The Syndicate

It benefits Scarecrow more to look like he doesn't want his victims dead. Somebody going around saying let's lynch *scarecrow victim* is going to look a lot less likely to be Scarecrow and therefore draw less attention. Yeah Bullz you might be overthinking that a little. Am I overthinking it or is ...

Bullzeye wrote:It benefits Scarecrow more to look like he doesn't want his victims dead. Somebody going around saying let's lynch *scarecrow victim* is going to look a lot less likely to be Scarecrow and therefore draw less attention.

EBWOP. I bet that double negative is going to drive Epi crazy.

It benefits Scarecrow more to not look like he doesn't want his victims dead. Somebody going around saying let's lynch *scarecrow victim* is going to look a lot less likely to be Scarecrow and therefore draw less attention.

I am not trying to argue with you, tbh, you remind me of me in LOST Again, when I was so sure about you and no one believed me, I had to beg Nutella & Wilgy to vote for you. Linki, Well, then, maybe he is wrong. Do you have a different role inmind for LoRab? Are you worried sheis last Falcone? ...

Seriously I don't know why I feel like I'm being pushed into defending LoRab. I don't care if we lynch her tomorrow as long as we lynch Scarecrow today and I'm convinced Dom is Scarecrow.

Sorry Bullz, I just don't have any large reason to believe Dom is Scarecrow over anyone else at this point, and he is reading genuine to me. I take comfort in the fact I won't be the only one who loses because nobody agreed with me . I know it's not a huge case but it is something I feel strongly a...

Also Matt if I were Thorne I'd have picked you to support as quickly as I possibly could, so you can cross that one off the conspiracy list.

Linki - Doing so made it very easy for Dom to suddenly claim Scarecrow victims couldn't possibly BE Scarecrow, so yeah I do think that.

Sorry Bullz, I just don't have any large reason to believe Dom is Scarecrow over anyone else at this point, and he is reading genuine to me. I take comfort in the fact I won't be the only one who loses because nobody agreed with me . I know it's not a huge case but it is something I feel strongly a...

Sorry Bullz, I just don't have any large reason to believe Dom is Scarecrow over anyone else at this point, and he is reading genuine to me. I take comfort in the fact I won't be the only one who loses because nobody agreed with me. I know it's not a huge case but it is something I feel strongly ab...

No one ever listens to me...

You know what? I can't. You're right. It would make sense for her to be waffling on Dom now that he claims to have been Scarecrowed.

I definitely think Dom looks worse than LoRab. IMO the most damning part of Typh's case is the point about MP, which falls apart when you realise that we have confirmation Scarecrow was making people need MP dead shortly after his failed lynch, regardless of how long it took to target MP himself. Th...

In fact I feel pretty strongly about this and don't think I can be convinced otherwise, so I'll be *Voting Dom* now to get this out of the way.

Isn't it though? It's true for today at least, looking through your posts I don't see where you've called out anyone individually save for LoRab after she called you out. Literally your posts go from "I've been scarecrowed" to "Juliets? DH? Enrique?" I'll grant you Enrique is a S...

But it ISN'T all I've been talking about? I have spun a few theories around, I commented on teh possibility of LoRab. I've discussed Enrique possibility. I'm trying to play a game. Discussion has gone way down. You are cherrypicking here. Show me where I said it was all you've been talking about. D...

Mp was targeted by scarecrow n7. His failed lynch was d4 I think. Since Robin is a role no player normally needs dead, why not immediately target him as scarecrow? Unless you were not paying a lot of attention, perhaps because you were out of the country like Lorab was. Well Matt was targeted to ne...

I went through LoRabs posts, mostly to see if she could be Falcone. But I hadn't seriously considered LoRab as scarecrow yet... and I think that makes more sense. - It would explain why MP was scarecrowed later than his failed lynch. She was out of the country for the first couple weeks of the game...

I'll have a look at your LoRab post now then.

There isn't a huge amount to it, hence the crazy, but I do find it suspicious that "Hey I was scarecrowed last night also anyone who says they've been scarcrowed probably isn't him". It's just a gut feeling mostly for now.

Yes. It's a hunch that grew as I was catching up earlier.

I was thinking maybe it was Dom, too, but I don't think Dom would march into the thread a day after we started to take the Scarecrow hunt seriously and announce "oh hai guys i was scarecrow'd too haha". I mean he did follow that up by basically excluding everyone who the Scarecrow has tar...

Yesterday was insane at work and I just couldn't be arsed to do anything when I got in, so sorry for not being here!

Matt wrote:No crazy theories here, sorry.

I'm working on one. Watch this space.

Good point. Are the people still scarecrowed certain their target is alive? My target is Scarecrow. So yeah, probably. Scarecrow targeted you to target him/her? I do not understand that at all. Not that I don't believe you, I do, I just can't figure out why they would do that. I never gave it much ...

Typhoony wrote:Good point. Are the people still scarecrowed certain their target is alive?

My target is Scarecrow. So yeah, probably.

I think I actually will *Vote DH*. Pretty much nobody thinks he's civ and the only argument I've heard against him being Scarecrow is SVS' insistence he'd definitely have targeted her first.

Lets vote Dom? Where's Dom been? Don't tell me he's been silenced today. :puppy: Dom has posted today. He asked me who was bad and I told him he was. Linki, well, I think there are only baddie blockers, but secrets, true. I guess it is possible. But I honestly think he would have targeted me Night ...

Golden wrote:Lets vote Dom?

Why?

Voting DharmaHelper because I really got more important shit to do and I wanna get this out of the way ASAP. He is one of my top Scarecrow candidates, has a vote already, and only SVS has a civvie read on him. Good enough for me. Convince me DH is Scarecrow. I already think he's probably an inmate....

Relax Bullz, lol, I labeled you as "Town/indy". And I didn't label you civ friendly because something in the back of my mind is hounding me, saying "Would Bullz put up that display of 'oh poor me' if he were bad?" and I keep coming back to "yes, yes he would" haha. I d...

Relax Bullz, lol, I labeled you as "Town/indy". And I didn't label you civ friendly because something in the back of my mind is hounding me, saying "Would Bullz put up that display of 'oh poor me' if he were bad?" and I keep coming back to "yes, yes he would" haha. I d...

Does anyone think DH is good at all? Bizarrely enough, I do. Linki @ Golden, once again, I am talking about her posts in this game. Not every game. Someone corrected her out of the thread about Lorabs gender, imo. :ponder: I think you underestimate bubbles wildly if you think she is silly enough to...

Does anyone think DH is good at all? Bizarrely enough, I do. Linki @ Golden, once again, I am talking about her posts in this game. Not every game. Someone corrected her out of the thread about Lorabs gender, imo. :ponder: I think you underestimate bubbles wildly if you think she is silly enough to...

Does anyone think DH is good at all? I dunno, do you? I mean, how many times do we lynch bubbles as civ for the exact same reasons before we stop finding the behaviour suspicious? Fair question. Another question I have is "if we lynch bubbles and she flips civ, how may people will assume that ...

I could see a Bubbles vote tonight if only to end all the discussion around her.

Linki - I disagree that it is my style.

omfg what is with all the linki tonight

S~V~S wrote: Linki, you can be pretty blendy, Bullz. I have no clue about you, either way. You could be bad, or not. :Shrug:

I'm never deliberately blendy. I think you have blendiness confused with not having a lot of time to keep up.

@Bullz - I do understand your perspective, but does the impact you had matter? Like, even in games where you have to be alive to win, I'll feel like a winner if I was a big help to my team and they end up winning. I dunno, I just personally don't feel like I won unless I was alive at the end. Can't...

@Bullz - I do understand your perspective, but does the impact you had matter? Like, even in games where you have to be alive to win, I'll feel like a winner if I was a big help to my team and they end up winning. I dunno, I just personally don't feel like I won unless I was alive at the end. Can't...

But why, Bubbles?

I don't think there is any way epi will give a win to people who aren't playing. Also, I know in my case, that my death is not what will determine whether I win, so it's interesting you are equating death with loss. Personally I think there's a difference between actually winning, and being on the ...

Also, I have not been scarecrowed. I say that overtly because people are speculating and while it may make me seem suspicious for not having been targeted, I think it would be worse to hide that fact. A lso, I'll throw out there, that scarecrow could very well have not targeted anyone on one night ...

I suggest you read the rules to find out that Bubbles doesn't have to have been around to kill someone if her teammate is alive. Fine, maybe she's bad. I've been on the fence about her since she became a topic of conversation. Regardless, as it has been pointed out there's no baddie kill tonight, t...

You. This is your first mention of me in my memory other than your investigation into bubbles. Please elaborate. I just wanted to put you on the spot and see what you'd say. I don't actually suspect you. Ultimately, I've ruled out low posters (for the time being - I don't think any of them were aro...

Oh I guess I've ruled out MP as well. Kinda forgot he was even alive.

You. This is your first mention of me in my memory other than your investigation into bubbles. Please elaborate. I just wanted to put you on the spot and see what you'd say. I don't actually suspect you. Ultimately, I've ruled out low posters (for the time being - I don't think any of them were aro...

EBWOP: voted for himself = outed himself. I've just got in from work, brain is fried.

Also I don't recall ever voting for Mac after he voted for himself. I count him outing himself as the point where he quoted the "breadcrumb" and erased any doubt as to what he meant. After that I gave up voting for him. Maybe I'm wrong but I definitely don't remember voting him after that....

Bullzeye was a little less convincing in his response, I haven't ISOd him yet but if he didn't give any other indication of being Scarecrow'd before he could just be saying that to be taken off the list. Which response is this? I was Scarecrowed on Night Eight. I didn't mention anything before now ...

I'm more than happy for us to kill scarecrow today but I agree with Golden about wanting to know why it can't be X or Y, as well as why any particular person might be scarecrow. For the record I'm fairly sure he is still alive.

Search found 3412 matches