistake," Roxy said. "It's not me, and you won't stand a chance without me!"

"Tell it to the judge," Llama said. The crowd grabbed a pool cue and charged Roxy, impaling her on it.

"Hey, she looks kind of familiar, huh?" said Dom.

"She's the D'Ysquith we abandoned years ago!" declared Splints.

"Oh well," said Sorsha sadly.

Roxy has been lynched. She was Chauncey D'Ysquith. It is now Night 7. You have 36 hours to send in your PMs.
I'm sorry Roxy.

I think I was right about golden and there is only 1 mafia member left. And her name is fingersplints.

We're not dead yet, boys. I could be bamboozling you, but take solace in the fact that, if my logic is correct, only me and splints can be bad.

I think it might be you.

Dom wrote:I'll vote Roxy. :/

Me too.

Who wants to vote first? Honestly, the last few posts have me feeling better about SPlints and worse about Roxy. I am starting to second guess myself and wonder if I am being rolled by Scotty.

Roxy wrote:What exactly do you want to "hear" Sorsha? I said all I feel about splints more than once this game. Do you want me to tell you she likes peanut butter almost as much as I do? Do you want me to list her fave led zep song? Maybe tell you I love her dog chico too much?

George Washington Carver invented peanut butter, and I'm partial to Achilles' Last Stand

Here are a couple of posts from Fingersplints I think are worth noting:

fingersplints wrote:Actually I don't want to miss another vote so I am going to vote Elo right now. I trust Roxy and I think she is right. It does seem like Elo has been being saved by llama. Iirc he is the one who first commented to me about greybonez and then when he was lynched he was like "you all should have listened to me about MM". seems sketchy

fingersplints wrote:I asked for a summary and literally the only thing I got was about greybonez. I don't think it's fair to say it's jumping on bandwagon considering I just entered the game so how was I supposed to express suspicion before then? Also while greybonez ended up being civvie I really think defending himself some would have gone a long way.

I'm not sure how you know what's going on in my life to judge how much time I should have or have not had to catch up, but I'm pretty sure everyone here except you who is not playing (has played, or is cohosting with me) the game I am hosting, so does not know that some pretty bad shit happened there and I have been preoccupied with that. I'm keeping up with what is being said now, but I literally haven't had a chance to read prior. (Minus greybonez - who I did read all host posts before voting)

I'm going to try to reread Elo first when I get a chance. I'm pretty good at reading Roxy, and I feel from her posts that she is a civvie. She seems pretty insistent, so I wonder if there is something there.

Very unsubtle defending of Roxy, and notably the only time she mentioned MM.

Recall that Splints replaces Lipsticklacey, and then read this:

Roxy wrote:I want to vote llama for saying to lynch Lips.
And we all know how I feel about noobs amirite?

I think a Roxy/Splints team looks probable. I would probably be more comfortable with a SPlints lynch than Roxy though, since the Eloh NK could be a setup.

Oh man, there's no poll thread is there? That's gonna make this more difficult.

RIP Eloh.

I think Roxy is a sensible choice for today, but I want to review the vote record to make sure. The Eloh kills seems like it might be a Roxy frame up.

I love when I put all my eggs in one basket and it works out.

Scotty wrote:
thellama73 wrote:
Scotty wrote:It also wouldn't surprise me if Roxy or splints were bad. If MM is good, I'm gunning for llama 146% tomorrow. But I think at this point I don't feel bad voting for MM
If MM is good, I'm not convinced there will be a tomorrow.
Ah, I guess we would be in lylo if mafia got a kill in tonight..

Would you be nice and tell us if we just lost?

I don't think we did. But everything is a gamble to a certain extent.

Scotty wrote:It also wouldn't surprise me if Roxy or splints were bad. If MM is good, I'm gunning for llama 146% tomorrow. But I think at this point I don't feel bad voting for MM

If MM is good, I'm not convinced there will be a tomorrow.

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
thellama73 wrote:Reminder to the gang that there are three living baddies, so don't spread the vote out or they can vote in a bloc and be tied with the civilians tomorrow after their NK.
I think llama slipped in this post. I thought Golden was his teammate, but I believe llama admitted otherwise.

Do you have some reason for thinking Golden was not civ?

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
thellama73 wrote:Reminder to the gang that there are three living baddies, so don't spread the vote out or they can vote in a bloc and be tied with the civilians tomorrow after their NK.
How are you so certain that Golden is not a baddie?

I didn't realize he had been killed by a civvie until you brought this up and I looked at the roles. You may remember me not really reading the role list from earlier.

Reminder to the gang that there are three living baddies, so don't spread the vote out or they can vote in a bloc and be tied with the civilians tomorrow after their NK.

Vote registered for MetalMarsh.

Elohcin wrote:So if you can tell me and it isn't infodumping or anything, what changed your mind?

Your responses to Roxy and MM failing to do anything to make me feel any better about him. I think I know you pretty well at this point. I can't read you as well as Epi can, but I am deciding to bet the farm that you are not bad at this point. We haven't caught a baddie yet. We need a hail Mary, and this is mine.

Elohcin wrote:Wow. Thank you llama did you role check me? haha, j/k. I am ready and willing to work with you 100%.

Nah, if I rolechecked you I wouldn't be so blatant about it.

Elohcin wrote:MM has to be Monty unless there are other things at play with the secrets and all. I think Roxy is his partner. I of course have already stated why. She must be Sibella since she claims to have had her vote forced and no one can target themselves. Unless she just flat out lied :P Let's get these two out and then try to find baddie #3.

Eloh, I am deciding to trust you here. Between the two of us, we need to take down MM and his band of wicked warriors. I know a lot of people are out to get you, but I am going to stand with you from now on, even if it means my own death. This is the gamble I'm willing to take at this crucial point in the game.

Roxy wrote:Llama I am fast losing trust with you this game. You said you would help me with elo yesterday and I would have helped with mm today but ofc you backed out when your vote could have clinched her lynch. Why? if you had doubts you did not share them when we were posting together. it seemed a sudden shift imo

I am capricious like that. I got nervous about the amount of people holding their votes until the last minute. It felt like baddie strategery, and Eloh's responses seemed legit to me.

I'm convinced either Eloh or MM is Monty, and I don't think it's ELoh at this point.

Roxy wrote:Llama I am fast losing trust with you this game. You said you would help me with elo yesterday and I would have helped with mm today but ofc you backed out when your vote could have clinched her lynch. Why? if you had doubts you did not share them when we were posting together. it seemed a sudden shift imo

I am capricious like that. I got nervous about the amount of people holding their votes until the last minute. It felt like baddie strategery, and Eloh's responses seemed legit to me.

I'm convinced either Eloh or MM is Monty, and I don't think it's ELoh at this point.

I guess we can add Eloh and MM to the list of Monty candidates.

YOu could just vote now and go to bed.

Voting MM. Going with my gut.

Well heck. I don't know what to do. I kind of still want to vote MM.

Roxy wrote:But do you think elo is bad?

I wouldn't agree to vote for her if I didn't.

Roxy wrote:
thellama73 wrote:ALthough it is kind of sketch how people keep blowing off MM as a suspect. After the last lynch, it was all "oh yeah, llama may be right, let's look at that" and then that all vanished. Hmm. Maybe I have to vote for MM after all. Will anyone join me?

I feel the same way about Elo. Just when I think I get focus on her you all lynch a noob civ. And before that TH - I could go on here but I think you get my point.

Besides what you are suspicious of MM for I did more than he did yet you show 0 suspicion of me. Why?

Because you are obviously not bad.

Okay, I'll play along with you on Eloh today, but if it doesn't work out, you have to promise to help me with MM tomorrow.

ALthough it is kind of sketch how people keep blowing off MM as a suspect. After the last lynch, it was all "oh yeah, llama may be right, let's look at that" and then that all vanished. Hmm. Maybe I have to vote for MM after all. Will anyone join me?

Scotty wrote: Llama, are you voting Elo?

Probably. That post sounded really insincere.

Elohcin wrote:What a day. First of all its been raining here for days and days. But today, the power went out while I was baking two birthday cakes and a wedding cake (yes, my oven fit it all). I also had a diswasher full of dishes, laundry in the washer and laundry in the dryer. This is my life I had to hand mix the last batch of batter and then transfer all my cakes to a couple ovens at Epi's place of work. Thank goodness we live in po-dunk Hoke and they see no problem with Mrs. Brown and her three chillin's in tow walk up into the school with pans full of half baked cake ready to use the culinary classroom while school is in session All is well now though, the power came back on a little bit ago and the cakes are ready to be frosted and decorated tomorrow.

I can't believe greybonez. Did he even really fight for himself? I hate to see that. Also, Roxy, I am not bad. I have acted a bit different this game, yes. I am trying to change up my game here and there so I am less readable. Too bad it just makes players think I am bad. You, however, have acted differently imo and you STILL have yet to give any evidence as to WHY you think I am bad except that I am "acting differently". Where are the quotes, man, where are the quotes?

Ah man, you were so close, but you tipped your hand here. Good playing from you this game, though. I look forward to next time.

Roxy wrote:so no one is going to look back on Elo? She has been so different this game it is unreal that I am the only one to notice - it is also why I think Epi was taken out early in a lycnh prob led by her teamies and since no one cba'ed to find their own suspicions ya'll are just playing follow the leader.

I'll consider it. She has seemed a little different this game. But I'm much more suspish of MetalMarsh for his eagerness to leap onto the "you said my team" bandwagon.

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
thellama73 wrote:I don't know which roles are bad and which are good since there is no role list on the front page. Does this mean Greybonez was good? That is a shame, then. You guys should have listened to me about MM.
What are you talking about? There's a role list on the front page.

Oh, there is now. There wasn't the last time I looked.

Dom wrote:
thellama73 wrote:I don't know which roles are bad and which are good since there is no role list on the front page. Does this mean Greybonez was good? That is a shame, then. You guys should have listened to me about MM.
I'm beginning to think so too, but am wary of you tricking me.

I am kind of tricksy, but then, so are you. I guess we just have to learn to cautiously trust each other.

I don't know which roles are bad and which are good since there is no role list on the front page. Does this mean Greybonez was good? That is a shame, then. You guys should have listened to me about MM.

fingersplints wrote:Anyone want to give me a summary on the suspicion of greybonez?
Sorry but it's unlikely I will get to read the whole thread until tomorrow

He's shifty and he tried to drag me into his web of shiftiness.

Golden wrote:Greybonez/MM/Eloh would make sense to me as a team. Scotty is bothering me, though, in that his views just changed a lot from being llama to now being greybonez/eloh team. I almost wonder if it could be Greybonez/Scotty/MM and if scotty is setting up the lynch of one of his own so that he can turn it on to Eloh tomorrow. Also, from day one greybonez/llama still makes a decent amount of sense.

Anyway, putting that all together I think a greybonez vote is the way to go, I'm on board.

Yeah, I've got a Scotty suspicion in my back pocket.

Okay, I'll go with greybonez. I also don't like splitting the vote. Yesterday was a mess.

Sorsha wrote:
thellama73 wrote:
Sorsha wrote:I voted for greybonez.
Do you think I should too?
I think you should follow your heart and vote for who you think is bad.

I think almost everyone is bad, but I only have one vote.

Sorsha wrote:I voted for greybonez.

Do you think I should too?

I like you too, Eloh, but I'm sad about Daisy.

Who should we lynch today? I'm down for Metalmarsh or Greybonez, but I don't want a vote spread like last time. Vote spread bad.

That was a great insanifier, Eloh. We all enjoyed it.

Oh look, I'm still alive. Let's not lynch me again, k?

Sorsha wrote:Well I made it and voted for bonez but doesn't look like it matters... Elo voted for llama

Nice playing with y'all! Thanks for the game, DFaraday.

Search found 88 matches