Return to “Rolling Stones Mafia Game Over!”
Alas, it was a chatzy moment I can't get back...juliets wrote:that IS weird Hedgie. Show us the picture maybe we'll know the name.Hedgeowl wrote:I know what you look like, but not who you are. How weird is that?
maybe one day I will get the chance. 
RIP Mongoose! Sorry I was wrong about you.MovingPictures07 wrote:It really bugs me the way this vote went down. I'm almost positive both DP and Mongoose are civvies, especially Mongoose, just based on the way this lynch went, and everything else in retrospect.
Epig has been slippery, almost too much. I really want to look back at his posts and examine them more.
I'd almost sig bet on Hedge being baddie. Her 'argument' today that Mongoose is baddie because she didn't vote in yesterday's poll and there was no kill last night was a HUGE stretch. Something I do NOT see her doing as a civvie.
Anyway, I have stuff to do now. I'll be back later tonight to see the result. Hopefully it's good, but unfortunately I don't think it will be.
Linki: Well, nevermind, there it is. That only convinces me. Hedge is DEFINITELY baddie. Epig very likely is, after this vote, or maybe it is DP...
cause that's what I am about to do, plus a new box of delicious aloe tissues.Mongoose wrote:Yeah I have, I guess. There's several baddies still alive, so it seems like wasted effort this late in the game.Hedgeowl wrote:This isn't much of a defense. Have you thrown in the towel? I hate voting you, but the logic of missed vote plus no kill makes me think you are bad this time friend.Mongoose wrote:I ain't murderin' nobody 'round these parts.
(Or, for your militant grammarians, "I am not murdering anyone around this vicinity or any other vicinity).
votes Mongoose
This isn't much of a defense. Have you thrown in the towel? I hate voting you, but the logic of missed vote plus no kill makes me think you are bad this time friend.Mongoose wrote:I ain't murderin' nobody 'round these parts.
(Or, for your militant grammarians, "I am not murdering anyone around this vicinity or any other vicinity).
A refusal? I don't remember that at all. I remember explaining her misinterpretation of what I said and her dismissal. If I missed anything else it's because of being too distracted by RL, not by willfully ignoring things. If there is anything else I can address please let me know. With so few players left it s hard not to assume that one of the several gunning for me is a baddie, so if it came across as a no u fine, but this is now a small game, soMovingPictures07 wrote:Maybe you're right. I've felt this certain and been wrong (and right) before. That being said, I wouldn't argue she has erred; rather, I think she's played a good game.Mongoose wrote:Oh okay, thank you for clarifying that.MovingPictures07 wrote:
I don't think she's baddie because she escaped death. I think she's baddie because of what I said earlier. Her escaping death adds nothing to the case for me; I was already convinced.
I agree with you on your analysis of DP certainly. I feel he is a stronger candidate. If he popped up bad, I think then we could analyze any possible BTS partners he may have.MovingPictures07 wrote: How is it weird? The baddies knew it would fail, why not go with it? In fact, it makes complete sense. Do you see a stronger case on anyone else right now, or do you disagree with mine? If so, why?
I could go on and on about this, but I will try to distill my thoughts on Hedge to a very concise graf. As someone who has played the same amount of time as her (we signed up the same week, tra la la), I just feel she wouldn't err in the ways that her opponents have been insinuating. This ain't her first rodeo, as they say.
If I may bounce the ball back (aww I miss 4-square), what makes you (or any of you) feel that she is a better lynch candidate in comparison to DP?
Are you saying you strongly believe Hedge is civvie then or something else?
I feel the night actions combined with her refusal to discuss what S~V~S brought up was a weak vote make her a more compelling case than DP -- call it a conspiracy theory, if you will. DP's gameplay is like this A LOT; I have played many games with him. As a result, I'm always hesitant to lynch him, and I have a hard time reading him. But that doesn't make his actions any less suspicious, though perhaps you understand my train of thought then.
That's a really strong statement considering how many things I said here. You are just going to discount all of it? Clearly everyone followed ÿour vote yesterday and we are to the point where just one more kill could allow the baddies to control the game. If you are so convinced I am bad and we can't dicuss it further then who else? If you are civ then at least we can talk about another baddie, since I don't even warrant discussion.MovingPictures07 wrote:Does anyone actually believe any of this?Hedgeowl wrote:Hey! I am alive! No one seems happy about this, but me.. Seriously, think about it, why would everyone vote for me, unless either I was the last baddie alive and you are all on to me due to literally one statement SVS thinks was suspect or the baddies are scapegoating me or Mongoose and I are baddie teammates (omg that's never happened, but that would be the most fun ever!
)
We are being played for sure and if someone dies tonight we will be in really bad shape tomorrow if there are 3 baddies left. They will control the lynch and I will be a prime target again wasting another lynch opportunity.
I am not sure if MP is genuine in his belief of me as baddie or whether DP jumped on that bandwagon too fast, but I suspect one of them is definitely bad. Will be watching them both closely.
sorry I haven't been more active this weekend , but I am now sick too. Blergh. Hope to recover soon.
Then again literally everyone voted for me, except Mongoose . Seriously, think about it, why would everyone vote for me, unless either I was the last baddie alive and you are all on to me due to literally one statement SVS thinks was suspect or the baddies are scapegoating me or Mongoose and I are baddie teammates (omg that's never happened, but that would be the most fun ever! ) 
birdwithteeth11 wrote:I'm in between either llama, juliets, and Hedge. Llama because I could see him being ballsy enough to try and take S~V~S out already. Juliets because I could see some attempts to save teammates in there. But I think I will be voting for Hedge today. S~V~S mentioning her and then getting killed off pretty much ended any discussion of her. And for some reason that really freaks me out.
Votes Hedge
Lots of linki.
Russtifinko wrote:Epi, are you saying here that you think the Lizzy vote were intended to nip any push for MP in the bud? And I know saying "it's gut" doesn't give you much chance at defense, so I'm sorry for that. I'm still not set on voting you, if that makes you feel any better.Epignosis wrote:That's the thing- it's all so circumstantial. One or two in that crew have to be rotten. That's when I look through the posts and am like the bear that went over the mountain.Mongoose wrote:Indeed, indeed. I don't know exactly how to connect the dots though. Do you have any interpretation(s)?Epignosis wrote:The Lizzy votes came in BOOM BOOM BOOM BOOM 1-2-3-4 like a band getting ready to play. They came in right when llama voted for MovingPictures.
That's the first thing that sticks out to me.
MP, to answer your question, I really can't peg any one thing in Epi's posts that makes me blame him. There's his A Person vote, which I have a hard time criticizing him for, and then it seems to me that he was the one pushing most strongly to look at Lizzy voters, which is a place I said I wouldn't be looking too hard. Lizzy voters comprise nearly half of those of us left, and I think it'd be easy for a baddie to say "let's get those bad Lizzy voters; they killed a civ!" and then subtly point us to the civs in that group.Admittedly, it's not damning evidence. It just still makes me nervous.
I am sure about 2 things: 1) there are baddies among us.
Linki with Roxy--I also am curious about your thoughts, Big D!
MovingPictures07 wrote:Alright, just got home from work. Going to be out of town this weekend, but will still have my laptop and internet access. I am getting ready and multitasking, but I'll hold off on my vote until a bit later because I'm still unsure.
I find it sort of convenient that Hedgeowl is insanified, the night after S~V~S was killed, especially given how strongly S~V~S felt about her.
Sure, DP is acting illogically and isn't really around and is being blendy, but he plays that way a lot.
I'll likely vote for Hedge, Llama, or DP currently. Hedge because of what I've said about her,
Juliets has made me feel better, but I always read her intentions as civvie, so my paranoia in that regard remains.
Ugh, can I have some discussion here? I feel like this vote could end badly with people just popping in like Day 2; I'd rather it not.
Linki: Russ. Can you elaborate any more about Epig per chance?
Hope you enjoy being wrong!thellama73 wrote:I reread hedge, and DP (I do not think juliets is bad) and I'm not seeing enough in either of them to deter my intentions. Hope you enjoy my vote, MP!
juliets wrote:I just finished reading MP (I had to also throw a jog into that time) and didn't see anything I felt was un-Moving Pictures like in these first days. His suspicions, though varied, seem to be rational. I won't be looking his way for the lynch.
I'm about to re-read Hedgeowl because of the issue brought up by SVS I think that Hedgeowl contradicted herself.I'm concerned however that Hedgeowl seems to be under either a smilie curse
MovingPictures07 wrote:Lest we forget also that Hedgeowl's vote for Lizzy was incredibly blendy and that she contradicted herself (something that S~V~S pointed out).
I think I might actually go her way now, tbh. I have to leave to go back to work in 10 minutes. Going to think about it. Want to hear what others have to say.
I did think that it's possible baddies were trying to frame Hedgeowl,
Mongoose wrote:Oooh I'm the cute brown one.
DisgruntledPorcupine wrote:I don't know what that means. I don't appreciate you lumping all us rodents together though.Mongoose wrote:DP seems extra squirrelly this game.Epignosis wrote:Were you to vote for a Lizzy voter, who would it be? Those are the folks I'm checking out.
How do you figure that guv'nor? (Love the cockney, but that's about all I got right now) Love ya Lizzy, but thinking something ain't right in Denmark if you know wha I mean.S~V~S wrote:Lol, looks like you do toothellama73 wrote:Cor blimey, looks loike svs 'as sum defenders!
Since only 5 votes are cast, i am gonna wait a bit if i need to save.
Catch up a bit in the meantime
No worries, this was not super clear. I meant I was agreeing with Lizzy's sentiment about why SVS voted for llama over it. However, I also consider Lizzy more likely to randomize early when she doesnt have strong suspicions, so this seems unusual for her. I think I agree with what Mongoose said above too.Mongoose wrote:It seems loike the typical Brad Pitt and tat from Llamer and SVS ter me. I daan't clock that their Hammer and Tack and forf is particularly alarmin' either way; doesn't seem loike a 'ex per se. glad ya 're 'appy wif the results, Roxy!juliets wrote:Ok, Hedgie let me make sure I understand: are you saying you are considering voting for SVS because you've seen she and llama disagree in past games? And why would that lead you to vote SVS over llama? Maybe I've totally misunderstood what you're saying.Hedgeowl wrote:I was going to agree with you because I have seen thos exact same situation with SVS and Llama before, but then I remembered this is Lizzy. Makes me go allLizzy wrote:Hai! This is my second attempt at posting. Stoopid phone! Anyway, I have to vote now because I am internetless and my phone reception is rubbish, so I'm expecting it to die again. I'll vote for SVS because Llama seems like his old self to me, except more cockney which is quite brilliant. :Pswinging back in forth in my feelings now, but hope you come back befor the vote ans explain more.
linki - Them 're spittin' dickie birds, 'oss.
Not at all. I was just a bit surprised you voted llama for it. It seems like whatver the topic day 1 you clash is all. I think of Lizzy as an earaly randomizer and liking mor solid cases to go on, so becasue of her quick jump makes me wonder if she has something to protect this time.S~V~S wrote:Whether or not we have done this before or not, does that mean you find both of our arguments dismissable?
I was going to agree with you because I have seen thos exact same situation with SVS and Llama before, but then I remembered this is Lizzy. Makes me go allLizzy wrote:Hai! This is my second attempt at posting. Stoopid phone! Anyway, I have to vote now because I am internetless and my phone reception is rubbish, so I'm expecting it to die again. I'll vote for SVS because Llama seems like his old self to me, except more cockney which is quite brilliant. :P
swinging back in forth in my feelings now, but hope you come back befor the vote ans explain more. 
[/quote] SVS and Llama arguing and disagreeing from Day 1, SVS votes for llama (although he wasn't lynched this time). Whew! It had to happen eventually, so I figured I'd just take the white elephant in the room by the tusks and go for it. Glad that's over with now.Mongoose wrote:Voting Birdy because forgot about the gym and see he doesn't have any votes. He doesn't look like he will get any votes unless people find voting for wire suspicious. Yes, it's a cop-out vote, but it's day one.
No worries, Hedge. That's pretty funny.
...and drinking and donuts and daisies 
and 
Mongoose wrote:It's a wonder the Animal Sanctuary Squad isn't totally hungover today!Hedgeowl wrote:Air Hockey Table + Ale + Apple = Party!
