The Syndicate

Long Con wrote:

Sorsha wrote:... I'm also eyeing LC and LoRab for entertaining the thought that Floyd might be silenced.

How is this a justifiable basis for suspicion?

Long Con wrote:

Sorsha wrote:Why pick sig? If you wanted to rile up the thread why not pick someone who was at least posting? What if we all bandwagoned sig, he was lynched and flipped civ? Or flipped bad? What would we have learned?

Why not sig? How is another player better than sig?

If everyone just smiled and agreed and voted sig, then that would really say a lot about everyone in the thread. I assume in this hypothetical situation that sig never showed up at all and defended himself? Ok. If he flipped Civ, then that would suck, if he flipped bad then it would have been good. How much we learned is based on the different reactions of players. WTF are you talking about, Sorsha? These questions are not useful or interesting at all.

You think I had some plan on how to handle every eventuality of casting a vote on sig? Is that how you play? That's... ridiculous. Am I to believe that you do that for every post you make, every vote you cast? Get outta here with that crap. I'm sorry, but your questions are pretty irrelevant. I made a move to get things going. That's the start and the end of that story. There is no explanation about "what would we have learned if...?"

DH, I already identified that smell hours ago.

timmer wrote:

DharmaHelper wrote:

timmer wrote:Hmm... you know, that's actually pretty compelling, and definitely has more meat than Floyd not being here... changing my vote.

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

Da fuq? Man, I can't keep posting I'm still technically working. Did I misunderstand? I thought the points you linked to re: LC were valid seeming???

Long Con wrote:This thread turned into an explosion of bullshit, hard to decide where to begin.

DharmaHelper wrote:I think I'll take this opportunity to vote LC.

DrWilgy wrote:I actually have no memory of what Floyd said, but I do remember that there was suspicion of him.

I'm kinda at a halt here. The people I was most suspicious of were Golden, Made, Scotty and Prisoner... Maybe SVS. Did SVS state that she was suspicious of anyone other than me?

timmer wrote:By the way Floyd was reading the thread about an hour ago. His lack of posting now becomes more of an issue when I know he has been here, knows he is in the hatch, and chose to say nothing. It suggests eother complete ennui or he's hanging in btsc somewhere. Either way it doesn't look good.

DrWilgy wrote:I actually have no memory of what Floyd said, but I do remember that there was suspicion of him.

I'm kinda at a halt here. The people I was most suspicious of were Golden, Made, Scotty and Prisoner... Maybe SVS. Did SVS state that she was suspicious of anyone other than me?

timmer wrote:

Sorsha wrote:

timmer wrote:I see 3 mentions about the main thread before she posted that?

I see one.....

You mentioned not being able to see the main thread twice, and lc made a comment about sif and wanting to read that over in the other thread?

Sorsha wrote:

timmer wrote:I see 3 mentions about the main thread before she posted that?

I see one.....

timmer wrote:I see 3 mentions about the main thread before she posted that?

LoRab wrote:OK, agreed with all who stated above that it's really annoying to not be able to see the main thread, in order to see what was said previously. As is obvious, I suspect Wilgy, although less so than Day 1, based on lynch result--knowing that mafia has game-related roles (or at least some mafia), the slip seems less likely to be a slip. That said, his defense still doesn't sit right. And I still don't like that he never answered my question about why he automatically went to the conclsion that the first player to post about being from a game was lying about what game they were from, and what motivation he thinks they would have for lying about what game they were from.

I also suspect sig. Suspicion of him has been brought up a few times. He had one post that definitely pinged me and I didn't mention it at the time because I had cut and pasted a bunch of quotes and then lost them and didn't get around to going back to getting them all again and needed to get on with posting. And I don't remember exactly what it was or why it pinged me. And I realize that isn't at all helpful. And I really wish I could go back and reread his posts now. Dammit.

DharmaHelper wrote:

Sorsha wrote:Do you have the results of phase three of your foolproof plan for lynching baddies yet DH?

You're sitting in it.

Long Con wrote:So, the bad guys probably placed people in both places. So they get to know what's going on... unless... anyone know from the original Lost Again game if the BTSC gets to cross over from Beach to Hatch? I assume baddie BTSC is uninterrupted. The good news is that we probably have a chance to lynch two baddies today. Let's at least try to show up our Beach compatriots and lynch well!

I look at our player list and I see a lot of people that I could vote for.

Quin wrote:

Long Con wrote:RIP Epi. So, whoever predicted this outcome... was right. The Hatch/Beach thing.

Outcome?

The Hatch/Beach thing.

DharmaHelper wrote:So Sorsha, of the Hatchies, whom do you suspect, and why?