The Syndicate

Phoebe Buffay

I went back to check, and Karin did her vote for Mary one hour after Mary had posted about ten posfs of gibberish, and also after people had already been talking about how Mary had given up and thrown in the towel. If Mary herself had given up, so had her team. Karins vote being one hour after Mary...

Phoebe Buffay

wow that is a pretty damn good case holy shit Do you think it is? Barbara only said some of the same things others have mentioned earlier about Karin (that she only talked about the teachers at the beginning of the game). Then Barbara used Karin's vote for Mary against her. All of Karin's votes hav...

Phoebe Buffay

RIP Merga. I was hoping we wouldn't lose you :( Barbara, Jennet, have either of you even read the thread since you died? Its honestly way too early and frankly there are other things going on right now. In addition I'm really starting to get worried about how lynches are being manipulated and then y...

Phoebe Buffay

Welcome back Barb and Jennet!

Please help us.

Phoebe Buffay

I voted for Malin again.

Phoebe Buffay

You're not really? I will be voting either Alizon or Malin, Malin is my preference, I just want to know what others think.

Phoebe Buffay

And here we are with a split vote, just like we didn't want. I still would rather vote Malin more than I want to vote Alizon or Anne.

Alizon, do you think Malin is bad? Do you think we can risk splitting the vote to put more votes on Malin?

Everyone who hasn't voted yet, where are you looking?

Phoebe Buffay

Merga Bien: forceful player, guides discussion, has strong convictions. She's either an A+ student or playing a hella crazy baddie game. I feel good about Merga even if I don't agree with all of her thoughts. Alizon Device: sharp tone, opinionated, engaged in the conversation. Seems to have a chip o...

Phoebe Buffay

RIP witches. I had nothing but good vibes from Margaret Reinberg. I was not as sure about Barbara or Anna Koldings but rest in peace all the same. That was a very weird October day at the quidditch pitch. Merga I know you feel strongly about Alizon, but we agreed to stick together this lynch to prev...

Phoebe Buffay

Day 7 No one has been lynched. :| Lots of discussion tonight, we have some feisty witches in here. I keep flip flopping on Alizon. She is someone I plan on rereading soon, especially re: her connection to Malin and whether or not that connection exists. I see a way that they could both be civs but ...

Phoebe Buffay

Voted Malin.

Phoebe Buffay

Malin, Agnes made one cryptic post that may have referred to Sarah Good and spent the rest of her time going after Entjen. She never elaborated or tried to make any points about Good. It's weird that you're clinging to what she said. What do you think Agnes knew about Sarah Good? Why do you think sh...

Phoebe Buffay

Do you think she can be lynched today?

Phoebe Buffay

Maret, do you have reasons to believe that Alizon isn't the student role you considered? Malin, your "case" against Sarah Good is one of the saddest things I've ever seen. All you did was quote her posts verbatim and then say "I think I've seen a baddie play this way before, and didn'...

Phoebe Buffay

Rest in peace to all the modkilled witches. It is sad to see you go even if you weren't currently playing. We likely lost some students in the bloodbath :( Malin and Maret seem to be misunderstanding each other even when they're in agreement. So I agree with Merga's post about Alizon knowing what th...

Phoebe Buffay

Voting Malin. I'm hoping both she and Alizon are bad, they have defended each other and been in agreement on some odd things, but I think the case on Malin is stronger.

Phoebe Buffay

You have oversimplified the case against you Malin. It is not about how hard you are or are not trying. I find you suspicious for trying to dismiss player's thoughts as being invalid and for guiding discussion in ways that suit your agenda. You don't think your complete dismissal of everything I sai...

Phoebe Buffay

I forgot that Nutter survived an Nk. That moves her down a few notches in my suspicions and bumps Malin up a few. It seemed that Malin had more reason to vote for Nutter but ended up tagging along on Nutter's vote for Margaret P instead. And when I mentioned that I didn't see the case on Margaret, M...

Phoebe Buffay

Rest in peace Jennet and Entjen. And goodbye again Agnes :( Another reason I am not in love with low poster voting in THIS game is that I know the punishment they receive for having missed votes, having replaced the very quiet Merga I, and lets just say it makes them an easy lynch. And when you are ...

Phoebe Buffay

I choose the gruesome death behind door #2.

Phoebe Buffay

Nice job ladies!

FYI I am having laptop issues so I'll only be able to play from my phone until further notice, hopefully only for a few days. My posts will likely not be as organized and thorough as I would like them to be. Posting from my phone can be a real witch sometimes.

Phoebe Buffay

Not a lot of time. Voting Mary. She never responded to my questions and I think she realizes she's been caught. She isn't bothering to defend herself or even offer any suspicions other than Jennet, a suspicion that only really makes sense if Mary is a Death eater. Now she's just posting nonsense. De...

Phoebe Buffay

Sorry for checking in so late in the Day, folks. It's been a busy few days for this witch. I can see I've already missed a lot of discussion today, which to be honest is a bit refreshing because it seems like we haven't had a day this productive since the game started. And welcome back, Agnes! :D I ...

Phoebe Buffay

Rest in peace, Margy P. The gargoyle strikes sound way more boring than the other three. fiddlesticks! I can't believe I missed the vote. It was a horrible result too. Who would you have voted for? ________________________________________________ I had forgotten what you all were talking about with ...

Phoebe Buffay

I voted for Karin. Karin has indeed only said a few on-topic things, all related to the professors and/or their alignment. Other than that, she just has voting posts. Talking about the professors seems like a good way for baddies to join the discussion without having to talk about themselves. If we'...

Phoebe Buffay

Okay, that's a bit of a weird pileup on Margaret P. Not sure what to make of it. I don't see how she stands out from the other low posters.

Phoebe Buffay

I agree Mary's vote record looks bad, and that should not be dismissed. Vote records are always a good way to catch baddies, ecuase they can lie in the thread, but ultimately they have to cast votes and not lynch their teammates. I am a little hesitant to jump on this yet, however, because it is on...

Phoebe Buffay

Malin Matsdotter - Malin seems to be the most level-headed player here. I don't see anyone else making as smart, thought-out decisions as she is. She strikes me as town. Hmmm... but didn't you say that baddies are more likely to play a careful, mistake-free game than civs are? Malin hasn't really s...

Phoebe Buffay

Phoebe Buffay

I saw that someone just did this in another game and it seemed like a really good idea. Especially since it's hard to keep all you witches straight sometimes. Jennet Bierley Merga Bien Bridget Bishop Krystyna Ceynowa Alizon Device Mary Eastey Entjen Gillis Sarah Good Katharina Henot Märet Jonsdotter...

Phoebe Buffay

No I meant Rebecca but I do think I mixed up one of her posts with yours. This was the post of hers I was thinking of: Roughly 20 minutes later she was here to make these comments but not to address anything game related as the lynch is coming closer to close time. Since she was online and posting, ...

Phoebe Buffay

Where is everyone? Lots of people haven't even checked in today. 9 witches have 10 or fewer posts: Alice Nutter, Alizon, Brita, Karin, Margaret P, Sarah Good, Kael, Anne Whittle, and Merga. There's likely at least one baddie in that group, lying low and blending in. I'm giving Alizon and Anne W a pa...

Phoebe Buffay

Thanks for the clarification, Lizzy. We can rule out nefarious motives for that information being given to us, then.

Phoebe Buffay

I didn't dismiss anything, Anne Whittle. I agree that it is likely we've lost Harry, but I'm wary of how the information was given to us. Why would the hosts reveal that? And do so on Day 4, when she died on Night 1? Don't you think that is worth looking into, at least a little bit? If you don't wan...

Phoebe Buffay

Not a bad point, Red Anne.

Jennet, can you confirm or deny what Anne said?

Phoebe Buffay

Yay Jennet! At least we aren't losing folks at night. Except poor Harry, it appears :( Yet a part of me doesn't want to take that info at face value. I mean why are we just now being told? What would cause that to happen? linki: Yeah it's possible Hermione is involved... but unless she checked Agnes...

Phoebe Buffay

Goodbye Anne Whittle! And welcome, Anne Whittle! Jennet it's possible there was some vote manipulation, but it did not seem like Entjen was worried at the end of the lynch despite being the top vote-getter, so I think there might be an explanation for what happened that does not involve hidden votes...

Phoebe Buffay

Sorry Krystyna

No poll tonight?

Phoebe Buffay

Voting Krystyna

Phoebe Buffay

I agree with you in theory, the metagame will have to evolve, but this is a sockpuppet game so I feel much differently about it I guess.

Phoebe Buffay

Like I said Krystyna, we will likely never agree about this. But what do you suspect me for, that you think a vote for me is just as solid as a vote for Entjen? You had not mentioned suspicion of me until Rebecca's post, and now suddenly I'm a frontrunner for how you can save yourself from the lynch...

Phoebe Buffay

And Bridget could have been useful at night with her role, regardless of how she was playing in the thread. You could have just left her alone.

Phoebe Buffay

Even if you thought she did want to get lynched, why would wanting to get lynched make her a baddie? You even agree that it's more likely a civvie would say something like that than a baddie. I will probably never agree with you on this and I need to figure out whether that's just based on our diffe...

Phoebe Buffay

Krystyna, I didn't get the same meaning from that post of Bridget's as you did. I took that to mean that she wasn't just avoiding votes. If she wanted to avoid votes, she would not have played the way that she does, because she knows she is controversial. "Trying to avoid votes" and "...

Phoebe Buffay

I'm trying to gather my thoughts about what I've read today, but Rebecca's segment on me in her post is looming large in my head and I can't seem to think clearly on other suspicions until I respond to it. Rebecca, I don't know why you only paraphrased my participation in the game instead of asking ...

Phoebe Buffay

Katharina, who do you think might have tried to kill you last night? Krystyna, do you believe that Draco and the other Slytherin students are baddies, or do you just want us to be wary of the possibility they could be? What do you think of your vote for Bridget yesterday, now that we know her role? ...

Phoebe Buffay

Well... they were all tied a second ago but looks like Brita might have had the same idea as me

Phoebe Buffay

Voted Ganymede to keep it a five horse race.

Phoebe Buffay

Sorry if you are good this game Bridget. That is a shitty reason to get votes.

Phoebe Buffay

Merga, Alizon, Entjen, Anna, Rebecca, Margaret, and Anne Whittle all missed the vote.

Search found 1043 matches